We're not talking about just 'sex', we are talking about the creation of entertainment media were a person is paid to have sex with another person/persons. I wouldn't call it a 'natural act'.
I used to be totally fine with porn, and to some extent I still am, however I do see it as a problem as well.
First off I think that the ease with which really hardcore porn is increasingly accessable today means very young kids are able to get their first views of sex being extremely warped. This creates expectations of what sex is that many are likely uncomfortable with, but will perform because porn has made it 'the norm'. Add to this how most porn turns sex into something borderline mechanical and/or centered around a fetish, which makes perfect sense from a 'product standpoint', but it also means that practically all porn sells the whole idea of sex as merely people using eachother to 'get off'.
The second problem I have is with the industry and its employees, I can't recall any ex-porn worker having anything good to say about their previous profession, instead what I've seen described comes across as a really shitty situation, where many turn to drugs in order to make it through 'shoots' and then again to forget.
Instead of blaming porn, easily accessible or not, we could mention the role of parents or even schools that could be more involved with sex education.
>I can't recall any ex-porn worker having anything good to say about their previous profession, instead what I've seen described comes across as a really shitty situation, where many turn to drugs in order to make it through 'shoots' and then again to forget.
Well, maybe if this population was not constantly vilified and ostracized, things would go better for them.
This can be said about the "mainstream" showbiz industry as well. Remember all the child stars with ugly adulthoods?
As for spawning fetishes and promoting unrealistic expectations, again, you can say this about a lot of mainstream media too.
Critics of porn seem to ignore other industries with the same problems when singling out porn for these criticisms, because !!sex!!
I don't know exactly what the fetishes/unrealistic expectations you say mainstream media is promoting, but I doubt they have as direct impact as porn does.
As for mainstream showbiz, I certainly don't hold it in high regard either, but I do think it does better than the porn industry. Basically I would be very hesitant about my kid going into showbiz, meanwhile I would do anything in my power to dissuade my kid from going into porn.
Coming from Australia, I find the whole anti-nudity-sex view of US extremely bizarre.
One one side Netflix and friends have figured out that Booms, Bullets, Bucks, Boobs and Butts are a golden formula. Like most HBO series involve some form of nudity.
On the other side the big media mafias are heavily censoring totally normal things.
Toxic masculinity and macho-isms, submissive femininity and repressed sexuality, hard-to-maintain body types, glamorizing hazards like fast cars and wreckless driving or acting like an asshole.
Much has been said elsewhere about and against these topics.
Thats just due to ignorance. Watch the two documentaries of After Sex ends.
And I think there can be some truth to that. Culture often was defined by the absence of anything sexual, since it was believed to adhere to higher forms of aesthetics instead of intrinsic sexual urges.
I think everyone should decide what constitutes the correct balance for themselves. It is just that these transgression of shame are mostly attributed to sex workers to their disadvantage.
But there aren't only happy sex workers and I think it isn't difficult to comprehend why people might want to refrain from engaging in intimacy with sex workers at all. Because to them intimacy cannot be reduced to stress relieve or their own fantasies. I don't think it is that bizarre.
But it is a huge problem if sex workers get penalized because they transgress your own personal boundaries.
I'm from a highly religious, Middle-Eastern culture. In the backwaters of this backwater, it's unthinkable for a male and female to even hold hands in public, let alone have a friendly greeting with a peck on the cheek.
Nobody would think even once about such acts in Western societies.
Now consider violence: people, in every culture, generally don't feel uncomfortable about depictions of violence in media.
Violence is presented as glamorous as soon as children are conscious of their environment. Through toys, comics, cartoons. But none of them dare to show even a kiss or a romantic relationship.
Why do you think that depictions of injury and death are considered more socially acceptable than the depictions of love and the act of creating life?
Can it not be reversed?
> Culture often was defined by the absence of anything sexual, since it was believed to adhere to higher forms of aesthetics instead of intrinsic sexual urges.
Imposing communal rules upon sexuality is more likely a form of control over mating rights:
By denying potential competitors' access to mates, we hope to increase ours. Almost all animals do this, we just codify it into our social constructs.
And this fact is very apparent when you consider that the ruling classes of cultures which repress sex, never really follow their own rules.
Other cultures have their own taboos regarding sex, of course, but it seems only the Judeo-Christian religions regard sexuality (in particular, female sexuality) as inherently evil or corrupting, certainly more so than violence, which is often seen as noble because it's linked, Biblically, with divine justice.
I'm not sure where you read this but it's terribly wrong. There's an entire book devoted to the beauty of marital relations (Song of Songs), and Paul explicitly commands married husbands and wives to give themselves to their spouse (that is, sex).
I'm aware of at least one instance where a puritan wife in the 17th century went to the congregation with a complaint that the husband was not having sex with her. The husband was rebuked for it.
Christianity regards sex as intimate and reserved solely for marriage; beautiful within that boundary and wrong outside of it.
Female sexuality is seen as responsible for the fall of humanity. The first wive of Adam was evil and did not listen, and Eve corrupted Adam into biting the apple. After that, female sexuality and will was something to be contained and cleaned:
> But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence. For Adam was first formed, then Eve.
> Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience as also saith the law. And if they will learn any thing, let them ask their husbands at home: for it is a shame for women to speak in the church.
