News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Dumblydorr on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:24AM (#21311424)
Lights seem incredibly inefficient to me. How many times have I been driving towards a green at the speed limit and it turns yellow just in time to force me to slam on the brakes or the gas pedal, all to let one waiting car go? Why not detect my coming and wait for an efficient yellow timing, thus I am not wasting gas and braking unnecessarily? This would substantially improve carbon emissions and brake dust, yet dozens of times per month, I see lights inefficiently block traffic unnecessarily.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Kudos on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:17AM (#21311885)
You can't always do this with current traffic planning. In busier areas you have to consider throughput at _other_ junctions and not just the immediate one. Changing one light's timing could make zero difference to that junction, but could totally screw up traffic flow downstream of it.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by uoaei on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:44PM (#21316414)
Your point is valid but isn't really a counterargument to what OP said. There is a balance to be struck.

Some sort of half-local/half-global optimization algorithm running in the "smart grid" would be a good idea.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by TheGallopedHigh on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:21PM (#21316846)
Optimizing traffic flow is major area of research in academia. Dresden has a full group dedicated to it
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lunias on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:43AM (#21311587)
Agreed. The traffic light paradigm that I've seen popping up more often (which really bothers me) is the red left turn arrow. Light's green, no oncoming traffic; but can't make a very safe left because there's a red arrow staring back at me.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by triceratops on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:07PM (#21318991)
Ontario solves that by having there be a left green arrow + regular green light. The left green arrow indicates a protected left but you are also free to make an unprotected left on the regular green light, once the left green is off.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by toomanybeersies on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:22PM (#21319081)
Australia and New Zealand have the same (except on the right turn arrow because we drive on the left).

I always thought this was normal. If the right turn arrow is green you have right of way, if it's red you must stop, and if it's not illuminated you give way to oncoming traffic and turn when safe.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by fma on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:39PM (#21317055)
For this scenario, I've seen new lights have the left turn arrow blinks. It lets you know you can turn left if it's safe to do so.

It took a while to get used to because in the past there simply just won't be any signal, to imply you can go if you want.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lilott8 on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:47PM (#21317153)
I've really loathed my time driving in socal coming from the midwest. The idea that I cannot turn left on green is one of the more appalling "features" of traffic management here (the way the lights work, in general is abhorrent). But slowly, throughout socal, I've seen the flashing yellow left-turn arrow; a subtle change to the UX that I think is brilliant and should be adopted everywhere.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by bradstewart on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:07PM (#21326062)
They've started putting these (blinking yellow arrows for non-protected left turns) all over Austin. Confused the heck out of me at first as well.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by CaliforniaKarl on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:25PM (#21318197)
If I remember correctly, in Southern California, some intersections have an additional left-turn arrow which flashes yellow, indicating that you may make the left turn if there is no oncoming traffic.

It's a separate light to make the flashing-yellow to solid-yellow transition clearer.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by ken on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:11AM (#21312433)
Explanation, for those who don’t understand the problem: in some states, like New York, a red arrow is different than a red circle in that it prohibits turn-on-red.

In other states, like Washington, the red arrow is equivalent to the red circle. We even have left-turn-on-red, so (unless you’re stuck behind an out-of-towner) this tends to be much less of an issue.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by andrewmunsell on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:59PM (#21317929)
For those Washingtonians that didn't know about left-on-red (I didn't before a couple weeks ago), you can turn left on red (or a red arrow) as long as it's from a one- or two-way street onto a one-way street (or freeway on-ramp), after a stop and if it's clear.

https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20181101-01/?p=10...

https://app.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=46.61.055

I've never done it myself and don't intend to start since I think it's a bit obscure and I don't want to argue with a cop about it if I get pulled over.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by WorldMaker on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:39PM (#21317061)
The variety in individual state traffic light rules is fascinating, and something that certainly doesn't help for US travelers. Some states are left-turn-on-red, others are not, telling which is which is not always obvious.

(For instance, Kentucky is no left-turn-on-red [either red arrow or full red; mostly the state doesn't use red arrows because they'd be redundant in that case], but allows for left-turn-may-yield on flashing yellow/amber.)

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by C1sc0cat on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:53AM (#21311680)
This where you need filter signals
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by dsfyu404ed on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:44AM (#21312148)
A red left arrow is just the state/municipality telling you you're too stupid to make the decision yourself.

