However, cell towers (and telephones in general) are important infrastructure. They should have been designed and maintained with the expectation that power failures will happen and failed safely over to battery/generator backup power.
The traditional POTS infrastructure was[1] designed to work without power for weeks. That involved no only battery backup, but also longer-lasting backup power (e.g. big tanks of diesel) for when the batteries ran out. Cell towers going down when the power was out for a few days is evidence that those towers were not designed to be critical infrastructure and shouldn't be used as a replacement for POTS or other actually-reliable communication methods.
[1] I have no idea if that reliability still exists, or if AT&T ruined that reliability in the name of "efficiency" and profit.
> [1] I have no idea if that reliability still exists, or if AT&T ruined that reliability in the name of "efficiency" and profit.
This is addressed in the article. It's unclear to me whether AT&T lines go down due to external power failure, but other providers don't use powered lines:
> Residents said even their once-reliable landlines and Internet, such as those operated by Frontier Communications, weren’t working. Comcast/Xfinity also was down.
> In the era of traditional phone service, Ma Bell’s lines were themselves energized and very reliable.
> But companies’ transition to Voice over Internet Protocol (VOIP) – with phone calls over the Internet – is dependent on outside electricity. VOIP calls fail when either the company’s facility or the resident’s home lacks backup power.
> Comcast customers lose service where the power is out at their home, because the services need energy to operate, according to Comcast’s Joan Hammel. Comcast service also stops if power is disrupted elsewhere in the network, she said. Comcast’s service, like all other companies who have transitioned to Voice over Internet Protocol (VOIP) telephony, fails when either the company’s facility or the resident’s home lacks backup power.
> “Like all PG&E customers, we are also affected by this power shutdown, said Vince Bitong of AT&T. “We are aware that service for some customers may be affected and we continue to move quickly to keep our customers, FirstNet subscribers and public safety agencies connected.”
We had similar issues when power went out in San Diego and took down most of the radio stations which are considered part of the emergency network. Until somebody actually lands in jail for not maintaining lawfully mandated emergency readiness, this kind of crap will continue.
> Federal regulators have rejected proposed changes by the Federal Communications Commission that would require all U.S. cell phone towers to have at least eight hours of backup power.
https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/sdut-cell-towers-fcc-12... (court challenge was CTIA Wireless Assn v. FCC, et al, No. 07-1475 (D.C. Cir. 2008))
The current regulations only cover fixed line or fixed-line-like wireless services https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/47/12.5
A better solution is to require cell phone manufactures with over one million installed units in a given region to include an AM radio feature, even if it only enables when there is no cell service for a while. I know that some AM stations were taken out along with cell towers, but AM signals travel far and there is no doubt that many with an AM receiver in those areas could at least receive a broadcast from out of the area, especially if the local stations are not broadcasting interference. For extra credit, include auto Morse code detection (for even longer range broadcasts and also hearing impaired).
So I don’t know if it’s a matter of antennas, or a matter of “who listens to AM anymore?”
That doesn't clear things up.
The HN title isn't even taken from the page, and yet -- somehow -- it's still up in all its totally inaccurate glory.
While I'm grousing, the HN link is to a tweet that just links https://www.mercurynews.com/2019/10/28/why-you-cant-make-cel... ; unless we're really interested in the reply tweets, the Mercury News link might be a better target.
> Of the 874 outages, 702 were blamed on loss of power to the cell tower site.
> A few, about 60, were down due to wind or fire damage to the sites themselves.