News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by cyborgx7 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:28AM (#21268549)
Because of political bias. Just look at the introduction of the (fake) Nobel Prize for economics. It exists purely to legitimize a neoliberal economic ideology. Awarding Chomsky a Nobel Prize would undermine that goal.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by taffer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:44AM (#21268956)
The idea that awarding a prize to the most respected scientists in a particular field is solely for the purpose of advancing an ideology is in itself extremely anti-intellectual and biased. Have you even looked at the work of the scientists who received the prize?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jhbadger on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:10AM (#21269099)
It's hardly "anti-intellectual" to note that unlike the actual prizes funded by Nobel over a century ago, the economics "Nobel" was created by the Swedish Central Bank only 50 years ago. That's not exactly an unbiased source. If there was no chemistry prize and Dow Chemical or Bayer stepped in to create one, it wouldn't be anywhere as respected as the actual Chemistry Nobel, would it?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by taffer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:12AM (#21269503)
The anti-intellectual part was to claim that the awarding of prizes to prominent scientists only served to promote a certain ideology. It is like saying that the Nobel Prize for Medicine would exist only to promote orthodox medicine.

> If there was no chemistry prize and Dow Chemical or Bayer stepped in to create one, it wouldn't be anywhere as respected as the actual Chemistry Nobel, would it?

The Nobel Prize was created by the owner of a Swedish chemical and weapons company. I don't see what's so great about it.

And as for the Swedish Central Bank, I think Paul Krugman hit the nail on the head: Oh, and cue the usual complaints that this isn’t a “real” Nobel. Hey, this is just a prize given by a bunch of Swedes, as opposed to the other prizes, which are given out by, um, bunches of Swedes.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by hedvig on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:36PM (#21277292)
I think its still fair to say that economics is not a science the way medicine is.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:44PM (#21278751)
>I think its still fair to say that economics is not a science the way medicine is.

Which is very unfortunate, because like medicine, the practice of economics has the power to influence decisions and affect lives.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by taffer on Thursday October 17, 2019 @02:47PM (#21285186)
The only difference is that people who reject medicine are rightfully considered delusional.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by throw0101a on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:44AM (#21269731)
> ... funded by Nobel over a century ago, the economics "Nobel" was created by the Swedish Central Bank only 50 years ago.

So will the Economics Nobel be legitimate when it turns 100 then?

The official Nobel site lists the Economics prize:

* https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/

What other authority on the matter is there than the actual organization itself?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by cyborgx7 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:18AM (#21269998)
There can be no legitimate Nobel Prizes added because Nobel is dead.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by throw0101a on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:34PM (#21277748)
This smells of "No true Scotsman" IMHO.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:40AM (#21269277)
I like how this is going towards “Swedish Central Bank is a for-profit organisation”
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:49AM (#21269775)
The Nobel for Economics is not down to Mr Nobel. It was instituted by the Swedish Central Bank, and I think the selection committee is organised differently to the real Nobels.

Edit: Brain having a moment off - s/Swiss/Swedish/

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by bzbarsky on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @01:48PM (#21273169)
The selection processes for the real Nobels differ significantly in their organization, for what it's worth, though it's mostly Peace vs all the others... In particular, for the Peace prize the Norwegian Parliament appoints a 5-person committee that then selects the prize winner, while for the others various Swedish academic institutions select a committee that then proposes laureates back to a larger body that votes on them.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by exoque on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:59AM (#21270359)
The swedish central bank, not the swiss.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:04AM (#21269064)
> The idea that awarding a prize to the most respected scientists in a particular field is solely for the purpose of advancing an ideology is in itself extremely anti-intellectual and biased.

Man, if you want to hear about anti-intellectualism and bias, go and look at the SMD theorem. Economists will continue to assume that Macroeconomic demand curves will continue to slope downward.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by vkreso on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:42AM (#21269713)
> Man, if you want to hear about anti-intellectualism and bias, go and look at the SMD theorem.

The D in SMD was actually awarded the nobel prize in economics.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:26AM (#21270068)
>The D in SMD was actually awarded the nobel prize in economics.

Debreu's work on general equilibrium, which was the basis of the award, had to skirt around the SMD theorem:

>Prize motivation: "for having incorporated new analytical methods into economic theory and for his rigorous reformulation of the theory of general equilibrium."[0]

In order for the Arrow-Debreu model[1] to give a unique equilibrium, which is usually desired, some strong (arguably, unrealistic) conditions must be assumed, otherwise there can be multiple equilibria, as guaranteed by the SMD theorem.[2]

In particular, the SMD theorem asserts that any polynomial function can be a market demand function, which fundamentally breaks the so-called "law" of demand in neoclassical economics. This is because most polynomial functions are not monotonically decreasing[3], as required by the "law" of demand, but give rise to demand curves that can curve up or down arbitrarily. As an example of such a function, just think of the curve generated by a generic cubic polynomial.[4]

This "anything goes" situation then leads to non-unique equilibria, since a supply curve can now intersect the market demand curve at more than one point. But since an equilibrium point is supposed to be where welfare is maximised in a society, the existence of non-unique equilibria means that there can be multiple economic arrangements under which social welfare is maximised. Then it's a matter of taste (i.e. "ideology") to decide which equilibrium point a society wants to be in.

[0] https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/1983/deb...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%E2%80%93Debreu_model

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonnenschein%E2%80%93Mantel%E2...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monotonic_function

[4] A graph of such a curve is shown here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Monotonicity_example3.png

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by vkreso on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:59AM (#21271083)
> Debreu's work on general equilibrium, which was the basis of the award, had to skirt around the SMD theorem:

Watch out for moving the goalposts. He was awarded the nobel prize after all. "Rigorous reformulation" does not sound like skirting at all.

