News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by theamk on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:42PM (#20959001)
> moat becomes a public good once the patent expires

I have heard this argument a lot of times, but I don't see how it applies to software patents in particular. At one of the previous jobs, I was doing some research, and there were lots of useful inputs: conference/journal papers, technical reports, thesises, and so on. The only exception are software patents -- I have never learned anything from them.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:26AM (#20961447)
Since we're take anecdotes as the standad: I've done research and read patents too. I found clever ideas in all of them.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by theamk on Friday September 13, 2019 @05:03PM (#20966530)
In all of them? I doubt it. I can believe that some software patent somewhere have a clever idea that is not described elsewhere -- but I still have to find such patent.

Let's take for exa/mple first google hit for "software patent", which for me is https://patents.google.com/patent/US6353926B1/en "Software update notification". In my opinion, it is completely useless.

- It has nothing particularly innovative. It describes a specific Windows update mechanism in needless details -- while it is a solid design, most engineers, given the same problem, would come up with similar design. I know I did, and I did not know anything about OSD, CDF or windows update subsystem at all.

- It does not present information clearly. The text is hard to read and needlessly complicated. There are better sources of information about this topic -- I am sure there is a MSDN article and a dozen of blog posts which describe this much better.

- It did not even motivate the inventor! I am almost sure that whatever motivation Microsoft had for promoting Open Software Description standard, it was not to get this patent.

So what good is this patent? As far as I can see, there is no public benefit at all. The only value is for Microsoft, so they can threaten others and stifle competition.