News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by KoenDG on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:42PM (#21634547)
I'm going to assume that it's true.

And I'm also going to say: If Burger King is forced to get a separate stove(or whatever it's called in the industrial-sized context they're in) just for that 1 burger, they will cancel that burger.

That's my prediction. Because it's too much of an up-front cost.

I'm very glad that this burger has entered the chain and is getting both the vegan/vegetarian community, as well as regular meat-eating people, like myself, in on it.

If people who eat meat start choosing this over a regular burger, it's a win. If this drives previously non-existing traffic to burger king, all of which uses this one product, it's a win.

This is about changing the industry at large. About creating big orders and showing the industry that this is worth investing in. And eventually: normalizing it.

We can solve the problem of the not-yet-vaporized grease particles later.

I'm not saying we should ignore it. I'm saying it's not a current priority. But it will be later.

I've tried the burger, and I liked it, I'll definitely pick it again.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cageface on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:19PM (#21634825)
I agree. I'm as vegan as I can be and still be a digital nomad but this seems like the lesser of two evils to me. I'd rather see this product stay on the market and introduce more people to the idea of eating less or even no meat.

I understand why some vegans are put off by the idea of eating something cooked on the same grill as actual meat but I think we need pragmatism more than anything right now.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by bscphil on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:06AM (#21635762)
> I understand why some vegans are put off by the idea of eating something cooked on the same grill as actual meat

I genuinely have never met a vegan who would be bothered by this, and I know quite a few. If there were still bits of meat on the grill it could still be kind of gross if they came off on the burger I guess, but most would have no problem with it. This strikes me as an extremely rare case, and I don't see any obvious grounds for a lawsuit.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by scandinavegan on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @05:44AM (#21637120)
Bits of meat sticking to the vegan burger would be a big no-no for me and the vegans that I know!

I'm not personally bothered by using the same tools to handle both meat and vegan options, as long as I can't taste it, if we're talking about backyard barbecuing with friends. But I expect more from a company.

I had an unpleasant experience a couple of years ago at Subway. I ordered a vegan sub, and the person behind the counter asked if I wanted them to switch their plastic gloves. "No need," I said, because I thought it was a moral question. But when I started eating the sub I could smell meat along the whole bread as I ate it. It was not pleasant when it was two decades since I last had meat, but I was drunk and hungry and finished it anyway.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by lm28469 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @06:35AM (#21637394)
> as long as I can't taste it

Isn't the whole point of this burger to taste like real meat ?

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cageface on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:27AM (#21635833)
I stopped eating meat long enough ago that I've lost the taste for it and I'm aware of how dirty factory farms and industrial slaughterhouses are so this does gross me out a bit. Would it bother you to eat food that was cooked on a grill that was also used to barbecue dogs? That's how some vegans feel about this.

But like I said I think getting some meat alternatives in front of the general public is important enough that I'll live with it.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by absolute-0 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @01:12AM (#21635992)
At its core, the reality is that all Burger King restaurants are franchises, and with that comes spotty coverage of some of the more punishing details for any canned preparation of their menu items.

I think the Impossible Whopper will stick around, but the sacrosanct vegan preparation was just a promotional gimmick to stimulate sales, with no intention of adherence to strict practices. My suspicion was always that the vegan options would be promoted for the initial release, but then it would be quietly walked back to typical preparation steps after the hype died down, and the rate of sandwich sales peaked and leveled off.

With that, you get shift managers of individual locations, hamfistedly claiming whatever they think passes for customer service, whether that be keeping the customer lines and drive through windows moving at a brisk pace during lunch and evening rushes, or bending over backwards for the squeakiest wheels in search of grease.

Meanwhile, dog meat analogies aside, the cult of the complainiest customers will only win so many victories. The patty might be vegan, and the last mile falls upon the 16 year-old kid behind the counter. Disgust, revulsion, and so on, at the thought of giving any money to a meat selling business that moves titanic quantities of animal carcass should give a vegan pause, before even stepping through the front door, if they're that serious about their belief system.

