News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by ElijahLynn on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:37PM (#21326450)
Also, some interactive examples of different voting techniques:

https://ncase.me/ballot/

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by throw_away on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:20PM (#21326957)
I came here to post this. I don't understand why Approval Voting and Score Voting don't get more love. The UX is easily understandable as we have been trained to thumbs-up and X/Y star ratings on everything from yelp and netflix. A simplified version in the form of the old pick one UX could be provided for voters who don't understand the new mechanism.

They both seem strictly better than what we have and yet I never hear anything about them. They even solve Arrow's Impossibility Paradox and have the confidence of Arrow himself.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by macawfish on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @03:57PM (#21327907)
FairVote has a lock on the "we need to change our voting system: this is the best alternative" message, and from what I can tell are dogmatically opposed to cardinal systems in general.

There's also a history of bickering and personal attacks between different voting reform activists, including people in leadership positions.

The various ordinal voting advocates (Equal Vote, CES, etc.) really need help on the messaging and movement-building front. A lot of lay people struggle to "get" the abstract framing these issues are often presented in. It comes easy to computer programmers and mathematicians because we're relentlessly trained to think abstractly about algorithmic tradeoffs and emergent limits of systems.

But a lot of people just don't see why this issue is important. It just seems like an obscure focus.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by ClayShentrup on Thursday October 24, 2019 @10:52AM (#21345238)
> The various ordinal voting advocates (Equal Vote, CES, etc.

Cardinal. FairVote is ordinal (IRV).

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by elihu on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:34PM (#21328226)
Fargo ND recently adopted approval voting (it was approved by voters by a wide margin), and there's a campaign to get an approval voting ballot measure in St. Louis.

The Center for Election Science seems to be the main advocacy group that's pushing approval voting. They're a much smaller organization than fairvote.org, but they seem to be getting more funding and gaining momentum.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by ClayShentrup on Thursday October 24, 2019 @10:56AM (#21345274)
Fargo citizens passed Approval Voting by a 64% landslide majority in 2018. https://www.vox.com/platform/amp/future-perfect/2018/11/15/1...

St. Louis will likely adopt Approval Voting in 2020. https://www.electionscience.org/st-louis-polling-results

STAR Voting will be on the ballot in Eugene, OR in 2020 and will almost certainly pass, given a previous county-wide initiative passed among Eugene voters. https://www.registerguard.com/news/20190828/star-voting-retu...

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by jacques_chester on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:58PM (#21328454)
Range voting is arguably the general case of approval voting and it has the same problem: candidates have no incentive to be honest about how the voting system works and most will campaign on "just mark 1" or "just give me the max score" in order to convert back to a FPTP.

This is not a hypothetical concern, something like this has already occurred in Australian politics. Queensland switched from exhaustive preferential (IRV where all candidates must be ranked) to optional preferential (1-n candidates may be ranked) and then ran "just vote 1" as their campaign slogan. In doing so they obliterated the centre-right and further-right parties that traditionally operate as a coalition in Parliament.

Relying on voters to be aware of the mathematics of a voting system and on candidates to represent those honestly is problematic. IRV is simple to explain, works well enough and can be efficiently hand-counted.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by throw_away on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @06:02PM (#21328900)
So, your argument is that because this system has a feature that allows it to revert back to exactly what we have now, but also gives options so that more informed voters can better indicate their preference, and is otherwise strictly better, we shouldn't do it and stick with what we have?

Arguments against IRV do not apply to SV/RV or AV. IRV and FPTP fall prey to shenanigans via Arrow's Impossibility Theorem because they require candidates to be ranked relative to one another (or you just pick the best one as in FPTP). Once they do not need to be ranked (as in two candidates can get the same vote from a given voter), then none of the Arrow problems apply.

SV and AV are also simple to explain, work well and can be hand-counted. And they don't have the huge problem that IRV and other ranked voting mechanisms have.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by throw_away on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @06:05PM (#21328928)
& how can IRV be hand-counted? It is the most difficult system listed here to compute and most difficult to explain to voters why the outcome happened.
Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by jacques_chester on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @08:28PM (#21329879)
> & how can IRV be hand-counted?

It's very easy. Australia regularly does it with millions of ballots.

Step one: you count the ballots by hand.

Phew, what an exhaustive list of instructions!

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by ClayShentrup on Thursday October 24, 2019 @11:02AM (#21345323)
No it is not "very easy". IRV is not summable, so a two-way communication is needed between every round. The San Francisco city elections page once explained this as follows: “Due to the requirement that all ballots must be centrally tallied in City Hall and not at the polling places, the Department of Elections has not set a date for releasing any preliminary results using the ranked-choice voting method.”

So you either have the communication between every round (which is essentially re-counting) or you physically take all the ballots to a central counting location, which introduces delays and chain of custody issue.