I'm a big fan of the "green for a few seconds then flashing yellow" arrow.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lunias on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:54AM (#21312241)
Seems like the only possible reason to me... sadly we live in a society that caters to the lowest common denominator rather than demanding and rewarding excellence. I worry for future generations.

When I lived in Tucson AZ almost every light was set up for lagging left turns. Where you can go when it's safe, but in the event of heavy traffic you'd be able to count on having a green arrow to empty the left turn lane - worked great!

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by magduf on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:17PM (#21314016)
>sadly we live in a society that caters to the lowest common denominator rather than demanding and rewarding excellence

You can't demand and reward excellence with car driving, because by assuming that people are all highly competent, you'll end up with lots of fatal crashes because of all the people who aren't competent. You can only assume car drivers are competent in societies where there's plenty of options for people who don't or can't drive, and America made the decision to not be such a society, so everyone has to be able to drive, even if they're an idiot.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lunias on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:05PM (#21318543)
I don't think that we have to assume competence when we have a system in place for issuing licenses, but you do have a point about people needing access to transportation. I do believe that any real solution would have to provide reasonable alternatives for people who do not meet the requirements. I also don't feel like the bar has to be raised much with regard to the licensing, but currently (and I believe knowledge of this to be reflected in some patterns of traffic control) the bar is clear-able by all with little to no competence check.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by magduf on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:14PM (#21326143)
>I do believe that any real solution would have to provide reasonable alternatives for people who do not meet the requirements.

Sorry, but that's completely impossible. You simply cannot have a spread-out, car-based society with "reasonable alternatives" for people who can't drive, unless perhaps you're going to heavily subsidize Uber and Lyft. Buses and trains don't work well in suburbs; trains only make sense with enough density to have enough ridership, and buses only make sense to fill in where train lines don't exist. In the suburbs, people stuck taking the bus get penalized with ridiculously long transit times, because the bus takes a long, circuitous route, only comes once or twice an hour, etc. That isn't a "reasonable alternative" when people with a car get get there in 10 minutes or less.

So you have two choices: a society like Germany's where at least in urban areas it's easy to get around without a car, and then you can have a very high competency requirement for car drivers; or a society like America's, where the whole society is designed for cars (except for a small handful of urban cores) and you have to have a car to achieve a middle-class existence, so you cannot have a high competency requirement because otherwise you are restricting peoples' right to movement and travel.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lunias on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @02:09PM (#21326839)
Offering reasonable alternatives is impossible? Why can't we begin to restructure our society to be more like, in your example; Germany, so that it is possible? Just because there are steps to providing alternatives doesn't make their eventual existence impossible, right?
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by magduf on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:29PM (#21328190)
>Offering reasonable alternatives is impossible?

The way it is now (with the sprawl that we currently have), yes, due to physics. You can't change physics. There just isn't any way to make a bus a viable transit alternative in a sprawling suburban area; everything is just too far apart.

>Why can't we begin to restructure our society to be more like, in your example; Germany, so that it is possible?

Well I wasn't really talking about long-term, I was talking more short-term, with the assumption that the sprawl we have will remain or be extended. I simply don't see any attempts in this country to increase density, except perhaps the "urban growth boundary" around Portland.

Sure, I'd love to see this country decide it wants to be more like Germany or Japan and stop all new sprawl, and instead require higher density development near city cores, so that public transit is more feasible, and also provide more funding for transit construction (since that usually drives density: people frequently want to live close to the subway stations). But there's a lot of fanciful things that I'd like to have; that doesn't mean very many people agree with me, and I don't see much agreement with me on this issue in America today, at least not from the voters.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by scott_s on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:41PM (#21317083)
> sadly we live in a society that caters to the lowest common denominator rather than demanding and rewarding excellence.

