News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by WalterBright on Friday November 22, 2019 @12:52AM (#21603132)
If someone drops something in my car, and I unwittingly drive off with it, it is still not mine. But I did not steal it. If the person asks for it back, and I refuse, then I am stealing it.

All the police had to do was knock on his door and ask for it back. If he refused, that's grounds for theft. If he denied knowledge of it (like if it had just fallen off somewhere) that doesn't sound like sufficient grounds for a search warrant, and if the search warrant did turn up evidence of some unrelated crime, that evidence shouldn't be admissible.

I'm no lawyer, but that's what sounds right to me.

(I don't agree that Finders Keepers is a legal basis for ownership, or that leaving your door open means it's ok to steal, or that a bank error in your favor means you get to keep it.)

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by lazyguy2 on Friday November 22, 2019 @01:04AM (#21603200)
If you hide something on my car to spy on me then it's not reasonable to expect it back if I find it. Charging somebody with theft for something like this is effectively rewarding the police for being incompetent.

One of the worst mistakes in modern government is pretending that the people 'serving' have more rights and privileges then everybody else.

They should have less.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by dbcurtis on Friday November 22, 2019 @02:41AM (#21603629)
> One of the worst mistakes in modern government is pretending that the people 'serving' have more rights and privileges then everybody else.

The correct term to use here is "powers". The people have "rights". The people delegate, through the constitution, certain "powers" to the government. The government, in turn, delegates some of those powers to the police. The police do not have "rights". The government does not have "rights". The government and police have "powers", and are supposed to exercise those powers within specified limits.

What is under discussion here is the limits of those powers.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by x220 on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:03AM (#21603736)
Police de facto have more rights because they can expect lenient punishment (or no punishment) for crimes they commit even when out of uniform. You can argue until you're blue in the face about de jure rights but those don't matter very much when a cop pulls you over and fears for his life.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Aloha on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:22AM (#21603826)
Not by intention however, but I'd mostly agree they do in practice.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by roenxi on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:32AM (#21605375)
Linking cause and effect in the big picture is too slow to stop and worry about intent. History is replete with horrific injustices that didn't happen because anyone intended it to turn out that way.

Intent is a reasonable yardstick to assess who goes to jail and who doesn't. It is a terrible way to deal with systems and processes. There isn't time and it isn't productive to defend a system with bad incentives and outcomes because it wasn't intended to be that way.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by tehwebguy on Friday November 22, 2019 @06:26AM (#21604640)
It is entirely intentional.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by imtringued on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:10AM (#21605651)
Where is this intention written down? Can you show me the relevant law?
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by tehwebguy on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:34AM (#21605859)
Qualified immunity laws and case law is what you are looking for.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Jamwinner on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:08AM (#21606178)
Not to mention being 'on the level'.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by coldtea on Friday November 22, 2019 @06:43PM (#21611270)
>The people delegate, through the constitution, certain "powers" to the government.

Did the people vote to delegate those rights? Were the people ever asked?

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by dbcurtis on Friday November 22, 2019 @11:41PM (#21612511)
Why yes, yes indeed they were asked, and yes indeed they did vote. Look up the voting procedures around the ratification of the US constitution. They are rather interesting. The vote was put directly to the people, intentionally bypassing the statehouses so that the vote would be directly by the people. (Where the definition of "people" is white, male, and I believe also had to be a landowner -- but still, considering the times, a radical level of democracy.)
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by coldtea on Saturday November 23, 2019 @07:43AM (#21613829)
>Where the definition of "people" is white, male, and I believe also had to be a landowner -- but still, considering the times, a radical level of democracy

So, at best the "people" of 3 centuries ago where asked. And not all the people, just the white, male, landowners (and rich -- poorer white male people only got to vote 1.5 centuries later or more in the US, even in general elections).

And why is this binding for people, including poor, non landowning, women, blacks, latinos, asians, etc, 3 centuries later?

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by freeopinion on Friday November 22, 2019 @01:38AM (#21603353)
I'd settle for experimenting with "same".

If a regular citizen can't plant a bug, neither can police. If police can conduct a stakeout, so can regular citizens. They just have to follow the same process. That might include going in front of a judge and getting a warrant.

