Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future...
by pessimizer on Sunday January 23, 2011 @10:09AM
(#2132487)
Did you read that article and decide that people are getting off due to questionable statistics? As far as I can tell, the article is about calculating the probability of random people matching a particular DNA sample, not about excluding people, which is a lot easier.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future...
by gnosis on Sunday January 23, 2011 @02:03PM
(#2133047)
"As far as I can tell, the article is about calculating the probability of random people matching a particular DNA sample, not about excluding people, which is a lot easier."
No.
The article is very clearly questions the role of DNA evidence as a whole.
A couple of relevant quotes:
"Defence experts were trusting that the scientists had interpreted the data correctly. This perpetuated the myth that DNA is infallible."
"There's a considerable lack of understanding, not just from the public, but from the judges and lawyers."
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future...
by pessimizer on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:06PM
(#2133199)
"This week we show how, even when analysts agree that someone could be a match for a piece of DNA evidence, the statistical weight assigned to that match can vary enormously."
This seems to be the author's opinion about what the article is about.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future...
by gnosis on Sunday January 23, 2011 @03:46PM
(#2133282)
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree about this.
Make of it what you will. The article speaks for itself.
Re:Hans Reiser: former genius, convicted murderer and future...
by pessimizer on Sunday January 23, 2011 @07:23PM
(#2133763)
It does, and when it speaks, it speaks of different statistical methods for calculating the probability of a random match to partial DNA samples.
edit: BTW, it's a very interesting article - thanks for pointing it out.