News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @04:11PM (#20955910)
I think private prisons could work if:

- Convicts could choose whether to be sent to a public or private prison.

- Private prisons had financial incentives for post-incarceration behavior. Eg: If their prisoner recidivism rate after 3 years was 10% lower than the average public prison, they would get a 20% bonus.

Those changes would create enough competition and align incentives such that we could see some real innovation in the criminal justice system. Sadly, I don't think these sorts of experiments will ever be tried. If someone ever proposes such a system, they'll be branded a supporter of "private prisons".

Re:California bans private prisons by abathur on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:39PM (#20956764)
A caveat, first: I think two of our larger-scale social issues are that incentives are often misaligned with the outcomes we actually want, and that we don't create structural room for innovation.

That said, I think this is still pretty fraught.

Incentives are just rules enforced with a carrot instead of a stick; we're just as likely to come up with bad incentives as we are to develop ineffective regulations and write loophole-ridden or misapplied laws. At sufficient scale, money tends to inspire a troublesome kind of creativity.

If the private prisons have sufficient profit motive and the problems they face prove tractable for data and bespoke or ML solutions, they'll analyze likely convicts as thoroughly as possible and do what they can to skim the most-profitable convicts off the top of the pool and leave public prisons with whatever is left. Maybe they'll just directly pay the prisoner or their family. Maybe they'll have a miserable as-bad-as-regulations-allow experience for uninvited plebians and a special experience to offer prisoners they want.

Will a certain incentive lead them to bribe judges, prosecutors, defense lawyers, or witnesses to get (or avoid) prisoners? Would they do the same to keep a former inmate from being convicted again within 3 years of release?

And then some donation-funded corner of the think-tank ecosystem will endlessly torture the data to "prove" private prisons get better outcomes than public ones and shop boilerplate legislation to restrict public and promote private prisons.

And once the prisoners are within their walls, they'll be sucking up all of the data they can to hone their prediction of whether they'll reoffend when they get out. Will they use it nobly to target support, or to ensure the whoever the algorithms pick as bad apples end up in constant manufactured trouble?

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:29PM (#20957155)
Please notice how far afield you had to go to postulate bad outcomes. For your scenario to play out, the people running private prisons must commit some pretty egregious crimes. Can you imagine the chutzpah of someone who tries to bribe a judge?! That's practically instant, guaranteed jail time. Judges only get bribed when judges ask for bribes.

If you applied this same level of scrutiny to the existing prison system, I'm sure you could come up with far worse outcomes using far less speculation. For example: What's to stop state prison guards from torturing inmates? Answer: Nothing, because they have qualified immunity.[1]

1. https://www.newsweek.com/prison-inmate-qualified-immunity-pr...

Re:California bans private prisons by ebiester on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:43PM (#20957667)
Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:19PM (#20957862)
Yes, sometimes there are corrupt judges. Note that the article doesn't say whether the owners of the detention centers approached the judges or whether the judges approached them. Both sides had to be evil (and know the other side was evil) for the scandal to happen.

If you read more into the cash for kids scandal, you'll see it was the tip of the iceberg. The level of nepotism in Luzerne county was absurd and the state did nothing to fix it. There were judges abusing their positions, using staff for personal errands, showing blatant bias against certain attorneys, fixing cases, etc. By the time the FBI was done, around a half dozen judges in the county were convicted of various offenses.

My takeaway from the whole thing was that judges have too much power and too little oversight. They're the one relic of the royalty/nobility system that we kept after the American revolution.

Re:California bans private prisons by abathur on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:31PM (#20958302)
It's not that far afield (and yes, I'm certain we could; and I would love to), because the mandate is to make money. We can expect that, on average, they will do everything people do to make money.

Some of that will be corrupt.

It's not that I don't think incentives can play a role; I just wanted to emphasize how incentives, profit, and creativity can go awry.

Re:California bans private prisons by scj on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:35PM (#20956721)
With private prisons, lobbying is likely cheaper and more reliable than innovation.

