News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by hristov on Saturday January 22, 2011 @06:59PM (#2131396)
Hans Reiser is above and beyond all a fucking psychopath. It is obvious to me that the cloning story is just a ploy for him to make some money. It seems ridiculous at first glance, but it has a chance of working.

You see Hans knows very well that he had a huge groups of fans and supporters and that those supporters were not very smart and supported him even after the evidence against him got more and more obvious and incontrovertible. I remember that even after he led the police to her body there were huge discussions on slashdot and some people were still talking about how he was still somehow unfairly treated by the justice system and Nina somehow brought this about on herself.

Psychopaths are very adept at using people, and I bet Hans just feels that there still are some people he can use out there. The problem is that after he showed her body to the police even his most ardent fans would have to admit that he killed her.

So he comes up with this story that he wants to clone her to give her the happy childhood that she missed. (Notice that he did not say that he wanted to give her her adulthood which she missed because he killed her).

Obviously a smart and practical person like him knows that this will not work. Even if cloning were possible, you would create a different person. It would be a different person with the same DNA but a different person nevertheless.

So yes, he is just a psychopath that wants to get another bunch of money from the fools that used to believe him.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by triffidhunter on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:25PM (#2131449)
It's easy to identify with wrongly convicted people. It happens, and it's widely reported, but it's rare. Many people are so horrified by the thought of going to prison for something they didn't do that they forget how unusual it is.

Because he was a programmer, contributing to Linux, people on /. and elsewhere wanted him to not be guilty. They identified with him on some level. As the evidence started to mount against him, it made people look for crazy ways in which he could not be guilty.

I agree with you, he's a psychopath. This new story is just further confirmation that he's lost touch with reality. All you have to do is go back and read his postings to linux-kernel to realize he's also a huge dick.

Oh, and reiserfs sucks.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jedsmith on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:33PM (#2131465)
> Oh, and reiserfs sucks.

I was with you until here. T'so is quoted as writing that btrfs has a lot of the same design ideas of ReiserFS, and that he supports btrfs as the way forward (he particularly disliked Hans and Namesys, though): http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/8/1/217

Some distros moved to ReiserFS by default, too.

Somehow I've never found the time to properly try it out, but I never really got the impression from others that used it that it sucks. I might be wrong, though.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by triffidhunter on Sunday January 23, 2011 @04:07AM (#2132094)
> I was with you until here. T'so is quoted as writing that btrfs has a lot of the same design ideas of ReiserFS,

When I was using reiserfs years ago, it ate all my data (/home unraveled). I like the features, and it was nice and fast for the time but I've held a grudge against it for years as a result. Looking at dumps of the on disk data structures showed massive corruption.

At work, we used it for a long time in a project where tail-packing is a huge win (many many small files). Never had any problems there.

So, it doesn't really suck I just had a bad experience.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by wazoox on Sunday January 23, 2011 @11:13AM (#2132628)
I had too, at a time, and it was because of a flakey ATA controller (some VIA-based shitty mobo). Don't throw the baby with the bath water :)
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by kinetik on Saturday January 22, 2011 @09:08PM (#2131597)
Some distros moved to ReiserFS by default, too.

SuSE, who later realized it was a mistake and moved back to ext3?

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jedsmith on Sunday January 23, 2011 @12:57AM (#2131891)
Even though they denied it, I'm willing to bet that SuSE (and others) made the move after realizing the Reiser community was about to be abruptly beheaded.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by SoftwareMaven on Sunday January 23, 2011 @01:36AM (#2131940)
Not just beheaded (a particularly gruesome term in light of this topic), but to have a very negative association. Remember that SuSe is open-source but supported by the very corporate Novel. I don't know that I'd want that association with my company, and the suits running Novel are probably less inclined.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by flomo on Sunday January 23, 2011 @05:45AM (#2132208)
The arrest was likely the instigator, but at that point it had long been clear that Reiser4 wasn't going to be accepted in the kernel mainline, and Reiser3 had gone off into an 'unsupported' limbo. The switch would have happened sooner or later.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by MichaelSalib on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:28PM (#2131455)
It happens, and it's widely reported, but it's rare

