News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by kumarvvr on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:47AM (#21418700)
I am curious as to what an art critic's view of such abstract paintings are. Like, in what way is Number 17a worth 200 million?

To me all I see is squiggly lines and random colors.

I do enjoy art, but mostly old school art, say Van Gogh. Paintings that depict expressions, humans, situations, etc.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by WhompingWindows on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:14PM (#21423219)
First off, Van Gogh is not even close to old school, he painted less than 150 years ago. Second, the main reason for high valuations in modern art is because the artists were well-connected and got to their ideas first. Modern art is about concepts, not representation of real-life. Thus, you have a blank white canvas next to the greatest "old school" Van Gogh Monet masterpieces in NYC and Paris.

Consider, those blank white canvases take very little skill and creativity to produce. What they are a snapshot of a moment in art where very rich, well connected artists got to the idea of a blank white canvas as a message "first." Thus, they staked their flag in the ground and claimed that signpost in the long road of art history, and their rich, well-connected art selling friends probably convinced some gullible curators and collectors that those completely contentless abstractions are somehow valuable.

I'll give Pollock and others their due, that is some very interesting technique. However, as an oil painter myself, I believe the solid color canvasses hanging in museums are a slap in the face to the craftsmanship and sheer genius of the great painters, Pollock included.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by pmoriarty on Saturday November 02, 2019 @12:18AM (#21425862)
"I believe the solid color canvasses hanging in museums are a slap in the face to the craftsmanship and sheer genius of the great painters, Pollock included."

While I'm not a fan of solid color canvasses myself, I don't object to them on the grounds of lack of craftsmanship, as I've seen plenty of paintings with masterful craftsmanship which I find don't move me in the least and which I find utterly boring and without value (such as Chuck Close paintings or other hyper/photorealist work). Conversely, I'm a great fan of children's artwork -- art that almost by definition completely lacks any skill or craftsmanship at all. I find it a lot more refreshing and original than much art by highly educated and skilled adult artists.

The same goes for some "naive" or "outsider" art, art of the mentally ill, and "primitive" art. All of these vary in skill level, of course, but even those created without much if any skill are often very powerful and show me a new and different way of looking at the world than what I get in traditional academic or popular art.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by Zeebrommer on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:34PM (#21423419)
Would you count Rothko under the solid colour canvasses? On paper they don't look like much, but the few that I've seen in real life somehow still really left an impression on me.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by cromulent on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:47PM (#21423536)
That brought back memories of this great podcast:

https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-many-deaths-of-a-...

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by phaus on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:48PM (#21423553)
They are aesthetically pleasing to me. I might even hang some prints on a wall, but it would be to add some color, not because I find them to be a superior display of artistic ability.

To be fair a lot of simple looking art like this is produced by artists with a sound understanding of composition and color theory. For some of them everything they do is done with intention and thought. However, having a sound understanding of color theory and composition are just two basic skills any good artist will possess in addition to a multitude of other skills.

Note that I'm not saying that artists have to adhere to standard color theory and composition. I'm saying that when people deviate from them usually the good ones do it in an intentional way with a full understanding, and the specific way they break the rules is well thought out and so it works.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by tonyedgecombe on Monday November 04, 2019 @06:41AM (#21440729)
Second, the main reason for high valuations in modern art is because the artists were well-connected and got to their ideas first.

I think this is what gets under my skin. I don't really have a problem with the artists, anybody who is able to fleece a few million from the super rich is doing a public service as far as I'm concerned.

It's the people in the galleries, auction houses and general art world that get up my nose. The ones that tell you you are a philistine because you can't appreciate a somewhat random splattering of paint or an unmade bed. We already have empirical evidence[1] that wine snobs don't know what they are talking about, perhaps we should try and find the same for art snobs.

[1] https://www.realclearscience.com/blog/2014/08/the_most_infam...

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @02:48PM (#21422395)
Art criticism is no different than any other field... it's completely baffling to people without education in it, and makes total and obvious sense to those who do.

