News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:38PM (#21431188)
It's kind of his "thing" to bounce around to different, interesting projects. He wrote the x86_64 spec while working at AMD (and was responsible for the K8s ala Athlon 64s), he played a big part in Apple getting their SoCs to best-in-class, and that's not nearly all he's done.

Incredibly accomplished man, I don't think he's going to stay in one place for very long. He'll probably come back to AMD at some point or another.

Re:AMD is having its day by sufiyan on Sunday November 03, 2019 @04:23AM (#21432930)
You really need to look a little more at Jim and his style. He has been around from the time of DEC (Digital Equipment Corporation). And has been a great engineer. But what sets him apart is not his technical competence, but his ability to organise great teams around him and get the work done. And he has always been the person who has been given the reins of companies in crisis. It is a marvel how he manages to get the product back up.
Re:AMD is having its day by Bombthecat on Sunday November 03, 2019 @04:48AM (#21432998)
Connections. I bet he has a hoard of people willing to work for him. Even if pay would be low. They know it will succeed. So he can assamble an avangers team (pun intended)
Re:AMD is having its day by K0SM0S on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:28PM (#21431391)
I'm seriously hoping he gets on board a big RISC-V project eventually, and contributes to pull this baby off to the races.
Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:38PM (#21431438)
RISC-V already has more accomplished people than Keller working on it, and I don't think his presence is required for it to continue to get better.

What RISC-V needs at this point is marketing and a company with a dedicated sales team, not technical competency.

Re:AMD is having its day by lliamander on Sunday November 03, 2019 @01:59AM (#21432431)
Now that POWER is fully open, it will be interesting to see which RISC architecture becomes the x86 challenger (if either). RISC-V is eating up Intel (and ARM) from below, but POWER has the, well, power to compete at top of the line (before Zen 2 came out, anyway). The next gen POWER is supposed to be built on Samsung's 7nm process.

If RISC-V wins, it will be because it has a better developer/enthusiast/hacker story, but if so it will take a longer time to get there.

Either way, I hope for he sake of our infrastructure that an open standard wins out, and that we have enough competing manufacturers that we never have a repeat of Intel's utter dominance.

Re:AMD is having its day by floatboth on Sunday November 03, 2019 @07:19AM (#21433430)
POWER is basically only top of the line though, other than the relatively rare NXP QorIQ chips that were used in e.g. AmigaOne stuff.

Most of the hype for RISC-V seems to be in tiny embedded stuff (e.g. WD's disk controllers) and academia (naturally). SiFive has finally made an out-of-order core, but I don't really see the market for big unix-capable RISC-V. RISC-V is really a royalty-free "MIPS in a trenchcoat", so expect it to be used where MIPS is used now.

ARM is everywhere, from smartphones (unfortunately Qualcomm dominance, but Apple is kicking ass in performance) to AWS EC2 (in-house silicon!) to massive HPC clusters (Fujitsu A64FX is impressive, they use HBM2 RAM (!) to make a SIMD-capable CPU into something almost GPU-like in a way). AWS has basically ensured that ARM is the next ISA for servers :P

Re:AMD is having its day by K0SM0S on Sunday November 03, 2019 @05:29PM (#21437174)
I'm certainly not downplaying ARM's domination in general, but don't take this bit for granted:

> AWS has basically ensured that ARM is the next ISA for servers :P

These hyper-scalers (inc. Microsoft, Google, Alibaba...) will take a little bit of everything, because they generally can always find cookie-cutter workloads impeccably suited to any architecture, but also as industrial diversification, for R&D, etc. Like AMD, the presence of some ARM CPUs in the biggest datacenters says little about market forces, what matters is how many actual FLOPS are effectively handled by each vendor. I'm positive Intel still has the lion share, and the inflexion point in favor of AMD (nearest competitor) would be 2023 at best, more likely 2025-26 assuming Intel eventually catches up in price/perf/W.

A reasonably heterogenous infrastructure is very good when you're an order of magnitude bigger than entire datacenters, or so I hear.