Why should we assume that? Based on incentives, one would expect false convictions to be rather common: after all, when false convictions are discovered, there's no punishment meted out to the judge, jury, prosecutors, police and forensics experts that helped wrongly convict in the first place.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by michaelbuckbee on Saturday January 22, 2011 @08:16PM (#2131529)
The Innocence Project states that there have been 266 post conviction DNA exonerations in the US.

http://www.innocenceproject.org/know/

I'm of the opinion that it's basically impossible to know how many wrongful convictions have taken place, but those 266 cases are surely the tip of the iceberg when you consider the difficulty in identifying the cases, determining if potential exculpatory evidence existed, testing that evidence and then pushing all of that through a courtroom.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by gnosis on Saturday January 22, 2011 @11:26PM (#2131779)
"The Innocence Project states that there have been 266 post conviction DNA exonerations in the US."

But were they really innocent?

DNA evidence can be misused in the courts:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20727743.300-how-dna-e...

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by pessimizer on Sunday January 23, 2011 @10:09AM (#2132487)
Did you read that article and decide that people are getting off due to questionable statistics? As far as I can tell, the article is about calculating the probability of random people matching a particular DNA sample, not about excluding people, which is a lot easier.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by gnosis on Sunday January 23, 2011 @02:03PM (#2133047)
"As far as I can tell, the article is about calculating the probability of random people matching a particular DNA sample, not about excluding people, which is a lot easier."

No.

The article is very clearly questions the role of DNA evidence as a whole.

A couple of relevant quotes:

"Defence experts were trusting that the scientists had interpreted the data correctly. This perpetuated the myth that DNA is infallible."

"There's a considerable lack of understanding, not just from the public, but from the judges and lawyers."

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by pessimizer on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:06PM (#2133199)
"This week we show how, even when analysts agree that someone could be a match for a piece of DNA evidence, the statistical weight assigned to that match can vary enormously."

This seems to be the author's opinion about what the article is about.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by gnosis on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:46PM (#2133282)
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree about this.

Make of it what you will. The article speaks for itself.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by pessimizer on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:23PM (#2133763)
It does, and when it speaks, it speaks of different statistical methods for calculating the probability of a random match to partial DNA samples.

edit: BTW, it's a very interesting article - thanks for pointing it out.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by RobGR on Sunday January 23, 2011 @05:13PM (#2133480)
There's this fellow who posts by the name "gnosis" on the interwebs, and I'm pretty sure he's the real killer of JFK. The DNA evidence for his innonence is . . . wait for it . . . NONEXISTENT !!!11!!! OMFG CALL NANCY GRACE NOW !!!
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by tptacek on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:44PM (#2131480)
There's a statistical bias in this argument; we remember the cases in which we've learned people were convicted on shoddy evidence, but pay little attention to the overwhelming vast majority of uneventful cases in which justice is (at least nominally) served. I think it's facile to suggest that false convictions are common, and I think it's possible to point that out without arguing that we should be any less vigilant against false convictions.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by binarybits on Saturday January 22, 2011 @09:05PM (#2131594)
There's also a countervailing bias that I suspect is far more important: most wrongly-convicted defendants have no way to prove their innocence, and so we never learn that they were wrongly convicted. Many criminal defendants are not sophisticated about the law, and their cases are handled by overworked public defenders. The courts in many states are extremely stingy about giving defendants access to evidence or legal appeals post-conviction. So even if potentially-exculpatory evidence emerges, the convict often can't do anything with it.

