News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by rtpg on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:59PM (#21415669)
This is a false dicothomy

The actual (IMO correct) position most of these people share is the following two points at once:

- businesses should have a moral position, since businesses are just a set of people

- that moral position should be right!

This isn’t rocket science! Stuff like “don’t support a business doing bad stuff” and “support businesses doing good stuff” is just really basic consumer activism.

There’s no need to go deep in metaphysics. It’s literally just “support good things, don’t support bad things”

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by Thorentis on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:56PM (#21415902)
This is not a false dichotomy at all.

Businesses should have a moral position, sure.

That moral position should be right? According to who? The business itself? Then that second point is redundant. Everybody thinks their moral position is right, that's what morals are. It's a tautology otherwise.

GitHub employees think their moral position on ICE is right. Many disagree. But according to them that's fine, because they think they're right so should be able to boycott who they like.

Replace Github with bakery refusing to serve same-sex couples. Bakery thinks they're right. Many disagree. But according to them that's fine, because they think they're right so should be able to boycott who they like.

You only think it's a false dichotomy because you personally disagree with the bakery and (presumably?) agree with Github. By saying "the moral position should be right", is you simply saying "and they should agree with me otherwise they are wrong".

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by mattigames on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:19AM (#21416242)
> GitHub employees think their moral position on ICE is right. Many disagree. But according to them that's fine, because they think they're right so should be able to boycott who they like.

A lot of music artists in the 50s and 60s refused to play on segregated crowds (where black people is separated from white people, usually blacks in the back), they did it because they though they were right and should be able to boycott doing business with those who disagree (despite their record-label or manager thinking otherwise) you think those artists should have done otherwise?

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by Thorentis on Friday November 01, 2019 @07:44AM (#21417767)
I didn't say they should have done otherwise. I'm actually arguing in favour of private individuals/businesses being able to make the decision on what they sell and who they sell to.

I'm simply pointing out what is almost definitely hypocrisy on the part of these Github employees. Tech companies are usually more progressive, and no doubt these employees would object to a private company, such as a family run bakery, choosing who they sell to. When the Github employees are advocating for their own company to do just that.

[dead]
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by dang on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:09AM (#21416422)
Please don't take HN threads further into ideological flamewar. Such discussions are repetitive and predictable and deteriorate as they go along. That makes them off topic here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by sascha_sl on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:30AM (#21418535)
dang, this is clearly on-topic. ICE is in the title of the post.

Not every response to a political post that is apathy incarnate is an "ideological flamewar".

Some things have to be named as what they are, this is not hyperbole. This is happening right now. And I'm sorry anything but your typical "but what about refusing services to the gays" makes you uncomfortable.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by dang on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:28PM (#21422778)
What makes political flamewars off topic on HN is that they are repetitive and therefore predictable. There's no curiosity in that, and HN is a site for curiosity. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Substantive conversation about the specifics of the OP is different; that's possible, and if people can do it, it's on topic here. But it takes discipline not to devolve into flame-throwing.

When a thread gets to the level of name-calling about concentration camps, there's no substantive discussion left to be had. Internet forums as a medium are quick to become vessels for venting rather than information sharing. That's what we want to avoid here. If your wish is to fight battles and smite enemies, please do so elsewhere. I'm sure there are many good reasons to smite them; we are certainly not saying that these issues are unimportant.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by iron0013 on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:34PM (#21422835)
dang, it's not name-calling to call concentration camps what they are. ICE literally runs concentration camps. There's no exaggeration, trolling, or flame-warring involved in saying so.

It's simply the same way that it's not libelous to call someone who committed murder a "murderer"--because they earned the title when they committed the murder.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by dang on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:36PM (#21422850)
When I said name-calling I was referring to words like vile and cynic.

Words like concentration camp seem to me in a different category. They aren't necessarily name-calling, but they do have dual semantics: a factual aspect and a pejorative one. If all a comment does is repeat those words and add additional pejoratives, that's not a substantive comment by HN standards.

