News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tyingq on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:37AM (#21408545)
Not excusing anything about MCAS, but the "cracks in an aluminum airframe" thing is a VERY normal and established cycle/process. Well known and a normal thing. This news piece is just journalistic piling on to hot news.

There is "no news" here.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by inferiorhuman on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:03AM (#21408864)
Not excusing anything about MCAS, but the "cracks in an aluminum airframe" thing is a VERY normal and established cycle/process.

Cracks can be a normal and expected thing. These parts were designed to last the lifetime of the airframe (around 90,000 cycles) and are failing in under 30,000 cycles.

This raises eyebrows for two specific reasons: 1.) Boeing was already installing subpar parts (edit: not pickle forks) from Ducommon in the 737 NG 2.) The wings fall off if the pickle forks fail completely.

This news piece is just journalistic piling on to hot news.

MCAS isn't the only fire Boeing is fighting right now (they're also battling poor quality control with their KC-46 and 787 lines among other things). Some guy on PPRuNe is claiming that the pickle fork problem was just improper manufacturing[1], which when put in context would make it appear as if Boeing has some major structural problems with its organization.

1: https://www.pprune.org/showpost.php?p=10595986&postcount=258

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by throwaway5752 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:49AM (#21410057)
Yes, but it's very long cycle failures at low frequency, and people suspect it's because of additional stress caused by winglets. Winglets reduce drag and save fuel, it's an important change. It may have been very difficult to predict and test this failure. And most importantly, the FAA and Boeing are handling it properly.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by inferiorhuman on Friday November 01, 2019 @06:18PM (#21424266)
Yes, but it's very long cycle failures at low frequency, and people suspect it's because of additional stress caused by winglets. Winglets reduce drag and save fuel, it's an important change. It may have been very difficult to predict and test this failure. And most importantly, the FAA and Boeing are handling it properly.

Cracks have been found in NGs both with and without winglets, so that is almost certainly not the issue at hand.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by notfromhere on Thursday October 31, 2019 @01:02PM (#21410984)
That's because when they merged with McDonnell Douglas, MD executives got the top spots in Boeing, so their shitty culture transferred over to the new company.

The long-standing joke is that MD took over Boeing with Boeing's money

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by chopin on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:19AM (#21409730)
> These parts were designed to last the lifetime of the airframe

Can these be replaced? If they have the expected lifetime of the airframe they might not be serviceable. Out of curiosity: can these cracks be repaired other than replacing the part?

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by msbarnett on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:37AM (#21409923)
> Can these be replaced?

Yes. The operation takes a couple of days per plane.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by rkangel on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:57AM (#21408784)
Metal fatigue is a reasonably well understood phenomenon, that is managed by the aircraft inspection cycle.

The actual crack appearance rate diverging from the modelled appearance rate at design time is a potential worry and indicates an issue somewhere along the line. How bad that issue actually is requires more investigation. It's a complex situation because metal fatigue is a statistical process, so you don't know if the cracks you've found are the best case or worst case.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tooop on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:01AM (#21408843)
Except for the fact that the these cracks are in the "pickle fork" - a part that is supposed to last the lifetime of the plane without cracking.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by mumblemumble on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:01AM (#21408851)
Or perhaps it's news that's just missing a few details.

Cracking and wear and tear on the structure might be normal, but it sounds like the issue here is that the 737NG airframes are showing signs of wear and tear much faster than expected.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by runeb on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:58AM (#21408791)
You are assuming they are relatively normal hairline cracks. They are grounding planes, so the cracks reported here might be different from that. There does not seem to be enough information to conclude sensationalist news.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tyingq on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:02AM (#21408852)
Airlines with many more 737's handled it correctly. Not saying it isn't a crisis. Just saying it's an airline specific crisis, not a Boeing crisis. That's the piling on bit.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by inferiorhuman on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:10AM (#21408949)
Airlines with many more 737's handled it correctly. Not saying it isn't a crisis. Just saying it's an airline specific crisis, not a Boeing crisis. That's the piling on bit.

The AD sets forth two distinct priorities: high cycle and low cycle airframes. Those with higher cycles required near immediate inspection because they are presumably more at risk for these cracks, in airlines with larger fleets inspections of younger frames may not be complete yet.

Southwest (owner of the largest 737 fleet in the world) grounded their (two, IIRC) NGs that required inspection sooner and failed that inspection. I don't believe Southwest has finished inspecting the other 600 or so planes in their fleet. Qantas (an airline with an enviable safety record) found cracks in much younger planes than expected (even after the expectations had been lowered from these parts lasting a lifetime to maybe lasting 1/3 that). Qantas took appropriate action, and were another airline to experience these cracks with such young airframes I'd hope they'd ground their NGs too.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by jacquesm on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:56AM (#21409502)
I'd hope that the Southwest and Qantas findings would cause other airlines to ground their NGs too if their cycle count is similar. Why assume that your aircraft are different?
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tyingq on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:36PM (#21415224)
Fwiw, all MAX are already grounded. As I alluded, the "normal" process works pretty well for cracks. If the MAX fleet needs "crack" attention, it will happen.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by jacquesm on Friday November 01, 2019 @06:36AM (#21417504)
The MAX and the NG are different aircraft.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737_Next_Generation

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tyingq on Friday November 01, 2019 @09:11AM (#21418312)
Sure, and the established process will fix it. This is not an MCAS level newsworthy event.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by inferiorhuman on Friday November 01, 2019 @06:17PM (#21424260)
Sure, and the established process will fix it. This is not an MCAS level newsworthy event.

