Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by coldtea on Saturday September 21, 2019 @04:07AM
(#21034113)
Well, memory aside (the iPad Pro having less) and perhaps SSD performance, how is the iPad Pro slower? What have you tried? It can run at least some code (the Geekbench) equally well. So what other programs could it run equally well?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by aloknnikhil on Saturday September 21, 2019 @04:53AM
(#21034245)
Video encoding. The iPad pro is significantly slower at encoding 4k video compared to my MacBook Pro.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by gvhst on Saturday September 21, 2019 @12:20PM
(#21036204)
Isn’t video encoding a multi-threaded workload?
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by aloknnikhil on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:17PM
(#21036563)
Yes. And the Geekbench comparison I linked to in my comment claims the multi-core scores are also similar.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by ubercow13 on Saturday September 21, 2019 @06:27AM
(#21034508)
Wouldn’t that be hardware accelerated on the iPad? What iOS app is doing software video encoding?
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by jasonvorhe on Saturday September 21, 2019 @07:32AM
(#21034690)
That's because of throttling though. Your MacBook Pro has fan(s), the iPad doesn't.
I'm pretty sure the iPad Pro SoC in a MacBook Pro case would be at least on par with the latest Intel-specced MBP
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by rubbingalcohol on Saturday September 21, 2019 @09:49AM
(#21035352)
Based on what evidence? A single core Geekbench run?
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by zamadatix on Saturday September 21, 2019 @04:57PM
(#21037901)
ARM SIMD is only 128 bit isn't it? Would eat pretty heavily on video encoding speed.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by aloknnikhil on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:16PM
(#21036558)
The iPad, magically, performs well in Geekbench but has throttling issues in a real world task? I find that hard to believe.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by saurik on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:25PM
(#21036631)
As someone who has literally been running thermal tests against a random Android device for days (note: not as an expert in hardware, but as someone writing software that is causing the device to overheat), analyzing at all of the temperature sensor and power regulator debug information in spreadsheets while varying the workload, it isn't even remotely surprising to me that pegging a single core (which was the point of this benchmark) might not generate enough heat to cause thermal throttling but running a multi-threaded multi-core workload might.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by aloknnikhil on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:31PM
(#21036681)
Oh, I'm not talking about single core scores. I'm talking about multi-core scores. The comparison link in my original comment is claiming similar multi core scores.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by holstvoogd on Saturday September 21, 2019 @05:04AM
(#21034273)
That makes sense, you're MBP has a pretty decent GPU to do that.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by Youden on Saturday September 21, 2019 @05:45AM
(#21034387)
The quality of the GPU usually has no impact on video encoding.
At best, you can use a hardware encoder that happens to come with the GPU but usually you won't want that because it comes with a compression hit compared to software.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by gambiting on Saturday September 21, 2019 @06:51AM
(#21034577)
It looks like you're getting downvoted and I'm not sure why - most encoding that I do is CPU-only, GPU encoding only works for a very limited set of codecs at a limited range of presets. If you need to encode anything other than those presets CPU it is.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by ttkari on Saturday September 21, 2019 @09:52AM
(#21035372)
Does this compression hit you mention also apply to encoders that use for example CUDA on Nvidia GPUs? With these there definitely are significant differences in encoding speed between different GPUs.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by Youden on Saturday September 21, 2019 @04:57PM
(#21037899)
There's no reason that using CUDA inherently leads to inferior compression but I'm not aware of a CUDA-accelerated encoder that's any good relative to a pure software encoder (or even NVENC, the pure hardware encoder on an NVIDIA GPU).
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by FullyFunctional on Sunday September 22, 2019 @01:02PM
(#21042417)
Well, it's not that simple. The CUDA model has a inherent penalty for divergent thread behavior, that is, when all threads do the same, peak performance is attained. If they all follow a different path, the result can be disastrous.
The relevance to media encoding is that the higher profiles do a lot of data dependent special casing. It's no accident that the earliest CUDA Video codecs only handled the base profile.
This also hurts a CPU implementation but much less.
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by lostlogin on Saturday September 21, 2019 @05:35AM
(#21034364)
How does a user distinguish between that being due to software versus hardware?
Re:iPhone 11 has the fastest single-core performance of any ...
by aloknnikhil on Saturday September 21, 2019 @01:14PM
(#21036540)
How does that matter for this comparison? The claim is that the iPad pro is as fast as the Macbook Pro. If the hardware encoder is slower than a Macbook Pro software encoder and the iPad pro is as fast as the Macbook Pro, then by that corollary, the Macbook Pro's software encoder should perform faster than its hardware encoder. Surely Apple wouldn't add a slower hardware offload and use that?