I assume you didn't intend this in a sinister way, but exercise caution when speaking of experimenting with prisoners. Even with good intentions, remember that these people have limited choices, and will probably lack the ability to withdraw consent (assuming it was given in the first place).

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:08PM (#20956984)
Isn't my proposal giving prisoners more choice? Right now they have no choice which prison they are sent to. Are you worried that some private prisons might engage in sleazy marketing, convince convicts to choose them, and then treat them like crap? That can easily be fixed by letting prisoners switch after a certain period of time. Heck, the law could be that anyone in a private prison can at any time choose to serve the rest of their sentence in a state prison. That would ensure a baseline of care.

Also, I think the point about lobbying proves too much. If lobbying is so much cheaper and more reliable than innovation, why don't all companies lobby instead of innovating? Apple has billions of dollars sitting around. Why don't they lobby to make the iPhone the sole phone used by federal employees? Heck, why don't they lobby to get rid of the new import tariffs affecting their products? I don't think companies leave $20 bills on the sidewalk, so lobbying must not be as effective as people like to believe.

I agree that lobbying is bad, but my objection to it is that the government is allowed to pass laws that coerce people in such ways, not that some companies take advantage of that power. Basically: hate the game, not the player.

Re:California bans private prisons by scj on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:43PM (#20957249)
To both of your points of having more choice and lobbying: Market considerations matter.
Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:53PM (#20957339)
Could you elaborate? I don't understand what you're getting at.
Re:California bans private prisons by salawat on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:09PM (#20968692)
Apple can't lobby to make the "Official phone of the United States" simply because there are significant hurdles in place.

Government procurement is a very different beast than most people would be used too. Imagine an organization tasked to deliver the world, but while spending the absolute minimum, and without showing anything that could remotely resemble favoritism in the process.

That's Government. The supplier must be reliable, yet everyone should have an equal footing from which to have a chance to grab a contract.

It has to be cheap, yet must satisfy every requirement necessary to fulfill the procurement's intended purpose.

There must an always also be at least the appearance of propriety in all transactions, or losing bidders have every incentive to challenge the integrity of the decision.

Given the significant hurdles represented by having to jump through all the hoops in winning a Government supply contract, it simply makes more sense to focus mercantile efforts elsewhere where returns can be made with far less risk.

Prisons on the other hand, run into the worst of both worlds. Private prisons don't make money without convicts. So they might lobby for increased mandatory incarceration as a punishment for violation of new laws. You also have operations where prisoners are exploited as slave labor (which is explicitly allowed by the Constitution). Which if you really sit and think about it, makes the threat of increased incarceration as a result of profit-motive for the private prison industry that much more dangerous, as by definition, you are delegating people to a more abusable status in the eyes of the law.

Hard-on-crime stances notwithstanding (I'm not taking sides, just pointing it out), one really needs to take into account on what spending on prisons really says about our society.

Begone yee incarceree! Ye has't offended in the eyes of Man and God, and to the Pit do we consign'st thee til through suffering that debt is repaid!

Vs.

Your offense has brought you here, being due to the threat to civil society your reckless and thoughtless behavior represents. Through the insecurity you suffer through here, it is our hope that you will come to understand the fragility of the civic construct, and come to see the error of your ways.

Vs. Yet still:

Clearly, our society has failed to incorporate/integrate you in a safe or constructive way. Here you must remain for a period until such time as it is deemed necessary to recompensense for the crime you have committed, or until it can be observed beyond a reasonable doubt that you no longer represent a threat to the civil life outside these walls.

A prison by it's nature does not function as anything else than a container or isolator of men and their proclivities. To create a profit making enterprise around that under the guise of "innovation shall make this system better" is foolhardy, seeing as the law, and punishments for breaking it often preclude any way to operate a prison or treat the offender in a "innovative" way.

