News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by mharroun on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:33AM (#21116427)
Incoming layoffs... between wework and uber the market will be "flooded" with talent.

I wonder if having wework on your resume is a good or bad thing.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by dcchambers on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:35AM (#21116457)
How many engineers does WeWork actually employ though? From everything I've read on here they're not really a tech company. I can't imagine that, even if it all goes up in flames, there will be many SWEs looking for new jobs from this.

Uber is another story. They've got a sizeable engineering force.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by puranjay on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:53AM (#21116700)
I honestly think Uber has over-invested in engineering. The problem they're trying to solve isn't so complicated that it needs their current engineering force. They don't have to add new features at as rapid a pace as a true software-focused company like, say, Stripe.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by PMan74 on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:52PM (#21117294)
From an external viewpoint stuff like building your own internal chat application seems like a "too many engineers with too little to do" kid of decision.

https://eng.uber.com/uchat/

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by pram on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:03PM (#21117402)
The chat program they’re referring to in the beginning was HipChat, which really was a steaming pile of crap. Uber was our largest user and they constantly brought the entire service down.

IDK if making their own was the right solution, but it was driven by necessity and not boredom I assure you.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by user5994461 on Monday September 30, 2019 @02:28PM (#21118268)
The largest user of HipChat, really? Uber must have been something like 5k-15k employees at that time. I thought HipChat was used in F500, much larger than that.

Anyway, HipChat was bought and killed by Slack. They avoided a dying product by accident.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by pram on Monday September 30, 2019 @02:57PM (#21118555)
Yes. It seemed like every single one of their drivers was getting messages from one of their chat rooms in HipChat. It was like 25k people in a single room iirc. They seemed to be using it for notifications or something?

At any rate HipChat was already dead prior to the sale. Atlassian made a new program from scratch called Stride which was its own little awful can of worms.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by pandanomic on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:56PM (#21120066)
Literally nothing in the first paragraph is true. For driver interaction, if it wasn't a push notification in the app then it would have been some sort of driver operations community tool like zendesk or similar.

> It was like 25k people in a single room iirc.

This never happened. I literally could not have happened. Uber ditched Hipchat when it was around 10k employees. The largest rooms I ever saw were outages or eng rooms with a few thousand, most with the room muted unless they needed something.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by pram on Monday September 30, 2019 @07:25PM (#21120603)
Theres really no point litigating this 4 years later (who cares) but it did happen. Uber had bots of some type, thousands of them in a single room. They were the largest user of our v1 API, which was an ancient shitty PHP base, and whatever they were doing put an enormous load on our backend during peak traffic periods and crippled the entire service.

Seeing this behavior was as easy as doing a join in mysql for user ids and rooms. I mean it's likely you wouldn't have seen it, or the room, or had knowledge of it unless you weren't directly involved with whatever it was?

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by user5994461 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @02:11PM (#21128725)
It's actually quite relevant. I've worked in mega corporation, 50k employees and above. The inability of third party software to cope with the amount of users is a major recurring blocker for using off-the-shelf software and a big driver for developing things internally.

Most open-source and commercial software advertise that they can scale, but throw the first 500 or 5000 users and it's breaking apart.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by pandanomic on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @04:57AM (#21123371)
With that context, I believe you. At the same time, I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that no one at Uber realized this either.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by ska on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:46PM (#21119518)
> It was like 25k people in a single room iirc.

Build it, and they will come ... and do something you hadn't planned for.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by joncrane on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:24PM (#21119337)
So why didn't they switch to Slack, Mattermost, etc rather than build their own?
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by pandanomic on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:53PM (#21120045)
They didn't build their own. The just forked Mattermost and skinned it a bit. Also invested/spent/donated $10k to have a say in Mattermost's roadmap.

Why not slack TL;DR - Uber, surprisingly, is cheap about off-the-shelf solutions. Cheaper than they are about balloons anyway.

Slack was trialed twice. Once in late 2015, and there were some bumps. Rather than stick with it, Uber ditched it citing it "couldn't handle their scale". Maybe that was true at the time, but I had a distinct impression that that's what the group in tech services at the time _wanted_ as well. Their lead on it was very much the type of person that would argue that there's no difference between hipchat and slack. If you asked the right person, you'd get the real answer: slack costs more than hipchat. Besides, the only person they had to convince was directors that didn't use chat anyway. All the executive leadership used Hangouts too. So they just needed to show the price graph comparison to justify, but as far as I know no qualitative productivity cost/savings/improvements measurement was made or factored into this.

Fast forward to the second try, late 2017. Supposedly when Dara came in he asked the same "why not Slack?" question. The UChat team was pretty intent on doubling down justifying their product, but a Slack pilot was done anyway. The pilot was a massive success by all accounts and basically everyone that made the switch was quite happy with it. Then tech services ended the pilot, sent out a survey, and were never heard from again. Would frequently give spiky answers when people asked for the results of the survey as well. Again - ask privately, and the answer you'll get is that Slack was just deemed as too expensive.

