Google has obviously decided that anyone searching for a medical term should only be shown pages that are equivalent to what a doctor would tell a scared patient in the first three minutes after delivering a diagnosis. Sure, those WebMD pages are probably going to be a bit more accurate than the wikipedia article, but largely because they're saying much less and have fewer opportunities to be mistaken. It feels rather condescending and patronizing.
There are >10k of these bangs, so I'm pretty sure you can even use this tool to directly search at other medicine related sites and portals (check here https://duckduckgo.com/bang) if necessary .
Instructions for setting up wikipedia's : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Help:Searching_from_a_web_brow...
Those pages are littered with Google ads. It's no wonder that they're prioritized over relevant and information rich results like Wikipedia.
Not necessarily: https://www.vox.com/2016/4/5/11358268/webmd-accuracy-trustwo...
It's difficult to imagine that most of the people haven't seen this a bunch of times as well.
And while I agree with this, I'd love to know why people keep asking and/or upvoting this same question over and over. Is it for the sole purpose of bashing Google or what is it? Honest question.
Candidly, I'm mystified by the complaints. Google's search works great, and has for years for myself and everyone I know IRL.
Any post about any product that isn't brand new on HN is going to get comments along the line of "Company X? Their product is garbage, it used to be great! I've been using <alternative that requires a ton of extra effort to setup> and once I got it going it was amazing!"
I think a few years ago this was somewhat reasonable but in my opinion DDG has not only matched but surpassed Google for most searches. As an example (to not make this as if I'm only asking you to do the lifting) a random search that's relevant for me would be 'spacex rocket thrust.' Since Google's results are based on arbitrary tracking and whatever per user magic marketing metrics they decide to apply, it's not repeatable but I imagine you'll probably get at least something similar. We should get identical results for DDG:
-----------
Google:
- 4 redundant wiki pages (all link to each other)
- 2 redundant links to spacex.com site (all link to each other)
- 1 irrelevant theverge article on an arbitrary launch
- 1 space.com link with some relevant information
DDG:
- 1 relevant wiki page
- 2 redundant links to spacex.com site
- 1 tangential article from space.com
- 1 space.com link with some relevant information
- 1 spaceflight101.com link with extremely relevant information
- 1 irrelevant link from teslarati talking about a 'spacex rocket package' for a roadster
- 1 cnn article comparing rocket thrusts
- 1 redundant wiki page
-----------
That was literally the first thing I searched for and I think DDG is clearly better there, though both overall results are quite poor. One big thing is a much better diversity of sources with much less redundancy. But the thing that really pushes this example over the edge is the spaceflight101. It not only provides the most relevant information by a rather wide margin, but is also a critical source for a wide array of related news, specs, and other information.
The reason I think both searches are quite poor is because of how much all search engines today lack any notion of context whatsoever. When I search for 'spacex engine thrust' am I searching for technical information, or am I searching for media information relating to recent launches or developments? That's something that ought be able derived from a contextual analysis of my query, yet nonetheless it quite obviously is not!
Google took us that big leap from 'Abraham Lincoln' not returning hardcore porn, but it feels like the progress we've made since then has been pretty.. meh. And I feel the last few years have seen an overall decline in search quality, but a relative increase in quality for the formerly secondary players such as DDG. In other words it "feels" as though Google of ~4 years ago > DDG today > Google Today. But of course this is, in some ways, going to come down to the person.
The trend is entirely clear for my search usage though - I just don't find what I'm looking for much of the time with DDG, so end up g!'ing. When that usage reaches a certain subjective redundancy threshhold I switch back to google.
To be clear, I don't like Google any more, and I'd be happy if more and more people stopped liking them too. An advertising/data-mining/surveillance company controlling access to information in a digital age is about as dangerous as you can get. Even so, I can still objectively praise some interesting cool tech that they produce...
>Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents.
Hence I believe repeating the same comment (or should be called rhetorical question) in almost every Google Search (or related e.g. DDG) thread isn't only repetitive but IMHO also goes against the quoted guideline.
Apparently, Google's search algorithm is one of the most hidden secret in the world, and has insanely complex evaluation mechanism in place, any anecdote feedback is not going to cause a ripple in shaping this algorithm.
2. Google hasn't changed - so until they do, I suspect they will continue to be criticized.
People generally will continuously criticize things that continuously screw them over.
I miss the early 2000s when I'd do a search for things and get information heavy, presentation light content made by non-commercial enthusiasts.
Though in my case I mostly don't blame Google as much as the commercialization of the internet and the short attention spans of the majority of its current inhabitants (who are a lot less bright and technical than the ones from the late 90s and early 2000s). What I do blame them for a bit is catering to those masses and their commercial focus rather than trying to improve the quality and depth of information we are exposed to. (I can probably also blame them for some of the censorship they seem to do based on these guidelines)
Yet today it's become the same thing with Google. They had a phenomenal search engine, but it's gradually gotten worse while other engines have taken some big strides forward. Its marketshare is just completely out of wack with its capability, and so I think that motivates people pretty strongly since it indicates a knowledge gap in the market. This is also a pretty new thing which further adds motivation - a few years ago Google search was, without doubt, king. Now, it's not. And, again similar to Microsoft, Google is increasingly destroying its reputation so it feels good to swap, let alone when other services are now also arguably superior!
To see some degree of evidence of this look at posts related to Google, but not their search. Posted just today (so there's going to be a large overlap in users) was this [1] post where a sunken car (found to contain a corpse) was visible via Google Maps. Nobody decrying Google Maps because it's still the clearly best service for satellite/street imagery. Gotta give the devil his due.
