News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by arvinsim on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:16PM (#21210521)
> The way it is going, I can guarantee with certainty that they can have all the financial leverage, moral leverage is what you need in the long term; they can never become a superpower.

I feel the same. This is especially apparent with how they handle their territorial disputes in South East Asia.

Hard to become a superpower when you are antagonizing your neighbors.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by davidgay on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:38PM (#21210652)
> Hard to become a superpower when you are antagonizing your neighbors.

I think the historical super-powers would disagree. Rome conquered all its neighbours. Britain had mostly terrible relations with France from the 11th to the end of the 19th century (and, at least according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_modern_great_powers, both can be reasonably viewed as superpowers in the 19th century).

And I'm fairly sure that the USA's relations with Latin America could readily be described as "antagonizing your neighbors" ...

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by chrisco255 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:00AM (#21210757)
Yeah this. Not just Rome, but think about the Spanish Empire. They conquered south and middle America seeking gold and forcing Catholicism on the natives. The British Empire? Hard to argue it was some sort of moral authority. They were just as bad as the Spanish. What makes a super power? Money and military. That's all. We can dress up American power with all the highest ideals we like, none of it means a thing without money and might.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by goatinaboat on Thursday October 10, 2019 @03:34AM (#21211874)
Rome conquered all its neighbours

This is not entirely true; Rome sent in the legions only when it had to. It “conquered” most of Britain via soft power, coopting local elites, introducing hypocausts, aqueducts and so on. Where it had to use hard power, it failed hence Hadrian’s Wall.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by NeedMoreTea on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:16AM (#21210826)
Then in the 20th century there were two proposals of Anglo-French union (1940 and 1956). That would have made an interesting alternative timeline. :)
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by spectramax on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:55PM (#21210736)
World has changed a lot since Roman empire, the British empire and the French colonialism. I am not convinced if the same dynamics still apply. You acutely omit the fall of the Nazi party for example. They didn't like their neighbors, tried to invade them and we all know how it went. You should be making a list of all the potential superpowers that didn't become by pissing off their neighbors.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by chrisco255 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:07AM (#21210791)
I wonder if the Nazis had stopped at Poland, Austria, and Hungary and just built up their power more slowly if they wouldn't have survived? The U.S.S.R. was no better but they had far more staying power and the remnants of that still influence politics to this day.

The main point I take from history is that the past does not necessarily determine the future. There's no such thing as fate. The Nazis could have won if they didn't make certain strategic errors. If Rome didn't make certain strategic errors, it would still be an empire today. China itself is older than Rome and there's really no guarantees that they don't win this whole cold war or whatever it is that's brewing.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by spectramax on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:34AM (#21210915)
I think the point I was trying to make is - I cannot imagine an empire such as the British empire going around conquering and taking over the world today. We have nuclear power. We have instant communication on a global scale. Organizing is easier than ever on the internet and once we have satellite internet, it is game over.

I just don't see the same type of century old analogies panning out in today's world. A superpower cannot antagonize, bully, invade and destroy neighbors like they used to in 13th century.

Your point of the Nazi party sounds plausible - if Nazi party had slowly built up their power, I think they'd had a hard time spreading on a global scale.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by chrisco255 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:52AM (#21211021)
Maybe. I think nuclear weapons are a deterrent for these world wars that happened in the 20th century and I agree on that point.

But the cold war still happened and it lasted a long time and there were many proxy wars fought in the process.

If world economy tanked for some reason and we found ourselves in another great depression, then all bets are off, though. Desperate people will do desperate things. They are more easily manipulated.

Any number of things could shift and the world is not as well put together as we would like to believe. It's a lot of duct tape and glue holding the whole thing together.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by polotics on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:49AM (#21211008)
How is China older than Rome? I see no more continuity in culture or society between those.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by chrisco255 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:54AM (#21211033)
China has had dynasty changes and civil wars for sure. But the language and culture are continuous for thousands of years. How many people speak Latin these days versus Mandarin?
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by AstralStorm on Thursday October 10, 2019 @04:28AM (#21212177)
Try again but ask about Romance languages.

Rome never forced Latin language on their members the way Mandarin was. Count the extant variants of Chinese and how they declined. In fact Greek was held in high esteem in the Roman empire.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by wutbrodo on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:22PM (#21210573)
> Hard to become a superpower when you are antagonizing your neighbors.

Er, is this true? I'd have thought quite the opposite: hard to become a superpower _without_ antagonizing neighbors.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by maratd on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:34PM (#21210624)
Do you truly feel that the US has antagonized Canada and Mexico within the past 100 years? I'm pretty sure they're our closest allies.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by wutbrodo on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:33PM (#21216474)
100 years seems like an arbitrary cutoff, and we sure as hell "antagonized" Mexico on our way to becoming a superpower not that much earlier than that by... Taking half their territory.

Canada has almost always been a virtual non-entity due to things like their incredible population sparsity and longitudinal cultural/economic integration with regions of the US. They are a counterexample, but the pattern very much points in my direction IMO.