It's fine to level the argument that the tiniest drop of raw sewage is unacceptable in any glass of water, but the reality is that the consumer's physiological fragility remains unharmed and unthreatened in a scenario such as this. The comingled vegan and animal byproducts are a reality, evident by virtue of the very nature establishment itself.

You get what you pay for. It's fast food. They won't stop selling the burger, but they might annotate Vegan* with an asterisk.

  * at participating locations
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by ukoki on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:54AM (#21636880)
So you are saying you would go to a restaurant that barbecues dogs, provided the dogs were barbecued on a different grill?

Surely anyone who thinks meat is that bad would never step foot in a restaurant that cooks meat in the first place, regardless of grills?

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by kalleboo on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @07:06AM (#21637548)
If you’re surrounded by a culture that eats dog with every meal you might not have a choice?
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by croisillon on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:16AM (#21636673)
Same here, "only" a vegetarian but when my falafel/döner place use the same fork to pick meat and my falafel I cringe a bit (and still eat it, yes).
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cramjabsyn on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:59AM (#21635948)
Wouldn’t bother me. Dogs, franks, sausages, burgers, steaks, whatever. If they scrape clean the cook surface and make an effort to keep things separated I’m happy.
[dead]
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by quelltext on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @06:13AM (#21637271)
Please list the "a lot of Asian countries".
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by tom_mellior on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:16AM (#21637974)
Not the parent and not taking any side in this discussion, but I was interested in looking this up, so here you go:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog#As_food "Dog meat is consumed in some East Asian countries, including Korea, China and Vietnam, a practice that dates back to antiquity. It is estimated that 13–16 million dogs are killed and consumed in Asia every year."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dog_meat "In the 21st century, dog meat is consumed in some regions of China, South Korea, Vietnam, and Nigeria and it is still eaten or is legal to be eaten in other countries throughout the world. [...] It was estimated in 2014 that worldwide, 25 million dogs are eaten each year by humans."

I guess if what you took exception to was the "a lot" part, then three Asian countries might indeed not qualify as "a lot".

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by quelltext on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:15PM (#21652205)
Yes, my point was that 3 is not a lot and it's not even that mainstream there. I don't know if there was an additional undertone in the original comment, but either way it was factually wrong. Dog meat consumption is really not that high.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by matt-attack on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:36AM (#21638108)
Why be defensive about facts. I don’t think anyone here would look down on those countries for it. The criteria for which exact species of plants animal and fungi is ok to eat is entirely arbitrary and regionally specific.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cageface on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:53AM (#21638237)
Exactly. I don't understand why Americans, for example, eat pigs every day and think nothing of it but are horrified by the idea of eating a dog. What's the difference?
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by quelltext on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @04:17PM (#21652219)
Fact is that it's actually not that many countries. I also don't look down on the practice. I hear that in Korea therr are specific dogs bred for consumption and quite tasty.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by bauruine on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:21AM (#21636699)
I wouldn't care. Rats, insects or something like dog food on the other side would may bother me so I think I get the point.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by zecg on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @04:41AM (#21636804)
> I genuinely have never met a vegan who would be bothered by this, and I know quite a few.

I am quite bothered by it, to the (IMO reasonable) point of not eating what I'm served and not coming back if I suspect that's the case.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by thescriptkiddie on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:20AM (#21636461)
I'm not vegan, just vegetarian, but I have some vegan friends and none of them have any problem with eating something cooked on the same grill as meat either. Like the previous poster, I can understand the concern, but I don't think it's a common one.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by gizmo686 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:58AM (#21638264)
I had a co-worker who was litterally allergic to meat. She would avoid eating even vegan options in favor of food she packed herself for fear of cross contamination.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by aries1980 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:41AM (#21639901)
If she had such a serious allergy, a separate oven probably won't solve the problem for her, but a separate restaurant.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by thunderbong on Monday November 25, 2019 @10:40PM (#21635485)
In my experience most of the vegan evangelists are not pragmatists
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cageface on Monday November 25, 2019 @11:25PM (#21635633)
If you care about animal welfare at all and you know what goes on in factory farms it can be hard to take pragmatic positions. All the same though I think it doesn't help to come across as too uncompromising if you're trying to win people over to your cause.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by lonelappde on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:54AM (#21640058)
This is a common argument, but backwards. The more important an issue is the more pragmatic you need to be, because results actually matter more than your gut feelings of discomfort, right?
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by neuralRiot on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @03:38PM (#21642441)
>I think we need pragmatism more than anything right now.

