News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Phoebus Cartel by andrepd on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:47PM (#21597798)
This is truly a "The Sun"-tier comment. So many things are wrong. The EU did not mandate halogen bulbs, it phased out incandescent bulbs, with many exceptions for situations and use-cases where alternatives are inadequate. You can (and should) buy LEDs which are many times more efficient and cheaper (per hour of life) that incandescent bulbs. Finally, halogen bulbs are not only not "mandated" but actually in the processed of being phased out as well.
[dead]
Re:Phoebus Cartel by andrepd on Thursday November 21, 2019 @07:41PM (#21601372)
I never said the poster was a "deplorable", so you must be projecting. The reference to The Scum is due to the fact that British tabloids have a recurring trope of making up ludicrous facts about "totalitarian EU regulations". I hope I cleared up that misunderstanding.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by uhhhhhhh on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:38PM (#21598534)
The comparison was to the Sun, which implies uninformed and inaccurate.

Your projection of "deplorable" is all of your own making.

A sign of the times, people being unable to accept being told they are wrong.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by the-dude on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:00PM (#21598827)
I'll refer to my sibling comment : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21597651

Thank you.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by big_chungus on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:30PM (#21598411)
LEDs still have PWM flicker and buzzing problems. This is unpleasant, inhibits focus, and makes them inadequate for me in all cases. Perhaps the fancy "smart bulbs" aren't as bad, but I don't have $125 for a single light bulb. I also don't want to fiddle around with my lighting and by multiple $125 bulbs until one works. I just want to put in a bulb and be done. The only lighting which has successfully done that for me has been incandescent or halogen.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by nicoburns on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:39PM (#21599329)
Smart bulbs often aren't any better than cheap ones. But there are people doing high quality ones (high CRI, and no flicker). These ones for example:

https://store.waveformlighting.com/collections/a19-bulbs/pro...

There are cheaper ones that are good too, but I can't remember the name.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by NullPrefix on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:38PM (#21600513)
> Smart bulbs often aren't any better than cheap ones.

But they can have telemetry.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by raverbashing on Thursday November 21, 2019 @04:20PM (#21599761)
You must be getting the absolute worse brand of LED lamp to have PWM flicker or using a crap dimer (or alternatively, have vision way beyond 60fps)

I have none of those problems with LED lamps that certainly didn't cost $125 (more like between 5x and 10x cheaper) and none of them buzz

Re:Phoebus Cartel by Majromax on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:46PM (#21600577)
> You must be getting the absolute worse brand of LED lamp to have PWM flicker or using a crap dimer

Related: is there any good source of reviews for LED bulbs that go into flicker (I seem to notice 120Hz flicker) and CRI? My local hardware store stocks a relatively paltry selection of bulbs (all built to cost), and I'm reluctant to experiment with the medium-size orders necessary to make shipping worthwhile.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by baybal2 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:24PM (#21599144)
If you see flicker, then you bought an LED lamp with a wrong kind of driver. You can dim LEDs to zero without any visible flicker if the circuit is designed properly
Re:Phoebus Cartel by gsich on Thursday November 21, 2019 @06:42PM (#21600992)
Not all use PWM.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by phaemon on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:34PM (#21597626)
The EU did not mandate that you use halogen bulbs.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by the-dude on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:36PM (#21597651)
Thanks for the comment, you are correct. It is one of the two viable replacements at the time of the incandescent ban : halogen or fluorescent.

Now we have LED.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#21597731)
Re:Phoebus Cartel by kps on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:54PM (#21598738)
Most ‘filament’ LED bulbs are driverless and flicker horribly.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by LargoLasskhyfv on Thursday November 21, 2019 @07:59PM (#21601478)
Could be, mine don't. And i consider myself sensitve to flickering. I just grabbed some from the hardware store while i was there and saw them on special offer. Some well known brand name. Guess i've been lucky.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by phaemon on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:06PM (#21598090)
The EU is its members. Every EU country voted to phase out incandescent bulbs, so that includes yours. This was not something imposed on your country against its will.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by pkaye on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:52PM (#21599464)
I had about 12 halogen recessed lights in my house. I replaced them with LED retrofit recessed lights and so far over three years none of them have failed. The LEDs are brighter and more power efficient. I think I paid for their cost over one year due to power savings and not even considering that I would be replacing one halogen bulb every month or two.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by l33tbro on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:43PM (#21598625)
LED's also have an inferior light quality to incandescent. The color rendering index of the average LED is usualy 70-80, usually with horrible green spikes.