I find that an odd perspective on successful public safety rules and policies with the aim of reducing serious injury and death during a dangerous activity.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by cgriswald on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:04PM (#21317340)
If they were serious about improving safety they’d have stricter licensing requirements. A one-legged turkey can probably get licensed in the states I’ve lived in. Once he gets it, it’s his for life. No need to prove he’s kept up his knowledge and skill. He just needs to take the occasional eye test. I see frequent conversations on Nextdoor about traffic laws where people are getting very basic stuff just plain wrong. Some of that could be explained by people moving here from other states, but it’s usually stuff in the driver’s handbook and in the worst case just doing a search of the vehicle code will give you the answer.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lunias on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:43PM (#21318828)
I think we'd see much greater reduction of serious injury and death by implementing stricter requirements and better training than simply doing our best after the fact to make sure everything is idiot-proof. A proactive approach rather than a reactive one.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by wbronitsky on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:35PM (#21317700)
I’m not sure there is a ton of utility in complaining about societal stupidity, right? How does complaining that people don’t follow rules help us be safer? What would you propose as an alternative to “cater[ing] to the lowest common denominator” for public health and safety issues?
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lunias on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:35PM (#21318775)
I'm not intending to complain, just presenting a viewpoint that minimum requirements are okay when it comes to regulation of shared resources, like the road. I don't believe that the requirements should be lowered beyond a reasonable level to cater to the incapable. I'd prefer a society which invested more in training and education as a form of harm prevention than implementing rules which reduce harm at the expense of the trained individual.

Specifically related to driving: I believe that the licensing requirements should be slightly higher and that more should be done to guard against bad driving and not just illegal driving. E.g. I've never seen anyone get a ticket for getting on the highway going a third of the speed of traffic, but that's certainly dangerous. Instead, people get tickets for exceeding a limit set by the capabilities of the lowest common denominator by a small percentage regardless of conditions (often not particularly dangerous - not an excuse for reckless driving, of course).

I simply think that there are better solutions. For one, public transportation.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lm28469 on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:33AM (#21312696)
> Why not detect my coming and wait for an efficient yellow timing, thus I am not wasting gas and braking unnecessarily?

At that scale trying to do anything clever will cost billions. Most red lights don't even detect motorcycles standing right on top of their sensor, we're decades away from smart lights detecting your car speed/distance and computing the most optimised yellow light timing.

Also, in most cases you should be able to roll off the throttle and coast to the light without having to aggressively brake. If it's not the case the yellow light is not timed well and you can contact the company handling the roadwork in your city.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by C1sc0cat on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:52AM (#21311676)
Amber is prepare to stop not an instruction to do a crash stop from my memoires of the UK highway code.

I.e. if you at or very close to the line you prepare to stop but if your very close you proceed carefully and make the turn.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by vinay427 on Monday October 21, 2019 @08:58AM (#21311731)
In most countries, if you cross the line or enter the intersection while the light that applies to you is red, it is a violation. This means that unless the yellow light is long enough to account for approaching drivers' reaction times/distances and braking times/distances it can result in crash stops. Many lights in every country I've driven in have an insufficient yellow-light period given these considerations.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by jtbayly on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:14AM (#21311868)
And jurisdictions with auto-ticketing based on red-light cameras shorten the yellow light, driving up income by making it very hard to avoid running a (barely) red light.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by seszett on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:40AM (#21312094)
That doesn't seem true, France for example has automatic cameras at traffic lights, and the yellow light has a duration fixed by law (3s on urban streets, 5s outside cities) and it has not changed since traffic light cameras were introduced. So that's one jurisdiction where your assertion is false.

(Anyway, in most places the fines from the automatic cameras do not go to the same administration that decides the speed limits and places the traffic lights, so in the end the common accusation of "they only want to make money from it" doesn't make that much sense)

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by magduf on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:18PM (#21314035)
>That doesn't seem true, France for example

He meant jurisdictions in America. Local governments here are infamous for shortening yellow lights. The companies that make automated cameras even have it in their contracts that the cities must do this.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by optimiz3 on Monday October 21, 2019 @03:50PM (#21316478)
> The companies that make automated cameras even have it in their contracts that the cities must do this.

Citation?

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by magduf on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @10:58AM (#21324319)
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by optimiz3 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:51PM (#21328825)
> The contracts in place with red-light camera providers often specify maximum yellow light times

There's a lot of room for weaseling the way that's written. The contracts could specify maximum times to cover incorrect configurations like 2 minutes - that would be sensible. Technically the article is correct but it leads the reader to conclude malicious intent where there may be none.

