Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique
by dekhn on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:18PM
(#21423265)
Agree. I didn't really pay much attention to art until I visited the Rijksmuseum during the renovation and saw the Night Watch in person in an empty, quiet room. It transformed what I understood about art (the dynamic range of that painting, as well as the characters who inhabit it, are both extraordinary). That led me down the rabbit hole of classic Dutch Masters and when I see things like Pollock, I really wonder if I'm missing some extraordinary thing that separates his work from that of a 3 year old flinging paint.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Have you seen the painting in question live? If you haven't I really recommend it. I didn't really get it either until I got a chance to really see some of his works up close. The the scale and details and layers and dynamism and the way the paint is sculpted into a 3D surface just doesn't come across on a computer screen.
You don't have to like it, but there is no way you can in good faith study a Pollock and come away believing a 3 year old could have done that.
Fair enough. I had the same experience with Van Gogh (the 3D paint scuplting). But I expect that even the zoomed-out version looks like something I'd care about, like a flower, not abstract.
Not caring for the way a piece of art looks is not a good reason to belittle the talent and effort that went into creating it.
Please note that all my lines written above are polite and do not belitte anybody. Instead, they are statements about what I feel and believe based on my experiences.
Agreed. I apologize for the way that came out. But will you conceded that saying a 3 year old could to that does come off as dismissive. There is skill and technique in what Pollock did even if you think the end result is shit.
Again, I apologize if I can off as confrontational last night. All I'm really asking as do you give Pollock just the same few minutes of up close study you gave Rembrandt that first time in the Rijksmuseum, before you write him off. Personally I might recommend Greyed Rainbow at the Chicago Art Institute. I know I felt pretty much the way you did until I actually got to really see some of his works in person and up close.