News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by elif on Friday October 04, 2019 @02:12AM (#21155241)
This line confused me as a place to end the answer to this question.

For instance, a creature with a tail is still bilaterally symmeteric. Us human males are still bilaterally symmetric. A full third leg would still be bilaterally symmeteric.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by Aardwolf on Friday October 04, 2019 @03:33AM (#21155588)
It would need toes of the same size on each side and a symmetric knee plus muscles to control it, I think it would need a leg and foot or hoove design completely independent from the outer ones, it couldn't copy or reuse the existing design, so less likely to evolve.

But if the kangooroo tail counts as a leg, it's indeed very different, but symmetric.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by kijin on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:29AM (#21156095)
Yeah, it would seem that we have plenty of three-legged animals already. A stout tail is what you get when you try to make a third leg that is perfectly symmetric and optimized for being positioned in the middle.
Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by perl4ever on Friday October 04, 2019 @06:30PM (#21162454)
Yes, things like starfish start out as bilaterally symmetric, both developmentally and evolutionarily.

But according to what I was just reading, the way a five limbed radially symmetric creature develops is not by growing two halves where each half is two and a half limbs.

What echinoderms supposedly do is the left half of their body grows disproportionately and the right half gets absorbed, and all the limbs grow from the left half.

In any case, if you do think it possible to also grow a third leg by halves, then presumably you are even more in agreement that bilateral symmetry does not prevent odd numbers of legs.

Re:Why are there no animals with three legs? by coldtea on Friday October 04, 2019 @05:27AM (#21156081)
>A full third leg would still be bilaterally symmeteric.

Not necessarily. You could have 2 legs on each side, and a symmetrical looking leg (e.g. hooves, or human like but with 2 toes on each side) on the center.