I share your concern that RISC-V is currently largely confined to the MIPS space; and indeed it's a totally different ballgame to break into ARM's space, let alone x86 (but I don't see why RISC-V would seek the latter, especially considering POWER is up there).

Re:AMD is having its day by MayeulC on Sunday November 03, 2019 @03:26AM (#21432787)
The open source community has been questionning RISC-V's openess lately [1]. While I wish they could correct that, maybe that could give POWER an edge.

[1] https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Libre-RI...

Re:AMD is having its day by K0SM0S on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:49PM (#21431489)
I don't really know what you mean by “more accomplished people than Keller” but I sure do share your overview.

My point was more that economies of scale happen with killer products (e.g. how CISC won over RISC back in the 90's, it wasn't about tech but about product, and as you say it falls down to sales and marketing). Somehow a guy like Jim got involved in some of the best scalers out there (AMD's x64, Apple's A chips, Tesla's self-driving AI, AMD's Zen, now something at Intel with 3D stacking most likely, and next...?)

Here's to RISC-V, anyhow!

Re:AMD is having its day by 0xcde4c3db on Saturday November 02, 2019 @11:21PM (#21431907)
To me, David Patterson is the most obvious person who might qualify for that description. He (co-)wrote the book on computer architecture and how it relates to performance (Computer Architecture: A Quantitative Approach) and led development of RISC-I and RISC-II ("RISC-V" is a reference to this lineage; I believe other projects not officially bearing the "RISC" name were counted as III and IV).
Re:AMD is having its day by K0SM0S on Sunday November 03, 2019 @12:51AM (#21432261)
He's a giant, no question about it.

I just hope the people involved in RISC-V are collectively able, as an industry, to deliver the kind of fabrication process backbone funded by great products 'agressively' marketed that saw the victory of pretty much all standards — CPU instruction sets very much included. A combination of very applied engineering + shrewd business mindset.

Re:AMD is having its day by 0xcde4c3db on Sunday November 03, 2019 @10:08AM (#21434252)
I think RISC-V is going to win for fundamentally the same reason that ARM won: it removes obstacles between product teams and processor cores. ARM didn't win by having the best instruction set design or the most advanced architecture, it won because licensing it was less of a hassle than licensing a different core/ISA. It's like ARM had a "buy now" button where everyone else had "contact sales" buttons. But extending that metaphor, RISC-V is "you don't need to click a button; it's already on your porch".

I assume that RISC-V still has a gap (relative to ARM) between the ISA/HDL levels and getting to an actual tape-out. But I think SiFive et. al. can tackle it.

Re:AMD is having its day by hakfoo on Sunday November 03, 2019 @03:55PM (#21436528)
I think there were a couple reasons ARM won:

* ARM wasn't directly in the manufacturing business. This meant they weren't a supply chokepoint when demand scaled by a factor of thousands. Just take the IP core and fab it yourself!

* They triangulated the market unexpectedly well.

There was a definite gap in the market between "performance at any cost" big architectures (x86/Itanium/Power/PA-RISC/SPARC) and "Draws no current, but gets winded running the clock for a VCR" (6502/Z80/68HC11/Atmel/PIC) little ones. For a long time, this was filled by on an ad-hoc basis-- one-off designs for game consoles, set-top boxes, and ahead-of-their-time smart appliances. Most of these were closed, single-vendor, no-interoperability systems where "ease of integration" and "off the shelf tools" didn't really matter, so we had all sorts of bit players.

It took the arrival of full-power handheld devices with third-party software support (PDAs and then smartphones) for a large demand to appear, and ARM was ready with a product line that fit the space well.

Compare the alternative, a world where we had had x86-based Windows CE devices and eventually iPhones. Intel/AMD/VIA would have been scrambling to put together the diversity of custom designs these devices cried out for. It would have required a massive respin of their architectures (look how hard it was to get Atom into a phone-ready state, and even then it did poorly) and then backlogged their foundries.