Incandescent lights are blackbody radiators and have a CRI of 100. So the quality of light and color rendering is equivalent to daylight.

Bums me out to hear that they're being phased-out in some places.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by nicoburns on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:41PM (#21599343)
It's not hard to find CRI 95 led bulbs. I have a couple that are CRI 97. They really do look like incandescents (or at least, much much closer than typical leds). The only issue I've had is that you only seem to be able to get them up to around 800 lumens.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by Jamwinner on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:56PM (#21599513)
You just clearly explained how they are inferior in multiple ways, even if carefully researched and mitigated for. Most people just want what worked, to keep working as well as it did.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by mc3 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:03PM (#21600200)
Getting used to not having what we had before is going to be the theme of this century, with environmental change. I have LEDs at home, no idea what spec, but honestly they are more than good enough. Prefer them to candles, or darkness.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by nicoburns on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:51PM (#21600625)
They also consume considerably less energy, run cooler, and last longer. A single 100W lightbulb consumes more energy than running my entire computer. What we want hasn't got much to do with it. Continuing to use inefficient devices will result in a planet that no longer functions. Nobody wants that.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by RachelF on Thursday November 21, 2019 @06:56PM (#21601110)
I've noticed that new LED backlit screens tend to be harder on my eyes then the old CCL backlit ones. Perhaps it's just me getting old though?
Re:Phoebus Cartel by bensonn on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:13PM (#21600292)
The incandescent light bulb ban is one of those things that can still get me fired up a decade later.

The idea that LEDs are now cheap, or cheaper seems like a tough argument. 4 packs of Phillips 40 or 60 watts used to be sold at the dollar store. $.25 cents per bulb. Or any hardware store had them for $1.19. Home depot currently has LED bulbs for 1.25 per bulb, 5x the price, IF you buy in bulk. 1.75 (7x the price) per bulb if you don't buy in bulk. If you aren't middle class or above $10 is a decent chunk of money. $10 is deciding between dinner or light, not both. The ban was indirectly a regressive tax that hurts the poor. Maybe if you spend money to buy in bulk then 2 years down the road you will be financially better off than if you bought incandescent bulbs. The poor don't have that option and the rich won't notice the pennies in savings.

The inefficiencies by heat loss doesn't make sense either unless you live in a very hot climate. Even in the PNW which is fairly mild, 9 months out of the year you the heat is on anyway. If the other 3 months are bright and sunny you probably don't have that many lights on.

I used to keep a light on in my well house to keep it just above freezing during winter. Had I not bought hundreds of incandescent light bulbs and stockpiled them I would have had to run a heater. The point here- a nation wide ban is overkill.

Conspiracy theory- I bet light bulb manufactures loved this ban, they probably even lobbied in support of it. Consumers have to pay 7x the price, sweet!

At least the ban solved the climate crisis.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by NullPrefix on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:37PM (#21600503)
60 Watt incandescent can be replaced by under 10 Watt LED. Assuming 50 Watt savings.

Assuming $0.10 kW/h (California is $0.16 ??). 1 hour of LED burn time saves 50W / 1000 * 0.10 kW/h = $0.005

Assuming LED bulb costs $2, assuming incandescent bulb is free. $2 / $0.005 = 400 hours until break even.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by jwilk on Friday November 22, 2019 @03:17AM (#21603801)
You got the units wrong, but the end result is correct:

50W × $0.10/kWh = $0.005/h

$2 / ($0.005/h) = 400h

Re:Phoebus Cartel by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:34AM (#21605387)
> 4 packs of Phillips 40 or 60 watts used to be sold at the dollar store. $.25 cents per bulb. Or any hardware store had them for $1.19. Home depot currently has LED bulbs for 1.25 per bulb, 5x the price, IF you buy in bulk. 1.75 (7x the price) per bulb if you don't buy in bulk.