I went to the University of Iowa, which has Jackson Pollock's Mural, his most important painting. It's worth about $250M. I'd just stare at it for long periods of time. It's extraordinary, breathtaking, a symphony of squiggly lines - but in no way random. The figures and sense of right-to-left motion are quite clear, but it's impossible to point to any little detail and see the whole. It's like trying to understand a symphony from one bar of what the second violins are doing, or trying to understand Thanksgiving dinner from a little smear of butter.

And it's an entirely different painting at different perspectives. Looking at it from 50 feet is a very different experience from looking at it from five feet. The tiny detail work is as extraordinary as the whole.

https://www.wikiart.org/en/jackson-pollock/mural-1943-1

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:19PM (#21422692)
>Art criticism is no different than any other field... it's completely baffling to people without education in it, and makes total and obvious sense to those who do.

Many fields are not baffling to people without specialized education.

Your description of Pollock’s mural reminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/915/

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:36PM (#21422855)
Many fields are shallow.

But this really boils down to a distrust of intellectualism, and the idea that Joe Sixpack's off-the-shelf opinion is more valid than the opinion of someone who actually studies the subject seriously - that the real student is merely an elitist snob who uses their study to lord over the cretins. Sigh.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by longerthoughts on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:47PM (#21423538)
I agree with you here but would just add that this line of thinking has limits. I am not a serious student of astrology but feel perfectly comfortable dismissing the validity of horoscopes and the authority of those who peddle them.

The trouble is if you assume an entire field is garbage then you're assuming the authorities of that field are either dishonest or deluded and you dismiss anything they say as self-sustaining nonsense. When that's the case, how do you change somebody's mind?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:14PM (#21423764)
And that's pretty much what all this "Pollock paintings are stupid" stuff gets to, right? That anyone who likes his work or claims to find special value in it is "dishonest or deluded". You can find quotes to that effect all over this post.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by missingrib on Saturday November 02, 2019 @03:35AM (#21426371)
Right, but what the parent comment is arguing (I think) is that there actually are fields where you can say that people who find special value in it are dishonest or deluded (astrology). The challenge comes in distinguishing which are valid and which aren't.

For the record, I like Pollock and find art history/criticism much more valuable than astrology. But, how would you explain that to someone who just sees it as paint smears?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:27PM (#21423877)
Art has nothing to do with intellectualism. And many subfields of art, even that with experts contemplating brush strokes, are very anti-intellectual in their core.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by PhasmaFelis on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:52PM (#21423018)
> Many fields are not baffling to people without specialized education.

And many fields are. I feel like at this point you're nitpicking their phrasing ("any" instead of "many") instead of addressing their point.

> Your description of Pollock’s mural reminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/915/

Note that comic doesn't claim that those differences aren't real, just that they're not visible or interesting to most people, which is pretty close to what the parent comment said.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:21PM (#21423829)
Of course they are real. And people can find them fascinating and other people can find them boring. Nothing wrong with either attitude.
[dead]
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by PhasmaFelis on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:11AM (#21425999)
> It says that they're dumb and meaningless and very real to the poor ignorant souls who think they're real.

Taking joy in something doesn't make you ignorant or dumb. Whether you choose to be a smug asshole about it is orthogonal to the object of interest.

> But modern art snobs are somewhat unique in claiming to be better than the rest of us. [...] I listen to a modern art snob talk about Jackson Pollock or whatever and I just hear, "I'm so much more intellectual, cultured, and sophisticated than you!"

Are you getting this from beat's comment above? Because I definitely don't see it. I've never seen it IRL, either. It sounds like you're taking your dislike of modern art, and maybe a couple of encounters with unpleasant fans, and projecting it onto the entire field.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by itronitron on Saturday November 02, 2019 @04:33AM (#21426540)
Great works of art often baffle art critics... https://youtu.be/Ofq_nl366VM?t=75
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dagw on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:53PM (#21423031)
but mostly old school art, say Van Gogh

