News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:02PM (#20957765)
An argument that's rarely made: Almost everyone whose work would be protected by software patents, is fervently opposed to them. Except patent lawyers and multinationals. That should tell you everything on whether they're a good idea.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:26PM (#20958258)
It depends on the kind of software. Patents protect capital intensive innovation that’s hard to figure out but easy to copy once you figure it out. That doesn’t describe most software. But it describes a lot of things that are software. I spent an entire summer working on network formation algorithms for cognitive radios. Aside from Matlab simulations I didn’t even write any code. My employer applied for a lot of patents on what was basically software (though commercially it’d be embedded on a baseband processor and you could put it in hardware if you wanted). If you’re a company that paid a room full of PHDs tens of millions of dollars over many years to write code, and could throw the code away and it’d still be worthwhile as long as you had the spec, then that’s the sort of thing where patent protection makes sense. Most software developers have no experience with such work however.

Intellectual property is a thing that exists. Somehow Apple’s Ax processors are several times faster than the best Qualcomm can do. That’s intellectual property. Given that, I’m not sure it makes sense to divide up patentability based on whether it’s software or something else.

(At the same time, I’d probably say that nothing bad would happen if we simply banned advertising. Since my paycheck never depended on ads I have to admit I don’t really get why it’s necessary, beyond the abstract intellectual arguments. People’s world views are limited by their direct experience.)

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by wiseleo on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:42AM (#20959233)
That sounds like it should not be pantentable.

At the core of the argument, software engineering is applied math. Math is not patentable. Software patents are workarounds around the fact that math is not patentable. Yes, the work is valuable, but it should not be patentable.

Here are USPTO's guidelines https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s2106.html

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:56AM (#20959553)
All engineering is just “applied math.” It’s the “applied part” that makes it patentable. (You cannot patent an algorithm. You can patent a method of getting getting radios to aggregate into networks. Or a method of wayfinding for a self driving car. Or a method of indexing and ranking web pages.)
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by wiseleo on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:25AM (#20959694)
Why?

The purpose of a patent is to grant a monopoly for an invention that would not be obvious to someone skilled in the art.

These business methods should not enjoy patent protection that prevents someone from independently discovering and implementing same solution. There is a finite number of ways to efficiently implement wayfinding for a self-driving car.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by bakuninsbart on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:28AM (#20959956)
Funny you mention wayfinding algorithms: There had been decades of progress in that regard without a single patent, only the last decade (since big business got in the game), the rules have suddenly changed.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2019 @07:03AM (#20960970)
I’m pretty sure the CMU folks have been parenting their stuff The whole time: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~tjochem/nhaa/ralph.html
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:55AM (#20961628)
Many universities obtain patents on research outcomes as a matter of policy.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @07:55AM (#20961259)
Hardware engineering works with matter which is not subjective and so it can't be handled by pure imagination as opposed to math and software.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:54AM (#20961620)
You can turn any software into an equivalent piece of hardware, which meets the non-subjective matter test you're proposing.

Similarly, I can convert any hardware into a software model of it, which makes it into pure imagination.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:31AM (#20963006)
You can't convert hardware into software model, the software model is necessarily an imperfect idealization, created deductively even, which thus doesn't necessarily work IRL, because fundamentally it's imagination.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:42PM (#20958370)
I spent a long time writing advanced code as part of a PhD as well. It relied heavily on existing FOSS code and patent-free work, and would never have been possible if I had had to seek permission for each patentable element used.

There is hardly any field where you can improve the state of the art, without stepping on dozens of patents. Of course you can ignore those patents if you don't care about making any money off your work. But if that's the case, you don't need patents in the first place.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:56PM (#20958449)
YMMV. Unpopular opinion: I don’t really like open source. I like patents and copyrights because they’re property rights you can use as the basis for markets. Markets are good. It’s hard to build markets with open source. Open source has resulted in a world where you can’t make money just selling software, you have to lock people into ecosystems and services to monetize your work. Symbian used to sell you an OS in return for a cash payment. That was it. Now, you get Android for “free” but only by turning your customers into the product. Same thing with web standards. With video coding standards, you just pay some money and you get the necessary patent licenses. But web standards are “free.” In practice that means just two companies (Apple and Google) get to control the standard by fiat. Is this better?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:22PM (#20958571)
> Open source has resulted in a world where you can’t make money just selling software, you have to lock people into ecosystems and services to monetize your work.