Why? What’s the emergency? BK raising their profits? They laughed at us not so long ago now they just realize there’s an opportunity here, i’d rather support local vegan eateries. It was as simple as putting a disclaimer in the ad “vegan burgers are cooked on shared equipment and can contain traces of meat”.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cdumler on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @06:32PM (#21643823)
What's the emergency? Climate change, animal cruelty, piss-poor management of resources for the production of our food. Good grief, we're _well_ behind the curve for getting things changed in our society and world.

I agree with Burger King is doing it for profit, but that's the point of capitalism: we if want change, we vote with our dollar. I have no huge love for impossible burger. It's too much like the real thing now that I'm years out from eating beef; however, I'm going to be buy some now and then because I want to see the product being sold.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by caf on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:48PM (#21634613)
If Burger King is forced to get a separate stove...

It seems more likely that they'd just have to tweak the way it's advertised, with some fine print making it clear that it's cooked on the same grill as meat products (as with "processed on equipment that also processes nuts" type disclaimers).

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by mc32 on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:57PM (#21634702)
I agree with this.

A problem is ultra-orthodoxy along with less than truthful advertising. As someone commented in line, don't let perfect be the enemy of good.

I know in other cultures I've worked in abroad this would not be a problem. People presume best effort with these kinds of things and don't take it literally --some people might but they'd be a tiny tiny minority. It was usually the foreigner who got upset that something wasn't 100% vegan even if in spirit things were and locals were okay with it.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by lonelappde on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @11:56AM (#21640069)
"Meat-friendly" burgers, like "gluten-friendly" food that has a little gluten in it.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by erikig on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:49PM (#21634614)
"Don't Let the Perfect Be the Enemy of the Good"
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by anonytrary on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:56PM (#21634684)
> If Burger King is forced to get a separate stove(or whatever it's called in the industrial-sized context they're in) just for that 1 burger, they will cancel that burger.

I'm not a fan of regulation obstructing experimentation, but in this case, I think requiring proper cooking process for something that is purportedly vegetarian is absolutely necessary.

I don't see the problem with fine-print like "may have touched real meat". The impossible whopper should be marketed towards omnivores who:

  1. Understand the personal/environmental problems with eating meat.
  2. Are interested in alternatives.
This market seems to be increasing. If this is profitable, then it makes sense to support a fully vegetarian pipeline for producing fake meat.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by shkkmo on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:54PM (#21634666)
There is no requirement of a separate grill, BK can use a microwave and/or advertise that while the impossible Burger contains 0% beef, it is cooked on equipment that also cooks beef (just like we do with peanut allergy warnings.)
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by monkin on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:47PM (#21634594)
> And I'm also going to say: If Burger King is forced to get a separate stove(or whatever it's called in the industrial-sized context they're in) just for that 1 burger, they will cancel that burger.

They will not kill it, it's too popular to make that decision, and has gigantic growth potential. From business perspective they will do everything to keep those few milion vegans getting into BK.

For me biggest problem is meat smell inside of their restaurants. Most vegans don't like that. ;)

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by Turing_Machine on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:34PM (#21635188)
> it's too popular to make that decision

It's popular enough to double the square footage devoted to grills (at, generally, a hefty monthly lease cost per square foot), double the energy consumption, and double the employee time for grill cleaning and maintenance?

I'm skeptical.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by mcphage on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @08:56AM (#21638252)
> It's popular enough to double the square footage devoted to grills

Why would they need the vegan grills to be the same size as the meat grills, unless they’re selling the same number of them? And if they are, doing so seems a no-brainer.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by noitsnot on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:00PM (#21634720)
My experience is they don't have enough room for two grills without melting some ceiling tiles because the kitchen ventilation is made for one. They used to (may still) cook the chicken sandwich on the same grill and claim it was gluten free.