I'm sure the irony isn't lost on you that not too long ago Van Gogh was decidedly "new school" and considered random colors and squiggly lines that most people didn't see the value in.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by lonelappde on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:50PM (#21425374)
This is the tragic comedy of people who espouse "conservative" values but don't put intellectual effort into it. There worldview is that whatever was canon before they were born is unassailable, and everything else and after is devoid of merit, but they can't explain why without appealing to authorities.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by wool_gather on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:43PM (#21428959)
I think you've got a good insight, but you're at least skirting the same intellectual trap you've identified, by generalizing about "people who".
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by kaffeemitsahne on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:26AM (#21427258)
Or maybe they just like Van Gogh and don't like Pollock?
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by donjigweed on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:14PM (#21423218)
I have zero artistic ability. My father is a very accomplished amateur artist. I've got into this discussion with him several times. Rather than Pollock's work, the best exemplar supporting the argument that artistic value is arbitrary is, in my opinion, Rothko's color field paintings [1]. My father explained to me that the reason it's in the Smithsonian is because he did something no one else had ever done before, he reduced the traditional landscape painting to it's absolute minimum. Same thing for Pollock, he did something no one else had ever done before. At least according to a very small clique of New York Jews. (Joking. Kind of. Not being anti-semitic, I'm an atheist Jew.)

Of course, the fact that this guy [2] is not also in the Smithsonian is strong evidence that it is in fact completely arbitrary.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_field [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owSZs7H24UY

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by watwut on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:43PM (#21423501)
Association of Jews with modern art is one of things that really really irritated nazi in Germany. They believed that Jews are intentionally destroying German culture by doing and promoting non traditional art.

But like, while somewhat over represented in Vienna modern circles, they were no majority at any point nor only the ones liking it. Probably not even more likely to like it.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by lonelappde on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:52PM (#21425382)
But hey, what's a little cultural cringe among friends, to show off one's ignorance of its connection to genocide.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by danielpal on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:05PM (#21422579)
I'll explain. Most people who criticize contemporary are, usually use a combination of its just a bunch of random lines or a "5 year old could have painted that" - as if the complexity of difficulty of an art piece its what makes it valuable. But nothing is further from the truth, a simple piece, with a strong composition such as Number 17a, could look simple but its quite powerful and complex.

Let me use an analogy you can better understand. I am sure you can appreciate music. Most people who listen to the Marriage of Figaro by Mozart, can understand it's a master piece. Yet, it isn't the most difficult balad Mozart composer and many other musicians have created far more complex balads. Also a gifted 5 year old could probably learn to play it and reproduce it quite accurately. Does that diminish its value because a 5 year old can play it? It's even possible for an average 5 year old to invent a similar balad after listening to it. But could an average 5 year old create something like the Marriage of Figaro from scratch without ever hearing it? It takes a pretty special 5 year old, like Mozart to produce something like that. And its the whole composition that matters, not just a few notes - anyone can play a few notes.

The same happens with Pollock. He was the first drip painter. And while an average 5 year old could drip some paint in a canvas (play a few notes), they won't be able to create a powerful composition of colors that mirrors a full Pollock composition. Sure, there are amazing reproductions of Pollock made by very trained art forgers - yet that doesn't diminish the value of Pollock just because someone else after analyzing his technique is able to reproduce it.

The value is another story. It's worth $200M because of its size and scarcity. Pollock wasn't a big art producers and thus there aren't many paintings around. Yet there are many people who love his work and want to buy it. Supply and demand dictates the price. Sure you can buy something similar from an art forger, but its not the same, the same way that listening to a album on a set of speakers is not the same as having the artist play live for you.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:21PM (#21422716)
>as if the complexity of difficulty of an art piece its what makes it valuable

But it is true. Of course it is not the whole story, but complexity and difficulty influence how humans interpret and value things.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by watwut on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:33PM (#21423410)
Realistic drawings are not considered difficult, not by artists. It is called fundamentals and you learn it in school. It takes effort to learn, but effectively it is just that.

Which is why more abstract drawings raised into prominence. And they are not so easy either - as much as five years old scribble, they don't create same effect not pleasing composition of colors or structures.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by longerthoughts on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:52PM (#21424083)
Complexity is not exclusively visual. The complexity of modern art largely comes in the form of the effect it has on the observer and the meaning they derive from it.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by robocat on Saturday November 02, 2019 @03:17PM (#21429437)
> Sure you can buy something similar from an art forger, but its not the same, the same way that listening to a album on a set of speakers is not the same as having the artist play live for you.

