Individual works last 20 years or until the first author's death, whichever is greater. The rights are assignable but non-transferable.
Corporate works last 20 years. The rights are transferable.
Then patents, NDAs, and non-competes are a whole other issue to resolve.
When you want to use some work it can be a hardship to tell if the author is dead. Fixed expiration time is much better.
It’s in the interests of the public to encourage the production and publication of new ideas and art. The vast majority of authors make very little for their efforts, and the majority of the benefit to society is gained simply by its publication and broad distribution. The additional benefit from derived works IMHO is much lower.
Copyright is not for your children. It is a limited right given specifically to you, the author or inventor. How did you confuse it with property rights? You are free to invest the earnings that you make from exercise of your copyright, and to give those investments and savings to your progeny; you are not free to so invest your works, because upon your passing, they are no longer yours, but enter the public domain. You chose to share those works with the public, taking their money with the understanding that the money would support you in your artistic efforts; the public, in turn, has a shared cultural knowledge which incorporates your art.
Your second paragraph is a bland restatement of the basic reason why copyright exists: Copying is easy, art is hard, so copyright is necessary to ensure that artists get paid enough to live on and create more art. However, art only happens within a cultural context, so it's also necessary to have a large and robust public domain. This balance between copyright and the public domain is reflected in the legislative history of copyright [1] around the time of the drafting of the Constitution.
To paraphrase a popular lyric, when you go knockin' on heaven's door, please leave your tools; you won't need 'em anymore.
You just made the perfect argument for a robust public domain.
I love project Gutenberg, I have several of its books on my iPad right now, but a single book shop selling copyright works probably does more in a week to promote actually reading stuff than Gutenberg does in a year.
I find out entirely reasonable for Disney to retain control of Mickey Mouse or DC to retain control of Batman as they’ve been continuously using and improving those ideas for almost 100 years. Otherwise unused aspects of culture need to be allowed to emerge (if after 30 years no one has put Mara Jade on film someone should be allowed to do it.)
Of course the Berne convention makes all this way more difficult than even normal law making, but c’est la vie
Nice idea in principle, but how are you going to prevent the Mara Jade et al. Trademark mmMintenance Holiday Special – directed by our janitor, starring a bum off the street?
> Of course the Berne convention makes all this way more difficult than even normal law making, but c’est la vie
Dress up as Mr. Duck and tell Mr. Trump that you're the better Donald. He'll get angry at Disney and resign from the Berne convention.
Alternatively elect someone that actually wants to renegotiate it. The USA doesn't have to take international treaties as decided by the powers that be, it's part of them.
That would be less fun though.
As for the US abandoning the Berne convention- it was ratified by the senate, so the President, even this reality tv drama of an administration, can’t just drop out (unless their is some detail of the ratification instrument I’m unaware of.) I thankfully still believe there is enough left of the constitutional apparatus that there remain some bounds on Presidential power, even when the president might be doing what I want.
If someone actually wants to watch this, they can rent a DRM'd Betamax tape (inventing this is certainly the most expensive step) for $999999/day.
You could of course make sure the "movie" is actually available by regulating distribution and prices. But you can't regulate how movies are supposed to be made without seriously restricting freedom of art.
What constitutes abandonment of a "derivative work mark" ultimately would probably be a delineation the courts would make. I'd hope that in a sane implementation of this scheme your strawman wouldn't hold up. It would be pretty easy to demonstrate that next to no money was spent on the creation or marketing of the product, and no one bought it, so that could still be considered abandonment. That being said, it wouldn't take much to produce new IP the keeps the mark alive so long it as it was 1) actually the same concept as the original mark (Mara Jade can't star in a rom com set in New York City without lightsabers. (Also Disney should call me about putting Mara Jade in a Rom Com set in NYC WITH lightsabers, because that would be amazing.)) and 2) gets some limited degree of public recognition.
It just now occurred to me that maybe trademark might be a better form of (long term IP) protection for stuff like Mickey Mouse.
I'm okay with Disney owning Mickey Mouse (and so forth) forever. I'm not okay with the toxic side effects of them hacking legal protections to serve their own narrow use cases.
So, as soon as they lock it away like this, they lose any rights to it. Whereas if they keep making it available, they can keep those rights forever!
Then, there are books. I don't really know what to do with them. Since books are work of a much smaller group of people (most often, 1 person), maybe it's ok for them to retain rights till their deaths.