Repeating pejoratives very much feels like "saying what something is" or "naming things as they are". But it feels like exactly the opposite of that to others, who then feel justified in escalating. That is the dynamic of flamewar, not conversation. We can't have both, and HN threads are supposed to be conversations.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by iron0013 on Friday November 01, 2019 @04:30PM (#21423381)
It's clear that you've thought about this, so what do you suggest is the appropriate way to have a constructive conversation with someone who openly endorses atrocities? The pro-atrocity side is welcome to describe the crimes they support in warm, fuzzy terms that do not offend those with delicate sensibilities, but the anti-atrocity side cannot even freely state their case because it naturally involves invoking the truth of horrific events. Are we bound to stay silent about such actions because those who support them may be offended by being associated with their plainly factual content?
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by dang on Tuesday November 12, 2019 @03:46PM (#21518007)
I'm sorry I didn't get a chance to reply to this. I meant to, but got swept away by the waves of everything that gets posted here.

Our intention is to give every sincere question a sincere answer, so I'm sorry to have left the wrong impression in this case. It's just not always possible given resource constraints. I'm sure we can revisit this in the future.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by iron0013 on Wednesday November 13, 2019 @11:04AM (#21525634)
Thanks! appreciate it
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by Thorentis on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:15PM (#21415990)
You can disagree with somebody's set of morals all you like. You can draw analogies to Hitler, Stalin, Mao, whoever. But: why should a private business only be allowed to choose its clients, if their morality aligns with yours?

EDIT: And the down votes begin the moment I don't agree with somebody's comparison to Hitler. Godwin's Law never fails to deliver.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by slykat on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:58PM (#21416167)
What bothers me the most is how myopic people are about this. Does anyone not see how dangerous it will be if we have the world's largest companies choosing to do business based on their internal moral grounds? Do we really want tech companies to have moral councils that vet customers?

If you want to fix ICE, then by all means, attack the problem at its source! Take that well paid Github salary of yours and fund the ACLU and other lobbyists fighting the good fight. Write your congressman. Call your congressman. VOTE! Campaign for the correct congressman. Code for your congressman. Push for policy that makes ICE employees (and all government employees) more accountable for human rights abuses. All of these actions will be more effective than campaigning for ICE, who will just migrate to a different cloud code review tool if the contract is cancelled (gitlab, bitbucket, or whomever else).

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by mattigames on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:28AM (#21416281)
I see you as the myopic here; by pretending you only have to the long term stuff (votes, campaing) and that the short term stuff doesn't matter or shouldn't be done (like the employees complaining in this case) like these kind of protests live in a vacuum; when artists in the 50s refused to play in segregated crowds you think they didn't ALSO advocate for the long term stuff like voting for congressmen in favor of less racism? Absolutely nothing lives in a vacuum, and creating noise against ICE like they are doing in this case can help even more than doing the politics part themselves, because the exposure they get influences other people reading such news.
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by slykat on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:52AM (#21416361)
I actually don't think this is a short term action. I think of this as a non-action. If Github pulls the ICE contract they will just use a competitor (Gitlab has already gone on record saying they will not restrict customers based on moral viewpoints). And regardless of which cloud code collaboration tool ICE uses, they will still be locking kids in detention camps and trampling human rights. No behavior change will happen at all at ICE if they have to change their git cloud provider.