Only the DigitalTrends article talked about contract imposed maximums. In the Chicago article it looks like the city that was acting in bad faith. There is no established link between provider imposed contracts violating best practices.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lutorm on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:14PM (#21317451)
It is governed by law in America, too. At least it is in CA.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by jtbayly on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:24AM (#21312586)
I didn't state that it was universal. It does happen to be true. You can look it up. There are even links elsewhere in this thread. Last I read about it was some time ago, but I doubt it has been fixed.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by bluGill on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:04AM (#21311779)
The border is at issue: I could stop in time, but I'd have to stop as fast as my car is able which is uncomfortable. Oh, and I just completed my regular mirror check, and so I don't know how long the yellow has been up. Do I stop or continue on?
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by dsego on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:13PM (#21316772)
You are either driving too fast or not paying enough attention.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by C1sc0cat on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:31AM (#21312011)
You should be looking ahead
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Retric on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:44AM (#21312139)
That’s a little pithy, how about: When approaching a stoplight you should be looking ahead during the window when a green to yellow transition would be important information.

Also, checking behind you has minimal value for drivers. Rather than any pattern it should be your absolutely last priority as it very rarely provides useful information and may be dangerous. That said, you should maintain basic awareness behind you.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by shantly on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:30PM (#21317646)
> Also, checking behind you has minimal value for drivers.

I think I'll keep tracking who's behind me, how close, whether anyone new has appeared, whether anyone looks likely to pass me soon, and so on, because it's sure as hell been important in practice. Most notably when something goes even slightly wrong in front of me.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by mcguire on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:45PM (#21317127)
"Also, checking behind you has minimal value for drivers..."

...unless you are entering a situation where you may need to decide if stopping is preferable to some other option.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by cgriswald on Monday October 21, 2019 @05:28PM (#21317621)
It’s an absurd statement anyway. It informs you of what other traffic is doing, where you can safely expect to maneuver in an emergency, and etc.

In one case, I’d say checking my rearview was worth thousands of dollars and maybe three lives. When approaching a crosswalk and reducing my speed to stop for pedestrians I saw clearly the guy behind me wasn’t going to stop (he maintained his speed and was looking down, probably texting). I honked and flashed to warn the pedestrians who stayed out of the crosswalk. Then I took my foot off the brake as the other car hit me. The damage was minimal because I just let him push me. I pulled into a nearby parking lot. The other guy took off without stopping. It was a new car so no rear plate.

If I hadn’t looked I’d have tried to stop, been pushed into the pedestrians anyway unless they noticed on their own, and my car would likely have been totaled.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Retric on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:25PM (#21319836)
That does not support ignoring traffic lights during the most critical 5 seconds to look behind you. Defensive techniques like slowing down when someone tailgates you are useful, but usually looking behind before and accident doesn’t enable you to do anything useful.

Also, talking your foot off the break increased the risk in that accident. If the driver had swerved at the last second they could have sent your car into the pedestrians you where trying to protect. In a rear end collision momentum pulls your foot from the peddle. So, you want to be hard breaking at the moment of impact to minimize the distance you move post collision.

Honking may have been useful, however unless you gave then ~2+ seconds of warning it was probably futile. Walking speed may be 4.5 feet per second, but acceleration and reaction times are not instantaneous.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by cgriswald on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @11:43AM (#21324946)
> That does not support ignoring traffic lights during the most critical 5 seconds to look behind you.

No one suggested doing anything of the kind.

Regarding my collision, you're just making stuff up.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Retric on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @05:15AM (#21332737)
> No one suggested doing anything of the kind.

That was the OP situation.

> Oh, and I just completed my regular mirror check, and so I don't know how long the yellow has been up. Do I stop or continue on?

As to breaking, or saving the car:

https://www.cartalk.com/content/bracing-impact-it-better-bra...

On it’s own that’s not going to make a huge difference, but I have seen recommendations to apply the parking break for similar reasons.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by cgriswald on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @11:45AM (#21335797)
> ...ignoring traffic lights during the most critical 5 seconds to look behind you.

> Oh, and I just completed my regular mirror check, and so I don't know how long the yellow has been up. Do I stop or continue on?

These statements are not describing the same activity.

> As to breaking, or saving the car:

Your link agrees with me. Read Tom's last paragraph. There was no traffic in front of me. The pedestrians were safely off the road because I honked and flashed. In the case that the pedestrians had kept going, I'd have done things differently. But it doesn't matter; because the point isn't whether braking or not braking was the correct decision.

The point is that by looking in the rear view mirror I became aware that a decision needed to be made.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Retric on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @02:31PM (#21337416)
> These statements are not describing the same activity.

Yes they are. The window when the length of a yellow light matters is short. If check your rear view mirror right before the intersection then even if the light turns yellow that’s irrelevant you’re still going to cross. Alternatively, if you’re very far from the intersection, then not noticing a yellow light for ~2 seconds is irrelevant, you need to stop regardless of how long it’s been yellow at that point. The transition between those states is very rapid.