Re:AMD is having its day by dnautics on Saturday November 02, 2019 @11:54PM (#21432043)
Patterson also worked on TPUv1 (iirc) and that wasn't so hot.
Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:53PM (#21431502)
I don't really know what you mean by “more accomplished people than Keller” but I sure do share your overview.

Look at the SiFive team for starters. Anyway, here's to RISC-V!

Re:AMD is having its day by Roritharr on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:55PM (#21431266)
I wish I knew what his secret is.

He can't be a genius of THAT magnitude, that would be a miracle.

Re:AMD is having its day by ownagefool on Sunday November 03, 2019 @04:25AM (#21432934)
There probably isn't a secret so much as he's a guy that likes to deliver and companies let him.

I go to company to company consultanting, and the companies almost always have very competent staff they just don't listen to.

Re:AMD is having its day by S_A_P on Sunday November 03, 2019 @10:56AM (#21434592)
This! I also consult and have been to quite a few companies. Often I find that the most assertive person is who gets the ideas/perspectives pushed through, not necessarily the most competent. Sometimes the confidence comes from experience and usually that leads to ok decision making. Other times not so much.
Re:AMD is having its day by baybal2 on Sunday November 03, 2019 @05:20AM (#21433095)
Just lots of experience. Normally, people don't hang out in semi as much as in software engineering, and that itself is extremely short.

Semiconductor engineering was hurt badly when it tried to borrow work culture from the dotcom world, and treating engineers as disposables.

I myself know of other man of equal magnitude in the analog world. He worked in electronics for 24 years, most of it in China. He worked for one of my employer, where he was deservingly fired for failing a potentially multi-million buck project. Apple hired him, literally, next week. I have suspicion he had his hands on Apple's Air Pods.

It was tough to work with him, he has a reputation of "Shenzhen's Rob Widlar." Very few companies can make a working environment for him.

Re:AMD is having its day by goldcd on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:19PM (#21431353)
The total of the investment in a new architecture/chip is significantly higher than one guys salary (although I presume he's compensated very well).

Maybe it's just once the corporate gears of a company have aligned to invest in something new/interesting - he's interested and they're paying.

Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:56PM (#21431274)
If you ask most people who have familiarity with x86_64, I'm certain they would use a different term than "genius."

Though the first step for you would be to work on projects you're more passionate about, and that are more technically challenging. A billing site (judging by your HN about section) won't challenge you in a way that will make you get better.

Re:AMD is having its day by jandrese on Saturday November 02, 2019 @11:34PM (#21431953)
But the funny thing is he leaves behind a string of industry defining successes in his wake. You can't argue that he's not tremendously influential and successful in the traditional sense.

He's the Kelly Johnson of silicon.

Re:AMD is having its day by mzarate06 on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:30PM (#21431397)
> If you ask most people who have familiarity with x86_64, I'm certain they would use a different term than "genius."

What term do you think they'd use, and why?

Re:AMD is having its day by amluto on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:46PM (#21431472)
Mostly backwards compatible hack.
Re:AMD is having its day by zaarn on Sunday November 03, 2019 @03:55AM (#21432837)
For a backwards compatible hack it works good enough. And "good enough" usually beats "better".
Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:50PM (#21431496)
"The reason we're stuck with this shitty fifty year old architecture that's steadily gotten worse through every iteration," "Satan," "Evil Computational War Criminal," a few less nice terms.

If you ask a Sun employee: "Enemy #1."

Less sarcastically: "slightly above average."

x86_64 is a nightmare, and we're a decade behind where we could be because it was what the industry settled for.

Re:AMD is having its day by CamouflagedKiwi on Sunday November 03, 2019 @12:25AM (#21432168)
That seems extremely unlikely. If a new architecture could offer that much advantage (a decade is massive in this space) surely there'd be some pressure to move. One could easily imagine Apple moving to ARM, for example.

Unfortunately, I think a much more likely situation is that x86 (/64) is only slightly hobbling things, and Intel are easily able to push past that with technical craftiness. As in many other cases, implementation trumps theoretical design.

Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Sunday November 03, 2019 @12:30AM (#21432192)
Apple is moving to ARM, the most recent iPad Pro outperforms its laptop line (last I saw, at least), they've spent a fraction of what Intel, AMD, and VIA have invested into x86_64, and basically every major Apple leak mentions that they're investigating moving the Mac line to ARM in a generation or two.

A new architecture can offer that much advantage; x86_64 wasn't even the third most-performant implemented ISA when it was released, and every other ISA makes gains far faster than it. SPARC and POWER are still competitive with it despite having 1/1,000,000th the amount invested in them, and in just a few years and with comparatively nothing invested into it, RISC-V is starting to rival a portion of the chips (though not the upper line of them yet).

It "won" because of backwards compatibility, nothing more.

Re:AMD is having its day by CamouflagedKiwi on Sunday November 03, 2019 @01:44AM (#21432398)
That's just not the case; Apple were already well behind in performance at the point x86_64 came out, due to them being stuck on POWER. They actively moved to x86, despite big compatibility issues, because of how much better they were.

The evidence is that architectures are just not as important as all that. x86 is clearly pretty bad in many ways, but clever tricks and microcoding have been able to overcome those issues.

Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Sunday November 03, 2019 @01:51AM (#21432410)
That's just not the case; Apple were already well behind in performance at the point x86_64 came out, due to them being stuck on POWER. They actively moved to x86, despite big compatibility issues, because of how much better they were.

This is a complete misinterpretation of the above comment.

Re:AMD is having its day by bsder on Sunday November 03, 2019 @01:17AM (#21432488)
> Apple were already well behind in performance at the point x86_64 came out, due to them being stuck on POWER.

The issue was chipsets and peripherals, not POWER performance (which generally always beat x86 at the same point).

The problem was that the entire ecosystem was built around communicating with an x86. So, you couldn't get a Northbridge or Southbridge equivalent that was even remotely close in performance or power consumption to those in x86 space.

Unless you decided that you were going to take on everything in chip design, you couldn't compete. And Apple didn't decide to take on everything until Intel told Apple to pound sand and pissed Jobs off.

Re:AMD is having its day by tigershark on Sunday November 03, 2019 @04:51AM (#21433006)
Absolutely false. They had to use liquid cooling in their top Mac at the time and it was still behind an opteron. Then the intel core architecture came out and pretty much destroyed it performance wise.
Re:AMD is having its day by goatinaboat on Sunday November 03, 2019 @06:54AM (#21433357)
The way I remember is that they couldn't get a PPC of the current (at the time) generation suitable for laptops - too power hungry, too hot. IBM weren't interested in supplying such a part so Apple were really left with no choice. It was a similar story of moving from 68k to PPC - the 68060 wasn't what they needed.
Re:AMD is having its day by fluffy87 on Sunday November 03, 2019 @06:18AM (#21433236)
There has never been a PowerPC system that beats x86 at any price point.
Re:AMD is having its day by bsder on Sunday November 03, 2019 @06:16PM (#21437450)
You are far too young.

The 601 based PowerPC's were the first to be able to do 3D graphics on the microprocessor well.

The G4 based titanium Powerbooks were sufficiently better that they became iconic at a time that Apple wasn't regarded that well.

Sure, the G5 and up were disastrous, but the writing was on the wall well before that. Chipsets on the G3 and G4-based systems used more power than the processor and that only became untrue because the G5 was quite so poor.

Re:AMD is having its day by foldr on Sunday November 03, 2019 @04:19AM (#21432918)
>not POWER performance (which generally always beat x86 at the same point).

Do you have a source for this? First time I've seen anyone claim that the G5 was competitive with contemporary Intel CPUs.

Re:AMD is having its day by usrusr on Sunday November 03, 2019 @06:41AM (#21433312)
Contemporary Apple marketing that was extremely proficient at putting Power in a favorable light (just sneak enough Altivec into every comparison to make up for the rest) + every single (of the then few) Mac users who parotted it religiously?