This is one of those statistics that will never be known with any precision, but even if the number of known exonerations is small (which I don't know to be the case) that doesn't prove that the number of innocents in jail is small.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by MikeCapone on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:58PM (#2131500)
I would think that most mistaken convictions happen to cases that receive very little scrutiny, including by the media (think poor uneducated ethnic minority with state-provided overworked lawyer).
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by lambda on Sunday January 23, 2011 @02:07AM (#2131968)
> overwhelming vast majority of uneventful cases in which justice is (at least nominally) served.

You are assuming in that statement that there is an overwhelming majority of cases in which justice is served. You even try to leave yourself an out with the "at least nominally", which demonstrates part of the problem with your argument.

Among the problems with this argument: the assumption that many of the crimes we are convicting people for are actually bad, and thus worthy of being considered crimes. The assumption that convicting and imprisoning people for the crimes that they commit is just, or even that it achieves whatever ends it is supposed to achieve. The assumption that people are convicted of crimes on the basis of whether or not they actually committed the crime, plus a small random factor due to mistakes, rather than systemic social reasons relating to class, race, poverty, and other social issues (even if many of the people who are convicted of crimes are actually guilty, if the guilty of one group are convicted at a far higher rate than the other group, it's not quite right to say that justice is served in this case).

You have to be careful about bias in the other direction; the just world fallacy. It's very easy to believe that we live in a just world (and part of why people find such hope in the idea of just deities); when something bad happens, many people try to find a reason or to justify it. But in fact, we do not live in a just world; we live in an impartial world, populated with imperfect people. Given that, you need to be skeptical of any time you find yourself thinking that the vast majority of any particular situation is just, especially with stakes as high as criminal justice.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by btilly on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:59AM (#2132087)
I don't have any up to date figures, but http://www.caught.net/innoc.htm suggests that the rate of wrongly convicted innocent people could be around 10%. So the vast majority of convicted people belong there. Indisputably a lot of people walk free who are guilty. But there are also a lot of innocent people behind bars.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by cma on Saturday January 22, 2011 @10:15PM (#2131676)
That assumes there is no internal "don't want to fuck someone's life up without cause" incentive internal to the individuals (i.e. that assumes psychopathy on the part of everyone involved in the justice system).
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by randallsquared on Saturday January 22, 2011 @11:53PM (#2131811)
That we have police and courts at all assumes that people harm others without sufficient cause. Any argument that we need no external incentives for everyone involved in the justice system to do the right thing is an argument that we don't need the justice system in the first place.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by cma on Sunday January 23, 2011 @01:33PM (#2132986)
What I meant was that to assume there was no incentive was to assume complete psychopathy on everyone's part. What you are saying is that while the basic empathy incentive may exist, it isn't enough. I agree with that just fine.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by js2 on Saturday January 22, 2011 @09:03PM (#2131591)
For those who don't appreciate exactly what psychopath means, see http://www.hare.org/links/saturday.html
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by lambda on Sunday January 23, 2011 @01:34AM (#2131936)
An interesting read, but I will note that the linked article is from Robert Hare's own website, and it reeks of pop-psychology and pop-science (lots of anecdotal evidence, and claims of him being a misunderstood pioneer, not much in the way of actual verifiable arguments or even proper citations). I know that the idea of the psychopath, the unrepentant criminal or person without the ability for empathy, has become popular recently, but I am skeptical of some of the claims I've seen about the nature of the condition itself, the diagnosis of the condition, how common it is, and the possibility of any sort of rehabilitation.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jacquesm on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:18AM (#2132297)
It's on his site because he asked the author apparently if it is ok to reproduce it, but it's written by one 'Robert Hercz', it was the cover story of the Sep. 8th 2001 issue of Saturday Night magazine.

That's not exactly a scientific publication either, but it is not as if he wrote it himself.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by superkarn on Sunday January 23, 2011 @12:30PM (#2132841)
Here's a blog that I ran into a while back. Lately the updates have been few and far in between. But it's still an interesting read. http://raising-a-psychopath.blogspot.com/
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jacquesm on Saturday January 22, 2011 @11:31PM (#2131784)
Thanks for that link, it wasn't the most pleasant piece I've read in the last month but certainly one of the more interesting ones.