> The pedestrians where safely off the road.

There was still pedestrians around you. A rear end collision that’s directly bumper to bumper pushes you forward. But, it’s possible for someone to try and evade at the last second which means they and you go in some random direction, possibly onto a sidewalk or other objects near the road.

Examples of off angle impacts with solid barriers: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/21/iihs-crash-tests-slam-some-p.... Though if these where cars the car would be violently pushed in the opposite direction.

Various rear end collisions: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=HD6QGx9d8ow. Which show a wide range of possibilities.

So, unless they where well behind you, picking your foot off the break was a poor choice for their safety.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by cgriswald on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @03:40PM (#21338105)
> Yes they are.

No, they aren't. You misrepresented his point, and now you're changing the argument.

> So, unless they where well behind you, picking your foot off the break was a poor choice for their safety.

You're still making things up. Nothing you have linked here supports your claims. When a car collides with another car, things can happen with variable degrees of predictability. Yet, you are arguing with certainty that despite a successful outcome I made the wrong decision in a situation for which you don't have all the facts. I'm not sure how you hope any of this will convince me I did the wrong thing.

Perhaps ironically, even by arguing that there was a right thing to do, you implicitly acknowledge that your previous statement about rear view mirrors which I objected to was wrong.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Retric on Wednesday October 23, 2019 @06:49PM (#21339885)
> You misrepresented his point

No, I said his situation was avoidable and said how to avoid it, thus invalidating his point. Talking about how to safely drive drunk ignores the possibility to not get into that situation.

As to your situation, you where not responding to a traffic light. In my original post I specifically said maintaining awareness was import, just a low priority. Checking your rear view window while breaking is perfectly reasonable as long as your not maneuvering to avoid a collision. As described not checking the rear view minor would have likely resulted in a near identical outcome, honking may have have helped or been pointless we don’t know.

As to making things up, my statement is in response to the correct action on a rear end collision based on the information you had at the time. Saying it was a good idea using information unavailable at the time is like lottery winners saying they made the correct choice. However, as people can’t actually see the future it’s possible to make a poor gamble that pays off.

Similarly, you where lucky that the oncoming car did not swerve at the last second which you had not way of predicting or responding to as your limited by human reaction times. The first videos I showed demonstrated my point but I don’t think you understand the physics involved. Watch the first shot here. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JszLYsU1Duo On a side impact ball 1 moves to the left, and ball 2 moves to the right. Now, considering that rewatch the first video with that idea. If you where rear ended at an angle you could have been shoved into the direction of the sidewalk as the other car was shoved away. The second video I posed starts with a collision like with a car being shoved to the left, except it’s hitting a stationary school buss who’s breaks and higher mass avoid significant movement.

If you still don’t understand, I can only suggest learning some basic physics from online videos or whatnot.

PS: And really your argument about not breaking is balancing people’s safety vs an slightly lower repair bill. That’s really hard to justify.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by exclipy on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:18AM (#21313264)
Nope.

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2016/362/schedule/14/made says: "(9) An amber signal, when shown alone, conveys the same prohibition as red, except that, as respects any vehicle which is so close to the stop line that it cannot safely be stopped without proceeding beyond the stop line, it conveys the same indication as the green signal which was shown immediately before it."

If you interpret this to the letter, it means that if there's no car behind you, you should indeed come to a screeching halt at an amber light. If it's "safe" to stop, then amber means stop.

Not saying I agree with this, but that's what the law says.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by SamBam on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:27PM (#21316924)
Not sure how you read it that way. "Screeching to a stop" is absolutely not "safely stopped."

Maybe we're using "screeching" differently. If I need to jam on the brakes such that there is a chance the car my skid, or someone with a seatbelt might be injured, that is not "safe," and the law says I should keep going. Absent those things, I'm not screeching to stop but just stopping short.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Dylan16807 on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:55PM (#21319982)
There's a middle ground in there that's completely safe but also very unpleasant. I might exaggerate it as a "screeching halt". It should not be required by the letter of the law.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by mcguire on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:43PM (#21317101)
Does the UK have something similar to Section 508? Light blue text on a white background is...problematic.

