Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found...
by throwaway5752 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:49AM
(#21410057)
Yes, but it's very long cycle failures at low frequency, and people suspect it's because of additional stress caused by winglets. Winglets reduce drag and save fuel, it's an important change. It may have been very difficult to predict and test this failure. And most importantly, the FAA and Boeing are handling it properly.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found...
by inferiorhuman on Friday November 01, 2019 @06:18PM
(#21424266)
Yes, but it's very long cycle failures at low frequency, and people suspect it's because of additional stress caused by winglets. Winglets reduce drag and save fuel, it's an important change. It may have been very difficult to predict and test this failure. And most importantly, the FAA and Boeing are handling it properly.
Cracks have been found in NGs both with and without winglets, so that is almost certainly not the issue at hand.
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found...
by notfromhere on Thursday October 31, 2019 @01:02PM
(#21410984)
That's because when they merged with McDonnell Douglas, MD executives got the top spots in Boeing, so their shitty culture transferred over to the new company.
The long-standing joke is that MD took over Boeing with Boeing's money
Re:Boeing is facing fresh crisis after another airline found...
by chopin on Thursday October 31, 2019 @11:19AM
(#21409730)
> These parts were designed to last the lifetime of the airframe
Can these be replaced? If they have the expected lifetime of the airframe they might not be serviceable. Out of curiosity: can these cracks be repaired other than replacing the part?
Cracks can be a normal and expected thing. These parts were designed to last the lifetime of the airframe (around 90,000 cycles) and are failing in under 30,000 cycles.
This raises eyebrows for two specific reasons: 1.) Boeing was already installing subpar parts (edit: not pickle forks) from Ducommon in the 737 NG 2.) The wings fall off if the pickle forks fail completely.
This news piece is just journalistic piling on to hot news.
MCAS isn't the only fire Boeing is fighting right now (they're also battling poor quality control with their KC-46 and 787 lines among other things). Some guy on PPRuNe is claiming that the pickle fork problem was just improper manufacturing[1], which when put in context would make it appear as if Boeing has some major structural problems with its organization.
1: https://www.pprune.org/showpost.php?p=10595986&postcount=258