> Has anyone found that recently Google search
> is becoming more and more useless?
Absolutely. I use DDG now. Google spams me with ads, and ignores my search terms.This 'search disease' seems to be spreading, too. Retailers like Amazon, NewEgg, Ebay, and others happily insert results that they want the user to buy, instead of putting the user in control. On Ebay, half the time they remove filters I want to use. Amazon haphazardly injects their off-brand products into my results, even if I sort by price. NewEgg and Walmart show me results of partner retailers whom I don't know whether to trust.
Maybe this state of affairs works for the average user. It doesn't work for me. It mainly causes me to wade through pages of useless results, trying to filtering them out by eye.
These days, if I have success with even a mildly technical Google search, it’s because I’ve enclosed every single term in quotation marks and/or turned on verbatim search, which doesn’t even work that well.
Google is trying so hard to think for you that they’re ruining their core product.
Further, I see there's now an option to disable "relevant" (personalized) searches.
https://www.google.com/preferences
"Private results
Private results help find more relevant content for you, including content and connections that only you can see."
Followed by checkbox.
The linked explainer suggests the "relevant" (personalized) search is informed by your activity with other Google products. Skeptical me thinks that's hardly the whole story.
"Search results from your Google products" https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/1710607
Either way, I may try google search for a while, see if there's any benefit over DDG.
Furthermore, if they show you spam sites, which also have google ads on them, then you're more likely to click on an ad and give google money than if they show you wikipedia, which doesn't have ads.
They don't want you to go to wikipedia, because it won't make them any money.
They are sacrificing their product quality for profit. This is the general trend in corporations with a fiduciary responsibility to their shareholders, rather than their customers.
In this case, the customer is the ad buyer, not the searcher, so those of us looking for things are actually 4th in line for prioritization, as it's like this:
Shareholders come first
Ad buyers come second
Ad real estate providers third
Searchers forth
We need a search engine where the search results are the product, rather than the people searching. We are the product being sold to the Ad buyers.So, say I search for corn, but Google thinks corn is bad for me, cause I've been eating too much of it, and potatoes are better, so they just go ahead and substitute corn with potatoes to help me out.
On one hand it's nice, they think they understand what I really need. On the other hand, it's very bit creepy when it goes overboard.
Can we create a github repo with examples? I believe dev experience using Google is going really downhill.
Github's search is, in general, very good at finding what you searched for, all of what you searched for, and nothing but what you searched for. The one thing I want, and it's vague and complex, is a way to filter out the several hundred or thousand very very similar repositories that come into being due to a popular tutorial, school lab assignment, or frequently forked and slightly modified repository using the rare function I'm looking into.
I heard from Bing engineers (circa '09-10) that every time Bing would release a relevance improvement, Google would increase their relevance metrics shortly thereafter, suggesting that their relevance is being artificially held back. It makes economic sense, and it'd be super easy to implement, so I believe it.
Often, I have to rephrase my search 5-10 times before I see a result worth clicking on.
"Saerang story lord of the rings"
The most important term got dropped and needed to be quoted to actually find what I wanted.
A separate and more concerning problem with Search is the emphasis on shallow information without outgoing links for more depth. The majority of searches on many topics (medical topics for example) will have the top results be "terminal" webpages that offer only a very shallow look at a topic without any way of finding more detailed information.
For example, when I attempted to look for a comprehensive breakdown of biodegredation of plastics (e.g. what kinds of environments reduce/increase biodegrading time, what types of plastics have longer times and why) I just kept finding pages by various advocacy groups that talked in vague generalities and offered no opportunities for further research.
"techniques for interpreting statically typed languages" - gives a bunch of super basic articles/questions about statically vs dynamically typed and compiled vs interpreted languages. DuckDuckGo actually gave better results for this.
I feel what's happening is that google is looking at what people are clicking during searches and then using that data to calculate absolute ranks for pages and websites. Those ranks are then not necessarily appropriate for different, less common queries or searching behaviors. However, this algorithm probably performs better in 99% of cases for some internal metrics, so Google ends up keeping it.
But is there any good result that includes all those words and which Google failed to find?
To answer your exact question: I don't know, perhaps not.
typical tcp packet sizeBetween google, bing and duckduckgo, only duckduckgo presented this above the fold: https://etherealmind.com/average-ip-packet-size/
Seems ok to me.
It should also be noted that the etherealmind.com link doesn't actually contain the word "typical", so if you think Google should try to outsmart users less, it's not reasonable to blame it for not showing that link.
Not sure if DDG is really that much better than Google here.
also top results tend to be from sites trying to sell something.
which makes sense because businesses can hire SEO consultants and spend their resources getting google to show them in the top results.
however people who just put stuff up and leave up for free don't hire SEO consultants.
https://www.google.com/search?tbs=li:1&q=search+my+exact+wor...
Google tends to ignore what I actually type in, and tries to search according to some weird NLP machine learning inference on what it thinks I'm actually trying to ask.
Top results will include maybe 50-75% of the words I actually typed in, and it will treat the rest as mere hints or related words.
My queries end up looking like this after several tries and fails:
"something" "another phrase" "also" "this"
If I type the whole phrase without quotes I just get a bunch of ads, blog spam, and irrelevant stuff that is pretending to be useful.
Hell, most dev-related queries will return shallow medium-style blog articles instead of SO / Github.