Also, IRV leads to more spoiled ballots. http://scorevoting.net/SPRates.html

So while there are more important reasons to prefer Score Voting and Approval Voting (better outcomes, better resistance to strategy, etc.), complexity is certainly not a non-issue.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by jacques_chester on Friday October 25, 2019 @08:15AM (#21354184)
First preferences are summable and it is usually clear, on the night of the election, who has won the majority in Parliament. This is called the "indicative count".

As for chain of custody, again, Australia has solved this problem. Every box is numbered, every seal on the box is numbered. All of them are signed out by electoral officials, witnessed by at least two scrutineers from different candidates. When the boxes are opened this process is repeated.

Do you know how many times ballot boxes have gone missing in an Australian election? Once. In a century. Once. For which the High Court voided the election because there was a minute but non-zero chance that the outcome would've been affected. It was re-run from scratch.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by throw_away on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @02:21AM (#21331653)
IRV has potentially multiple vote transfer steps and passes whereas all the other mechanisms are a single pass sum. IRV is easily the most complex to both compute and understand compared to the other alternatives (AV/SV/FPTP).

Furthermore, doesn't Australia use it only for House elections where you don't have to compute across a particularly large population?

Your tone is rather dismissive here.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by jacques_chester on Friday October 25, 2019 @08:10AM (#21354156)
Australia uses it both for House and Senate elections. Millions of votes cast in a day. Indicative count on the night.

My tone is dismissive because I am tired of being told IRV is "too complex" or "won't work". Because it's simple and it has scaled flawlessly for decades. You just need to believe the experience of other countries is more valid than a theory.

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by throw_away on Friday October 25, 2019 @12:42PM (#21356756)
The AU senate is STV, no? And even then, the largest polity is NSW with only 8M people. 12 US states are more populous than this.

But, I'm with you that IRV is workable (there's ample evidence) and better than the abomination that FPTP is. I guess my point is that AV/SV address these concerns through their simplicity (I find both of them less complex than IRV in both voter UX and result computation) and also that they avoid the unintuitive problems mentioned in the OP ncase link, which can potentially be even worse than the problems of FPTP simply because they are hard for even educated voters to wrap their heads around, whereas the problems of FPTP (vote splitting) are easier to explain (but still bad. this isn't a defense of fptp).

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by yyyk on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:28PM (#21329537)
Range voting is an abomination. It's the perfect example of a system ranked as good by Arrow Theorem logic which horribly fails most actual requirements for a voting system - unlike Approval Voting, which despite the tactical voting non-issue is practically reasonable.

[Some practical requirements for/questions about a voting method:

* Does it always have a winner?

* Can the resulting winner always enjoy public legitimacy?

* Is the voting system simple enough for the public to understand?

* Can it map to useful public choices?

* Is it susceptible to cheating?

* Does it bias towards the center or not? (Note that some people might prefer biasing and some not).

* Can voters signal to politicians they must change course? ]

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by ClayShentrup on Thursday October 24, 2019 @11:03AM (#21345338)
Score Voting is objectively the best of the commonly proposed voting methods, with any mixture of strategic or honest voters. http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html

It is objectively one of the simplest voting methods based on summability, rates of spoiled ballots, speed it takes the average voter to complete a ballot, etc.

http://scorevoting.net/Lorenzo

Re:Ranked-choice voting is on the ballot in New York City by yyyk on Thursday October 24, 2019 @01:21PM (#21346849)
Score voting? Is that how they're calling it now?

However it is called, there are many reasons for why it is so bad, but they all boil to one point: it's asking voters for information they do not have while ignoring the human realities of the vote. As we code monkeys say: GIGO.

99% of humanity doesn't have a 'Score' for politicians* , but the reality of the vote is that whatever choice the voter has, the voter can push effectively by giving min/max scores - or at least is very likely to think it can be helpful, and feel guilty when they don't do it - imagine losing an election because you merely gave your preferred candidate an 8!

A Range Voting election where everyone gives min/max scores de facto may look mathematically identical to Approval Voting, but it is far worse in reality.

That's because voters will then convince themselves their choice is deserved - their politician is a 10 and the other is a 0, an enemy. The problem in other words is that voters will mostly not partially abstain, but be pushed into a false polarization beyond what is useful for society. Psychology, not math.

There are other points, but this message is long enough. TL;DR: "Score" voting is the triumph of mathematically optimized voting methods that ignores too many human considerations.

But look, I am willing to go half way: Approval voting is a perfectly good method and I can accept Borda. Both are strictly better than the current method even according to the weird measurement "The Center for Range Voting" uses. Approval can even be seen as a (sane) version of RV, so there's no reason at all for the center to object.

* Oh, and the 1% who actually has a score? That's almost worse, because these scores are nearly always the compilation of single issue organizations which tend towards the extremes and never look at circumstances.