This is a non action move in my opinion. I see it as slacktivism, if Github pulls the contract, people will pat themselves on the back, and count it as a win. You could argue the exposure might have some effect, but given that ICE human rights abuses have been very well documented by the leading publications, I'm unsure if additional exposure will bring change. I do strongly believe that funding lobbyists is the a great short term thing we can do. From an exposure viewpoint, I think the best thing we can do is raise exposure and support in the blue areas of the country. However, these protests are not doing that.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by mattigames on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:03AM (#21416405)
If I have learn anything about politics is that very well documented facts don't always have more importance in the public eyes than the noise made about a subject, the full political campaign of Trump had practically 0% of any truth whatsoever, just rambling insults and other easily-repeated slogans void of any truth but emotional appeals to a big chunk of the voting population; and he won with millions of votes. So no, I think stuff like this does a bit more than "some effect".
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by slykat on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:14AM (#21416442)
I agree that noise can impact change, but the problem here is we've already got this noise within the Blue states. In order to get a policy change you need to have majority of Congress which means the noise needs to be felt on the Red states. So yea, if this was happening in a corporation based in Texas, Florida, or Georgia, I'd believe this was an action. Right now this exposure is going into publications that target people who already share the same viewpoint as the protestors.
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by Rapzid on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:07AM (#21416208)
I understand what you are saying but I do not believe all morals and values are created equal.

For one, many disparate cultures have separately developed values that are very similar. In a lot of these cultures values intersect more than diverge.

Second, I do not believe discriminating on an entity based on the perceived harm it is causing others is the equivalent to discriminating on an individual or group based on intrinsic characteristics the individuals were born with.

Further, I believe it's potentially desirable to attempt to derive a set of values and morals based on reasoning; attempting to maximize for the constructive and empowering and minimize the destructive and oppressive.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by manigandham on Friday November 01, 2019 @03:12AM (#21416789)
> "perceived harm"

That's the entire problem isn't it? Perceived by who? Do people actually know the truth or is it just what they assume? How is this kind of policy not immediately susceptible to all sorts of abuse?

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by Sophistifunk on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:07PM (#21415705)
> - that moral position should be right

You do realise that what this actually means is "this person agrees with me"

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by rtpg on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:19PM (#21415750)
How is this a problem? Like.... seriously.

This is the whole point of everything. If you believe strongly in a thing, then you should fight for it. And other people in society will judge you for it (rightly so!)

So yeah, you decide that you care enough about "sanctity of marriage" so you decide to not sell cakes. So everyone who disagrees with you boycotts your business. Others believe that sexual orientation is such an important thing that they make it illegal for you to do this! This is how stuff happens!

There isn't some sort of rules-based pre-judgement for this sort of stuff. It gets played out over time. And you're responsible for your decisions in this front.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by rumanator on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:13PM (#21415984)
> How is this a problem? Like.... seriously.

It's a colossal problem because it is an authoritarian stance hidden behind incoherent arguments of morality. There is no morality or ethics. There is only pushy people trying to strong-arm everyone around to comply with their personal world view under the threat of being cut off from a product/service.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by leftyted on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:31PM (#21416066)
You envision society as a battleground for various moral perspectives. I think there's some truth to that. But are there any ground rules? If so, what are they? Are you giving me license to firebomb ICE facilities because I "believe strongly" that ICE is evil? Or is the law a red line that no one can cross? If so, what about "bad laws"? What about civil disobedience?

Another perspective on this is that, for a society to function, people need to be able to agree to disagree about most things. This means that we are all morally compromised and we all must be morally compromised in order to live together. A society in which everyone follows their own moral impulses is a society that will not function.

I find myself wavering between these two perspectives (the first being yours). I don't mind people protesting. But how about blocking roads? How about vandalizing your ideological opponent's office? How about smashing windows? How about preventing your ideological opponents from speaking? It seems to me that your perspective minimizes the danger here. There's no guarantee that things will just work out. We might reach a level of polarization after which we simply won't be able to cooperate.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by sterlind on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:23PM (#21415763)
right, it's impossible to establish a universal, objective framework for morality. instead, we can only make compromises between majorities and vocal minorities, codify them as laws and ethics, and enforce them.

however, that doesn't absolve you of sticking up for your moral code, depending on what it is. for example, I'm gay. I know that Chik-Fil-A is complying with the law, and that its owners are funding advocacy for conversion therapy and other anti-LGBT issues. I wouldn't want Chik-Fil-A to be dismantled, since it's lawful, but I refuse to eat there, since my personal morals prevent me from giving money to people who want to hurt people like me. I'd also support protests of Chik-Fil-A, since protest is a lawful action (at least, social media campaigns and picket lines.)

