News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by daniel_reetz on Friday September 13, 2019 @10:04AM (#20962242)
I see the same behavior. I think it's time to assemble a list of examples.
Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by bogdanoff_2 on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:14AM (#20962856)
"thesaurus that organizes words by category" - gives a bunch of online dictionary pages. I was trying to find a specific physical book I remember using in high-school.

"techniques for interpreting statically typed languages" - gives a bunch of super basic articles/questions about statically vs dynamically typed and compiled vs interpreted languages. DuckDuckGo actually gave better results for this.

I feel what's happening is that google is looking at what people are clicking during searches and then using that data to calculate absolute ranks for pages and websites. Those ranks are then not necessarily appropriate for different, less common queries or searching behaviors. However, this algorithm probably performs better in 99% of cases for some internal metrics, so Google ends up keeping it.

Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by icebraining on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:59AM (#20963270)
> "techniques for interpreting statically typed languages" - gives a bunch of super basic articles/questions about statically vs dynamically typed and compiled vs interpreted languages. DuckDuckGo actually gave better results for this.

But is there any good result that includes all those words and which Google failed to find?

Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by bogdanoff_2 on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:20PM (#20964190)
I don't remember the exact phrasing I ended up using, but I think I remember finding through DDG a StackOverflow question that was essentially "how to make an interpreter for a statically typed language" and it did not appear on Google.

To answer your exact question: I don't know, perhaps not.

Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by brlewis on Friday September 13, 2019 @10:09AM (#20962292)
I bet googlers on HN who work on ranking would appreciate that. Here's a recent one from me:

  typical tcp packet size
Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by CDSlice on Friday September 13, 2019 @10:12AM (#20962325)
What exactly do you mean by that? When I search it up I get a SO answer saying what the max packet size is and another (closed) SuperUser answer that says that their is no average tcp packet size because that depends on the specific application. Both of those seem pretty good to me, but I'm not a low level networking guy.
Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by dunkelheit on Friday September 13, 2019 @10:27AM (#20962455)
I think the problem is that google confidently and authoritatively displays (in a big and bold font) "65535 bytes" which is an answer to a different question.
Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by brlewis on Friday September 13, 2019 @10:31AM (#20962498)
I definitely wasn't asking for maximum packet size, which a search feature showed in huge print as the answer to my question. I don't expect the search algorithm to know my precise intent, but I'd like it to weigh the word "typical" highly.

Between google, bing and duckduckgo, only duckduckgo presented this above the fold: https://etherealmind.com/average-ip-packet-size/

Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by icebraining on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:10PM (#20963375)
In Google, after that card, I get their "People also ask", and the second question is "What is the average packet size?", which links to https://superuser.com/questions/964682/what-is-the-average-s...

Seems ok to me.

It should also be noted that the etherealmind.com link doesn't actually contain the word "typical", so if you think Google should try to outsmart users less, it's not reasonable to blame it for not showing that link.

Re:Elevating original reporting in Search by Kique on Friday September 13, 2019 @10:47AM (#20962647)
I'm seeing that etherealmind link as #4 on Google, and then #3 on DDG. And the results above it on DDG are also related to the maximum size, and the entire sidebar on DDG is the same stackoverflow link about the maximum size.

Not sure if DDG is really that much better than Google here.