Is there a definition of "safe to stop"? I would imagine a screeching halt wouldn't qualify.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by C1sc0cat on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:29AM (#21313401)
Not sure that doing an emergency stop unless really required is safe - you could always get a tank slapper or potentially case injuries to passengers if say they are reaching for something and bash their hand etc into the internal parts of the car.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by chooseaname on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:38PM (#21317038)
"Screeching" to a stop is never a "safe" stop. A driver is traveling too fast for the conditions and the road if he has to screech to a stop when he sees yellow.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by throwaway66920 on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:17AM (#21311888)
It shouldn’t. Yellow lights are supposed to last an amount of time based on the speed limit at that section so this doesn’t happen.

Traffic simulations are generally quite complex. In your proposal, if your approach is not detected correctly, you either stop traffic for a car which isn’t there, or you never stop traffic for a car which is there.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by ken on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:16AM (#21312490)
I would love to learn more about traffic simulations they use. I saw some software traffic simulators in college and they looked nice but in no way included real-world driving.

It’s hard to imagine, given how bad traffic is, that our streets were planned by sophisticated computer simulations. There’s one place near me where it can take nearly an hour to go 3 blocks during rush hour, due to people blocking the box. Do simulations take that into account?

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by magduf on Monday October 21, 2019 @12:20PM (#21314061)
As I've said before, I think traffic engineering is probably the most intellectually dishonest profession there is, at least in America.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by abduhl on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:12PM (#21319390)
Oh man wait until you learn about machine learning where they don’t even have a real world result to compare it to
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by throwaway66920 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @11:55AM (#21325133)
You mean... unsupervised machine learning? That doesn’t feel intellectually dishonest to me
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by garaetjjte on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:20PM (#21316839)
Sometimes there are countdown timers displaying time to red/green change. I don't know why they aren't deployed more widely, they are very convenient.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Y-bar on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:30PM (#21316953)
There have been research showing that while a majority of people who sit in an intersection with timers appreciate them… It also increases the number of accidents because people spend too much attention to the timer and fail to look at the environment whether or not it is safe to accelerate. There is also evidence that suggest that countdown timers from green to red cause more drivers to accelerate and increase the risk of accidents there as well.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by m3at on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:50AM (#21320473)
Not for individual car owners, but in Japan some buses connect with neighboring signals which are more likely to turn green when the buses are approaching. Having buses usually quite close to schedule probably helps
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by deftturtle on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @04:20PM (#21328123)
My solution is to have a blinking green, which indicates that it’s about to turn yellow. We might also lengthen the yellow duration, but knowing that the light will switch gives time to decide if you can speed up or decelerate safely, without wasting energy.

I’d be very curious to see how a blinking green system plays out in tests.

Another thought: if we manage traffic like regulating fluid flow and pressure, we could avoid situations where a single car exiting a parking lot shuts down the highway instantly. That single car should have to wait maybe 5-10 seconds before triggering the lights, and the blinking green would let highway drivers adjust. Forcing 20 cars to rapidly stop for an already stopped car makes no sense.

As the single car waits, pressure “builds” so to speak, and eventually the light decides that the fluid flow should change.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by imglorp on Monday October 21, 2019 @09:08AM (#21311817)
> Why not detect my coming

This bugs me. $50 of hardware can accomplish this, today. Raspi running vehicle detection code. If something is coming and the other way is clear, why not flip the intersection before it arrives?

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by tsimionescu on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:29PM (#21316945)
> $50 of hardware can accomplish this, today. Raspi running vehicle detection code.

That's only true if you want hardware that sometimes detects some kind of vehicles, in the right weather and from the right angles.

Truly reliably detecting this is much further away. The consequences of not getting it right are not as catastrophic as getting it wrong in a self-driving car, but they could still mess traffic up pretty badly.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by adrianmonk on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:15PM (#21319765)
I've thought about this and my own take on it is this is actually an opportunity that has not yet been exploited. The cost of the hardware is $50 now, but that has only recently become the case.

Your reaction might be that it has been $50 for like 5 or 10 years now, and if so my response is that in this area, that is recent. It's a pretty slow-moving, late adopter industry. Most of the equipment getting installed probably hasn't been redesigned in years or decades. The people approving stuff want to buy from known vendors. The vendors are making money steadily now and don't want to go out on a limb with unproven tech.

Which doesn't mean it's impossible. I interpret it the opposite way: the fact that it hasn't happened yet doesn't mean it won't or can't. I would expect it to take this long or longer.