> This "anything goes" situation then leads to non-unique equilibria, since a supply curve can now intersect the market demand curve at more than one point. But since an equilibrium point is supposed to be where welfare is maximised in a society, the existence of non-unique equilibria means that there can be multiple economic arrangements under which social welfare is maximised.

Economy (or climate or orbits) exhibit chatoic and complex behaviour and it is not surprising that they can have multiple stable points (look up bifurcation diagrams for a simple representation of chatoic solutions). If I am not mistaken, one can hear such things routinely in university economy classrooms today especially when giving caveats about models being wrong in general. Even when you include game theory and Nash equilibria with respect to economic solutions, there might not be efficient ways to reach the equilibrium points at all!

> Then it's a matter of taste (i.e. "ideology") to decide which equilibrium point a society wants to be in.

That is to assume that every equilibrium solution you get is tied to a specific policy or a set of them (or even more, an ideology!) or that points can be reached easily which are very strong assumptions. Maybe some ideologies don't exhibit any reachable equilibrium points or pertain only to unstable ones.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Thursday October 17, 2019 @12:06AM (#21278827)
>Watch out for moving the goalposts.

Says the one who's been moving the goalposts in the first place. The point of this thread was about whether or not the Nobel prize in economics was anti-intellectual and ideologically biased. You chimed in with:

>>>The D in SMD was actually awarded the nobel prize in economics.

Which is why I responded, because this was a non-sequitur and an appeal to authority (of the people awarding the prize, and the question was whether or not these people were biased).

>He was awarded the nobel prize after all.

That means nothing in the context of this thread, and is another appeal to authority.

>"Rigorous reformulation" does not sound like skirting at all.

The SMD theorem was a big deal, yet Debreu wasn't awarded the prize for that, but for a rigorous reformulation of Walrasian equilibrium,[0] which has very strong assumptions.

In particular, that rigorous reformulation, known as the Arrow-Debreu model,[1] fails under weaker (i.e. more realistic) assumptions, because of the SMD theorem.

This is skirting the issue.

>Economy (or climate or orbits) exhibit chatoic and complex behaviour and it is not surprising that they can have multiple stable points (look up bifurcation diagrams for a simple representation of chatoic solutions). If I am not mistaken, one can hear such things routinely in university economy classrooms today especially when giving caveats about models being wrong in general. Even when you include game theory and Nash equilibria with respect to economic solutions, there might not be efficient ways to reach the equilibrium points at all!

A few points:

- It's nice and all that caveats are being given, but what tools are being taught to economics undergrads to handle chaotic and complex behaviour? Please supply links to some university course syllabus as evidence (I'm happy to read material in a language other than English).

- If economics students aren't being taught tools to handle chaotic and complex behaviour, then giving caveats is just paying lip service.

- Game theory and Nash equilibria are tools to deal with equilibria, which is what neoclassical economics is comfortable with. To be more realistic, you need to look at what happens in disequilibria, as you've pointed out yourself.

- Chaos theory also showed that equilibria may never be attained at all by a system, so the obsession with equilibria in economics is, at best, unproductive.

>That is to assume that every equilibrium solution you get is tied to a specific policy or a set of them (or even more, an ideology!) or that points can be reached easily which are very strong assumptions. Maybe some ideologies don't exhibit any reachable equilibrium points or pertain only to unstable ones.

Agreed. Unfortunately, neoclassical economics, thanks to its underlying ideology, assumes that equilibrium points can be reached by the "free market" and are desirable.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_equilibrium

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow%E2%80%93Debreu_model

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:10PM (#21271969)
"Then it's a matter of taste (i.e. "ideology") to decide which equilibrium point a society wants to be in."

I think this statement is quite representative of the world we live in, don't you? My personal experience is, strongest adherents to an ideology are the least productive people .

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by taffer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:31AM (#21269210)
All models are wrong by definition. The purpose of a model is to be a simplification of reality in order to gain insights and not to perfectly replicate reality. In physics, there is even the metaphor of the spherical cow[1] to make fun of the need to simplify things in order to understand them. Just because a model is simple doesn't mean that it is bad or worse than a model with more complex assumptions.

[1] https://web.archive.org/web/19991009000912/http://lheawww.gs...

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:39AM (#21269271)
> All models are wrong by definition.

I would agree.

> Just because a model is simple doesn't mean that it is bad or worse than a model with more complex assumptions.

I'm not condemning it being simple. If we were just talking about small or exceptional exclusions to the rules like Giffen or Veblen goods, then I wouldn't have made the above post. We're talking about fundamentally incorrect building blocks that aren't even acknowledged in the literature.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:49AM (#21270272)
>In physics, there is even the metaphor of the spherical cow[1] to make fun of the need to simplify things in order to understand them.

It's a joke to remind us of a sobering fact: that unreal assumptions lead to unreal results.

>Just because a model is simple doesn't mean that it is bad or worse than a model with more complex assumptions.

But if a model with more complex assumptions is a better approximation to reality than a model with simpler assumptions, would you not adopt the former?

What has happened in economics is that people have clung on to, say, Newtonian mechanics, instead of embracing Einstein's relativity.

Even this does not quite adequately express the enormity of the inertia that you see in economics, because at least Newtonian mechanics is right most of the time, whereas neoclassical economics is wrong most of the time. The SMD theorem guarantees, for example, that most market demand curves will NEVER satisfy the fundamental neoclassical "law" of demand.

Let me also point out that your comment is rehashing Friedman's positivism.[0] Even in quantum mechanics, which has for decades been dominated by the positivism of the Copenhagen interpretation, people are now transcending that positivism because they've come to the realisation that quantum mechanics can't be advanced without overcoming the crutch of positivism. And Friedman's assertions about assumptions are unsound anyway.[1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essays_in_Positive_Economics

[1] For a critique of Friedman's argument about assumptions in models, see https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-6435....