Microsoft made a lot of money selling Windows and their Office suite precisely by locking people into their ecosystem.

You say you like markets, yet you don't like others offering goods at a lower price (free software), but you do like government-enforced monopolies on ideas (patents, and even copyright). If we're diving things into 'market' and 'not market', shouldn't you categorize them in the exact opposite way as you did?

> Now, you get Android for “free” but only by turning your customers into the product.

You also get linux for free, or you can pay for Windows and still be made into the product. The only way I can see someone arriving at your position is to selectively pay attention only to cases where free software with anti-consumer features crowded out straight-forward proprietary software, and ignore cases where free software turned out good (compilers, linux, firefox, text editors, libre office, lineageOS, VLC, etc. etc. etc.)

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by mch82 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:20PM (#20958560)
Lots of companies use open source wrong. Treat open source like an industry standard[1] and it is very possible to release products built upon open source.

Every product Apple sells incorporates various standards, including open source. The key is to use open source to reduce the barrier to participating in a market and then add value on top of open source to make a profit.

[1]: https://www.nist.gov/standardsgov/what-we-do/federal-policy-...

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:13AM (#20961360)
>It’s hard to build markets with open source.

Only if you can't create something valuable. But if it's not valuable, then it's not your property, it's worthless.

>Now, you get Android for “free” but only by turning your customers into the product.

Paid services still turn the customers into the product, e.g. Windows. Also Android is not open source.

>get to control the standard by fiat

Commercial dealers have a long track record of anticompetitive practices. It's the whole reason why antimonopoly law was written.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:40AM (#20963086)
fix: Android is cancer because it's a proprietary walled garden. Cancer is enforced through walled garden, and walled garden is enforced through closed source. Old tale holds true: proprietary software harms the customer and Android is a vivid example of it.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by pjc50 on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:48AM (#20959258)
Patents don't give you markets either, they give the base patent holder control over the entire ecosystem.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by CalChris on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:28PM (#20958614)
I like both patents and open source because there's a difference between innovation and infrastructure. If I bust my ass in my garage innovating my stealth widget then I'd like to protect that. But I live in the 21st century and I use LLVM, Linux, ... developing said widget. So I like both. I doubt I could get my widget off the ground without open source infrastructure but I'm incented to move the bar with my widget. This is a good thing.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:48PM (#20958399)
You are allowed to file patents that are novel extensions of an existing patent. You might not be able to use it because of the original patent, but you can absolutely file one.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:55PM (#20958441)
> You might not be able to use it because of the original patent, but you can absolutely file one.

That is precisely my point.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:58PM (#20958459)
Your argument was that it's "impossible" to improve the state of the art due to existing patents. I explained that it's possible. Are we agreeing or have I missed something?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:29PM (#20958620)
My argument was that while you can improve the state of the art, rarely do software patents incentivize you to do so.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:25AM (#20961440)
Why don't they?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by bluecalm on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:08AM (#20959611)
Just because you have spent a whole summer figuring something out doesn't mean you should have long lasting government protected monopoly to use it. The problem with software patents is that it's very likely other people would come up with similar solutions if they spent time on the problem. There is no reason to give the monopoly to the one first around the post. This is especially true for things that took a few months and very little capital to figure out.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by skybrian on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:13PM (#20958186)
Did you mean patent trolls?

At least some multinationals would benefit from software patents going away, since they are often used defensively.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by woliveirajr on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:13PM (#20958522)
In some countries, ideas aren't patentable, just products are.

Software might have some kind of protection, even how you design your DB is protected, but you can't forbid someone to make a similar software that does the same thing.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by mch82 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:15PM (#20958528)
I’d argue software should be patentable, but not copyrightable. Patents last up to 15 years, copyrights last life + 70 years.

Software is engineering, not art. It should be protected like technology, not art.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by bluecalm on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:16AM (#20959653)
I very strongly disagree. If I spend years to develop software and someone copied the code and sells it then I think it will be almost universally perceived as unfair enrichment by others. If I come up with a clever solution to do voice calls and then another person comes up with the same solution in their app then it's tough luck but there aren't many people who would feel it's unfair. After all we both based our work on existing knowledge and our ingenuity unlike in the previous case where people copying didn't do any work themselves.