If a regular citizen could break up a bar fight, the police should be able to take the same actions. If police can set up a sting operation, so should citizens be allowed.

Obviously, we don't want everybody running around conducting sting operations or traffic stops. So we set some bar for regular citizens that makes it less likely. But police should have to face the exact same bar. The difference is that we pay for their time, training, equipment, etc. If a certain level of training is required before anybody can make a traffic stop, that training should be open for anybody. We just pay the admission and the salary for police to take the training. Regular citizens foot their own bill.

Edit: poor proofreading

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by L0stRegulator on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:06AM (#21603753)
So the obvious question then is should we be allowed place trackers in police cars, so we can track them on Waze (for example), and it would be a crime for them to remove it.

Equivalencies of Powers/Rights is a good thought experiment that would keep the powers of the enforcers from multiplying without limits.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by dbdjfjrjvebd on Friday November 22, 2019 @07:22AM (#21604900)
If authorized by a judge then yes.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by fargle on Friday November 22, 2019 @02:05AM (#21603470)
amen.

and if magnetic shit falls off my car, that's the breaks, suckers.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by DagAgren on Friday November 22, 2019 @05:15AM (#21604341)
So which do you think makes more sense: Police are not allowed to arrest people, or everyone is allowed to arrest?
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by icebraining on Friday November 22, 2019 @06:11AM (#21604572)
Everyone being allowed to arrest is actually not far from truth in many places: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen%27s_arrest#United_Stat...
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Frondo on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:55AM (#21605534)
Former private security guard here: in our training, we were told that we, as private citizens, could "arrest" someone, if you're willing to sign your name to an arrest warrant. You'd want to have the cops on the way, and be willing to face a false arrest lawsuit for detaining them, so you'd better be really 100% sure you caught them in the act of doing something illegal.

We were also taught it's almost never worth doing this; basically, if someone's shooting people and you're doing an armed job, yes, use your gun to try and stop them or detain them, but if it's just property damage or theft, call the cops and let them do their thing. The risk to you isn't worth it, nor is the risk of a false arrest lawsuit.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by vonmoltke on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:58AM (#21606078)
I think that hints towards freeopinion's point. You, as a private citizen, should have exactly the same legal liability with respect to false arrest as a police officer.

Then the question is, is such a good idea?

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:38AM (#21606502)
Everyone is allowed to arrest. Police only get that power as an extension of their citizenship.

There was a curious case a few years back of a non-citizen who had been a military police officer and became a civilian cop because nobody checked his documentation. His military activities were perfectly legal but all arrests made as a civilian were invalid.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by freeopinion on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:29PM (#21609717)
There's also the case of the lady in Florida who pulled the police officer over for speeding.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by m463 on Friday November 22, 2019 @02:01AM (#21603451)
> the people 'serving' have more rights and privileges then everybody else

I was told the difference between a policeman and a citizen (via citizen's arrest) is that a policeman can arrest someone for a misdemeanor.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by icebraining on Friday November 22, 2019 @06:15AM (#21604588)
According to Wikipedia, misdemeanors are OK too, as long as they were committed in the presence of that citizen.

I think the real difference is that the cops have qualified immunity, meaning they aren't at fault even if the arrest turned out to be unjustified, and regular citizens do not.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Clubber on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:57AM (#21606064)
I think police can be at fault, it's just the individual police officer doesn't typically pay the fine, it's their jurisdiction (city/county), i.e. the citizens.

I don't mean to sound pedantic, just having a conversation.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by wodenokoto on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:14AM (#21603785)
So police and firefighters shouldn’t be allowed to run red lights?
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by nothrabannosir on Friday November 22, 2019 @04:10AM (#21604044)
Not OP, but: not per se, no. Only in the pursuit of some specific task which requires them to do that. Just like a citizen can run a red light if they have to rush someone to a hospital.

Or at least I’d hope they can.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by thomasfedb on Friday November 22, 2019 @06:22AM (#21604623)
It's probably a defence rather than being directly permissable.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by nothrabannosir on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:32AM (#21605365)
Sure, but in the context of an ethics exploring thought experiment, those are the same. This is about what the law should be (if I understand the game correctly).
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Broken_Hippo on Friday November 22, 2019 @04:58AM (#21604271)
Well, this depends.