Which is a nonsensical comparison, given that (good) LED lamps (which you can get at around that price) not only save a ton of energy, but also last a lot longer. Those 1.75 give you the same amount of light over their lifetime as 2.50 worth of incandescents you buy in bulk, so it's already cheaper even if you ignore the energy savings.

> Maybe if you spend money to buy in bulk then 2 years down the road you will be financially better off than if you bought incandescent bulbs.

Suppose you are a poor family. An incandescent light bulb fails. What do you do? Well, you move the bulb from your most-used lamp to the one where the bulb failed. Then, you buy a single LED bulb for 1.75 and put it in that most-used lamp. Assuming your typical household, your most-used lamp probably is a "60 W" lamp that gets at least 3 hours of use per day.

The replacement LED with the same light output uses about 8 W, possibly less. At 52 W less power consumption, that means that at (1.75 - 1) / .1 / (52 / 1000) = 144 hours of use, or about 48 days, they have already saved the 75 cents that they paid above the price for the four-pack of incandescents. Another 108 days later, they have saved another 1.75 in energy costs, so now they can buy the next LED without exceeding the total cost of 1 dollar.

So, yes, you have to be able to invest an additional 75 cents for less than two months in order to be able to switch over to LEDs. I am not saying that that can't be a problem for some, but you are sure way overblowing the scale of it.

In the long run, every single LED you buy saves you around 50 bucks total (replacement and energy costs), so once you have managed to come up with that 75 cent investment capital at the start it's about the best thing you can do if you are poor, and in no time you will be able to buy LEDs in bulk, too. Except, of course, that doesn't really make much sense because they last so long, so you are probably better of buying single bulbs when you need them, because they only get cheaper and more efficient. An incandescent bulb that you changed once a year you won't need to change for the next ten years if you switch to LEDs.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by bensonn on Friday November 22, 2019 @11:01AM (#21606758)
Wow, you used a lot math, I mostly made up my numbers and then made guesstimates based on those. :) $50 saving per bulb- holy shintos!

I concede, in most climates and most use-cases LEDs are a better buy. Most of my overhead lights are LED bulbs. I am not anti-LED or an LED-denier!

The whole thing just seems bizarre, even years later. Light bulbs are a small part of household electricity usage- water heater, heating/cooling, appliances, etc take more energy. Household electricity is a small part of all energy use- changes in industrial and transportation would have a bigger impact. While light bulbs represent a tiny fraction of overall power consumption they are probably the most visible and commonly used/purchased item. As a general rule it doesn't make sense to target areas that will cause the most disruption, to the most people to provide the smallest impact- if there has been any impact at all. Has anybody measured the impact? I tried to search for results of the ban but didn't really find anything meaningful. Has household electricity/ft2 usage dropped?

I would be curious if electricity usage did not drop at all. "oh it is an LED and is efficient so I will leave it on all day" I am sure there is a name for the effect/paradox. As far as I know impact wasn't measured. Is it another, "we did something, pat on the back" projects with no meaningful improvements?

Re:Phoebus Cartel by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Friday November 22, 2019 @02:25PM (#21609060)
> $50 saving per bulb- holy shintos!

... and that's with your cheap US electricity prices!

> Light bulbs are a small part of household electricity usage- water heater, heating/cooling, appliances, etc take more energy.

Well, that really depends on where you live, though. Here in Germany, heating mostly uses natural gas and oil, and AC is uncommon in homes, so lighting is a bigger percentage of electricity use. And potentially also of energy use, because heating with electricity is way less efficient than burning the fuel in your home in terms of primary energy use.

But also, you just have to take the efficiency gains that you can get, and that one was, overall, an easy one to get. If heating is 90% of your electricity use, but you have no way to make that more efficient, it's of no use that it's 90% of your electricity use. Lighting was overall easy to do, plus it didn't even cost anything, but rather saves everyone a not that insignificant amount of money now. Plus, for the migration to renewable energy, the efficiency of lighting is more important than the efficiency of other energy uses: You only need AC when the sun is shining and thus solar power is available, while you need lighting when the sun is down, and people generally want to be able to switch on light whenever they feel like it, while most bigger consumers of electric energy can deal relatively well with shifting their load profile: You can stop charging your car, or heating your house, or cooling your fridge, or washing your clothes for an hour of high demand/low availability without any impact on usability, but just shutting off all lights isn't really an option.