The price of a man's years is set by the people already, that is. No private prison can innovate on that except by changing or altering the suffering they experience therein contained from the rest of society. Their Wardens' alone reaping the benefit of the custody of society's delinquents.

Furthermore, even the vaunted Market can be severely damaged by the "free labor" potential generated by prison inmates.

I just see far too much potential for negatives and far too few possibilities through which one could wave a magic wand and both dispel the wickedness of the alleged offenders heart (if it actually exists), and also extracting something resembling justice for the victims should it be appropriate.

Re:California bans private prisons by birdyrooster on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:18PM (#20957522)
This is incredibly easy to game. A bad actor would create a prison which focused only on convict selection, and fully ignored the bonus for recidivism and pumped people through. Prison not only needs to be ethical for individuals, but for the rest of society.
Re:California bans private prisons by kortilla on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:08PM (#20957796)
So you invented a loophole and then said it would be trivial to game if they can use that loophole. Prisons aren’t universities, there isn’t an admissions process.
Re:California bans private prisons by birdyrooster on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:10PM (#20963372)
I didn't invent the loophole, the parent comment did and I was pointing it out.
Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:27PM (#20957577)
Why would private prisons be allowed to refuse specific inmates? State prisons can't do that.
Re:California bans private prisons by jackvalentine on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:10PM (#20957808)
They wouldn’t do it overtly but they’d develop some signal to dissuade undesirable inmates from wanting to go there.
Re:California bans private prisons by codedokode on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:19PM (#20957527)
> Private prisons had financial incentives for post-incarceration behavior. Eg: If their prisoner recidivism rate after 3 years was 10% lower than the average public prison, they would get a 20% bonus.

Then the best strategy would be to make sure that the prisoners die as soon as possible.

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:30PM (#20957598)
Are you suggesting that the private prisons would murder convicts soon after they're released? That's uhh... that's just a little bit illegal and people who commit murder tend to get caught and imprisoned for a very long time.

But let's assume that the private prisons could somehow keep getting away with murder. If anyone ever looked at the stats and saw that people released from private prisons had much shorter life expectancy, then convicts would choose state prisons. Then the private prison's revenue dries up and they go out of business.

Re:California bans private prisons by verall on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:35PM (#20957633)
> If anyone ever looked at the stats and saw that people released from private prisons had much shorter life expectancy, then convicts would choose state prisons.

No, they would not, because there is huge information asmyettry here and, and generally convicts have lost access to the sorts of publications with this info.

Re:California bans private prisons by kortilla on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:09PM (#20957803)
Of course they would. Prisons inmates are not isolated from information.
Re:California bans private prisons by jellicle on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:24PM (#20957890)
You're not too familiar with prison, I guess.

By and large, I would expect inmates to choose the closest prison to their family, regardless of quality metrics. What good does it do to know that some prison 2000 miles away has a really good meal program?

Re:California bans private prisons by kortilla on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:26AM (#20959701)
Which state is 2000 miles in size? This article is about state prisons.
Re:California bans private prisons by verall on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:20PM (#20958230)
Yes, they are?

Considering most inmates do not have access to the internet, do you expect the state to publish these stats in good faith? Inmates to trust them? Or do they just subscribe to print editions of The New York Times?

I guess I'm not sure if you're speaking in hypothetical or talking about inmates today. As the article is on California I'm assuming we're both discussing USA.

Re:California bans private prisons by kortilla on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:27AM (#20959704)
Inmates today. They talk and information spreads very quickly into prisons via family members and other visitors.
Re:California bans private prisons by fooker on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:36PM (#20957634)
>Then the private prison's revenue dries up and they go out of business

Eventually. In the meantime ..say.. for about 10 years they make great money.

Re:California bans private prisons by pornel on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:19PM (#20957528)
Incentives for this are all weird. You have literal customer lock-in, so you can promise anything and deliver nothing.