On the way to an emergency? Of course they should. And people should pull over.

And only sometimes while on the job. For example, if they catch someone for speeding and happen to go through a red light, I don't find that to be a grave thing. Speeding is easily a public hazard. Going off to investigate a theft where the thief has left the property, though? No need to run the light as the delay won't make a difference. Going to a car accident, especially with hurt folks or that is blocking traffic? Yes. Car accident in an open section of parking lot? Rarely necessary.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Spooky23 on Friday November 22, 2019 @07:48AM (#21605062)
They have protocols for that and generally follow them.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Broken_Hippo on Friday November 22, 2019 @12:48PM (#21607975)
Ambulances, sure. Firefighters? Yeah, usually. Cops? You'll have to convince me if you are talking about midwestern American cops. I know they go through lights... because. Or they'll hurry to something non-vital, where there is no one getting hurt, yet scurry none-the-less. I never realized how common this sort of thing was - lights and freaking sound - until I moved away.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Spooky23 on Friday November 22, 2019 @01:48PM (#21608634)
Are you listening to the police scanner or something? How do you know where or how they have been dispatched?

I live in a small northeast city off of an avenue where there are two trauma centers, a firehouse that does about 5,000 calls/year and a police HQ. I see and hear plenty of these vehicles. When you see it enough, you can spot the different patterns in how police, ambulances and fire trucks respond.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Broken_Hippo on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:55PM (#21609971)
1. I know the cops do the light thing simply by knowing a few cops.

2. I don't know where they are dispactched or anything. I could tell the difference between sirens though.

3. I know not all dispatches are emergencies that need lights, sounds, or running lights. If someone has broken into your business, for example, and the person is no longer there, there is no need for speed, lights, and so on. I'm in a larger city in another country now... and there are less sirens and stuff here. It is really weird. I know they respond and the crime rate is probably lower, but... priorities are different as well. I generally didn't see the same patterns with fire trucks and ambulances in the states, and honestly never had a complaint about them. Just the police.

Edited to add an afterthought.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by bluGill on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:06AM (#21606153)
Those protocols are why something like 95% of the time when you see an ambulance with the lights on there is nobody in the back. (The worst case of a broken leg is serious internal bleeding that only an expert can detect, then they get there and it is just a broken leg)
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:42AM (#21606546)
Not unless they are operating an emergency vehicle. That requires lights or siren to be active to qualify. Emergency flashers on a civilian vehicle do the same thing for everybody else.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by logfromblammo on Friday November 22, 2019 @01:13PM (#21608243)
Cops should not be allowed any power that is not available to every person, by virtue of their automatic eligibility for the county posse under authority of the sheriff, and for the state militia under authority of the governor.

Cops are supposed to be professionals, with keeping the civil order of their state and/or county and/or municipality as their full-time job, but the authority to arrest criminals historically extends from the sheriff of the county, to every person whom he or she may designate, either orally or in writing. If the sheriff asked for assistance from an ordinary person, and they effected an arrest, that was legally an official act of the sheriff. Similar extension-of-authority constructs exist for a municipal mayor/council, state governor, and federal president.

Without a preexisting order to assist, as one might have as a municipal cop or full-time county deputy, there is no official cover for an arrest, and the person making one would have personal liability, if they made a mistake. That privilege of immunity for mistakes made during establishment or maintenance of civil order is supposed to keep professional cops from being too fearful of civil liability lawsuit to do their jobs effectively. I would argue that they are now not fearful enough to conduct themselves in a manner consistent with their positions in the community, as part of it, simply being persons who have been given a standing order to assist the office of the president/governor/sheriff/mayor in their duty to keep civil order. They have now set themselves apart from the communities in which they live, behind the cordon of their thin blue lines, as adversaries to those whom they see as enemies of civil order.

As such, they have become blind to those occasions on which their actions are actually upsetting to the civil order. In other words, they get into some crazy bullshit legal arguments, and sometimes get away with it.

The privilege they enjoy is actually in having their personal actions taken as extensions of a higher lawful authority, rather than as their own.