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by taffer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @02:26PM (#21273679)
> But if a model with more complex assumptions is a better approximation to reality than a model with simpler assumptions, would you not adopt the former?

Not necessarily. Maybe the simpler model is enough to understand what is going on. Maybe a more complex model suffers from over-fitting and performs worse than the simpler model. It really depends.

> The SMD theorem guarantees, for example, that most market demand curves will NEVER satisfy the fundamental neoclassical "law" of demand.

Does it really say that? Or simply that weird market demand curves are possible in a few exceptional situations?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Thursday October 17, 2019 @12:51AM (#21279005)
>Maybe the simpler model is enough to understand what is going on. Maybe a more complex model suffers from over-fitting and performs worse than the simpler model. It really depends.

If only physics departments everywhere would adopt this philosophy! Physics undergrads would then be liberated from the yoke of Einstein's relativity, let alone the tyranny of the mind-blowing quantum field theory with its insufferably complicated Feynman diagrams.

It does not depend. The simpler model in economics is fatally flawed, and is the one suffering from over-fitting (to a straight line, no less) and contributing to the bad reputation of economics as a "dismal science".

>> The SMD theorem guarantees, for example, that most market demand curves will NEVER satisfy the fundamental neoclassical "law" of demand.

>Does it really say that? Or simply that weird market demand curves are possible in a few exceptional situations?

Yes, it does.[0] The exceptional situations are precisely those that neoclassical economics assumes are the norm, namely, that there is only one agent and one commodity in the market.[1]

As soon as you have more than one agent/consumer in an economy, the mathematics will undermine the "law" of demand, because the inter-agent interactions would generate non-linear terms in the market demand function.

And once you have terms of higher order, the demand curve generated by that function will have sections that slope upwards, exactly what is being forbidden by the "law" of demand.

And we haven't yet taken into account the very real fact that multiple consumers cannot possibly have the same preferences. Or that these preferences can change with different levels of income.[2]

In short, neoclassical microeconomics only works in a communist economy of identical clones with identical preferences and incomes.

Oh, the irony.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonnenschein%E2%80%93Mantel%E2...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_agent

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homothetic_preferences

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by taffer on Thursday October 17, 2019 @02:15PM (#21284883)
> If only physics departments everywhere would adopt this philosophy!

Let's take electrical engineering as an example. If you model an electrical circuit, you assume that there simply is a voltage source where electricity comes from. That assumption is of course complete nonsense: In reality, electrical energy is not just there, it has to be generated somewhere, for example in a power plant. The electricity also flows through a grid that is shared with many other consumers.

So, according to your requirement to always use the more realistic model, electrical engineers should always model a whole power plant and an entire power grid in each circuit, because otherwise their model would be bullshit.

> Yes, it does.[0]

Do you know of any empirical studies that show that the models currently used in macroeconomics actually cause problems with real data?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Friday October 18, 2019 @10:21AM (#21291590)
>Let's take electrical engineering as an example.

I'd usually say you're shifting the goal posts, perhaps muse about how dehumanising and simplistic it is to think of humans as components in an electrical circuit, and move on. Then I thought that it'd be more illuminating to address your analogy, because your reasoning suffers from the same problem that I've been talking about.

>If you model an electrical circuit, you assume that there simply is a voltage source where electricity comes from. That assumption is of course complete nonsense: In reality, electrical energy is not just there, it has to be generated somewhere, for example in a power plant. The electricity also flows through a grid that is shared with many other consumers.

I think it might help to read Musgrave's paper[0] (the abstract will do if you can't get the paper itself) on the three kinds of unrealistic assumptions, in which he attacked Friedman's twist. The assumption you pointed out is the most benign type: a negligibility assumption. It's like assuming that a object falling through air experiences no friction: complete nonsense, but air friction exerts only a negligible effect on most falling objects, unless the object is, say, a feather.

In the case of your example, taking into account the power plant adds nothing to the analysis, because the electrical circuit you're concerned with usually doesn't output electricity. Usually. But in the 21st century, that can change...

>So, according to your requirement to always use the more realistic model, electrical engineers should always model a whole power plant and an entire power grid in each circuit, because otherwise their model would be bullshit.

Firstly, I did not say the more realistic model should "always" be used. The situation in economics is more like the more realistic model is ignored in favour of the incorrect unrealistic model, even when the more realistic model is appropriate. The analogy with Newtonian/Einsteinian mechanics is quite shaky here, since as I've said, Newtonian mechanics is vastly more accurate than neoclassical microeconomics.

To take another example from engineering and continue the theme of relativity, error corrections required for GPS depend on an understanding of relativity.[1] If, as you've previously suggested, the simpler and more easily understandable model should be preferred, then we would not have GPS and allied technologies today.

Secondly, in the 21st century when we have renewable energy, electrical engineers are now required to take into account a power grid, because consumers are now also power plants if they have solar power, for example, and want to feed the excess power generated into the power grid.

The point is this: if the circuit you're modelling is a passive one that doesn't generate electricity, sure, make use of the unrealistic assumption that there's an unknown voltage source. However, if your circuit is also a voltage source, that assumption is then false, and you need to update your model.

The same should apply in economics. Unfortunately, it turns out that markets and economies are far more complex systems than power grids: as soon as you have more than one agent (e.g. humans, corporate entities, HFT algorithms, etc.), the simplistic analysis derived from marginal utility theory fails. So, outside of the laboratory perhaps, the models used in neoclassical microeconomics are probably almost never appropriate for the problems they're treating.

>> Yes, it does.[2]

>Do you know of any empirical studies that show that the models currently used in macroeconomics actually cause problems with real data?