That's not a double-blind standard - you are comparing pipes to chairs. Although I can understand that one may care for the homeopathy or placebo effect of having the "real" item.

But I believe that there are artists that could make a better Pollock than Pollock himself.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by umvi on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:52PM (#21423015)
It doesn't take much to forge Pollock. It's like an author taking the output of monkeys pounding on typewriters and publishing it. Not hard to forge compared to JRRT.

Modern art is a sham. I only appreciate art that I recognize takes skill above my own to create. Anyone can come up with random novel "art". For example, I could buy a SpaceX rocket and launch a piece of feces into low earth orbit. "Poop in Orbit" would be extremely novel and random piece of modern "art".

Michaelangelo blows my mind. Pollock makes me roll my eyes.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:01PM (#21423116)
I can draw stick figures and call them forgeries of Michaelangelo. That doesn't make them good forgeries. Read the original article for some sense of the technical difficulty of forging Pollock in a way that couldn't be easily spotted by a Pollock expert.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by umvi on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:20PM (#21423283)
Yes, and I could hire a team of "umvi experts" that study 1000 samples of my written signature. Then it would be really hard for people to forge my signature because I have a team of experts that have studied me to the point they know my subconscious nuances. That doesn't mean I have any skill whatsoever, it just means people wasted time training their neural nets to recognize my idiosyncrasies in order to prevent forgeries.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:13PM (#21423748)
So basically, you're saying that Pollock is easy to forge, as long as no one understand what makes his paintings distinctive?

I mean, I could probably spot an amateurish Pollock forgery, and I'm no expert. And while forging his general style would be difficult, forging specific works would be nearly impossible - the layers are very specific. It would be even harder to forge drip technique paintings, where his direct control of the "brush" was limited.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by umvi on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:36PM (#21423955)
> So basically, you're saying that Pollock is easy to forge, as long as no one understand what makes his paintings distinctive?

I'm saying it's easy to make Pollock-esque paintings. I bet you could study Pollock for a few hours and then make a Pollock-esque painting that would fool 99.9% of the population. You can't do that with Michelangelo.

> forging specific works would be nearly impossible - the layers are very specific.

Obviously. That's like me throwing a fistful of sand on the floor and taking a picture of it and saying it would be very hard for someone to forge the picture because the sand grain positioning is very specific - which is technically true.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by lonelappde on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:56PM (#21425402)
Why don't you provide some evidence for your claim, since you believe all the evidence in the OP is invalid?

I could claim that whatever it is you do (including your HN comment) is no more complex or interesting than monkeys banging on typewriters.

Saying that careless sprinkling sand is as good as a Pollack is very nearly the same as saying picking numbers off the top of your head is as good as a secure RNG for crypto. It's not, in ways only an ingorant person fails to understand.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by longerthoughts on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:40PM (#21423983)
>I only appreciate art that I recognize takes skill above my own to create

Even if you had the skill to create a passable forgery of a Pollock, which you probably do not, you're attributing no value to the importance of concept and initial creation. A kid performing a Beethoven piece at a recital is not Beethoven.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by umvi on Friday November 01, 2019 @07:28PM (#21424781)
Simple thought experiment:

I let you study Michelangelo's sculptures for 24 hours using any resources you want. I then hand you a block of marble and a chisel and ask you to create a Michaelangelo-style scupture.

We then present your sculpture alongside an authentic Michelangelo sculpture and ask 50 random people on the street to identify which one was made by you and which was made by Michelangelo. I would wager 100% would reject your sculpture as inauthentic (based on an obvious lack of skill).

Now we repeat the same experiment but with Pollock. I would wager 50% would reject your painting as inauthentic and 50% would reject the Pollock painting as inauthentic (people would randomly choose).

Pollock paintings require no skill, just a large canvas and a few contrasting colors to splatter and drip. There is no dexterity or experience required to make a painting in the style of Pollock, unlike Michelangelo sculptures.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by longerthoughts on Friday November 01, 2019 @07:51PM (#21424899)
1) You’re responding to a point about you attributing no value to concept by doubling down on the importance of realist technique and ignoring everything else. Even pieces that truly don’t require technical skill can still have value, which you don’t seem to grasp. A realistic portrait is far less interesting to many than something abstract that makes you reflect.