It is established that the state has the authority to require that motor vehicle owners permanently affix a license plate to their vehicles, which remains the property of the state, and not remove it, and to return it to a designated authority on demand. But this is all written into public law. You can't just arbitrarily extend that power to some cop shop's magnetic GPS tracker. If you want it to be a crime to remove it, you have to write that into its own law. Otherwise, you have to follow the same law for theft (or unlawful conversion) as everyone else. And that opens up a reciprocal liability for putting your property on someone else's property without their authorization.

I suppose the opsec moral of the story is to drop found trackers onto the public road, or report it as lost property, instead of leaving it inside a locker. Putting a classified ad for lost property in the public notices section of the local paper for three consecutive weeks might have been a fun experiment in "fruit of the poisoned tree" lawyering.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by tw04 on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:15AM (#21605696)
So if I put a bumper sticker on your car and walk away, then come back 3 months later and ask for it back and you refuse, then that's stealing? Really?

Because I'd say me putting something on your private property is vandalism. And you removing said vandalism is in no way a crime. They didn't have a warrant, and their device wasn't identified as belonging to the authorities. Just because the police vandalized your property (without informing you about what they were doing) shouldn't* make it any more of a crime to remove than if a private citizen did it. This is the same bullshit that empowers police to harass minorities "because we're cops".

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by h4waii on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:18AM (#21606272)
IANAL, but doesn't vandalism sorta need destruction or damage to happen?

That level is destruction is open to interpretation, but it still requires some form of destruction or damage to be classified as vandalism.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by tw04 on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:40AM (#21606523)
Sure, and I doubt you would take someone to court over most definitions of vandalism. But I could pretty easily argue that when they affixed it to my car it scratched the clearcoat resulting in $XXX of damage.

CLEARLY he's not going to counter-sue, but it's ridiculous to claim it's THEFT when you violated my privacy/trespassed on/against my property while affixing the thing to my property (without a warrant) in the first place.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by a3n on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:38AM (#21606497)
The application of the bumper sticker is the vandalism, just like graffiti.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by magduf on Friday November 22, 2019 @11:20AM (#21606962)
Applying a bumper sticker is absolutely vandalism. It mars the paint finish. Paint on cars is surprisingly delicate, and is easily damaged by mechanical means, such as by setting objects on the roof. The bumper sticker itself won't hurt the paint, unless you leave it there for a long time, but trying to remove it is very likely to.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by alasdair_ on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:53AM (#21605516)
The battery in these units is often hooked to the car battery to keep it charged.

Theft of electricity is a crime. Indeed, before explicit computer intrusion laws, hackers used to be prosecuted for the theft of a few cents of electricity involved in the computation of their “crime”.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by itronitron on Friday November 22, 2019 @01:15AM (#21603248)
>> (I don't agree that Finders Keepers is a legal basis for ownership

you don't even have to find it, if something is in your car then the cops will insist that it's yours, although that doesn't necessarily make it a legal basis for ownership

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Hamuko on Friday November 22, 2019 @10:29AM (#21606391)
The police arguing that something being in your car doesn't mean that it's yours is a good thing for the bag of cocaine and explosives in my car.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by hanniabu on Friday November 22, 2019 @09:38AM (#21605893)
This sets a precedent for anybody that follows and tells them that if they want to arrest somebody they just need to put a tracker in a place they will find it so they can arrest them for theft afterwards.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by chrismcb on Friday November 22, 2019 @06:46AM (#21604735)
There is a valid argument that it is yours. If it's in your possession now. While you may not have ownership, you could imply that by someone attaching the item to your car they were giving it to you.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by Darmani on Friday November 22, 2019 @04:50AM (#21604234)
This is correct. Theft requires the mens rea of turning someone else's property into your own. If you mistakenly believe the item is yours, you cannot be guilty of thefttheft. IIRV, the same goes if you believe an item is abandoned.
Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by fnordfnordfnord on Friday November 22, 2019 @11:51AM (#21607329)
>All the police had to do was knock on his door and ask for it back. If he refused, that's grounds for theft.

No, it's not. For all the police knew, as you say, it could have fallen off on its own. Definitely not PC.

Re:Indiana man charged with theft for removing police tracki... by threatofrain on Friday November 22, 2019 @01:08PM (#21608200)
I shouldn’t be inconvenienced or violated in the attempt to return things to you though. In these kinds of morally dubious scenarios, either you make all effort or the materials in question fall below a level of societal notability.