This is a really garbled question. Firstly, nowhere did I assert that economic models "cause problems with real data". I really don't understand this assertion and would welcome any clarifications.

Secondly, I think you misunderstand the point of my argument about the SMD theorem. The point is that, as soon as you have more than one agent/consumer (human, firm, algorithm, what-have-you), they will interact in a non-linear way, giving rise to a nonlinear market demand function that gives a "weird" market demand curve.

This has nothing to do with any effect that the belief in a certain economic model would have on the economic behaviour of an agent. That is an entirely separate question altogether.

Back to your question about whether "weird market demand curves are possible" only "in a few exceptional situations". The SMD theorem basically says no: in all but the most exceptional cases, multiple market equilibrium points can exist.

The implication is that the aggregation problem[3] is not solved by the neoclassical assertion that the market demand curve for a well-defined commodity has the same pleasant mathematical properties -- in particular, that it is monotonically decreasing ("downward-sloping"), i.e. obeys the "law" of demand -- as the demand curve for that commodity of a rational agent.

And the reason why the aggregation problem isn't solved is because, as soon as you have more than one agent or commodity (like in most IRL markets), you get a complex system. And when you have a complex system, you can't draw line diagrams like you do in the textbooks. You need to do modelling and numerical analysis. There's a field called complexity economics[4] that's only beginning to do that, some 40 years after the SMD theorem appeared. Better late than never, but it's still a lot later than the other less "dismal" sciences, which have come to realised that they're dealing with complex systems and have updated their thinking accordingly.

[0] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-6435....

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_analysis_for_the_Global_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonnenschein%E2%80%93Mantel%E2...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aggregation_problem

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complexity_economics

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jtolmar on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:55AM (#21271773)
> The idea that awarding a prize to the most respected scientists in a particular field is solely for the purpose of advancing an ideology is in itself extremely anti-intellectual and biased.

The very idea of it is anti-intellectual? That's absurd. There's nothing magical about awarding prizes to scientists that prevents it from being done with a motivation. The committee famously cancelled the prize for a year to avoid awarding it to Einstein, since he was a Jew with radical political beliefs.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by badpun on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:44AM (#21269728)
Economics is not a science though.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by me_me_me on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:53AM (#21269801)
Therefore economist created their own award and pushed it as 'nobel' price in economics. Quite hilarious .
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by throwaway8879 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:54AM (#21269811)
It is a science, just a very dismal one!
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ernst_klim on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:50AM (#21268981)
I doubt that. When you see evaluations like "plot", "neoliberal", "cultural-marxist" etc etc, you're dealing with a heavily ideology-loaded stuff, which is by definition based on selectivity of facts (since the reality never follows ideology, reality can't be fit into ideology, and even soviet union had ideology only on paper).
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:42AM (#21269286)
Could you please elaborate, because I’m sure am not alone in my complete failure to understand what you mean.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ernst_klim on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:07AM (#21270448)
Neither social institution could adhere to any rigid ideology. A social institution, which does not correct basic assumptions and axioms lying in its foundation according to new knowledge and data, is doomed.

Any widespread movement or social institution exists under the pressure of new facts, new social norms, hence any social institution is a flexible moving target.

Only the heterodox, marginal movements can adhere to a rigid ideology. Mainstream science can't have one, only marginal branches can.

Modern economics is not a "neoliberal" plot, of course, there is a strong scientific discussion, various competing theories within it, which are constantly being validated using statistics, and omitted, if proved wrong. Economics today, 25 years ago and 50 years ago vastly differs even in methodology, it's a very vigorous field.

To say that this edifice is grounded in some ideology, one needs to omit all that constant scientific discussion, render empirically proved parts as ideological, axioms as "truths" etc.

This kind of intellectual dishonesty could come only from a ideology-loaded follower of some heterodox (and usually pseudoscientific) theory, most likely grounded in some ideology (guessing from value judgments of op like "neoliberal" -- left one) rather than verified by empiric data.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @12:17PM (#21272070)
I think the problem is many mistake mainstream political opinion for the prevailing scientific opinion. Most economists do not agree with the way our economy is being managed right now. The current political prevailing wind is definitely neoliberal.

Of-course most people do not read economics papers.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Thursday October 17, 2019 @12:29AM (#21278920)
>Mainstream science can't have one, only marginal branches can.

This is like native speakers of a language (say, English) asserting that only non-native speakers of their language have accents. You do, you just speak with an accent that's considered to be standard.

>This kind of intellectual dishonesty could come only from a ideology-loaded follower of some heterodox (and usually pseudoscientific) theory, most likely grounded in some ideology (guessing from value judgments of op like "neoliberal" -- left one) rather than verified by empiric data.

And mainstream (i.e. neoclassical) economics[0] does that, even in the face of mathematical reality, let alone empirical data.[1] The ignorance of the implications of the SMD theorem,[2] because it implies that the aggregation problem remains unsolved and the fundamental breakdown of the "law" of demand, was a profoundly anti-intellectual move.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoclassical_economics

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21269064

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonnenschein%E2%80%93Mantel%E2...

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ernst_klim on Thursday October 17, 2019 @03:54AM (#21279842)
> The ignorance of the implications of the SMD theorem

You are confusing different things together. Mainstream exists in a form it is not because Mainstream translates the Truth™, but because there are no better theories yet.

Newton's mechanics is worse than Einstein theory in describing celestial bodies' movements, yet the former was better than anything until the latter appeared.

I have a lot to argue against neoclassical economy, especially about its view of a person as a profit-driven (rational, as they call it) degenerate, or fondness of regressions in the mid of chaos.

Yet it changes in the right direction, behavioral economics appeared, regressions are taken with a grain of salt now, rational choice is heavily criticized.