Especially the bits about the fact that it's not a disease per se but more of a natural variation and the fact that it occurs as much as 1% of the time are quite something to absorb.

The first implies that there is no cure, the second that you probably know at least a few of them, even if they're of the 'subclinical' (according to the article) variety.

I think I've worked for one.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by evo_9 on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:28PM (#2131454)
I think if he really wanted to try to hold onto and milk his supporters he would have never taken the police to the spot he buried his wife - instead clinging to the story he was an innocent man.

I think he's just f-n nuts (or possible brilliant and nuts).

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by tptacek on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:37PM (#2131470)
Had he not led the police to the body, he'd have gotten life without parole: he was convicted of a particularly heinous first degree murder. It is still unlikely that he'll ever be released. But after revealing the body, he has, as a formality, a chance at eventual release. I don't think the tea leaves you're reading really say anything about his mental state.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by hristov on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:39PM (#2131472)
Well he did get a sentence reduction out of that. He was initially convicted to first degree murder which carries 25 years to life minimal. For showing the body he got the sentence reduced to second degree murder which carries 15 years to life. So 10 years of life behind bars would probably have been a higher priority for him than milking his supporters.

Of course I doubt any of this matters, because it is doubtful he will get paroled. But hope spring eternal.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by njharman on Sunday January 23, 2011 @12:54AM (#2131888)
guiltyness and fair treatment by justice system are orthogonal. just saying, without commet as to this particular case.

if ones rights are trampled to prove their guilt then that guilt must be put aside / go unpunished. otherwise authority has very little incentive to abide your rights and very much incentive to violate them.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by Confusion on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:03AM (#2132285)

  Obviously a smart and practical person like him knows 
  that this will not work
It's interesting how people will acknowledge the guy is insane and in the same breath accuse him of being sane enough to understand something doesn't work. Arguments based on that premise can't hold: if someone is insane, all bets are off. Especially because you can't know how this huge failure (being incarcerated is losing the 'get-what-you-want'-game big time!) affected his mind.

I'll offer an alternative 'explanation': his mind does in fact contain all kinds of 'feeling guilty' thoughts, but it doesn't know how to handle them. Hell, the appropriate pathways may be missing. As a response, his mind comes up with some plan to restore her to life. Never mind his justifications: they may just be made up by other parts of his mind, so it can ponder a narrative that seems coherent/consistent to itself. He may just ve trying to silence nagging guilt in the only way he can.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by JshWright on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:13AM (#2132293)
hristov never said he was insane, he said he was a psychopath. Psychopaths are often _exceptionally_ rational people.

(Note: I'm not agreeing or disagreeing with histrov, I'm just saying that calling a psychopath "smart and practical" doesn't contradict his argument)

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by Confusion on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:56AM (#2132331)
Note that I'm not necessarily disagreeing with hristov either. I'm just arguing that psychopaths are not just rational people and are known to behave in what are generally considered to be 'insane ways'.

The idea that psychopaths are often exceptionally rational people is a misconception, popularized by the common depiction of the 'accomplishments' of highly intelligent psychopaths. Most psychopaths are not highly intelligent. Moreover, as far as psychopaths seem to function as normal people, it's because they employ rational methods of thinking to know how to behave to get what they want. However, that their behavior is mostly based on rational ways of thinking, does not necessarily mean they are actually any good at those ways of thinking. Only the highly intelligent are.

And even then: point in fact: murdering your wife is hardly ever, and certainly not under the circumstances Reiser did, a rational thing to do.

Psychopaths behave in insane ways, specifically because they only employ rational modes of thinking, which are necessarily insufficient to make proper decisions about 'how to get what they want'. Why is that? Because you always lack enough information to make proper rational decisions. I can't rationally decide whether to eat another cookie.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by shasta on Saturday January 22, 2011 @09:51PM (#2131645)
> (Notice that he did not say that he wanted to give her her adulthood which she missed because he killed her).