Cracked pickle forks are absolutely noteworthy. Qantas flies its 737s in relatively mild weather, has a reputation for technically skilled pilots and excellent maintenance staff. If there were any fleet where you'd expect to find no cracks it would be Qantas. Instead Qantas has found a third NG with cracked pickle forks (out of a total of 33 NGs that required inspection).

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by wil421 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:43AM (#21408601)
Just to add, here’s a forum discussion from 5 years about about aircraft cracks in general. People are saying they are common in all aircraft even during manufacturing.

https://www.airliners.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=773937

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by msbarnett on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:20AM (#21409079)
The issue here isn’t about airframe cracking in general, which is fairly normal and expected in the lifetime of the plane, but cracking in the “pickle fork” in particular— which is abnormal, as these are not normally expected to crack during the plane’s lifetime according to Boeing’s own modelling and expectations — engineers had rated these at 90,000 cycles, the effective lifetime of the craft.

This appears to indicate (yet another) QC and manufacturing deficiency (Boeing already is dealing with other such issues with the 787 and KC-46).

The claim by OP that this is normal because aluminum cracking is normal is really wide of the facts. This part was engineered to withstand the forces it experiences for a certain timespan, and the fact that some now appear to be failing in less than one-third of the lifespan the materials engineers expected it to calls into question whether Boeing or a subcontractor is failing to engineer these components to spec.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by vultour on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:07AM (#21408908)
Except this is not about cracks in the airframe but in a component that is certified for significantly more cycles than when the cracks are being found. If these were benign FAA wouldn’t have released an AD to inspect and repair them.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by wil421 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @12:26PM (#21410520)
I believe it was 27,000 vs the 30,000 Boeing stated. How long is 3,000 landings in days/years?

The FAA is going to be investigating Boeing for everything minor and major if they want to gain a fraction of the credibility they lost.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by msbarnett on Thursday October 31, 2019 @12:31PM (#21410590)
> I believe it was 27,000 vs the 30,000 Boeing stated. How long is 3,000 landings in days/years?

Boeing's originally stated lifetime was 90,000.

After the initial discovery of the unexpected cracking, the FAA ordered an inspection of all pickle forks with more than 30,000 cycles within 7 days -- this is probably the source of your confusion. The "youngest" cracked pickle forks discovered so far was on a plane with 27,000 cycles, which is to say 63,000 cycles early (not 3,000 early) with respect to what Boeing rated it for.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by wil421 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @01:20PM (#21411250)
Makes sense thanks for the clarification. That’s a hell of a lot more and very concerning.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by manicdee on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:37PM (#21415229)
The 27k vs 30k number is Qantas claiming they don’t need to inspect their planes yet because their planes still have 300 cycles to go.

Inspection costs money. It might only take an hour to perform the inspection but that plane will be out of service for days.

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by notfromhere on Thursday October 31, 2019 @01:19PM (#21411235)
As the comment below states, the difference is 27,000 vs 63,000.

For more context, the pickle fork holds up the wings, so if those fail you are SOL

Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by samastur on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:03AM (#21408865)
Yes and I am sure all these airlines know this too and yet they are grounding them even though it costs them real money. It seems these airlines are less comfortable with the kind of cracks they noticed or the speed of their growth, but maybe you have a first hand knowledge why they are just wrong.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by dhimes on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:48AM (#21408675)
Then why are they grounding the planes? Are they fools?
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tyingq on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:52AM (#21408727)
No. An individual airline or two didn't handle things right. Boeing didn't screw up, and it's completely unrelated to the whole MAX thing. Similar issues exist for Airbus. Aluminum cracks.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by alistairSH on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:22AM (#21409103)
Yes, metal cracks and Boeing provides service intervals to inspect various pieces of the airframe. These cracks are appearing sooner than expected. The pickle fork is a critical piece of airframe - if it cracks badly, the wings come off. Grounding the planes is the correct action in this situation.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by diggan on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:26AM (#21409141)
No one is relating this article or what they are talking about to MAX/MCAS, you're the only one bringing it up. The article even mentions "The new problem is distinct from Boeing's ongoing crisis over its 737 Max planes"
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by tyingq on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:49AM (#21410067)
"Fresh" is right in the headline, and MCAS is in the article more than once. Gimme a break.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found... by jseliger on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:34AM (#21409240)
https://www.perell.com/blog/boeing-737-max

also HN discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21304277

Engineers seem to have lost control of the company.