The problem is that no heterodox theory provides both an axiomatic basis and empirical framework to compete mainstream economic science. What would you propose instead of Neoclassical economics? Nothing?

It's not ignorance to accept theory that is not always true, it's stupidity to omit theory without having anything better, as Lakatos would say.

As for ideology, I don't see such a thing. People in mainstream science vary from Joseph "We all need to follow Venezuela example" Stiglitz to post Austrians like William White.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Saturday October 19, 2019 @10:42AM (#21298743)
>Mainstream exists in a form it is not because Mainstream translates the Truth™, but because there are no better theories yet.

Where have I heard that before? Oh yeah, the string wars in theoretical physics.

>Newton's mechanics is worse than Einstein theory in describing celestial bodies' movements, yet the former was better than anything until the latter appeared.

In its early days, the Copernican model was no better than the mainstream Ptolemaic model at describing the motion of celestial bodies:

For his contemporaries, the ideas presented by Copernicus were not markedly easier to use than the geocentric theory and did not produce more accurate predictions of planetary positions. Copernicus was aware of this and could not present any observational "proof", relying instead on arguments about what would be a more complete and elegant system.[0]

>I have a lot to argue against neoclassical economy, especially about its view of a person as a profit-driven (rational, as they call it) degenerate

I think you're confusing a person with a firm. A person has rational preferences[1] -- another unrealistic assumption -- while a firm seeks to maximise profits.

>The problem is that no heterodox theory provides both an axiomatic basis and empirical framework to compete mainstream economic science.

The idea that an axiomatic basis is necessary for a good theory is classic physics envy[2], and ignores the fact that even physics itself does not have an axiomatic basis, because that is Hilbert's sixth problem, which remains open.[3]

I don't know why this phenomenon is called "physics" envy anyway: it seems like you want economics to follow the model of Euclidean geometry, hence "mathematics" envy, which is even more absurd.

I get that mainstream economics has become more diverse, but neoclassical economics, which I believe is still the dominant school, is based on postulates that are simply unsupported by empirical -- and even mathematical -- evidence.

>What would you propose instead of Neoclassical economics? Nothing?

A critical synthesis of everything that isn't marginalism? An empirical search for a new framework with postulates backed by evidence?

And perhaps economists should learn more mathematics and have the courage to invent their own tools. After all, if you want to carry on with your physics envy, you should know that Feynman invented his own integral[4], which mathematicians derided for a long time for its lack of rigour... until its power became clear, at which point the functional analysts got down to work to extract the deep mathematics underlying Feynman's formalism.[5]

>It's not ignorance to accept theory that is not always true

This is an acceptance of Friedman's discredited positivism.

>it's stupidity to omit theory without having anything better

We have, and had, better: marginalism (aka neoclassical economics) was heavily criticised even during the 20th century. It's stupidity to cling to a theory when there are better ones.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copernican_heliocentrism#Early...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preference_(economics)#Applica...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physics_envy

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilbert%27s_sixth_problem#Stat...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_integral_formulation

[5] https://ncatlab.org/nlab/show/path+integral

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:15AM (#21270540)
Very well put! Thank you! I agree.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by nerfhammer on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @04:53PM (#21275524)
Out of 84 economics Nobels, maybe 9 were about macroeconomics. Which of those 9 do you think serve only to legitimize "neoliberal" ideology?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by pytester on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:36PM (#21276077)
Krugman wrote a column once I quite enjoyed where he stated that he couldn't quite see why people objected to the TPP because "more trade" isn't something to object to. His own comment section proceeded to school him in what the trade agreement actually contained.

This is something that would be quite hilarious to see from an actual scientist about a topic that is supposedly their field of expertise but it's very much something you'd expect from somebody who is there to legitimize a neoliberal (no quotes necessary) ideology.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by nickik on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:14AM (#21271246)
The Nobel prize of economics is not fake. It was added later and it financed by the centeral bank, but it is approved by the Nobel foundation and listed on their website with the other prices.

And the claim that it 'legitimize a neoliberal economic ideology' is baseless nonsense if you actually look at who got the prices.

Chomsky doesn't get a nobel price in economics because nonthing he has done is close to worthy of that price. Whatever some Hacker News comment thinks.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jacobush on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:37AM (#21268592)
Aren't these orgs pretty independent from each other?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by coldtea on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:48AM (#21268648)
Supposedly "Independent" orgs play into the same wider networks all the time...

Here's an example from an article posted yesterday. While one might not agree with the article's main premise regarding climate change not being real or anthropogenic (I, for one, don't), the mechanism described here is all too common across many areas of science, economics, politics, public policy, etc:

"(...) many of the world’s major national academies of science (such as the Royal Society in the U.K., the National Academy of Sciences in the U.S.A and the Australian Academy of Science) persuaded themselves to issue reports giving support to the conclusions of the IPCC. The reports were touted as national assessments that were supposedly independent of the IPCC and of each other, but of necessity were compiled with the assistance of, and in some cases at the behest of, many of the scientists involved in the IPCC international machinations.(...)"

That's how one can find and quote N "independent" studies and organizations approving something or verifying another, when, looking carefully there's a single, well funded, or politically well supported, central origin behind all of their "findings", and their "independent verification" is basically a high level re-telling of what was giving to them (with nobody bothering to run the numbers).

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by tomp on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @05:57AM (#21268697)
About as much as Sweden is an "independent" country (really just a US puppet, as we've seen in the Assange affair).

