News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by perl4ever on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:46PM (#21154611)
"Almost all animals are bilateral," he said. The code for having two sides to everything seems to have got embedded in our DNA very early in the evolution of life—perhaps before appendages like legs, fins or flippers even evolved. Once that trait for bilateral symmetry was baked in, it was hard to change."

What about starfish and other echinoderms? They may not have exactly three limbs, but they aren't bilaterally symmetrical, and they are animals.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by mishac on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:59PM (#21154657)
Weirdly, echinoderms are considered part of the Bilateria clade.

Apparently they're bilateral as juveniles and only become radially symmetric as adults (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bilateria)

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by cjensen on Friday October 04, 2019 @12:13AM (#21154703)
Yep. If you look carefully at a most starfish, you can see that they are bilaterally symmetric. For example, when there are five legs, if you mentally halve the animal along a leg, only one of the five legs results in both sides matching.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by gowld on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:42AM (#21155111)
That still undermines the articles thesis and that an odd leg can't be bilateral.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by kittiepryde on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:46AM (#21155131)
I have one head and four appendages (two for each side, but only one head bilateral down the middle). I don't see why they couldn't have a leg, bilateral down the middle ( like a head?)
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by fla on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:02AM (#21155454)
Or a tail
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by smackay on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:50AM (#21155659)
Anyone know if there is "handedness" in tails, particularly in monkeys where they use their tails while climbing. Do individuals always curl their tails clockwise or anticlockwise around a branch?
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by e12e on Friday October 04, 2019 @04:53PM (#21161791)
Well, technically you have a tail too. I suppose a better description would be a spine, stunted in one end (tailbone), extended at the top (head), with two set of limb pairs (arms, legs).
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by matt-attack on Friday October 04, 2019 @02:10PM (#21160307)
Well said and excellent point.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by elliekelly on Friday October 04, 2019 @12:21AM (#21154731)
Whoa, it does actually look like a little biped flubber: http://science-at-home.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/starfi...
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by eternalny1 on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:44AM (#21155119)
Hence the "almost all".
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by perl4ever on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:15PM (#21162365)
Well, if I were a starfish, I would take issue with that dismissive phrase. They are members of a large, and, I assume, proud phylum.

"Echinodermata [is the] second-largest grouping of deuterostomes (a superphylum), after the chordates...Echinoderms are also the largest phylum that has no freshwater or terrestrial (land-based) representatives."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echinoderm

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by perl4ever on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:11PM (#21162339)
Well, that's exactly what proves the point that you could evolve three legged animals from bilaterally symmetric ones.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by avar on Friday October 04, 2019 @04:54AM (#21155946)
You've misunderstood what bilateral means, it doesn't mean "two of each", it roughly means that there exists a point at which you could bisect the animal with a mirror and "see" the hidden side.

So e.g. humans are bilateral even though we only have one nose, mouth, anus, penis etc, because if you mirror half of a human bisected down the middle you "see" the other side.

The same can apply for animals that have an odd number of appendages such as starfish and other echinoderms.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by lucideer on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:37AM (#21156116)
If that's the definition of bilateral, the article title makes no sense as this property wouldn't preclude animals having three legs. So the definition intended in the article must be narrower.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by avar on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:10AM (#21156249)
Neither the article nor the paper makes that claim about bilateral symmetry. From the abstract of the paper:

"As is reviewed here, the strongest constraint on the evolution of a triped is phylogenetic: namely, the early genetic adoption of a bilaterally symmetrical body plan occurring before the advent of limbs. Presumably, this would greatly constrain any three‐legged animal from ever evolving."

In other words, an animal can have an odd number of legs and be bilateral, but due to how animals grow and develop it's less likely to evolve than an even number of legs.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by lucideer on Friday October 04, 2019 @09:28AM (#21157417)
From the article:

> why are there no animals with three legs? That might go back a long, long way, Thomson said.

> "Almost all animals are bilateral," he said. The code for having two sides to everything seems to have got embedded in our DNA very early in the evolution of life—perhaps before appendages like legs, fins or flippers even evolved. Once that trait for bilateral symmetry was baked in, it was hard to change.

(emphases mine)

Thomson suggests bilateral symmetry as the reason for not having three legs. It's strongly implied that they're mutually exclusive. Not sure how else you could read this excerpt.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by avar on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:02PM (#21160826)
By "that trait" I believe he's referring to that particular way of getting to bilateral symmetry, not that an organism that doesn't do it like that can't be bilaterally symmetric.