2) Please try to replicate a Pollock. I think you’ll be surprised.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by umvi on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:10PM (#21424997)
> Even pieces that truly don’t require technical skill can still have value, which you don’t seem to grasp.

No, I understand. The Japanese flag is a red circle on a white rectangle. Takes no skill to design or draw. But I still think it's has value as a symbol. But I wouldn't pay $200M for it and I certainly wouldn't prop up the person who made it as some sort of highly skilled artistic juggernaut. I would think "neat concept, but I could've done that" and that would be it.

> Please try to replicate a Pollock. I think you’ll be surprised.

Please try and replicate my signature. I think you'll be surprised at how difficult it is (I've been perfecting it for 20+ years signing documents) and that should cause you to respect me much more, right? If not, please explain why not and in doing so you'll understand why I don't care for Pollock or his work.

Anyone can just make up a new form of art and "perfect" it by just doing it over and over (like your signature). I could invent a new form of music by randomly mashing keys on a piano in a way unique to me. So what? There is no negative feedback loop so therefore the "perfection" process is completely nebulous and arbitrary and takes no real effort because there is no defined destination.

Can we at least acknowledge the massive skill gap between learning to play a Chopin piano piece and pioneering a Pollock-esque field of art where there are no rules or negative feedback loops to correct you?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by SamReidHughes on Saturday November 02, 2019 @03:29AM (#21426354)
Playing a Chopin piano piece is much, much easier. You can tell Pollock is legit just by looking at his art.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by flowerlad on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:28AM (#21427579)
I don’t think Pollock’s drips are art either. But I do think Picasso’s cubist paintings are art. And yet some of Picasso’s paintings are easy to re-create so would fail your test.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by mcavoybn on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:19PM (#21422690)
I am no expert, but I think the value of art is based on what someone is willing to pay for it. Art collectors and galleries will estimate this value based on a variety of factors like: How wealthy are the potential buyers? In what context is the artwork being released? Have there been other works by artists which went for a similar price? Etc. etc.

Also, art can be looked at as a science experiment where the artist performs an experiment and shares their results with the world. Expressionism is one such "field of research" with Jackson Pollock being a prominent researcher. His body of work is like a groundbreaking experiment and each painting is an artifact of that experiment. In other words buying a Jackson Pollock is sort of like buying one of Einsteins papers.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:45PM (#21422939)
The economic value of art is based on what someone is willing to pay for it. That's very different from value in general.

Van Gogh's "Starry Night" is probably the most valuable painting in the world, a canonical work recognized instantly by probably half the world's population. Van Gogh died penniless. He gave away his paintings for food and wine.

Does that mean "Starry Night" was worthless when Van Gogh painted it, just because no one would pay him for it? Or is the intrinsic value of the painting distinct from its economic value?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by mcavoybn on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:08PM (#21425223)
>value in general

When you are in a philosophical vacuum, generalizing value is useful. However, markets concertize value. The question of "why has this been so valuable" is firmly answered by "this is how much someone payed for it".

"What is value?" is an excellent philosophical question. "Why is (some item) so valuable?" is easily answered by a simple analysis of history and statistics.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Sunday November 03, 2019 @11:01PM (#21438927)
If we think about it that way, what's the difference between value and price? Not much.

I think it's very important to consider value independently of money, and Van Gogh's paintings are an excellent example of that.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by watwut on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:22PM (#21423303)
And yet, his suicide and mental problems helped to his popularity after death. Had he drew same pictures without such fascinating story, he would be known less.

Intrinsic value is about what you value. Which may be million different things and changes over time.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by ronilan on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:11PM (#21423195)
I’m not an art critic and I don’t know what the paintings are worth, but what I do know, for what it’s worth, is that each and every time I look a “squiggly lines” and think “wow this looks great” it turns out to be a painting by Jackson Pollack. So, for me, there is something there. Something that impressionism doesn’t have.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by colechristensen on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:47PM (#21422958)
A novel in a foreign language is just squiggly lines on paper too.