(edit: Assange, not Snowden)

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jacobush on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:17AM (#21268816)
I meant Norway vs Sweden, but your point is well taken. If you want kowtowing even more overt, there is the Pirate Bay raid. That goes beyond the pale.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by toxik on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:28AM (#21268876)
That’s when I understood that this idea of justice for all under one rule of law was bunk. It is justice against those who don’t have by those that do have. Interestingly I’m not sure if that drives me further right or left. Neither I guess.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:43AM (#21269304)
Justice is a legal concept and by that measure both Assange and Pirate Bay had to be prosecuted. Or am I misunderstanding something?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jacobush on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:31AM (#21270738)
I agree with toxik below with caveats. [0] Specifically I was referring to how the Minister of Justice just casually called the Police and ordered a raid. This is not just frowned upon in Sweden, it's against the Constitution. [1]

[0] The Assange case has the veneer of legality. The Swedish law against statutory rape is actually very strict, stricter than what you might believe. It's just about everything else in the whole sordid affair which is horrible.

[1] Yes, Sweden has a constitution, not as neatly cut and well defined as the US one, but it exists. The point is ministers must not push their departments around, but let them follow the law on their own. It's even got it's own name "minister rule". ("Ministerstyre".)

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by toxik on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @02:54PM (#21274023)
Thank you for your corrections, it’s hard to remember exact details on the spot but it’s equally important to not let these gross violations of Swedish sovereignty and due process go unnoticed.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by toxik on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:08AM (#21269477)
You are missing entire swaths of information about particularly TPB from Wikileaks. Swedish police basically rushed the process when the US embassy said “fucking shut it down or face sanctions.” There were prosecutorial issues and the trial was a complete farce with one of the judges sitting in some copyright lobby’s board of directors. Absolutely made a mockery of justice and due process.

As for Julian Assange, the hearings with the two alleged rape victims DO NOT describe rape. It describes an asshole having sex with star struck women.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:13AM (#21270512)
How am I missing that? Does that information somehow magically make it not a legal matter?

If there are procedural violations it does not have any bearing on whether TPB broke the law or not. It only means that TPB owners can revert that particular decision if they are right.

Assange - yeah, I'm amazed how people can still revere him. His personality aside, his blocking of information related to Russia or China to be published on Wikileaks is atrocious and pretty telling.

But again, that's beside the point. It's kind of weird to me, this whole "sturstruck" angle. When that happened he was no way near a celebrity. Also, why do you have to whitewash it like that? The "it's not rape, he's just an asshole" defense sounds pretty whitewashy to me.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by antirapepolice on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:23AM (#21269587)
> As for Julian Assange, the hearings with the two alleged rape victims DO NOT describe rape

They do by the Swedish law.

> with star struck women.

So justice to you means blame the alleged victim?

I still prefer the Swedish way, the tribunals, the judges, and all the ceremony of a real justice system to your tribal "white men are always right" rite.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by tomp on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:55AM (#21271030)
Oh come on. If it was actually about rape, law and protecting women, they would have actually pressed charges, not just dropped the case as soon as he came out of the embassy, and leave him to the Americans.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jariel on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:01AM (#21269858)
Both points - that Chomsky has not received the Nobel price due to 'bias' and that the Nobel Price for economics is a neoliberal 'plot' are essentially false and conspiratorial.

I like Chomsky because he's such an antagonist (we need them) but I think he also misrepresents a lot of information.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by macspoofing on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @06:44AM (#21268953)
>It exists purely to legitimize a neoliberal economic ideology.

As opposed to which model? The highly successful communist alternative?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:02AM (#21269050)
There are non-neoliberal economic ideologies that aren't Marxian.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by macspoofing on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:06AM (#21281108)
Like what? What is the reasonable alternative to 'neoliberal' economics?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:17AM (#21281185)
> What is the reasonable alternative to 'neoliberal' economics?

Probably something that doesn't blow up every 5-7 years or pushes us into a climate apocalypse.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by macspoofing on Thursday October 17, 2019 @01:30PM (#21284349)
Again. What is that thing?

"Climate apocalypse" is a function of capitalism/"neoliberal economics" only insofar that this system provides things that make living nice and comfortable - like smart-phones, air-conditioning on hot days, heating in the winter, affordable air travel, meat, washing machines, etc - and there is no way to provide those things to 7 billion people without major impact on the environment. You can choose a system that makes everybody poor and consequently environmentally friendly - but do you really want to?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:40AM (#21270184)
It's bizarre this is being downvoted when, before the 70s, the United States can, in no imaginable way, be defined as being "Communist." After the 70s, Neoliberalism was the predominant ideology, which replaced the prior Keynesian + expansionist ideology (not sure if there was a term for this iteration of ideology like there is for the post-70s--"Neoliberalism").

How, then, would there have been an economic system which fits neither Neoliberal nor Communist models? It's super simple: there are more than two competing systems.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by Supermancho on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @01:57PM (#21273297)
The example proposed, as a proxy argument (saying that there are alternatives), has nothing to do with Marxism or non-neoliberal ideologies. This is a derail, which goes from possibly earnest into the droll discussion about terminology instead of the point made.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by antirapepolice on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:25AM (#21269600)
Socialism is not Marxian.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by allemagne on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:12AM (#21270497)
And Marxists would tell you that socialism is inherently Marxian, and Xi Jinping would tell you that the PRC is socialist (with Chinese characteristics!), and Americans will tell you that universal healthcare and Sweden are socialist.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by antirapepolice on Thursday October 17, 2019 @04:42AM (#21280055)
> And Marxists would tell you that socialism is inherently Marxian

But they would be wrong, it's the other way around.

> and Xi Jinping would tell you that the PRC is socialist (with Chinese characteristics!),

It is, economically speaking, at least until it entered the WTO it was 100% a socialist country.

You're conflating politics and economics, China is a socialist country, Sweden is mostly a socialist country, Italy is mostly a socialist country, the state has a lot of economic power in these countries.

It is simply true.

