News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:19PM (#21422692)
>Art criticism is no different than any other field... it's completely baffling to people without education in it, and makes total and obvious sense to those who do.

Many fields are not baffling to people without specialized education.

Your description of Pollock’s mural reminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/915/

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:36PM (#21422855)
Many fields are shallow.

But this really boils down to a distrust of intellectualism, and the idea that Joe Sixpack's off-the-shelf opinion is more valid than the opinion of someone who actually studies the subject seriously - that the real student is merely an elitist snob who uses their study to lord over the cretins. Sigh.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by longerthoughts on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:47PM (#21423538)
I agree with you here but would just add that this line of thinking has limits. I am not a serious student of astrology but feel perfectly comfortable dismissing the validity of horoscopes and the authority of those who peddle them.

The trouble is if you assume an entire field is garbage then you're assuming the authorities of that field are either dishonest or deluded and you dismiss anything they say as self-sustaining nonsense. When that's the case, how do you change somebody's mind?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by beat on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:14PM (#21423764)
And that's pretty much what all this "Pollock paintings are stupid" stuff gets to, right? That anyone who likes his work or claims to find special value in it is "dishonest or deluded". You can find quotes to that effect all over this post.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by missingrib on Saturday November 02, 2019 @03:35AM (#21426371)
Right, but what the parent comment is arguing (I think) is that there actually are fields where you can say that people who find special value in it are dishonest or deluded (astrology). The challenge comes in distinguishing which are valid and which aren't.

For the record, I like Pollock and find art history/criticism much more valuable than astrology. But, how would you explain that to someone who just sees it as paint smears?

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:27PM (#21423877)
Art has nothing to do with intellectualism. And many subfields of art, even that with experts contemplating brush strokes, are very anti-intellectual in their core.
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by PhasmaFelis on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:52PM (#21423018)
> Many fields are not baffling to people without specialized education.

And many fields are. I feel like at this point you're nitpicking their phrasing ("any" instead of "many") instead of addressing their point.

> Your description of Pollock’s mural reminds me of this: https://xkcd.com/915/

Note that comic doesn't claim that those differences aren't real, just that they're not visible or interesting to most people, which is pretty close to what the parent comment said.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by LudwigNagasena on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:21PM (#21423829)
Of course they are real. And people can find them fascinating and other people can find them boring. Nothing wrong with either attitude.
[dead]
Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by PhasmaFelis on Saturday November 02, 2019 @01:11AM (#21425999)
> It says that they're dumb and meaningless and very real to the poor ignorant souls who think they're real.

Taking joy in something doesn't make you ignorant or dumb. Whether you choose to be a smug asshole about it is orthogonal to the object of interest.

> But modern art snobs are somewhat unique in claiming to be better than the rest of us. [...] I listen to a modern art snob talk about Jackson Pollock or whatever and I just hear, "I'm so much more intellectual, cultured, and sophisticated than you!"

Are you getting this from beat's comment above? Because I definitely don't see it. I've never seen it IRL, either. It sounds like you're taking your dislike of modern art, and maybe a couple of encounters with unpleasant fans, and projecting it onto the entire field.

Re:Jackson Pollock's painting technique by itronitron on Saturday November 02, 2019 @04:33AM (#21426540)
Great works of art often baffle art critics... https://youtu.be/Ofq_nl366VM?t=75