The recidivism metric would probably cause private prisons to try to avoid or eject worst prisoners, so you'd end up with a 2-tier system, where private prisons are hotels for "nice" people, and public prisons are a hell-hole for the rest.

Or maybe some prisons would run training on how not to get caught.

Re:California bans private prisons by squiggleblaz on Friday September 13, 2019 @12:28AM (#20959177)
> The recidivism metric would probably cause private prisons to try to avoid or eject worst prisoners, so you'd end up with a 2-tier system, where private prisons are hotels for "nice" people, and public prisons are a hell-hole for the rest.

Yes, so you'd have to run the metric based on who was initially assigned to the prison. "Oh, John was assigned to your prison, but one look at his record and you decided to expel him? Well, you're still responsible for his recidivism, because you chose to not serve him. Oh, Jack was assigned to state prison, and you tried to encourage him? Well, you're not responsible for his recidivism, because you selected him."

But yeah, I agree in general that the thing about metrics is that they can be gamed.

Re:California bans private prisons by acchow on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:32PM (#20957947)
> You have literal customer lock-in

You could let the prisoners freely switch to public while they're locked up.

The main issue I have with this system is that the "consumers" making the choices (the prisoners) of product aren't paying for the cost. So incentives aren't really aligned.

Re:California bans private prisons by m0zg on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:28PM (#20957579)
>> Private prisons had financial incentives for post-incarceration behavior.

I bet if you just paid the felons the same amount they cost to incarcerate, relocated them away from their peer group, and forbid contact, a lot of them wouldn't re-offend, like, ever. It's down to basically a combination of poverty and peer pressure (as in "just when I thought I got out, they pull me back in") most of the time.

This is sort of how exile worked in Russia before the revolution: nonviolent offenders were sent to Siberia and simply lived there. No hard labor or anything, no incarceration per se, but you couldn't leave, and all your correspondence was subject to review and censorship.

Re:California bans private prisons by e12e on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:12PM (#20958178)
There's a tention between "paid per prisoner day" and "fewer prisoners come back to stay".

You could get a bonus for not getting "return" prisoners - but it'd have to be better than gaining life sentences (though in general, harder to compete in three strike legislations where you'd be incentivesed to allow prisoners to commit crimes in order to trigger three strikes).

Perhaps there's a way to pay for recovery - but if your business depends on there being prisoners, it's hard to see how you could motivate anything but an increase in prisoner population.

Certainly an end to prisoners would mean bankruptcy?

[ed: you might have a goal of lowering crime, and by extention prisoner population. A private prison, paid to house prisoners, would be commercially committed to the opposite; increasing the prison population.]

Re:California bans private prisons by fnord77 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:43PM (#20957250)
then we'd have all sorts of ad campaigns from private prison aimed at at-risk communities and people, promising all sorts of things while still lobbying law enforcement for arrest quotas.
Re:California bans private prisons by goalieca on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:34PM (#20957625)
Why do we need competition for prisons?
Re:California bans private prisons by salty_biscuits on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:36PM (#20957635)
It is a nice idea, but I don't think many private companies are looking that far into the future to figure out where to best get their revenue. They can gamble on something that might not be totally under their control years out into the future, or just try to get more bodies in the prisons now. A ruthless "rational" actor would go for the second option.
Re:California bans private prisons by ClumsyPilot on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:06PM (#20958148)
There is an assumption that private prisons will perform better than public ones, and so far data does not support it. What great innovation came out of private prison system?

You we trying to optimise out the 'inefficient' government, by saddling it with much effort designing incentives and making sure they are not abused. You might as well run prisons yourself - publically.

Re:California bans private prisons by supernintendo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:42PM (#20958368)
No no no. This is exactly the mindset we need to avoid when addressing problems in our justice system. I am sorry but the entrepreneurial / venture capitalist mindset is not suitable here. Private prisons should not exist. Public prisons should be focused on rehabilitation, not retribution. As pro-capitalism as I am, the only future I see in your idea is abject market failure. We’re not talking about product here, we’re talking about human life. The market hasn’t been able to solve health care so what makes you think it’s going to be able to solve mass incarceration?