What the U.S. take wrong (among many other things) is that it is not bad for the citizens. I live in Italy and would never change it for Silicon Valley. I don't want to live where homeless are homeless because the staste cares more about selling more guns, so that another mass shooting in a school can happen, than helping poor people.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:41AM (#21269710)
I have no idea what this means in this context.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by antirapepolice on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:33AM (#21270760)
Socialism predates Marx.

Marx is socialist, socialism is not (only) Marxist.

You can be socialist without being Marxist.

So "There are non-neoliberal economic ideologies that aren't Marxian." it's not technically true.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:39AM (#21270834)
> You can be socialist without being Marxist.

Okay, understood.

> So "There are non-neoliberal economic ideologies that aren't Marxian." it's not technically true.

These two things just don't even remotely follow. Socialism isn't Marxism, therefore there have only ever existed Neoliberal and Marxian economic systems?

What do you think Neoliberalism is?

Furthermore, do you believe the United States was Neoliberal in, say, 1963?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by antirapepolice on Thursday October 17, 2019 @04:34AM (#21280020)
I don't know the history of the U.S well enough, but McCarthyism ended in the 50s, the cold war started immediately after the world war II against communism, so I can't really say U.S. was radically different from now.

One thing worth noting is that fascism (and neo-fascist/nazi groups) was anti capitalist, but not (of course) marxist-socialist.

They have some common ideas, the nationalization of the means of production for example, but it ends there, they aren't against social classes, they aren't against private property, they are simply against free market.

If for Marx communism was the goal, for fascists the goal is complete autarchy.

I would add neo-fascism to the list of anti capitalist movements, even though I sincerely hope they'll disappear ASAP.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by ianleeclark on Thursday October 17, 2019 @08:19AM (#21281202)
> I don't know the history of the U.S well enough, but McCarthyism ended in the 50s, the cold war started immediately after the world war II against communism, so I can't really say U.S. was radically different from now.

I don't know what to tell you, but the Keynesianism the US applied before 1973 is fundamentally different from what followed in Reaganomics--i.e., Neoliberalism.

I don't think you have a strong grasp on what the word means.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by antirapepolice on Thursday October 17, 2019 @11:49AM (#21283307)
> Keynesianism the US applied before 1973 is fundamentally different

It is true, but I think it was more about war reconstruction and applied automation that drove the public spending up.

Governments had to deal with the consequences of the war and made everything possible to give people a job, a purpose, to let the war behind.

The crisis of 1973 revealed the truth: that kind of growth is not sustainable, especially if it's global (in Italy we call that period "Italian economic miracle", it was more "spending the Marshall's plan money without thinking of the consequences on the future").

But without doubts it was different from Reaganomics, if I'm not wrong it was even possible to approve in the 60s a public healthcare system (kind of) in USA named Medicare. Of course the conservative attacked the idea and Reagan in particular was very vocal about invasion of the freedom and all the usual things they say.

But, if Reagan's idea of economy won is not because Reagan was particularly good, but because lobbies invested an enormous amount of money on propaganda and people in the 70s had good jobs, a powerful enemy to fight, baby boomers had lived 30 years of peace, fought no war and didn't think enough of the consequences of leaving the poorest behind.

They had been educated to believe that if you put enough effort in something, you will succeed.

If you don't succeed, it's because you haven't worked hard enough.

In places like Europe, were being socialist was not seen as a crime, public debate never ceased to address the fundamental differences between a free market economy (even with Keynesian bits) and a more equal society based on the idea that everyone deserves the same level of services from the state and the same protection, regardless of the single economic power.

So in a way USA before 1973 was more similar to what we call socialism, but not for the same (correct?) reason.

It was the best way they had found to sustain growth and fight unemployment and consequently discontent, but they did'nt really believe in a more equal society, that is the base for the economic ideas of socialism.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by swebs on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:20AM (#21269162)
The highly successful (for the working class at least) protectionist capitalism.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @07:44AM (#21269310)
I’m SUPER interested how protectionist capitalism has helped the working class. Could you elaborate?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by swebs on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @08:06AM (#21269463)
Here's a great read on how offshoring labor has affected the US labor market.

http://economics.mit.edu/files/7723

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:00AM (#21270374)
That offshoring will lower wages is a pretty obvious thing. But that's not what I've asked.

Where is it evident that protectionism would sustainably help and not reduce aggregate demand or in fact not lower employment? And how would one prevent even more entrenched oligopolies?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:13AM (#21270516)
>I’m SUPER interested how protectionist capitalism has helped the working class.

Australia is an example of a protectionist capitalist society: in fact, its first federal government was formed by a party called the Protectionist Party, with the support of the union-based Labor Party.[0] Unions are relatively strong there, compared to the rest of the world, and Australia's immigration policy is pretty tight, which protects workers there from foreign competition. Consequently, workers have some of the highest (minimum) wages in the world, and enjoy relatively excellent working conditions. The economy has also been doing well since the 1990s, despite the GFC and everything.

The EU is probably another example: strong labour laws with stringent labour market tests and excellent working conditions, as well as stringent requirements on a wide range of commodities that has to be satisfied by imports.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barton_Government

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:22AM (#21270610)
Wait, but unions are not necessarily protectionist. Also the protectionist government you are referring to was active until 1903, yet the productivity growth in the 1990s was followed by Labour winning majority in the parliament. What am I missing?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:37AM (#21270812)
>Wait, but unions are not necessarily protectionist.

Please define what you mean by "protectionist".