There is strong moral argument for copyright, a sentiment most people at least in Western culture agree with: you shouldn't be able to take work of others without doing any yourself.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by cyphar on Friday September 13, 2019 @05:53AM (#20960624)
The problem is that patenting a kind of screw is not the same as patenting an algorithm or field of computer science. Software uses many more kinds algorithms than any physical product uses screws. It's impossible to avoid minefields for any reasonably large project.

Let's not forget that for quite a few years, asymmetric cryptography was patented and you couldn't implement any kind of cryptosystem that used it. God knows what the state of cryptography would be today if we didn't have our equivalent of a "dark age" thanks to fears over patent litigation.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by CalChris on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:13PM (#20957824)
Ask Larry Page if he is fervently opposed to software patents.

https://patents.google.com/patent/US6285999B1/en

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by dboreham on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:25PM (#20958910)
Patents are behind a kind of shell game played with the investor class: investors like to think they own "assets". So entrepreneurs have over time decided to play a game where patents are treated as assets. They tell the investors that they own these nice valuable assets called patents. Both sides probably know the whole thing is BS, but they play along.

In this context, _nobody_ is going to stand up and call BS on the game. Certainly not Larry.

Senior engineers in BigTechCo get paid bonuses for patent filings so they're unlikely to speak up for fear of those bonuses.

I feel a bit nervous posting this to be honest, but hey..

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by opportune on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:37PM (#20957968)
>multinationals

Also the nature of patents incentivizes you to claim patents even if you fundamentally disagree with the patent system, if you want to continue doing business. Otherwise a troll or competitor could try to shut you down

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by NeedMoreTea on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:06PM (#20958147)
It's years since it was his work.

Now it's protecting the turf of the large corporate, from any whiff of competition by fair means and foul.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by CalChris on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:53PM (#20958428)
About 20 years. In fact it expired on June 2 and you’re free to use it. You are free to use the work that he was incented to do. His work is now our work.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by SeanAppleby on Friday September 13, 2019 @09:46AM (#20962078)
Google only uses their patents defensively when sued for patent infringment. A world without patents would result in the same result for them but with less overhead.

In this landscape where it's almost impossible to build products without stepping on patents, the only way to defend a large company against being bled to the bone by patent lawsuits is to have a deep warchest of patents to file countersuits, basically just MAD for software.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by cameronbrown on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:22PM (#20958238)
The alternative is being defenceless when a patent troll comes around. Hate the game not the players.

I'd be 100% for ending software patents. We already ban patents on mathematics.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by mcny on Friday September 13, 2019 @05:38AM (#20960561)
Why not ban all patents altogether?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by cameronbrown on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:59AM (#20963271)
Because that's a silly idea?

Because people will horde their inventions to themselves and reduce the rate of progression of civilisation?

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by mcny on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:30PM (#20964287)
> Because people will horde their inventions to themselves and reduce the rate of progression of civilisation?

I bet someone else who isn't silly like that will rediscover likely within twenty years of the hypothetical hoarder.

Also, you can hoard it under the current regime anyway:

> WD-40's formula is a trade secret, and has not changed over the years, according to historian Iris Engstrand. To avoid disclosing its composition, the product was not patented in 1953, and the window of opportunity for patenting it has long since closed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WD-40

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by cameronbrown on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:31PM (#20965530)
Within 20 years, sure. But extrapolate that for any invention which has significant commercial value, and you've got a problem. This why patents exist in the first place.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by mcny on Friday September 13, 2019 @09:46PM (#20968377)
> Within 20 years, sure. But extrapolate that for any invention which has significant commercial value, and you've got a problem. This why patents exist in the first place.

I didn't think of that. I don't think the situation is quite so cut and dry though.

Imagine how many patents like one click [1][2] we can avoid if there simply was no patent.

I am not convinced that patents have an overwhelmingly positive effect on society at this point in history. We have to consider that communication (both one to one and one to many) is a lot cheaper today than even two hundred years ago.