Don't be lazy. Stand up for what you believe in. The law is the lowest common denominator, and legality doesn't absolve you of your actions.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by admax88q on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:31PM (#21415798)
So what are you saying then? That there are no moral absolutes? Or just that because people disagree on what is moral business should be allowed to act in interest of profit only?
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by malvosenior on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:02PM (#21415684)
Many, many people feel that enforcing existing immigration laws is morally right and a "good thing".

I think defining what is morally right is harder than rocket science and literally impossible in some cases.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by geofft on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:37PM (#21415823)
That's fine, that doesn't change anything. If GitHub and their employees disagree so strongly on right and wrong that one side believes doing X is immoral and the other believes not doing X is immoral, GitHub can either attempt to convince their employees that they are in fact right, or let them leave.

(If GitHub does not believe they have a moral obligation to sell to ICE, they can drop the contract and keep their employees. It's a very small contract, less than one engineer's salary, and they committed to donating that money anyway. So I'm assuming that GitHub feels a moral or equivalently strong obligation to keep the contract, possibly of the form of feeling an obligation not to let employees influence moral direction. If not, this is just a story of bad business sense.)

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by rtpg on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:23PM (#21415764)
others think the laws are fundamentally unjust.

Even others (a plurality I think) don't have strong feelings on the laws, but know one of the following: - the executive has selective enforcement rights - (at the time) congress + the WH could change laws! - the laws were written with an understanding of selective enforcement

and so rightly recognized that this was a bad thing that could be made right.

There is an n-sided die about how people see this problem, and people acted in accordance to it. And yeah, it means that some sides don't believe in the legitimacy of other sides. They're incompatible after all.

Besides, it's not the point. The point of the game isn't to make a set of meta-rules for defining what is morally right. It's for, on a case-by-case basis, to say "this thing is good/bad" and then act on that.

I don't need to be able to answer every moral hypothetical to be able to say that _this one specific thing is bad_. To bring it back to HN, it's a P=/=NP problem. I can say one thing is good/bad without providing the full strategy for determining every thing. And then we work from there.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by malvosenior on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:37PM (#21415824)
I think your entire argument would make a lot more sense if you replaced “right” with “what I think is right”. Your position is just one side of the dice (as you say).
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by manigandham on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:13PM (#21415724)
The whole point of morality is that it is subjective. You can not determine what is right as a rule.
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by dang on Friday November 01, 2019 @02:03AM (#21416579)
Please don't take HN threads on generic tangents. They lead to shallow, predictable discussions. A public internet forum is not, as a medium, capable of addressing such questions. If you really want to discuss something like that, write an essay (or a book) and then post it here, or maybe someone will.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by istjohn on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:29PM (#21415785)
That's nonsense. Philosophers will debate subtleties around morality until the end of time, but that shouldn't prevent us from taking a stand against evil when we see it.
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by throw_m239339 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:59PM (#21415918)
> That's nonsense. Philosophers will debate subtleties around morality until the end of time, but that shouldn't prevent us from taking a stand against evil when we see it.

"evil" is exactly what religious people called homosexuality for centuries, which is ironic considering your statement. Morality is purely an opinion, just like religion.

[dead]
Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by Ygg2 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:30PM (#21416064)
Looks at US, Russia, China, Turkey, etc.

Yeah, good thing everyone can agree on A), right?

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by rumanator on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:20PM (#21416021)
> taking a stand against evil when we see it.

Except that "evil" is just a loaded word that tries to pin an absolute take on morality on a personal opinion. There are people who take stances against evil by persecuting others based on religion, gender, race, and even political leanings, and they feel so strongly about the morality of their positions that they feel that even extreme violence is justified.

Re:GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract by manigandham on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:45AM (#21416342)
Ask what "evil" means in different parts of the world and you will come to vastly different definitions.