Also, I think the angle for getting this adopted isn't really efficiency, it's cost saving. Right now, some lights are on sensors (instead of just timing) but they do it with induction loops (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induction_loop). If you could match or surpass the reliability of those at a lower cost, you might get people to switch.

But once you've crossed that hurdle, you can improve efficiency too, of course.

Of course, you have to keep in mind that the camera has to be mounted in the proper position. So it's probably not really $50 of hardware unless you can (in most cases, at least) piggyback on something that already exists. Although that seems possible because the signal light does need to be visible by cars approaching the intersection.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by skeletonjelly on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:01PM (#21317950)
The hardware is the tip of the priceberg my friend
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by qtplatypus on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @12:32AM (#21320398)
The cost isn't the hardware. The cost would be doing all testing to prove and certify that this is safe in all situations.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lm28469 on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:37AM (#21312736)
> $50 of hardware can accomplish this, today. Raspi running vehicle detection code.

$50 * 300 000 (quick google search about the number of traffic light in the US), That's not taking into account installation and regular maintenance.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by clairity on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:13PM (#21316774)
$1.5M (maybe 3X that with other costs) is literally a rounding error for the US federal budget: expenditures are $4.4T and revenue is $3.4T (that $1T/yr deficit is maddening btw).
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by mcguire on Monday October 21, 2019 @04:47PM (#21317158)
How long would it take you to install a traffic light camera system? Would you do that for $100?
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by imglorp on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:25PM (#21318703)
It's probably easier to install than the typical sensor loop under the asphalt. The camera and cpu could be on the same circuit board as one of the LED lens units, which are already sealed units heated against snow. It would need an additional comm line down to the controller from each light head, which might just be a cable pull through conduit.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by lm28469 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:28AM (#21321691)
Besides being weather proof it would also need to be theft proof. It would also probably have to pass some sort of certification(s) as it would control traffic lights which could be dangerous in case of malfunctions, regular tests, &c.

I'm all for optimising things but sometimes it's just not worth the hassle. A well timed orange light is good enough.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by CaliforniaKarl on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:29PM (#21318234)
In addition, even if it is inside an enclosure, it has to be able to withstand the elements (including extremes of temperature and humidity), and be able to have virtually 100% availability outside of power-loss situations.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by r00fus on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @01:23AM (#21320580)
Traffic circles / roundabouts (for smaller intersections) are better. I wonder how mass adoption might impact air quality and fuel efficiency.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by bjourne on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:08PM (#21318032)
Sorry for stating the obvious, but.. if you have to slam on the brakes when approaching an intersection, you are driving too fast. :)
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by tomohawk on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:35PM (#21318301)
This may or may not be true. In one of the areas near us, they installed red light cameras and had short yellows. You'd be on a 55mph road and get a 2-3 second yellow. Slamming on the brakes or running the red were the 2 options. With a 4 second yellow (which is actually state law), you can come to a normal stop. You could fight your ticket in court, but you had to prove the yellow was short. The state highway department had equipment you could use to time the light to prove your case. Time consuming, but doable if you didn't have a job or were retired. If you did that, you would get off, but they would still not change the light. Pretty ridiculous.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by userbinator on Monday October 21, 2019 @10:00PM (#21319677)
but you had to prove the yellow was short.

That sounds like something a dashcam would be able to easily show.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Gibbon1 on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:03PM (#21318528)
I think California changed the law, so it's legal to enter on the yellow. If it changes to red doesn't matter. However you can't block the box either. That was specifically to prevent muni's from shortening the yellow to generate revenue.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by bjourne on Monday October 21, 2019 @07:36PM (#21318776)
But do you have to drive at the posted limit? Even if the yellow time was 4 seconds, 55 mph (90 kmh) gives you almost no margin of error.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Dylan16807 on Monday October 21, 2019 @11:00PM (#21320004)
Suggesting that the speed limit is "driving too fast :)" in good weather is ridiculous. If there is a problem, it is completely on the yellow light.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by bjourne on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @05:37AM (#21321759)
Then perhaps, if drivers are unwilling to consider obstacles on the road, the speed limit should be lowered.
Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday October 22, 2019 @03:53PM (#21327869)
We could lower the speed limit in front of every intersection, or we could use light timings that fit the designed speed limit of the road.

One of these is really stupid, and one isn't.

Re:Traffic lights worldwide set to change after a Swedish en... by habnds on Monday October 21, 2019 @06:30PM (#21318253)
driving is incredibly inefficient, lights are just a small part of it