News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by henryfjordan on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:16PM (#21318646)
The courts very much got it right in this case. Joe Shmoe has health problems and will listen to a "doctor" but they don't have a bridge half-built in their backyard or an automotive manufacturing setup. There's just no risk to letting people say they are engineers, and the first amendment should only be infringed upon for good reason.

Let's take this case as an example. Anyone can send a letter saying "The traffic light is too short; here's the math to prove it". Saying "I'm an engineer" might help you get that letter noticed, but it would almost certainly be illegal to reprogram the light without a professional engineer's sign-off independent of that letter no matter the person's qualifications. The state was never at risk of acting on his advice no matter how he represented himself. So why not let him say it?

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by grepthisab on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:30PM (#21319500)
No pretending to be an engineer can have deadly consequences. Imagine someone saying they're an engineer and being contracted to build a bridge or building. That could (and has) have disastrous consequences.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by NOGDP on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:34PM (#21319526)
You can be an engineer without an engineering license. Safety-critical jobs usually require a professional engineering license, but there are a lot of engineering work which is not safety-critical.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by SECProto on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:45PM (#21319590)
When it comes to civil stuff (i.e. the safety critical thing people think of when they hear engineer - bridges, buildings, highways, flood protection...) you absolutely can't call yourself an engineer without professional accreditation in every jurisdiction I know.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by NOGDP on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:01PM (#21319680)
Even then (buildings for example), I believe some of the work can be done by non-licensed engineers. Stuff like land surveying, some electrical, CAD/modelling work, design of plumbing, heating, etc. can be done without license. I know a few people that aren't licensed but work on condos as engineers. I'm guessing a lot of the stuff has to be reviewed/approved by a licensed engineer, but that could be 1 to 5 licensed:unlicensed for example.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by SECProto on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:11PM (#21319744)
Definitely! Engineers don't do all the work. But if you're working in the field, you don't call yourself an engineer unless you're licensed.

(For context: I work in the field and am not a registered engineer, though I studied it in university. I would never call myself an engineer)

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by 7952 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:17AM (#21320826)
I guess this confusion is why a lot of professions use "chartered" to signify this.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by OJFord on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @11:45AM (#21324980)
Chartership for engineering most certainly exists, and there are many good reasons it should be more popular within software engineering.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by richk449 on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:27PM (#21320134)
You have an engineering degree, but you wouldn’t call yourself an engineer?

What do you call yourself?

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by SECProto on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:31PM (#21320158)
An engineering graduate, or an engineer-in-training. You can call yourself an engineer once you have several years of experience, pass some exams on law and ethics and whatnot, and get a professional designation.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by ballenf on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:37AM (#21320653)
Do the ethics courses focus on when you’re allowed to call yourself an engineer?
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by zo1 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:06AM (#21321284)
That is downright ridiculous, sorry. You are an engineer, just not a "certified" or "accredited" one for some sub-set of tasks/things/requirements. The fact that we have to even discuss this as if saying you're an engineer is some ultra-taboo because people might "mistakenly" allow you to do mission critical or potentially dangerous work without asking for your specific accreditation is disturbing and Orwellian-like policing of plain language.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by journalctl on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:55AM (#21321860)
No, it’s why actual engineering isn’t currently suffering the influx of unskilled dilettantes like software is.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by NOGDP on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:20PM (#21328601)
Getting an engineering license doesn't require much in terms of skill beyond what you'd learn in undergrad.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by slavik81 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @11:21PM (#21330749)
The work experience requirement is pretty important, though. That's how you learn the practical side of the field.

I have a degree in EE, but there's a 0% chance I could safely design electrical equipment. In school they taught me how to analyze circuits, but I know nothing of the electrical code, let alone practical matters like mechanical stresses on wires. Without somebody to learn from, I would learn a lot of things the hard way—when the design fails.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by NOGDP on Friday October 25, 2019 @12:45PM (#21356781)
You learn those things the same whether you will get an engineering license in the future or not. The engineer exams don't actually test this kind of knowledge.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by SECProto on Friday October 25, 2019 @05:53PM (#21359607)
You have to have 4 years of accredited experience working under an already-certified professional engineer. This experience get audited, and references get called to confirm the types of experience and whether it is adequate. The auditor is free to say "this two month period and that six month period were not adequate experience. You have to get 8 more months experience before you can qualify." It's not the exam alone, but rather the combination of multiple factors: required education, required experience, examinations, and ongoing professional training (required to do several dozen hours per year of certified professional training to stay current).
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by slavik81 on Friday October 25, 2019 @07:49PM (#21360373)
In my jurisdiction there are no technical exams for applicants with a degree from an accredited program. I regard the exams as much less important than work experience under the supervision of someone who knows what they're doing.

I am a licensed professional engineer with a B.Sc. in EE, so I've gone through every part of the process for designing electrical equipment except for acquiring work experience in that subfield. The only thing preventing me from signing off on an electrical drawing is that I do not believe I am qualified.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by ajdlinux on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:24AM (#21320856)
There's only one state in Australia that has mandatory registration of engineers. There are several more states that are currently starting up mandatory registration schemes, and of course the national professional bodies operate voluntary registration and accreditation schemes.

Now of course that doesn't mean that you can just start building bridges as a non-accredited engineer, I expect the courts would look unkindly on you in a negligence lawsuit if your company had engineers that couldn't demonstrate their professional qualifications and development.

This is seen as a problem and the professional bodies are pushing more states to adopt mandatory registration, so we'll see more of that in the next few years, but it's not like Australia is a land where bridges fall down weekly without mandatory registration.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by danielscrubs on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @06:14AM (#21321983)
The funny thing is that civilingenjör (engineer) is a protected title in Sweden.

Also amusing that it's a Swedish person fighting with the American mindset (My Constitutions!). It's very rare to see those.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Dylan16807 on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:42PM (#21319930)
I could at least pretend that might happen if there was only one kind of engineer. But someone that incompetent at hiring might also hire the wrong kind of engineer. The rule doesn't do anything to help.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by slavik81 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @03:20AM (#21321076)
A P.Eng. is professionally obligated to refuse work that they're not competent to perform. You can't hire the wrong kind of engineer, because the engineer knows if they're the right kind or not.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by ultrarunner on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @03:45AM (#21321192)
Then the wrong engineer just also shirks professional obligation.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by slavik81 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:58AM (#21321526)
Which would result in their license to practice being revoked by the professional association.

It takes ~8 years to fulfill the requirements to acquire a professional license. It's not worth the risk of being caught.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by slavik81 on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @12:56AM (#21331180)
Just to expand, I've never heard of an engineer from the wrong field signing off on a document (e.g. an EE signing off on a structure), but here's a lesser example of unskilled practice and the corresponding disciplinary action: https://www.apega.ca/assets/PDFs/discipline-decisions/18-011...
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by solotronics on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:50PM (#21329682)
I am a network engineer and as far as I know there is no professional board for this.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by erikpukinskis on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @07:59PM (#21329738)
That means you’re not an engineer.

That’s not an insult, I’m sure you’re quite skilled. But outside of the software industry “engineer” is a term that signifies certification.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by kortilla on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:05AM (#21320287)
Well they couldn’t sign off on the part that requires a registered engineer... soooooo