I think reasonable people should push for an end to all patents.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click [2] https://patents.google.com/patent/US5960411A/en

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by cameronbrown on Saturday September 14, 2019 @02:47PM (#20972872)
I already said I wanted to get rid of software patents, so we're in agreement with one click.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by ken on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:23PM (#20957882)
What is your basis for this claim? Was there a survey?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:54PM (#20958072)
Just the impression I got from the general developer community, and articles such as https://www.infoworld.com/article/2619609/why-software-paten...
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:05PM (#20958144)
The exposure to the patent system for most developers is seeing egregious examples being used by patent trolls. Then there's the confusion between design patents and utility patents. So yes, I would say most folks find them distasteful, for the same reason that most folks overestimate crime rates.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by dboreham on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:27PM (#20958927)
Most developers I know (at least the senior ones) are named inventors on several patents so I doubt your theory that engineers don't understand the space.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:33AM (#20961491)
Most developers I know are not named inventors on any patents.

It's not so much about understanding the space, it's about the mental availability of examples used to estimate the general state of the world.

People who watch TV news regularly overestimate the crime rate. Why? Because TV media focuses on the dramatic and attention-grabbing -- "if it bleeds, it leads". No effort is made to present a statistically valid sample of reality. Nobody is publishing "little old lady walks home safely for two thousandth time".

Similarly for patents. There are millions. Which ones get press? It's not a perfectly random sample, what we see is the absurd and outrageous examples, ones which deserve criticism and anger. But if you base your estimate of the entire system on examples chosen specifically because they will arouse anger, then you have an inaccurate estimate. Because "patent for neat idea lives quiet life until expiry" or "patent amicably licensed on reasonable terms" or "patent application invalidated by prior art during examination" don't make it to the front page of HN.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by sterileopinions on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:36PM (#20957966)
>Almost everyone whose work would be protected by software patents, is fervently opposed to them.

Please provide some kind of basis to this claim.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by dboreham on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:20PM (#20958889)
>Please provide some kind of basis to this claim.

Well...I think all the basis is likely to be anecdotal unless someone performs a survey.

One data point: I've been doing this stuff for decades and I have never had reason to _read_ a patent filing. That has to indicate something, no? If they were so "inventive" wouldn't we need to read them to find out about new inventions. The only patents I've read were a) ones where I was the named inventor (even then I didn't understand them) and b) where I was employed as an expert by lawyers fighting trolls in litigation.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by kstrauser on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:46PM (#20959018)
This exactly. The point of patents is to encourage people to publish their research, but I've literally never heard of anyone reading through software patents to get ideas. The entire putative reason for their existence is basically mythical.

Furthermore, our company lawyer would probably choke me if he caught me reading patents, as then we'd be subject to much higher damages if we were ever claimed to be infringing something.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by ehvatum on Friday September 13, 2019 @04:27PM (#20966149)
>I've been doing this stuff for decades and I have never had reason to _read_ a patent filing

Knowing of a software patent exposes you to willful infringement, and you'd need a lawyer to understand what the bloody hell most software patents are even claiming to patent.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by kemitchell on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:29PM (#20958938)
I'd venture to guess you've read several "white papers" or even academic papers describing inventions claimed by patents.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:28PM (#20958275)
I'll repeat my other comment: Just the general impression I got from the developer community, and articles such as https://www.infoworld.com/article/2619609/why-software-paten...
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by egdod on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:59PM (#20958103)
> multinationals

What is that supposed to tell me?

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jmpman on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:40PM (#20957985)
I like software patents. Made tens of thousands off of them, and then used those same patents at another company when the first company forced a cross lic agreement. First company ultimately lost millions and didn’t realize why. But, their lawyers probably got a bonus.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by human20190310 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:53PM (#20958069)
I don't understand this story at all.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by dboreham on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:34PM (#20958961)
jmpman developed some tech at BigCo A. Their lawyers filed patents for that tech, naming jmpman as the inventor. jmpman got bonuses from BigCo A for those filings (typically O($10k)/patent). jmpman then moved to BigCo B, continuing to work on same tech. Meanwhile BigCo A demanded that BigCo B enter into a patent cross-license agreement, presumably with the goal to gain free-of-charge licenses to use BigCo B's patent portfolio. BigCo B agreed. Result was that while BigCo A thought they had made a sweet deal, in fact they licensed foc the tech jmpman had previously developed to BigCo B which went on to make $$$ exploiting it. If they hadn't pulled the cross license stunt, BigCo A would have made $$$ in royalties form B's use of jmpman's tech.