> changes in industrial and transportation would have a bigger impact

Well, maybe, but at what cost? It's trivial to have a "bigger impact" if you have infinite resources to spend. The interesting question is how much impact you can have per investment, and one that gives you a 50 bucks return on every dollar invested (or so) is pretty good based on that measure.

> As a general rule it doesn't make sense to target areas that will cause the most disruption

Except ... this didn't cause any disruption? You had good lighting options available all the way, the migration to LEDs was to be expected, and now everyone is saving money. Where is the disruption in that?

> I would be curious if electricity usage did not drop at all.

Chances are it didn't, but that's simply because people have more devices that use electricity now. I.e.: It would have risen if not for LEDs. But then, the switch to LEDs, while most visible, is not the only thing that's going on, the EU at least also has regulation on the efficiency and standby consumption of power supplies now, which also reduces energy consumption of new devices (or old ones, if you swap out the power supply).

> "oh it is an LED and is efficient so I will leave it on all day" I am sure there is a name for the effect/paradox.

I think "rebound effect" is the term, and I suspect there's probably some of that. But then, it's an about 8-fold increase in efficiency, so it's not that easy to use up again. I am pretty sure people don't use more than eight times the light now than before, and if they use twice as much, it's still clearly a win.

> As far as I know impact wasn't measured.

Well, it's probably difficult to do so, to any degree of accuracy, so possibly not. But it seems very unlikely that it was useless.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by papreclip on Thursday November 21, 2019 @05:51PM (#21600624)
LED bulbs are much, much more expensive, don't live up to their advertised lifetime in my experience, cause problems when used with dimmers, produce more problematic waste...

Most importantly, the light is of vastly inferior quality. You will never match the beautiful spectrum of incandescent light with LED or fluorescent.

A few decades down the line we will be reflecting on how the LED cartel took us all to the cleaners

Re:Phoebus Cartel by solotronics on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:28PM (#21597543)
why not use LED lights? at this point they are much cheaper and a magnitude more efficient compared with halogen
Re:Phoebus Cartel by unlinked_dll on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:37PM (#21597663)
Seriously, they're not that expensive. I haven't changed a lightbulb in like 2 years, except for moving. Haven't even needed to buy any new ones since my city utility got some state subsidies (or something along those lines) and gives out bulbs multiple times a year.

Also would advocate for more strip lighting in homes. Looks better and saves a lot of space. My home office is all strip lighting.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by dsego on Thursday November 21, 2019 @07:31PM (#21601308)
They do loose some of the light over the years. I read it somewhere online, a guy tested the output after a few years and compared to new ones. Don't know correctly, but it was something like ~10-20% of loss in 2-3 years or something. I'm probably way off, but it was definitely not insignificant.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by gaius_baltar on Thursday November 21, 2019 @01:46PM (#21597788)
> why not use LED lights?

OP didn't provide details, but sometimes LEDs are a no-go, e.g., RFI from the internal power source in lab environments.

Re:Phoebus Cartel by nicoburns on Thursday November 21, 2019 @03:42PM (#21599352)
That's the exception though. You could probably still use incandescents for that purpose (I believe the EU regulations have exceptions for this kind of thing). Most people can use LEDs just fine.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by dsego on Thursday November 21, 2019 @07:22PM (#21601255)
Halogens burn out quickly, I think it's because they run too hot. I had a bunch of them in my previous apartment, and had to replace a bulb every few months or so. There were even dark marks on the ceiling from the heat.
Re:Phoebus Cartel by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Friday November 22, 2019 @08:10AM (#21605205)
> Halogens burn out quickly

No, they don't, they last about twice as long as normal incandescents.

> I had a bunch of them in my previous apartment, and had to replace a bulb every few months or so.

Which says nothing. How long did they last? And did you compare to normal incandescents in the same appartment? Some places have increased mains voltage that just causes bulbs to burn out faster. BTW a problem that you can avoid with high-quality LEDs.

> There were even dark marks on the ceiling from the heat.

Well, possibly there was, but the solution to that is CFL or LEDs, not normal incandescents, because those produce even more heat. Halogen are more efficient because they run the filament hotter, but therefore the amount of heat they give off is lower (lower wattage for the same amount of light, plus higher proportion of that is converted to light instead of heat).