News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by rmetzler on Monday October 07, 2019 @05:29AM (#21178910)
I’ve seen standups with 20 people where 2 or 3 talked for more than 10 minutes. That’s not what it’s meant to be.

While I would also like to do the daily status email, I see value in doing a synchronized standup. It helps planning for the day.

Not all people are great communicators and I’ve seen lots of developers spend days on tasks which should take 1 or 2 hours max. Standups highlight these issues, but you need to listen and go to these people in private to understand their problems. And you should absolutely take up people if they offer to help you.

I tend to bring pen and paper to remember what I wanted to say and to note when I here something that’s relevant to me.

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by sandos on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:54AM (#21179376)
Its highly dependent on personality of course, but Ive also seen this. A person that REALLY likes to talk for 10 minutes about details... which nobody really cares about. He even understood that it was not what anyone else wanted, but he thought "the standup is useless unless I get to say something elaborate and long-winded!"

He could not understand that "I had not trouble yesterday, and today I will keep going on my task" could be a useful update to the team. I mean, in general it isn't but when something unexpexcted happens you are supposed to say it, not something unique for every day. 90% of my dailies are basically: "I am still working on X, and its moving forward, continuing today".

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by EdwardDiego on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:45AM (#21179327)
> I’ve seen standups with 20 people where 2 or 3 talked for more than 10 minutes.

Did the scrum master not feel able to intercede? Protect the process etc.

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by LunaSea on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:48AM (#21179339)
The scrum master shouldn't exist.
Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by EdwardDiego on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:49AM (#21179350)
I agree, when the team is working, everyone's a scrum master :)
Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by diamondo25 on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:06AM (#21179127)
Standups with more than 6 people will already create a meeting of at least an hour. I mean, standups help is small teams to keep everyone excited (if you all agree on it!), and nobody likes meetings, so if it looks like a meeting and people need a 'token' to speak, then the point of the get-together is already far gone.

Why not join the meetup with afterwork drinks? That way you can really say what blocked you ánd talk about the things that you'd do in a standup...

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by EdwardDiego on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:48AM (#21179335)
> Why not join the meetup with afterwork drinks?

That excludes certain segments of your workforce in ways that make HR sweat. Parents, alcoholics, people of faith... you've made attending the meetup more difficult.

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by dagw on Monday October 07, 2019 @06:18AM (#21179180)
Why not join the meetup with afterwork drinks?

Mandatory after work 'fun' can be highly controversial.

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by javagram on Monday October 07, 2019 @09:26AM (#21180491)
> Standups with more than 6 people will already create a meeting of at least an hour.

Not my experience, teams of that size I’ve been on do standup in 10-15 minutes.

Re:The pointlessness of daily standups by antisemiotic on Monday October 07, 2019 @07:00AM (#21179418)
So the way to fix dysfunctional meetings is not to split them into manageable sizes, but rather shift them into some sort of impromptu unpaid overtime, and bribe your staff with alcohol in hopes that they won't notice?