But, this is why historically patents were not a big deal: all tech companies (this is before software patents were even allowed, so we're talking hardware patents) all entered into cross licensing agreements and everyone used each other's inventions mostly without royalties paid.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jmpman on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:31PM (#20968757)
Glad someone understands me.... nice summary.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:49PM (#20958041)
> Except patent lawyers and multinationals. That should tell you everything on whether they're a good idea.

I know you're implying "no, it's a bad idea". But doesn't the involvement of the individuals who do patent law as their sole job qualify them to know more about it then "almost everyone"?

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:04PM (#20958142)
If 'it' is patent law, then yes. If 'it' is software development, then no.

Do we want to encourage the development of patent law, or of software?

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:08PM (#20958163)
Patent law is pretty well-developed at this point. And patent lawyers typically have degrees and relevant experience in the field they focus on. So most software patent lawyers know as much about software as you or I do.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by justinclift on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:26PM (#20958260)
> ... most software patent lawyers know as much about software as you or I do.

Please provide evidence.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by wiggles_md on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:35PM (#20958329)
Passing the patent bar requires a baseline of technical knowledge. I don’t know that a patent attorney, agent, or examiner knows “as much about software” as you or GP, but it would be wrong to believe they are ignorant on the subject. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USPTO_registration_examinati...
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:34PM (#20958318)
I've worked with several. Computer science degrees, publications, time working at Microsoft and IBM, etc. All of them were as qualified or more qualified than I am.

As it happens one of them left his law firm and founded a software company.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by Supermancho on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:16AM (#20959386)
> most software patent lawyers know as much about software as you or I do.

> I've worked with several

To be fair, that's not a compelling answer. Given the outrageous cases that are publicized, I can understand how there is an incentive to NOT know (or act as if) in an exploitative manner. According to a razor, it's less likely that the competence is a standard or relevant.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:37AM (#20961516)
What would make it a compelling answer?

I have noted elsewhere that the outrageous examples are publicised because they are outrageous, but that doesn't make them a valid statistical sample of all software patents.

Patent lawyers need to understand the material well enough to draft the claims and perform clearance searches. If they can't do that then they are sailing towards failing their fiduciary duty; a lawyer anxious to hold onto their bar membership would refer you to another one with a speciality in the field.

If I go to a criminal lawyer and ask for tax help, they will refer me to a tax lawyer. If I go to a chemical engineering patent lawyer to talk about a compression algorithm, they will refer me to a patent lawyer who specialises in software and computing.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by viraptor on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:26PM (#20958262)
You can be an expert in anything. Someone being an expert in torture doesn't mean non-experts can't say torture is a bad idea overall.

> who do patent law as their sole job

Then they have all the incentives to keep patents alive.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:39PM (#20958354)
And as a software engineer I have a strong incentive for copyright to exist. That doesn't disqualify me from holding opinions about it.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by viraptor on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:16PM (#20958538)
I think it's a bit different. Your job wouldn't disappear if copyright disappeared. You may need to change your approach in business, but on a technical level, things stay almost the same. We were pretty much in that situation in some European countries in early 90s. (at least from enforcement point of view - lots of pirated software sold at marketplaces in the open) People still created software.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:38AM (#20961520)
If there was a way to bet on this, I would wager the net present value of my income for the next 30 years on it and expect to double my money.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by Despegar on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:58PM (#20958094)
It'd be extremely foolish for any advanced economy to give up on intellectual property, including software patents. Which is why it's not going to happen.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by kstrauser on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:51PM (#20959029)
Everything I've ever read on the subject says that China is far and away the greatest infringer of IP. American companies have almost zero capacity to prosecute infringement claims in China, but Chinese companies operating in America have no particular barrier to suing.

Frankly, I'm amazed that American companies haven't banded together to call for the end of software patents to erase that enormous and expensive trade deficit.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by bakuninsbart on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:48AM (#20960048)
IP infringement is one half of the coin, industrial espionage the other.

Historically, some of the very earliest documented cases of industrial espionage were performed against China by european powers. - The US is not innocent in that regard either, but probably much better at hiding their activity. We needed Edward Snowden to substantiate what people in the industry here in Germany had been suspecting for decades [0]: I've heard of numerous cases where german companies are developing new tech, and shortly before or after release an american company with close ties to the government releases an equal product.