Further, this hypothetical system is ripe for exploitation. Aside from the potential exploits others have raised, have you considered the parallels to other industries such as defense contractors? Your idea creates an incentive and profit motive for crime. It’s the type of thinking that could literally result in corporations creating artificial mass shooters in pursuit of all the easy money that could be made. Sorry, but I think this is an extremely bad take and I actually worry about a dystopian future where this takes place. Pull on this thread at your own peril.

Re:California bans private prisons by thrwaway3489 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:32PM (#20957945)
Isn't the primary issue anyone has with private prisons the same one we have with defense contractors: that they might, would, or do subvert the system to get innocent people imprisoned or their prison terms extended in the case of private prisons, or promote wars America doesn't want or need in the case of defense contractors?

What I mean is nobody really cares if prisons buy commercial toilet paper, for example. (As opposed to a hypothetical government toilet paper.) Nobody cares if the military uses the private industry for procurement of computers or whatever. We don't feel the government should be creating its own version of all private industry products.

But when the prison itself is private - and likewise when defense contractors themselves are developing, shopping around, and selling new weapons only to the military, that the military didn't ask for - then suddenly there is a new player in the budgeting process.

Ideally few or no people are committing crimes. If the prisons have excess capacity, free beds - good! But if it's a private prison, how can they fill those beds? Well, by working to imprison more people.

This is the incentive structure that people don't like about private prison.

In the United States it's de facto "illegal" to walk around while being black: there is a high chance you will eventually be jailed on non-existent charges. (And accept a plea bargain, for example, rather than risk a really long term.) I'm a white guy. If I had lived the exact, exact same life, done every single action exactly the same (and this is true of other people reading Hacker News) I likely could have been jailed for no reason at all, just for walking around while being black. That's a fact. I probably would accept the plea bargain I'm offered, too, and resolve to work for change later. What am I going to do? Tell the judge and prosecutor (who often is scored based on how often he gets a conviction/plea) that he and the system are racist? How well will that go over? Will it get me my freedom? Or will it get a vindictive term from the judge. I'd rather just sit in prison for a few months and then avoid the cops better next time, I think I would decide. (Rather than risk a 20 year prison sentence, again, totally innocent of anything. A few months' plea - which my counsel would probably advise I take - is nothing compared to that.)

So why are innocent black people jailed? Well, to fill prison beds, apparently. That is one of the reasons that people don't like private prisons.

We don't want anybody to be "selling" prison, so we don't want prison to be a private enterprise. It's quite straightforward and is something most people understand very easily.

Re:California bans private prisons by squiggleblaz on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:05AM (#20959325)
> So why are innocent black people jailed? Well, to fill prison beds, apparently. That is one of the reasons that people don't like private prisons.

Utter nonsense. Black people are jailed for being black in America because American police are racist and American legislators are racist and American media are racist and American prosecutors are racist and American judges are racist. And then, because of this, black people in America have learnt that police, legislators, media, prosecutors and judges are best avoided.

If private prison operators have an incentive to get more people to serve more time, then they're not going to pick black people because they're just smart business people and black people represent an untapped growth market. If they've actually done anything to encourage oversentencing, they only reason they picked black people is because them and everyone around them are racists.

Re:California bans private prisons by thrwaway3489 on Friday September 13, 2019 @06:36AM (#20960813)
fair comment. if you increase quotas for number of arrests then the racist cops will just pick random black people to arrest because they're racist, can make something up, and a racist judge will believe them.
Re:California bans private prisons by the-pigeon on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:20PM (#20957538)
Ah I see you've never implemented an incentive program before.

EVERY SINGLE SYSTEM GETS GAMED. NO MATTER WHAT YOU MEASURE.

Every metric you could possible think of can be manipulated in ways you can't imagine. But give private companies the incentive and someone in them will figure it out.