Part of abstract art not understood is just that, a foreign language. Part of it is a navel gazing community congratulating itself. Part of it is a popularity contest with random winners.

It’s the problem with a specialty which is tending towards a singularity: quality becomes ever harder to judge and by ever fewer people who must dedicate ever more time to even understand. There are lots of hangers on who have only vague ideas about the quality and as a result the field gets overrun with nonsense. That doesn’t mean there is nothing there.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by pmoriarty on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:21PM (#21422708)
There are a lot of things the general public do not understand about art. One of those is that to some artists, especially ones that create non-representative art, the process of creating their art is just as or even more important than the final product.

To a consumer, viewer, or critic of art, the value of a work of art may be in the final product, but the artist may not view it that way at all, and it could be valuable to them because of, say, the way the process made them feel at the time, or how it helped them work through some personal issues they were going through.

So, yeah, you might feel like some abstract work of art is "garbage", or think that "my 2 year old could do that" or something, but your reaction is really irrelevant to some artists. Some artists want to be seen, recognized, acknowledged, and appreciated by the public, while others work just for themselves and really couldn't care less what you or anyone else thinks of their work.

As an abstract, visual artist myself, I find my work to be very meditative for me, and akin sometimes to digging through layers of earth and excavating something buried within, which can be fun, intriguing, or therapeutic for me. I do strive to make the final result pleasing to myself, but to me the process of creating the work itself has value, and what some random person off the street thinks of it is really of no consequence to me.

As for what a painting is worth on the art market, you have to realize that for many art buyers, these paintings are seen as investments, and their price is determined by what people are willing to pay for them (which is often determined by what they think these paintings will be worth to other investors in the future), not necessarily by them having any "objective value".

Also, what's often valued in art market and to academic critics is someone doing something first, or stretching the boundaries of what is considered art. The first "blue canvas" or whatever, is worth a lot of money even though it took absolutely no skill to create, while anyone else creating a "blue canvas" today would be ignored because they're neither being original nor pushing the boundaries of what's considered art.

As Salvador Dali once said, "The first man to compare the cheeks of a young woman to a rose was obviously a poet; the first to repeat it was possibly an idiot."

On the other hand, the value of art in the art market is a testament to Any Warhol's definition of art: "Art is anything you can get away with."

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by russellbeattie on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:43PM (#21423493)
I actually developed my own understanding of art after seeing a Pollock painting in person. Like the statue of David, the painting was huge, which surprised me.

I then realized art isn't just about whether you could have done something, but would you have done it. Whenever I look at art now I ask myself both questions: Could I have painted like Rembrandt? No. Would I ever have thought to drip paint onto a massive canvas and call it art? No. Both are equally as a valid. This applies to music and books and movies, etc. Would I ever have thought of the plot to Reservoir Dogs? Never.

Art, in my opinion, still has to evoke emotion, and be the result of a creative effort. So a music piece generated by a computer doesn't really count, but the code written to program it definitely does.

Of course art is art and everyone has their opinion about it, this is just my way of looking at it.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by carrozo on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:51PM (#21423001)
Great summary. Feel free to share your work here? :)
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dfxm12 on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:05PM (#21423144)
Like, in what way is Number 17a worth 200 million?

I don't know if you mean this painting specifically, or paintings in general, but obviously, art is worth what someone is willing to pay for it. Now, there are many reasons a person might pay a lot for a piece, or how a piece might end up selling for more than an expert would expect. Here are just a handful:

1. Someone buys expensive art and donates it to a museum for a nice tax deduction. The more the painting is, the more the deduction. The person who bought Number 17A immediately donated it to a museum.

2. Two collectors are both really rich and both really interested in a piece and get into a bidding war. It only takes two, but sometimes there are many people who want a particular piece or a piece from a particular artist.

3. A collector (or dealer) might try to spur interest in an artist by overpaying for a piece to try and reset the price for said artist.

4. You can launder money by buying or selling art at auction.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by v0x on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:20AM (#21426024)
Just wanted to point out that point 1 is very rarely valid; while you do get a tax break from donating to charity, what you save in taxes is not offset by the cost of the donation. The only case I can really think of where that is the case is if you have some property appraised at a value significantly higher than what you can actually sell it for on the market.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by protonimitate on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:56PM (#21423051)
> I am curious as to what an art critic's view of such abstract paintings are. Like, in what way is Number 17a worth 200 million?