Maybe he wants to kill her again.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jacquesm on Saturday January 22, 2011 @10:55PM (#2131740)
That was uncalled for I think. It's not even remotely humoristic and if it was not meant as humor then this comment is probably a new low for HN.

The bit where he writes in this letter about wanting to raise her with his children to me clearly indicates the man is out of his mind, far more than his crazy plan of resurrecting her does (and as if murdering your wife isn't indication enough in that direction). I don't see any evidence that Reiser wants to kill his wife again but I do think that when he has served his sentence and is released that he probably should be placed in a hospital of sorts.

Of course his plan doesn't stand a snowballs chance in hell of working in the first place, clearly he has lost whatever marbles he still had.

Involving the kids in his minds view of this scheme is particularly painful, I think they'll need all the healing they can get without this sort of weirdness, they've been scarred for life already.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by shasta on Sunday January 23, 2011 @08:10AM (#2132351)
> clearly indicates the man is out of his mind

I'm not a psychologist, but I think you may be on to something here. Thanks, you've talked me out of donating.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by brendoncrawford on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:06AM (#2132027)
> That was uncalled for I think. It's not even remotely humoristic

Come on, you didn't even give a small chortle?

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by code_duck on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:36AM (#2132066)
No, I shook my head and pondered how clearly mentally unbalanced Reiser is.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jonhendry on Sunday January 23, 2011 @04:39AM (#2132126)
At the very least, I think it shows that he wants a version of his wife that could be controlled and manipulated.

Really not a healthy mindset, I don't think. And that's not even getting into sexual issues.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by kiba on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:20PM (#2131439)
How do you know that Hans Reiser is a pyschopath?

Maybe it's just a ploy for him to make money, or maybe that's his way of remorse.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by hristov on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:44PM (#2131482)
Because he has continued to show any lack of remorse. Let's look even at this story. He did not say that he wanted to clone her to try to reverse the terrible thing that he did (i.e., murdering her). Or to try to give her life back that he took away. He said he wanted to give her the happy childhood that she missed.

I am not sure whether Nina had an unhappy childhood, but if she did that was clearly through no fault of Reiser's because he met her when she was an adult. So even in this he cannot bring himself to admit that he did something wrong.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by pjscott on Saturday January 22, 2011 @08:20PM (#2131532)
The way you put that is kind of creepy. A clone of someone is a completely different person, who just happens to share DNA. To think of a clone as "Nina, reincarnated" or some such thing is not just wrong; it's potentially harmful to the emotional welfare of the clone in question.

Cloning someone can not reverse murdering them. Cloning someone can not give someone back any life they may have lost. Cloning someone can not give them a happy childhood. I know this is academic now, but if (when?) there are human clones walking around, this kind of thinking is going to be a problem.

Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by starpilot on Sunday January 23, 2011 @01:55AM (#2131953)
I'm going to say something sounding terribly naive: It's almost as if Reiser thinks humans are essentially genetic code that can be duplicated to produce exact copies. It's like he's objectified people as physiological analogs of his own work.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by jonhendry on Sunday January 23, 2011 @04:46AM (#2132138)
He wants to make a symlink to Nina.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by omarchowdhury on Sunday January 23, 2011 @12:24AM (#2131847)
I think what you fail to see here is that the "creepiness" is built in to Reiser's ideology.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by res0nat0r on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:25PM (#2131448)
If he is really remorseful how about asking the public to donate to a fund that goes directly towards his children?
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future... by kiba on Saturday January 22, 2011 @07:30PM (#2131461)
A pyschopath don't feel remorse, therefore it doesn't matter what he ask the public to do.

Remorse is an internal state. It would be like telling children to apologize without the children actually feeling bad for their action.