IMO the only way to run things like prisons is to hire people that strongly care about the public good to run them. Hire people who want to run a good organization that accomplishes the organization's goals. Which for prisons should be rehabilitation and safety.

Re:California bans private prisons by dang on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:26PM (#20958261)
Please don't use uppercase for emphasis.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:52PM (#20957712)
If you look at my comments throughout this thread, you'll see that I am aware of the potential for incentives to have undesirable higher-order effects. Many people in this thread have suggested certain concrete undesirable consequences, and I've replied to them.

In contrast, you are putting forth a fully general counterargument to any incentive structure. But clearly financial incentives work in many cases. It's what sports teams use for their athletes and coaches. It's what businesses use for their leadership teams. When we need the best people possible to perform at their best, we tend to pay them money and pay them more money if they meet certain goals.

> IMO the only way to run things like prisons is to hire people that strongly care about the public good to run them. Hire people who want to run a good organization that accomplishes the organization's goals. Which for prisons should be rehabilitation and safety.

Yes, ideally we'd have every job staffed people who are wise, kind, competent, and hard working. But we don't have nearly enough of such people and we judge traits inaccurately. So instead we have to make do with less effective but more practical methods. Financial incentives are one of those options.

Re:California bans private prisons by wwweston on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:35PM (#20957962)
> a fully general counterargument to any incentive structure.

A general counterargument is worth considering. Any incentive sufficiently powerful to draw forth extra resourcefulness in its legitimate pursuit is quite likely to also draw forth extra resourcefulness in its illegitimate pursuit.

> It's what businesses use for their leadership teams.

This is may help your case considerably less than you think if you look closely. Various forms of the principal-agent problem pop up all the time. Pink and Kohn have also forwarded some research suggesting that extrinsic incentives have diminishing returns or run counterproductive in some cases. And Goodhart's law is a proverb in the business world for a reason.

Aligning incentives is still important, but getting optimal performance is rarely as simple as tying rewards to a goal. Hell, half the time defining optimal performance is a project.

And when the underlying issues involve social safety and significantly curtailing someone's liberties via imprisonment (and the already fine tension between them), it's an especially tricky topic.

Re:California bans private prisons by ShorsHammer on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:52PM (#20958065)
How exactly can a private prison "illegitimately pursue" having a lower recidivism rate?

Simply handwaving it away with incentives being gamed seems to complete ignore that you are suggesting that there will be widespread systemic corruption of the entire nation's judicial system. Perhaps the general counterargument could really take a moment to focus on the details.

Prisoners not being convicted of more crimes down the line seems to be a no-brainer in societal benefit, or does the line of generalised argument presented here think that's not the case with some more handwaving about optimal outcomes?

Re:California bans private prisons by tlb on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:59PM (#20958097)
For instance, they could teach prisoners how not to get caught.

EDIT: what does it mean that I love thinking about ways of gaming systems like this?

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:54AM (#20959547)
> what does it mean that I love thinking about ways of gaming systems like this?

That you might be a good security researcher? From https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/03/the_security_...:

> Uncle Milton Industries has been selling ant farms to children since 1956. Some years ago, I remember opening one up with a friend. There were no actual ants included in the box. Instead, there was a card that you filled in with your address, and the company would mail you some ants. My friend expressed surprise that you could get ants sent to you in the mail.

> I replied: "What's really interesting is that these people will send a tube of live ants to anyone you tell them to."

Re:California bans private prisons by wwweston on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:39PM (#20958353)
> How exactly can a private prison "illegitimately pursue" having a lower recidivism rate?

Picking prisoners would be one obvious way.

Now, you can say "well, we'll just make sure they can't do that." That's fine; the overarching point here is that you can't simply set up an incentive system without thinking about the ways it can be gamed, among other unintended consequences.

Though: do you know that you can make sure prisons can't do that? Is it legal to forbid them a choice? Can you set up a system for distributing prisoners that's resistant to capture or influence? It's a little bit like saying "we'll just make sure our software is secure."