Art criticism has almost nothing to do with how much a piece is worth at auction. The price of a painting essentially comes down to the "fine art" world being a popularity contest.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by AnimalMuppet on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:00PM (#21423106)
Pollock is a famous name. How many people want to own a famous name, just for pride? How many Pollocks exist? (Or even, how many "big name" art pieces exist?) The first number is considerably larger. That's why the price is high.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by jancsika on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:58PM (#21423076)
> Like, in what way is Number 17a worth 200 million?

That's not a fair question to ask an art critic.

I mean, if you asked me why it's worth forty of your minutes to listen to Gyo:rgy Ligeti's Violin Concerto, I'd take a shot at it.

But if Ligeti's music happened to be tied to an international black market such that his scores were being bought and sold for a quarter of a billion dollars what could I possibly say?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dekhn on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:18PM (#21423265)
Agree. I didn't really pay much attention to art until I visited the Rijksmuseum during the renovation and saw the Night Watch in person in an empty, quiet room. It transformed what I understood about art (the dynamic range of that painting, as well as the characters who inhabit it, are both extraordinary). That led me down the rabbit hole of classic Dutch Masters and when I see things like Pollock, I really wonder if I'm missing some extraordinary thing that separates his work from that of a 3 year old flinging paint.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dagw on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:41PM (#21423998)
Have you seen the painting in question live? If you haven't I really recommend it. I didn't really get it either until I got a chance to really see some of his works up close. The the scale and details and layers and dynamism and the way the paint is sculpted into a 3D surface just doesn't come across on a computer screen.

You don't have to like it, but there is no way you can in good faith study a Pollock and come away believing a 3 year old could have done that.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dekhn on Friday November 01, 2019 @06:15PM (#21424245)
Fair enough. I had the same experience with Van Gogh (the 3D paint scuplting). But I expect that even the zoomed-out version looks like something I'd care about, like a flower, not abstract.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dagw on Friday November 01, 2019 @06:28PM (#21424349)
Not caring for the way a piece of art looks is not a good reason to belittle the talent and effort that went into creating it.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dekhn on Friday November 01, 2019 @07:25PM (#21424761)
Please note that all my lines written above are polite and do not belitte anybody. Instead, they are statements about what I feel and believe based on my experiences.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dagw on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:04PM (#21424962)
Agreed. I apologize for the way that came out. But will you conceded that saying a 3 year old could to that does come off as dismissive. There is skill and technique in what Pollock did even if you think the end result is shit.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by dagw on Saturday November 02, 2019 @04:01AM (#21426435)
Again, I apologize if I can off as confrontational last night. All I'm really asking as do you give Pollock just the same few minutes of up close study you gave Rembrandt that first time in the Rijksmuseum, before you write him off. Personally I might recommend Greyed Rainbow at the Chicago Art Institute. I know I felt pretty much the way you did until I actually got to really see some of his works in person and up close.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by goto11 on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:10PM (#21428781)
The incredible prices for some art does not correspond to appreciation by art critics. It is investment objects so the prices correspond to what the investors think they will be able to sell them for in the future which in turn depends on things like name recognition and perceived staying power.

It is certainly not art critics that decided that a Pollock should cost 200M. But is considered worth 200M because some billionaire will pay that much for it.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by B1FF_PSUVM on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:18PM (#21423797)
> Like, in what way is Number 17a worth 200 million?

>To me all I see is squiggly lines and random colors.

I favor the Bitcoin hypothesis - a consensus derived worth for a portable, mostly anonymous, value store of no intrinsic utility - just slightly ahead of gold and diamonds really ...

(Only usefully available to the really rich, though)

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by krsdcbl on Saturday November 02, 2019 @06:00AM (#21426785)
A lot of art is just "squiggly lines and random colors" - the inherently interesting thing is what kind of feeling or atmosphere the actual arrangement provokes
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by kpU8efre7r on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:02PM (#21423119)
It's worth what people are willing to pay.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by sixplusone on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:03PM (#21423126)