In both cases - tech services claimed that Slack was too expensive because of a price that was linearly extrapolated from their website. A lot of people didn't buy this, because that's just not really how enterprise contracts work. But tech services isn't accountable to UChat users, just the eng leadership they report up to.

In any case - everyone* else is still paying the productivity cost of using UChat/mattermost. It's more reliable than hipchat, sure. But is's miles away from being as useful as Slack. Especially the mobile apps - mattermost is a low quality, utilitarian react native app.

*Except ATG. ATG uses Slack because they actually don't fall under the CTO's jurisdiction. And executive leadership all still presumably use hangouts, because the UChat mobile apps are too crap.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by jamesmishra on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @01:51PM (#21128436)
When Uber trialed Slack in 2015, there were clear performance issues. Uber was aware of the potential issues ahead of time and slowly onboarded individual teams. As the onboarding went on, functionality like searching for an individual user clearly deteriorated.

I left Uber before the late 2017 Slack test, so I know nothing about it, but I think "It costs too much" is a very fair objection to using a chat app, especially for an unprofitable company that would have to pay for >30k seats.

At this point, I'm sure that Slack has resolved these performance issues for the sake of onboarding all companies that are Uber-sized or larger.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by paxys on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:00PM (#21121624)
TL;DR - the team that evaluated whether Slack would be good for the company also had the most to lose if Slack was selected over their own product.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by influx on Monday September 30, 2019 @10:48PM (#21121571)
Someone needed a promotion.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by jnwatson on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:44PM (#21117220)
Absolutely. They need a huge operations and driver support/sales team, but R&D not so much, outside of the self-driving money pit.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by bjtonline on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:40AM (#21116525)
WeWork has done a significant amount of hiring in New York City for SWEs with very generous compensation, and honestly hasn't really had much for them to do.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by JohnJamesRambo on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:59AM (#21116766)
Should have made them get their realtor licenses.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by CydeWeys on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:59PM (#21117358)
Any idea how much the actual salary for these positions was vs the stock component which may well be worth nothing?
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by untog on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:53PM (#21117299)
Compared to Uber they're still small. But I recall an article not so long ago talking about the tracking WeWork had installed in their offices that gave them startling insights like "people tend to drink more coffee in the mornings". They've been just as guilty as any of hiring a bunch of developers just so they can call themselves a "tech company".
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by Wowfunhappy on Monday September 30, 2019 @05:47PM (#21119998)
> that gave them startling insights like "people tend to drink more coffee in the mornings".

To play devil's advocate a bit, isn't this how science works? If you're not checking the obvious, you won't discover that people actually drink more coffee on the afternoon, or what have you.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by perl4ever on Monday September 30, 2019 @10:26PM (#21121446)
Personally, I generally drink no more than one medium/large coffee all day, but sometimes in the morning, sometimes in the afternoon, and sometimes I spend all day drinking it and reheating it, and still have some left when I go home.

I guess I kind of wait until I feel particularly down and tired, but otherwise well hydrated, and that's when I want coffee, but not always at the same time of day.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by martinald on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:41AM (#21116538)
At least 500 doing a quick search for 'software engineer' at 'wework'. Probably over 1000 for different job titles, etc.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by jannotti on Monday September 30, 2019 @03:02PM (#21118594)
I wonder how many of them are independent founders being facetious. They might be, literally, a software enegineer who is "at" wework.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by Marazan on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:45AM (#21116607)
That just seems mind boggling to me.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by acjohnson55 on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:55AM (#21116726)
They're a tech company in the sense that their internal and client-facing operations are enabled by custom tech, and they have the scale that that stuff needs to be pretty mature. But I wouldn't necessarily assume a WeWork engineer is doing cutting-edge stuff (not that they're not; I just wouldn't assume it).
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by greenyoda on Monday September 30, 2019 @03:37PM (#21118926)
> They're a tech company in the sense that their internal and client-facing operations are enabled by custom tech...

If that's the definition of a tech company, then Citibank, United Airlines and Fedex are also tech companies.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by acjohnson55 on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:47PM (#21121861)
Arguably, yes.

I don't think that's exclusive of the other types of company you can be.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by Nextgrid on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:46AM (#21116619)
Well in case of Uber their engineering side is quite strong. WeWork? Not saying their engineering is bad, but as far as I know there's nothing groundbreaking there besides a standard CRM & billing system? So I think as an engineer having Uber would be a very good signal your resume, WeWork would be just like any other company.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by chisleu on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:38AM (#21116491)
Flooded means I'll be able to find more than 3-4 qualified applicants per quarter? Good
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by 0xDEFC0DE on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:51PM (#21117904)
I think those folks will still shoot for top companies, so if that’s you, most likely.