> you are suggesting that there will be widespread systemic corruption of the entire nation's judicial system.

I'm far from the only person suggesting that private prisons corrupt the criminal justice system, but yes, that's part of the argument.

Some people concerned about the issue believe that industry lobbyists work to back criminal code changes requiring more prison sentencing. Others believe in milder phenomena like judges internalizing lower costs of imprisonment and therefore using more of it in sentencing. The former could be described as corruption without being even slightly illegal. The latter might not even be recognized as a form of corruption, but it'd be a systemic issue unless you think imprisonment is underused in the US.

Re:California bans private prisons by tomlockwood on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:52PM (#20958056)
> In contrast, you are putting forth a fully general counterargument to any incentive structure. But clearly financial incentives work in many cases.

Yeah but I think the big question here is - in what cases?

There's a lot of evidence to suggest financial incentives are in some cases, bad.

Take for example, the financial incentives given to people for running a private prison. Bam.

Re:California bans private prisons by civilian on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:48PM (#20958032)
If "gaming" the system means less recidivism, that sounds good to me.

Prison ships to Australia were originally paid per passenger that boarded in Britain. The death rates were horrible, in the double-digit percentages. When the transport ships were instead paid per passenger that _arrived_ the death rates went down phenomenally.

And someone like you might say: "omg these prison ships gamed the system by saving lives!!!" Yes, that's what we want to happen.

Re:California bans private prisons by dannypgh on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:52PM (#20958058)
You can lower recidivism rates by reducing rates that people are released. Or, for that matter, by providing legal assistance to ex-cons who reoffend. Not sure people who want to see real criminal justice reform would be happy about either...

(edit: not sure what the downvote is for, but I want to be clear that I'm not for gaming the rates in this way. I'm merely saying we don't want to incentivize lowering recividism rates at the expense of everything else)

Re:California bans private prisons by okonomiyaki3000 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:29PM (#20958280)
What we want is not just less recidivism but fewer people going to prison in the first place. If you're getting paid for lower recidivism rates, you'll want to increase the rate of people going to prison one time, not zero times. It means you might lobby for the kinds of laws that would make that happen or you might bribe judges to get the kind of inmates you want (which might mean people who are possibly innocent or would really be better off with probation or house arrest).
Re:California bans private prisons by kortilla on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:06PM (#20957783)
Good. We can only hope prisons would try to reduce recidivism in order to make more money. That’s the point.

It’s a fantasy to think you can simple “hire people that care about the public good”. If that were the case the government wouldn’t be filled with incompetent red tape slingers vying for nothing more than a good retirement.

Re:California bans private prisons by Groxx on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:22PM (#20957880)
Sure, but zero incentives don't work either, for obvious reasons. Neither of which implies there aren't better or worse options along the continuum.
Re:California bans private prisons by winstonewert on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:57PM (#20958089)
> EVERY SINGLE SYSTEM GETS GAMED. NO MATTER WHAT YOU MEASURE.

Yep. Thinking that you can just design a good incentive structure and be done with is hopelessly naive.

> IMO the only way to run things like prisons is to hire people that strongly care about the public good to run them. Hire people who want to run a good organization that accomplishes the organization's goals. Which for prisons should be rehabilitation and safety.

Thinking that you can just hire people that care about the public good is just as naive as thinking that you can just devise the right incentive structure.

Re:California bans private prisons by gnarmis on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:24PM (#20956635)
On the second point, I think folks are rightly dubious about the effectiveness of incentives broadly[1]. There's also some hilarious historical examples of incentives backfiring or having unwanted side-effects (like the Cobra Effect [2].)