In what sense are unions not protectionist? Their sole function is to protect the labour market. I'd view unions in Australia as really protectionist: they've managed to secure very high minimum wages, as well as highly restrictive immigration policies that Trump praised to high heaven.[0]

>Also the protectionist government you are referring to the cabinet which was active until 1903

Their immigration policy[1] lasted for decades, before being replaced by the current immigration policy. The Protectionist Party[2] hung around until 1909, when they merged into the Commonwealth Liberal Party. This party was a predecessor of the current Liberal Party:

Protectionist + Anti-Socialist -> Commonwealth Liberal

Commonwealth Liberal + National Labor -> Nationalist

Nationalist + dissident Labor + Australian -> United Australian -> Liberal

So there is still protectionism hanging around in both major political parties today.

>the productivity growth in the 1990s was followed by Labour winning majority in the parliament. What am I missing?

It's spelled Labor, because modern spelling.[3] And Labor was in power from 1983 to 1996 (Hawke[4], then Keating[5]), so that productivity growth in the 1990s... probably Labor's fault? Lol. I think the proliferation of personal computers may have had more to do with it.

[0] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-06-27/donald-trump-tweets-s..., https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/mar/01/donald-trump...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Australia_policy

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protectionist_Party

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_Labor_Party

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Hawke

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Keating

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by jevgeni on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @02:53PM (#21274011)
Protectionism in economic sense are measures that inhibit international trade. Tariffs, selective subsidies and too restrictive immigration policies are good examples. Maybe in Australia they use the word differently, but in Europe this is what is meant by “protectionism”.

The function of unions is decidedly NOT to “protect the labour market”, but to provide organised market power to a group of labourers. A union fulfils its function even if it secures jobs for its members at the cost of say workers of another trade or those who are not unionised. Hence a union can satisfy its members but reduce the overall employment.

Also, I don’t understand. At first you claim that the 90s boom was due to protectionist policies. Now you claim that it’s because of personal computers. Which one is it then?

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by morningseagulls on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:25PM (#21278663)
>Protectionism in economic sense are measures that inhibit international trade. Tariffs, selective subsidies and too restrictive immigration policies are good examples. Maybe in Australia they use the word differently

I'm not sure which part of the Australian politics I've described doesn't fit your definition of what protectionism is.

I've certainly gone into great length about restrictive immigration policies: in fact, one of the first pieces of legislation of the Barton government was the 1901 Immigration Restriction Act,[0] the passage of which was a condition of Labor's guarantee of confidence and supply for the minority Protectionist government.

The 1901 election itself[1] was straight from the textbooks: Protectionist vs. Free Trade vs. Labor. Protectionism (Protectionists and Labor) won that election, both in terms of seats and popular vote. You couldn't get a more literal election than that.

As for tariffs and selective subsidies, Australia has that too.[2][3][4]

>The function of unions is decidedly NOT to “protect the labour market”, but to provide organised market power to a group of labourers. A union fulfils its function even if it secures jobs for its members at the cost of say workers of another trade or those who are not unionised. Hence a union can satisfy its members but reduce the overall employment.

You're presuming a fragmented union ecosystem, which isn't quite the reality in Australia. The Labor party was founded as the political arm of the unions; this shows a high enough degree of co-ordination amongst the unions at the very least.

And once you have a party in parliament, you get the power to influence policy-making in such a way as to protect the labour market. A single union may only be able to protect its own members, but a well-coordinated group of unions is well-positioned to protect the entire labour market itself. Labor did that in spades in the early days of federation, and still does to this day.

>At first you claim that the 90s boom was due to protectionist policies. Now you claim that it’s because of personal computers. Which one is it then?

I did not. You wrote:

>>yet the productivity growth in the 1990s was followed by Labour winning majority in the parliament. What am I missing?

I pointed out that you missed the fact that Labor was in power from 1983 to 1996.

I then made the facetious statement that perhaps it was Labor's fault that the 90s boom happened: this was a joke because, clearly, nobody blames a party for a good economy.

I then went on to suggest that the productivity growth may perhaps be more reasonably attributed to the proliferation of PCs, and the attendant automation. There are other plausible factors for the boom: the economic rise of China must surely have been one.

In any case, it's simply not true that the 90s boom was due to protectionist policies. Labor during the Hawke-Keating years was uncharacteristically enthusiastic about reforms, and I think the success of their policies may have inspired the Third Way of Blairite Labour.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Restriction_Act_19...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1901_Australian_federal_electi...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_tariffs_in_Australi...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_import#Australia

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australia_Tax

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by seamyb88 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @09:42AM (#21270207)
Yes, because everybody was trying to make Communism work and there were never any extremely powerful opponents to it, working in the background to make sure Communism never worked. It just didn't work and we should forget about it. The best way is surely to have a handful of individuals run the show. Case closed.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by travisoneill1 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:16AM (#21270541)
Having powerful opponents is inevitable. If a system of government can't stand against that then it is not a viable system.
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by gitrog on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:50AM (#21270958)
This seems like a ridiculous oversimplification for finding good alternative forms of government.

A small community of people could come up with the greatest governmental system we could ever dream of, but if the leaders of the current system believe it to be a threat they could wipe out its adherents before it is ever properly understood by the wider population. Or spread misinformation about it to dissuade people from finding out more about it for themselves.

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by phillc73 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @11:45AM (#21271644)
Sounds a lot like what happened to the Free Territory / Mahknovia in Ukraine in the early 20th Century.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Territory

Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by Gupie on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @10:24AM (#21270638)
Are you being ironic when you say there were "never any extremely powerful opponents to it"?
Re:Still Manufacturing Consent: An Interview with Noam Chomsky by seamyb88 on Wednesday October 16, 2019 @01:37PM (#21273037)
I absolutely am. It would require others to understand World history in relation to the terms they, and I, are using in this discussion, for them to get that irony.

I have absolutely zero faith in the average HN user to understand, but why should I explicitly appease their ignorance? The downside is people like you, who obviously realise that it could be irony, might imagine the avg HNer would legit say it.