[0] https://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-intellig...

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:59AM (#20961664)
It's unlikely that China will remain so in the long run, as their own R&D output continues to rise.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:03PM (#20958130)
Foolish for the companies currently on top, yes. Not necessarily foolish for consumers, that are harmed by competition being stifled by patents.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:32PM (#20958308)
By itself, knowledge is a public good. It's not excludable (I can't block non-payers from getting it) and it's not rivalrous (your use doesn't reduce its value for someone else).

Public goods are chronically undersupplied in a normal market situation. Providing them imposes a cost on the provider, but because the good is non-excludable you're relying on the goodness of consumers to pay for it. Some will, some won't, but the net amount recovered will be less than it would be otherwise.

So what do we do about the undersupply of public goods? There are a variety of options. Taking knowledge as a particular example, one option is the patent system, which grants a temporary legal monopoly on the claims in the patent. It creates an artificial excludability that allows the provider of the knowledge to recover more of the cost of providing it. Overall that should raise the production of knowledge.

But, you say, that reduces competition. And sometimes it will. But many ideas can be substituted and so the competitors will patent different things. In fact the monopoly of the competitor gives them an incentive to find new ideas that the competitor hasn't found yet, an incentive which was weaker in the original situation.

The alternative is provision through a central supplier, typically: government. But it turns out that the costs of developing knowledge still remain, so how are they paid for? Taxes, essentially. Generally speaking the costs work out to be about the same, but become differently distributed. Instead of knowledge being created by active, incentivised parties who can then get a return from those who value the knowledge most, the incidence of cost falls on everyone.

Someone who doesn't value that knowledge gets ripped off, and someone who values it very highly gets subsidised.

That said: pure research almost always needs to be publicly subsidised because, by very sensible policy, the laws of nature can't be patented. And representatives passing public budgets can give consideration to which public goods ought to be subsidised, beyond the cold light of economics, as a principle of fairness or morality or furthering humankind.

But most knowledge is not pure research. So either we pay for it with taxes, or we pay for it with patents, or we pay for it by getting less common knowledge. Nothing comes for free. Not even ideas.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:48PM (#20958402)
A very nice, very theoretical answer. But how are software patents actually used in practice? As drivers of innovation, or as a way to use not-too-clever-but-essential ideas as a moat to keep out competitors?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:53PM (#20958430)
Absolutely as a moat, that's what makes them valuable. The point is that the moat becomes a public good once the patent expires. The moats would exist without patents, but there would be less total knowledge and less competition for an indefinite period, rather than a fixed one.

That greed is a motivation for obtaining a patent doesn't make them bad, any more than my decision to care about my wages makes me bad. Greed will exist either way, the question is how best to direct it towards maximising the total good.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by theamk on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:42PM (#20959001)
> moat becomes a public good once the patent expires

I have heard this argument a lot of times, but I don't see how it applies to software patents in particular. At one of the previous jobs, I was doing some research, and there were lots of useful inputs: conference/journal papers, technical reports, thesises, and so on. The only exception are software patents -- I have never learned anything from them.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:26AM (#20961447)
Since we're take anecdotes as the standad: I've done research and read patents too. I found clever ideas in all of them.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by theamk on Friday September 13, 2019 @05:03PM (#20966530)
In all of them? I doubt it. I can believe that some software patent somewhere have a clever idea that is not described elsewhere -- but I still have to find such patent.

Let's take for exa/mple first google hit for "software patent", which for me is https://patents.google.com/patent/US6353926B1/en "Software update notification". In my opinion, it is completely useless.

- It has nothing particularly innovative. It describes a specific Windows update mechanism in needless details -- while it is a solid design, most engineers, given the same problem, would come up with similar design. I know I did, and I did not know anything about OSD, CDF or windows update subsystem at all.

- It does not present information clearly. The text is hard to read and needlessly complicated. There are better sources of information about this topic -- I am sure there is a MSDN article and a dozen of blog posts which describe this much better.

- It did not even motivate the inventor! I am almost sure that whatever motivation Microsoft had for promoting Open Software Description standard, it was not to get this patent.

So what good is this patent? As far as I can see, there is no public benefit at all. The only value is for Microsoft, so they can threaten others and stifle competition.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by harshreality on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:37PM (#20958977)
> Public goods are chronically undersupplied in a normal market situation.