More broadly, I don't think it's that easy to think that private prisons can even work well as a solution, regardless of whether they should be allowed to exist as a matter of public policy and ethics. Consider one summative look at this issue provided in this evaluation[3] -- it's dubious whether they're even cost effective, one of the strongest pro-private-prison arguments there has been in public debate, and how there's much better alternatives than the kind of perverse incentives bundled with private prisons, like re-evaluating whether parolees should be allowed in public housing, and providing more transition housing so when sentences are complete, inmates aren't forced to spend even more time in prison because they don't have an address to go to.

[1] https://hbr.org/2009/03/when-economic-incentives-backfire [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobra_effect [3] https://publicpolicy.wharton.upenn.edu/live/news/2304-privat...

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:54PM (#20956880)
I'm not sure why but your comment was hidden as dead. I vouched for it because… WTF? It's a totally fine comment. Anyway…

I agree that existing private prisons are wasteful and cruel, but I think that could change if they had different incentives. Right now, convicts can't choose between private or public prison. That lack of choice means that private prisons have no incentive to be better than state run prisons. Private prisons usually charge per head. If no prisoners want to stay at the prison because it's a hellhole, revenue dries up and they go out of business.

I'm familiar with the cobra effect and ways in which adding financial incentives can cause counterproductive outcomes. I'm not particularly worried about that happening with private prisons. Financial incentives backfire in two cases:

1. When they fail to account for higher-order effects. (As happened with the cobra bounty in India.)

2. When they replace social incentives. For example: If a friend asks me to help them move, I'll probably oblige. But if I show up on moving day and I see some paid movers helping, I'll resent that. That's basically what happened with the day care that charged for being late. Previously, parents would show up on time because they felt a social obligation (guilt). When the day care added a late fee, that guilt disappeared because the transaction moved from the social realm to the financial realm.

I think the motivations of wardens and guards in both private and state runs prisons are pretty similar, and I don't think they're motivated by social incentives. For them, it's a job. They want to minimize the amount of stress at work, and that usually means minimizing the amount of violence prisoners do towards one another. Adding some financial incentives isn't going to solve all the problems with prisons, but considering our existing recidivism rates, I seriously doubt it will hurt.

[dead]
Re:California bans private prisons by jamiequint on Thursday September 12, 2019 @04:56PM (#20956359)
Why should we care if someone makes a profit if we get the outcomes that we want? The profit is not what is evil, the poor conditions and poor outcomes are. If incentives are effective at producing good outcomes it would be stupid to not use them.

p.s. It is possible to disagree with someone without being a moralizing asshole, you should try it sometime.

Re:California bans private prisons by celticmusic on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:50PM (#20956848)
because the incentives are bass ackwards. These companies lobby for laws, and there's no way they're lobbying for less prisoners.
Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @04:51PM (#20956318)
If the incentives you proposed were enacted, there would be no private prisons because any company that tried would go bankrupt. (Unless you mean that the state would cover any costs incurred by the private prison, in which case you'd just get prisons run by grifters.)

California's state-run prisons have a recidivism rate of 65% within 3 years. A 2% rate of conviction over 50 years is lower than the population of non-convicts. It's not possible for any organization to accomplish that. Also, the company would have to wait 50 years for payout. Even if that payout is with interest, 50 years is beyond the time horizons of most governments, let alone companies.

Re:California bans private prisons by criddell on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:08PM (#20956474)
> How about a structure where they don't make any profit whatsoever (state only covers costs) unless, say, 50 year recidivism rate is below 2%?

You're creating incentives for the prison operator to make sure prisoners are never released.

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:10PM (#20956497)
It's private prisons, not private judges. The prisoner would be released when they'd served their sentence.
Re:California bans private prisons by jacobush on Thursday September 12, 2019 @05:58PM (#20956906)
If someone was up for parole, you could very easily discover bad behaviour on their part, so they would have serve the full sentence.

How's that? Waddayknow, they committed a new crime while in prison. Guess they have to stay a bit longer now. Sad.

Re:California bans private prisons by chroma on Thursday September 12, 2019 @06:16PM (#20957065)
Crimes committed while in prison count as recidivism.