> When a woman has a discharge, and the discharge in her body is blood, she shall be in her menstrual impurity for seven days, and whoever touches her shall be unclean until the evening. And everything on which she lies during her menstrual impurity shall be unclean.
It's generally bad form to parade speculation as fact.
>The first wive of Adam was evil and did not listen,
The first wife of Adam according to the Bible is eve. Perhaps you're referencing some work of Jewish mysticism, which would be totally irrelevant in a discussion on the Bible and what Christian's believe.
Your post is a bit of a mess of misconceptions and misinformation. Ritual uncleanliness occurs in the OT for a huge number of things, including for male emissions, birth (both male and female), skin infections, and generally contact with blood / any bodily fluids... It's concerned with whether one has been involved in things of the world, which is improper for one wishing to approach an entirely otherworldly God.
But such context tends to be lost when is more concerned bashing religion than with understanding the text.
Christianity regards all forms of sexuality except one to be sinful, and that exception only counts if consecrated by ritual. That's equivalent to considering sex to be sinful by default.
We're not discussing "rituals around sex" in the general case anyway, absent any historical or cultural context. We're discussing the Judeo-Christian complex, specifically the way its rituals have influenced Western cultural beliefs about sexuality, and how those rituals have encouraged the demonization of perfectly healthy and natural forms of sexual expression.
And as soon as you assume intention and purpose behind the creation of things, it is a given that some actions and uses will be deviations from those intentions.
The Bible lays out restrictions on sex because it starts with grounds above and claims that sex has a purpose higher than just the fulfillment of the individual(s) involved.
You can claim that these are just man-made restrictions for whatever ignoble purpose, but that's begging the question somewhat by dismissing the fundamental and crucial claims here without engaging them. IF the Bible is correct regarding God and creation, such restrictions are logical implications.
One, you have the not-so-uncommon addiction to porn. Because of the wide and free availability of porn content today, it's very easy for a person that's susceptible to addiction to fall into a vicious hole.
Secondly, it can lead to spreading aggressive, potentially dangerous fetishes. I might be wrong about this, but I think a lot of the dangerous fetishes wouldn't necessarily exist (or at least wouldn't be so popular) if it wasn't for them being so readily available on the internet.
Sex workers would be an entire discussion topic on its own - but I think it's safe to say that the information available on the dark net crosses all lines - from legal to human rights.
I'm not suggesting we should shun it or disallow it completely - but I think celebrating would also be an extreme that's not worth the consequences.
You can say this about anything. Movies, video games, the internet, alcohol, sugary foods, fast cars, social media upvotes.
> Secondly, it can lead to spreading aggressive, potentially dangerous fetishes.
Again, this statement can also apply to things like violence in movies and games. And much has been said against that kind of reasoning :)
> I'm not suggesting we should shun it or disallow it completely - but I think celebrating would also be an extreme that's not worth the consequences.
I didn't mean literally celebrating like parading them around on a palanquin, but treating them with respect at the very least.
Create an environment that at least allows some discussion about it, instead of indignantly shutting these topics down upon hearing the first syllable.
What about movies, music, books, games, sports?
Why do you think porn stars should not be treated like any other actor, artist, author, musician, developer, sportsperson?
Almost every culture guilts people into remaining in unsuccessful relationships and makes people feel like a failure if they have to break off a relationship.
A lot of the things we do and consume are poor, distant derivatives that barely resemble the real thing. Pornography is easily among the worst offenders.
Again you bring technology into it, when spectator sports have existed long before the first Colosseum.
> Pornography is easily among the worst offenders.
How? Why?
If you go your school league game, you're not doing sports but you hang out with people from your community. Modern professional sports are much like pornography: completely empty in both regards.
Again, why do you think they're any different from movies, music, books, art, or any other form of entertainment you approve of?
Surely you find joy in something? Why do you believe people should not find joy in sports or porn?
It's like asking someone how can they approve of steak and disapprove of marshmallows. As if they were the same thing because they both provide some calories and can be eaten.
So this is a story to tell:
Rush - Theatrical Trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4XA73ni9eVs
Conor McGregor: Notorious - Official Trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syOgWwz2fiE
But when I watch it play out in real time it's not a story?
Porn has storylines. And I suggest watching WWE :)
> It's like asking someone how can they approve of steak and disapprove of marshmallows.
It's like a connoisseur of steak condemning the consumption of marshmallows for made-up hypocritical reasons.
Same with marshmallows. They're food, technically, but a poor, distant ersatz of a real meal. Both in taste and nutrition.
Saying this will make people, including any trans friends you have, go "hmm" at you if you're not careful.
There are probably cisgender people with this as a kink, but the concept is almost exclusively promoted by people who fear trans women and think transitioning is all about sexual gratification. Which is complete nonsense.
Besides...it's just another kind of transformation fantasy even for those hypothetical cisgender people. It's harmless. It's not a dysfunction unless you're some kind of weird prude who thinks sexual fantasies are dysfunctional. Go off and imagine yourself as some fantastical creature being gently, consensually railed by a dragon. It's fun.
Porn stars and sex workers should be celebrated instead of being ostracized.
There aren't many other professions who contribute as much to reducing stress and fulfilling the fantasies of so many people across the world. Most sex workers do it without any thanks and barely make enough from it to survive. Not only they have to brave a constant risk of disease and violence, they have to carry this outdated stigma throughout their lives, not only for themselves but also their families, even after they quit.