On top of that, we're talking about _becoming_ a superpower, not being one. Once you're already a superpower, your neighbors often become varying degrees of vassal, which is why Mexico and Canada are among our closest allies. You're hardly a superpower if you haven't neutralized your neighbors (diplomatically or otherwise). Look at the blood feuds over tiny bits of land in the rest of the world, and consider how cool Mexico seemingly is with their land's massive, unprovoked conquest. They accepted it (and their good relationship with us) because they didn't have a better choice.

How many superpowers can you think of that didn't antagonize their neighbors, especially on their way to becoming one? Rome? Persia? Britain? Russia?

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by saghm on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:45PM (#21210691)
I definitely think there has been some antagonism from the US government towards Mexico a lot more recently than 100 years ago
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by davidgay on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:42PM (#21210672)
It's technically (just) more than 100 years, but the Zimmerman Telegram (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zimmermann_Telegram) is not something your (potential) enemy sends to one of your "closest allies".
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by jcranmer on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:49PM (#21210713)
The line of 100 years just misses the US occupation of Veracruz and the Zimmerman Telegram (or the Mexican Revolution in general), which was one of the lowest points of US-Mexico relations. US-Canada relations were pretty testy in the pre-WWI era as well, and the declassification of War Plan Red [1] did cause a brief stir.

Then again, the US has antagonized many countries simply by electing Donald Trump.

[1] In the inter-war period, the US military used a series of color classification schemes to sketch out what the US response to wars with various countries would look like. Red was Britain. And in event of war with the UK, the US plan was to invade Canada, irrespective of Canada declaring neutrality (which was Canada's plan in such a scenario).

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by chrisco255 on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:12AM (#21210808)
Which countries has it antagonized? China? Canada and Mexico have signed onto the USMCA. Japan and India's leaders both seem to adore Trump. Watching Trump at the U.N. two weeks ago, he seemed to be a very capable diplomat and seems to have good relations with most nations.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by soperj on Thursday October 10, 2019 @01:00AM (#21211057)
"I'm altering the deal, pray I do not alter it further." But yes, totally okay with USMCA, that's why we decided to put the US first in the name.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by jcranmer on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:22AM (#21210858)
Canada and Mexico signed the USMCA not so much because they felt it was better than NAFTA but because they didn't want Trump to do any worse. And it's not like Canada is happy about Trump's emergency steel tariffs that hit Canada's exports--the fact that USMCA would cause Trump to lift them was one of they reasons to sign it, and Trump certainly was in no rush to lift them afterwords.

Not to mention there's lots of dislike towards Trump's tendency to rip up treaties just because Obama signed them--Vietnam wasn't happy about Trump dropping TPP, Europe was not a fan of him leaving the Paris climate treaty or the Iran nuclear treaty, etc.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by arvinsim on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:29PM (#21210608)
Yeah but superpowers do try to avoid it, not actively foment it.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by bigpumpkin on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:46PM (#21210693)
Considering the three past superpower: UK, USSR, and USA. I find that the degree of which they antagonize their neighbors depend on their geography.

UK is an island and a seabased power whose primary interest in Europe was to prevent the creation of a dominant European power which could overpower it. Therefore it created a number of alliances and rivalries to serve this purpose. On other continents, however, it were more aggressive to secure trade and colonies.

The USSR as a landbased Empire that had a flat border to the west, was fairly hostile to its western neighbors in Eastern Europe and even to China to the East. Although a Russian would argue that they created buffer states in response to the memory of being invaded twice by Napoleon and Hitler.

The USA is a sea based empire with a continent behind it. Therefore it originally was very hostile against its neighbors, be they Native American or European colonies. After securing the continent by reaching the Pacific, it ensured the dominance of the Caribbean through the Monroe Doctrine (similar to China's position vis-a-vis the South China Sea) today. And then afterwards played Balance of Power against any major power from emerging on Eurasia.

China has a number of formidable foes on its immediate periphery. It is almost impossible to dominate them all militarily, especially with the US against it. Therefore it will attempt to establish economic dominance over Southeast Asia and the Middle East. The Belt and Road initiative alleviates it from a over reliance on Sea based imports of oil (especially through the Strait of Malacca which the US navy could easily blockade).

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by irrational on Thursday October 10, 2019 @12:48AM (#21211000)
Assyria was a superpower for a lot longer than the USA has even existed. Their relationships with their neighbors was almost entirely antagonistic.

https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/f4af/bb82f1b7920fa9444e29eb...

Nearly the entire history of the Ancient Near East was superpowers antagonizing their neighbors. Throughout human history, superpowers NOT antagonizing their neighbors is almost unheard of. The easiest way to become a superpower, historically, was to antagonize your neighbors.

Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by _tik_ on Wednesday October 09, 2019 @11:28PM (#21210601)
Their goal is never be become a superpower.This is just western paranoia Their action is based to protect their interest and to avoid chaos in their society. China experience with the west is based on their experience in the Opium war.
Re:Dealing with China Isn’t Worth the Moral Cost by petre on Thursday October 10, 2019 @01:14AM (#21211140)
Never assume. Chinese presence in the South China Sea, Vietnam's EEZ hints otherwise. Chairman Xi is a somewhat ambitious bureaucrat with no sense of humour. We'll see how he handles HK: soft power or Tianamen style.