As an example, think of what it would take to add a third leg to a human being. Now we have two and one leg is a mirror image of the other. Those would presumably be the outer legs, how's the central leg going to look like? Is it going to be a copy of either the right or left leg, or some combination with 9 toes (4 outer, big toe in the middle) etc.?

Carrying that sort of information in the DNA is going to be harder than following the default template of "make this here and mirror it", which is how most structures are encoded in DNA.

Furthermore I think the reason the paper's abstract mentions phylogenetics (but I don't know, I can't access the full thing) is to say something to the effect that if an organism doesn't have any hands or legs, adding them in pairs of two is inherently simpler than adding three, since the rest of the body structure is already mostly following that template.

Once you start going down that road it's hard to "go back", which is why modern animals carry a lot of structures that are only the way they are today because they evolved from some initial past state.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by perl4ever on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:23PM (#21162416)
"As an example, think of what it would take to add a third leg to a human being"

Apparently the way radial symmetry actually develops is that one side of the body grows and the other withers away, and the remaining side produces the radial parts.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by klodolph on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:51AM (#21156179)
The funny thing here is that the particular example is relevant, because sea stars and other echinoderms belong to the taxon Bilateria (look at their larvae!). And it illustrates the difficulty you run into when you try to use morphology or other features to derive your taxonomy.

Cnidaria are an interesting comparison, because they are radially symmetric but not members of Bilateria. They are among the closest relatives to Bilateria.

(People may recall the article about Ctenophores that was posted recently, which are also not in Bilateria, and are actually much more distant, even from Cnidarians.)

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by ahartmetz on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:31AM (#21156098)
Our internal organs aren't fully symmetric, though. The heart is more on the left, the spleen is on the left, and the liver is on the right.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by klodolph on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:55AM (#21156195)
This is a misreading of the parent comment—“there exists a point”. In general you can dig up problems with using morphology for your taxonomy, but you haven’t actually discovered a problem here. The bilateral animals go through a development phase where they are bilaterally symmetric.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by ahartmetz on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:40AM (#21156385)
Oh, a point in time. I was thinking space. By the way, that part really needs clarification, because it can be trivially true - given indistinguishable cells, one to three cells or four cells on a plane are always mirror symmetric...
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by sysrpl on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:02AM (#21156221)
Okay, well then what about flounder?
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by duskwuff on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:01PM (#21159604)
Bilaterally symmetric during the larval stage; the asymmetry develops during their life cycle.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by elif on Friday October 04, 2019 @02:12AM (#21155241)
This line confused me as a place to end the answer to this question.

For instance, a creature with a tail is still bilaterally symmeteric. Us human males are still bilaterally symmetric. A full third leg would still be bilaterally symmeteric.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by Aardwolf on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:33AM (#21155588)
It would need toes of the same size on each side and a symmetric knee plus muscles to control it, I think it would need a leg and foot or hoove design completely independent from the outer ones, it couldn't copy or reuse the existing design, so less likely to evolve.

But if the kangooroo tail counts as a leg, it's indeed very different, but symmetric.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by kijin on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:29AM (#21156095)
Yeah, it would seem that we have plenty of three-legged animals already. A stout tail is what you get when you try to make a third leg that is perfectly symmetric and optimized for being positioned in the middle.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by perl4ever on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:30PM (#21162454)
Yes, things like starfish start out as bilaterally symmetric, both developmentally and evolutionarily.

But according to what I was just reading, the way a five limbed radially symmetric creature develops is not by growing two halves where each half is two and a half limbs.

What echinoderms supposedly do is the left half of their body grows disproportionately and the right half gets absorbed, and all the limbs grow from the left half.

In any case, if you do think it possible to also grow a third leg by halves, then presumably you are even more in agreement that bilateral symmetry does not prevent odd numbers of legs.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by coldtea on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:27AM (#21156081)
>A full third leg would still be bilaterally symmeteric.

Not necessarily. You could have 2 legs on each side, and a symmetrical looking leg (e.g. hooves, or human like but with 2 toes on each side) on the center.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by robbrown451 on Friday October 04, 2019 @01:34AM (#21155062)
But he's right in that echinoderms split off before much in the way of legs, fins and flippers evolved. (despite technically being members of Bilateria as someone else points out)
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by JoshTko on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:41PM (#21161184)
Difference in environment. And odd numbered appendage on land is costly and does not provide a speed advantage (Enough to offset cost). In sea, locomotion is completely different and an odd number appendage could linearly provide benefit commensurate with cost.