We already have strong intellectual property protections, and yet you still claim we have an undersupply of those kinds of public goods?

Is there a lack of software being produced?

Is there a lack of books? Of blogs?

If the right software algorithms or the right books or blog posts aren't being written, isn't it because we've broken culture to discourage sharing? Every good idea that generates the next great algorithm or the next amazing book or blog post is sparked mostly by other people's work. Standing on the shoulders of giants and all that.

What we've done is to discourage free exchange of ideas and writings, without actually preventing it (piracy is still commonplace, just not in polite company).

Western society has fetishized the ownership of practical ideas (inventions), as well as words and pictures and sounds, despite no evidence that it actually helps promote progress.

IP creation is high-risk even with current IP protections. Reward (for labor) is highly variable. Most work ends up not being worth much. So the reluctance of most people to toil to invent something is due to not having the financial security (financial independence or a secure job) to do that. Most people who aren't famous can't live on a book advance, and there's no model for advances on not-yet-patented inventions. IP protection does not remove those barriers.

> In fact the monopoly of the competitor gives them an incentive to find new ideas that the competitor hasn't found yet, an incentive which was weaker in the original situation.

In the software patent world, when that happens, the competitor typically isn't inventing new groundbreaking ideas as a result of being forced to; they're hacking around the patent in very obvious ways, sometimes resorting to sub-par alternatives. Why? to avoid paying a ridiculous patent license fee which the patent holder is using as a moat rather than the original intention of recouping whatever sales they'd lose to their competitor.

Companies like Apple and Amazon, if they don't get to wage cold wars against their competitors for things like 1-click or whichever corner or symbol you use to get your phone to do something, would soldier on and continue selling mobile devices. Not only would it not make any difference to anyone, but it would increase interoperability since companies would be more likely to reuse familiar design patterns.

Here's a pure algorithm-design case study on the horrible effects of patents even by non-trolls: h.265 patents discouraged and slowed down mass adoption and prompted a bunch of major companies to waste a lot of time developing a marginally superior but much less efficient alternative in AV1. And for what? What poor starving coder wouldn't have developed h.265 except for the piles of gold bars they received for their effort? Wait... they did get piles of gold bars, didn't they?

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:49AM (#20961591)
> We already have strong intellectual property protections, and yet you still claim we have an undersupply of those kinds of public goods?

Normal market situation here refers to a competitive market without government intervention. Copyright, trademarks and patents are all government interventions. These greatly improve the attractiveness of creating software and publishing books.

> Every good idea that generates the next great algorithm or the next amazing book or blog post is sparked mostly by other people's work. Standing on the shoulders of giants and all that.

This is what I mean by knowledge being a public good. When it is shared, it becomes more valuable to society as a whole. But if sharing it is a burden with no prospect of profiting, less sharing will occur. Everyone wants to have a fire service, for example, but unless there is some mechanism to ensure everyone chips in, fire services will be undersupplied.

> What we've done is to discourage free exchange of ideas and writings

Patents are public. Trademarks are public. Copyrighted works are submitted to national libraries.

It's harder and more expensive to get unpatented work. I can download any patent from the USPTO free. If I want to read a paper published by the ACM or IEEE then there is a good chance I'll have to pay for it.

> In the software patent world, when that happens, the competitor typically isn't inventing new groundbreaking ideas as a result of being forced to; they're hacking around the patent in very obvious ways, sometimes resorting to sub-par alternatives.

And sometimes they will come up with better alternatives. But without having the patent being public, they wouldn't have anywhere to begin, because the details are completely secret. Patent coverage can last for 20 years, but the concepts and possibilities it can create start from the instant the application is first published. Whereas a company sitting on the idea for 20 years doesn't spark anything. For anyone. At all.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by Beldin on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:34PM (#20958321)
Note that international patent law isn't national patent law. Sure, it's possible to have your patent valid in multiple areas. But e.g. Chinese patent practice isn't quite in line with EU or US patent law.

Secondly: patents are inherently a form of publishing your ip. The "giving away" part is enforced by laws, but the whole concept of patents is to make knowledge publicly available. Typically, "giving away" is only restricted to commercial uses - anyone who duplicates the patented invention for personal use is fine. You may argue that that is foolish for an advanced economy, but that is what most of them do.