Those were different times for Apple. The ship was noticeably turned, but the storm not over yet.

Re:AMD is having its day by geerlingguy on Sunday November 03, 2019 @09:56AM (#21434184)
By the time the G5 required massive liquid cooling rigs and was nowhere near ready for laptop use... even die-hard Mac users were not parroting the party line any more. For most, the Intel move was a welcome one, as that was also during the height of the move from desktop to laptop. There was almost no chance for a decent G5-based laptop, at least not one as nice and sleek as the G4s that were already in existence.
Re:AMD is having its day by nl on Sunday November 03, 2019 @07:20AM (#21433437)
Amusingly we can compare it with a clean design that was supposed to replace x86: Itanium. That had the full weight of Intel and partners behind it and was such a flop that it's been completely ignored in this thread.

X86_64 is genius because it is the perfect example of the art of the possible.

It drove SPARC into irrelevance, forced Intel to adopt it instead of Itanium and drove PowerPC out of consumer computers. I'd love to have a nightmare like that on my resume.

Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Sunday November 03, 2019 @06:04PM (#21437377)
I was going to mention Itanium, but didn't want to go through the "But Itanium was terrible!!!!!" flamewar that happens every time it gets brought up.
Re:AMD is having its day by tux1968 on Saturday November 02, 2019 @11:32PM (#21431947)
Where could I read more about this analysis? Genuinely interested to understand how x86_64 is such an albatross and more details about what could be accomplished in its absence.
Re:AMD is having its day by kick on Sunday November 03, 2019 @12:14AM (#21432127)
Previous HN thread on (some of) the failures of x86 itself (it notes that most of this is not solved with x86_64):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=276418

There's plenty of criticism of CISC in general, but that gets into flamewar status.

A lot of modern abstraction, vulnerabilities and inefficiency can be summed up with "x86_64 sucks to write for, so let's build a new (or recreate an old) abstract machine!"

In its quest to maintain fifty years of (near) compatibility with an architecture originally used in a calculator, the industry created a monster.

There's a reason Apple (and Sun and MIPS before it) was able to get competitive with Intel's chips despite only getting a silicon team like half a decade ago and using an architecture generally seen as low-performance: they ruthlessly removed cruft, cutting ties with backwards compatibility in the process.

Backwards compatibility is a scourge unto innovation and ease of use, as even Intel saw (IA64, for all of its faults, was better than x86_64 in virtually every way).

I have a lot more criticism of x86_64, and can get a lot more technical in that criticism, but this comment is already getting a bit on the heavy side.

Re:AMD is having its day by sharpneli on Sunday November 03, 2019 @03:34AM (#21432802)
IA64 had a glaring fault that trumps all of it’s advantages. It was explicitly a vliw design, so the user had to, or compiler, manually set multiple different kind of ops per single instructions.

Modern superscalar OoO is pretty much like that, except there is a piece of hardware internally that does it, almost like a hardware jitter. This freedom both means the magical compiler doesn’t have to exist but also it allows processors to have varying amount of execution units. See that you could actually use one more int alu? Just add it and even older software is able to automatically get the benefit.

Re:AMD is having its day by nl on Sunday November 03, 2019 @09:14PM (#21438422)
Ironically the link you posted supports the opposite view: that x86_64 is ugly but that isn't really an issue. Quote:

in summary: x86 is ugly (and below is why I think so) but we don't care because compilers enable us to just forget about what ISA we're using. This is a good thing. This is the way it should be. But it's also an example of what the OP was talking about -- bad hardware design (in this case the x86 ISA; the actual hardware is quite good) not mattering because software is sufficiently good

Re:AMD is having its day by Razengan on Sunday November 03, 2019 @11:54AM (#21434986)
That is admirable and pleasantly envious. Smart people like that being able to work on what they want at any organization they want makes everything better for everyone: the corporations, the users and the world in general.