News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:26PM (#20958258)
It depends on the kind of software. Patents protect capital intensive innovation that’s hard to figure out but easy to copy once you figure it out. That doesn’t describe most software. But it describes a lot of things that are software. I spent an entire summer working on network formation algorithms for cognitive radios. Aside from Matlab simulations I didn’t even write any code. My employer applied for a lot of patents on what was basically software (though commercially it’d be embedded on a baseband processor and you could put it in hardware if you wanted). If you’re a company that paid a room full of PHDs tens of millions of dollars over many years to write code, and could throw the code away and it’d still be worthwhile as long as you had the spec, then that’s the sort of thing where patent protection makes sense. Most software developers have no experience with such work however.

Intellectual property is a thing that exists. Somehow Apple’s Ax processors are several times faster than the best Qualcomm can do. That’s intellectual property. Given that, I’m not sure it makes sense to divide up patentability based on whether it’s software or something else.

(At the same time, I’d probably say that nothing bad would happen if we simply banned advertising. Since my paycheck never depended on ads I have to admit I don’t really get why it’s necessary, beyond the abstract intellectual arguments. People’s world views are limited by their direct experience.)

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by wiseleo on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:42AM (#20959233)
That sounds like it should not be pantentable.

At the core of the argument, software engineering is applied math. Math is not patentable. Software patents are workarounds around the fact that math is not patentable. Yes, the work is valuable, but it should not be patentable.

Here are USPTO's guidelines https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s2106.html

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:56AM (#20959553)
All engineering is just “applied math.” It’s the “applied part” that makes it patentable. (You cannot patent an algorithm. You can patent a method of getting getting radios to aggregate into networks. Or a method of wayfinding for a self driving car. Or a method of indexing and ranking web pages.)
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by wiseleo on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:25AM (#20959694)
Why?

The purpose of a patent is to grant a monopoly for an invention that would not be obvious to someone skilled in the art.

These business methods should not enjoy patent protection that prevents someone from independently discovering and implementing same solution. There is a finite number of ways to efficiently implement wayfinding for a self-driving car.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by bakuninsbart on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:28AM (#20959956)
Funny you mention wayfinding algorithms: There had been decades of progress in that regard without a single patent, only the last decade (since big business got in the game), the rules have suddenly changed.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2019 @07:03AM (#20960970)
I’m pretty sure the CMU folks have been parenting their stuff The whole time: https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~tjochem/nhaa/ralph.html
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:55AM (#20961628)
Many universities obtain patents on research outcomes as a matter of policy.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @07:55AM (#20961259)
Hardware engineering works with matter which is not subjective and so it can't be handled by pure imagination as opposed to math and software.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:54AM (#20961620)
You can turn any software into an equivalent piece of hardware, which meets the non-subjective matter test you're proposing.

Similarly, I can convert any hardware into a software model of it, which makes it into pure imagination.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:31AM (#20963006)
You can't convert hardware into software model, the software model is necessarily an imperfect idealization, created deductively even, which thus doesn't necessarily work IRL, because fundamentally it's imagination.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:42PM (#20958370)
I spent a long time writing advanced code as part of a PhD as well. It relied heavily on existing FOSS code and patent-free work, and would never have been possible if I had had to seek permission for each patentable element used.

There is hardly any field where you can improve the state of the art, without stepping on dozens of patents. Of course you can ignore those patents if you don't care about making any money off your work. But if that's the case, you don't need patents in the first place.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by rayiner on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:56PM (#20958449)
YMMV. Unpopular opinion: I don’t really like open source. I like patents and copyrights because they’re property rights you can use as the basis for markets. Markets are good. It’s hard to build markets with open source. Open source has resulted in a world where you can’t make money just selling software, you have to lock people into ecosystems and services to monetize your work. Symbian used to sell you an OS in return for a cash payment. That was it. Now, you get Android for “free” but only by turning your customers into the product. Same thing with web standards. With video coding standards, you just pay some money and you get the necessary patent licenses. But web standards are “free.” In practice that means just two companies (Apple and Google) get to control the standard by fiat. Is this better?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:22PM (#20958571)
> Open source has resulted in a world where you can’t make money just selling software, you have to lock people into ecosystems and services to monetize your work.

Microsoft made a lot of money selling Windows and their Office suite precisely by locking people into their ecosystem.

You say you like markets, yet you don't like others offering goods at a lower price (free software), but you do like government-enforced monopolies on ideas (patents, and even copyright). If we're diving things into 'market' and 'not market', shouldn't you categorize them in the exact opposite way as you did?

> Now, you get Android for “free” but only by turning your customers into the product.

You also get linux for free, or you can pay for Windows and still be made into the product. The only way I can see someone arriving at your position is to selectively pay attention only to cases where free software with anti-consumer features crowded out straight-forward proprietary software, and ignore cases where free software turned out good (compilers, linux, firefox, text editors, libre office, lineageOS, VLC, etc. etc. etc.)

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by mch82 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:20PM (#20958560)
Lots of companies use open source wrong. Treat open source like an industry standard[1] and it is very possible to release products built upon open source.

Every product Apple sells incorporates various standards, including open source. The key is to use open source to reduce the barrier to participating in a market and then add value on top of open source to make a profit.

[1]: https://www.nist.gov/standardsgov/what-we-do/federal-policy-...

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:13AM (#20961360)
>It’s hard to build markets with open source.

Only if you can't create something valuable. But if it's not valuable, then it's not your property, it's worthless.

>Now, you get Android for “free” but only by turning your customers into the product.

Paid services still turn the customers into the product, e.g. Windows. Also Android is not open source.

>get to control the standard by fiat

Commercial dealers have a long track record of anticompetitive practices. It's the whole reason why antimonopoly law was written.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by GoblinSlayer on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:40AM (#20963086)
fix: Android is cancer because it's a proprietary walled garden. Cancer is enforced through walled garden, and walled garden is enforced through closed source. Old tale holds true: proprietary software harms the customer and Android is a vivid example of it.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by pjc50 on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:48AM (#20959258)
Patents don't give you markets either, they give the base patent holder control over the entire ecosystem.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by CalChris on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:28PM (#20958614)
I like both patents and open source because there's a difference between innovation and infrastructure. If I bust my ass in my garage innovating my stealth widget then I'd like to protect that. But I live in the 21st century and I use LLVM, Linux, ... developing said widget. So I like both. I doubt I could get my widget off the ground without open source infrastructure but I'm incented to move the bar with my widget. This is a good thing.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:48PM (#20958399)
You are allowed to file patents that are novel extensions of an existing patent. You might not be able to use it because of the original patent, but you can absolutely file one.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:55PM (#20958441)
> You might not be able to use it because of the original patent, but you can absolutely file one.

That is precisely my point.

Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:58PM (#20958459)
Your argument was that it's "impossible" to improve the state of the art due to existing patents. I explained that it's possible. Are we agreeing or have I missed something?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by deogeo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:29PM (#20958620)
My argument was that while you can improve the state of the art, rarely do software patents incentivize you to do so.
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by jacques_chester on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:25AM (#20961440)
Why don't they?
Re:End Software Patents (2007) by bluecalm on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:08AM (#20959611)
Just because you have spent a whole summer figuring something out doesn't mean you should have long lasting government protected monopoly to use it. The problem with software patents is that it's very likely other people would come up with similar solutions if they spent time on the problem. There is no reason to give the monopoly to the one first around the post. This is especially true for things that took a few months and very little capital to figure out.