(psst, train your own, damnit)

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by scandox on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:42AM (#21116547)
So you mean flooded with "talent"?
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by goobynight on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:00PM (#21116782)
The people at these companies actually handling individual contributor level execution are pretty talented. It's just that the plan/model they work under is not sustainable.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by goatinaboat on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:19PM (#21116968)
Cultural fit is so important these days and every one of them was a cultural fit at an extremely shady company. Even if they weren’t participating in the rampant excesses, they were still willing to go along with it.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by flmontpetit on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:40PM (#21117188)
We're talking about an office here, not a SS regiment.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by samstave on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:59PM (#21117368)
We should start a google sheet of startup ideas where ppl from this and all pools can say “I have talent that would work for that” and others can say “I’d fund that”

Actually, we just need this in general...

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by streetcat1 on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:28PM (#21117076)
The market is always flooded with "talent". The problem is finding good engineers which are around 1 in 100 resumes.
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by rightbyte on Monday September 30, 2019 @02:25PM (#21118223)
How do you know the other 99 are bad?
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by vkou on Monday September 30, 2019 @02:47PM (#21118457)
They didn't go to Stanford. /snark
Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by lazybreather on Monday September 30, 2019 @04:36PM (#21119435)
On a side note, I was quite surprised/shocked to see Waymo's recent valuation. $105Bn!! That is after Morgan Stanley cut it by 40%. So it was 165 Billion dollars prior to that. 165!!

Now, Uber has it own share of quite extensive R&D on self driving tech. How can it be a $50 Bn market cap company today? With all the markets it is present in? For me, it looks like an opposite case of that of WeWork. Conspiracy against the company right in public market. It began with Travis getting all the heat for pretty trivial things, all the way till the IPO and now.

I honestly don't understand how a company which practically revolutionized public transport all over the world and created a business model which gave a bazillion uber-for-X companies be valued so less.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by danbarker on Monday September 30, 2019 @07:32PM (#21120650)
Uber's tech and business model is relatively easy to replicate. So much so, that in many of their markets they already have at least one close competitor, or near-perfect competitor if you count Lyft (who have a similarly good app to Uber in my estimation; many of the other substitutes seem to have a pretty acceptable app that is missing some of the polish of Uber).

This makes their business vulnerable to price competition and raises doubts about their ability to make large profits over any long period of time. At the moment, they are losing money, but their (still high, imo) valuation is based on the fact that they are the biggest player and this means they have 'mind share' / brand awareness. If they try to start making a profit e.g. by pricing above their costs and not giving so many subsidies / bonuses, then they are vulnerable to any of their numerous competitors stealing market share by undercutting / offering their own bonuses or subsidies. They are already in fierce competition in many markets so it doesn't seem that their brand is necessarily enough to give them a huge and defensible advantage.

By contrast, all reports I have read (e.g. https://www.ft.com/content/7c8e1d02-2ff2-11e9-8744-e7016697f... ) indicate that Waymo's self-driving tech is the best in the market by some margin, with Cruise a distant second (and everyone else, including Uber, way behind that). And Waymo's technology is fundamentally more complicated and difficult to copy than a taxi hailing app. You couldn't have multiple local competitors to Waymo popping up in each city around the world, in the same way you have with Uber. So their competitive advantage seems a lot more defensible, meaning that their potential to earn defensible profits from their technology seem stronger in the long run. Continuing on this idea of defensibility: whereas people are happy to try any new cab-hailing app that launches with a promotion, the decision on which self-driving tech to use is going to be a lot more strict, in that unless it really works, it's not viable. So having the best tech makes a BIG difference, unlike for ride sharing.

The car industry is worth $1tn+ per year. The market for ride sharing is probably one or two orders of magnitude smaller than that ($12bn by 2025 according to this: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ride-sharing-market... , although Uber's revenues are already $11bn so I question the accuracy of this). Uber is a loss-making and non-unique ride sharing company with so-far unfilled aspirations to develop market-ready self-driving tech. Waymo is a self-driving tech company with apparently real potential to disrupt the trillion-dollar car industry with their unique technology.

Finally, Waymo's valuation is only on paper, whereas Uber's is in a public market. As WeWork (and Uber) have recently demonstrated, private valuations may not hold in private markets. However, given the reasons above, I actually think that the Waymo valuation might be more reasonable than the Uber one.

Re:WeWork says will file to withdraw IPO by lazybreather on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:47PM (#21121864)
Wow. I just looked at Cruise's numbers. 19Bn. That explains a lot. I guess I've been way out of touch with happenings of self driving world. Thank you for the details.