News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by maehwasu on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:05AM (#20950106)
So "feudalism" = "things I think are bad?"

The gig economy has many, many downsides, but those downsides don't share much at all in common with feudalism, even by analogy.

If we let all words deteriorate to mean simply "good" or "bad" (with gradations of good or badness), we're barely communicating.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by qazpot on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:11AM (#20950132)
> If we let all words deteriorate to mean simply "good" or "bad" (with gradations of good or badness), we're barely communicating.

doubleplusgood and ungood comes to mind.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by BaronSamedi on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:55AM (#20950403)
We could even take an additional step on the path of honest communication and instead of "good" and "bad", say "things I like" and "things I dislike".
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by simias on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:39AM (#20950719)
That's not the same thing. I like ice cream but it's bad for me. I don't like having to pay for it but it's probably good for society that ice cream makers are rewarded for their work, at least if I want to be able to eat more in the future. The world would be a literal paradise if doing thing we like and doing good things were always one and the same thing. I don't see how you can discuss morality and ethics without "good", "bad", "right" or "wrong".

IMO the problem with modern political discussion (especially online) isn't vocabulary, it's lack of nuance and empathy. "Good" and "bad" are not really the problem, but rather when you only classify things are either completely good or completely bad with no middle ground.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by BaronSamedi on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:09AM (#20952330)
You are using the word "bad" equivocally. Bad as in "bad for your health" is one thing (no problem with that), bad as in "eating ice cream is morally bad" is quite another. What would the claim that eating ice is morally bad even mean?

All I'm suggesting is that we take care in our language and be up-front about subjectivity rather than mask it with objective-sounding reifications. This isn't an attack on morality nor its importance, rather it is an acknowledgment of the fact that such judgments are ultimately based on what we as individuals or as a society find acceptable or unacceptable (i.e., like or dislike). It is perfectly possible to have a strong sense of ethics without claiming that one's ethics are somehow objectively or empirically "true".

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by false-mirror on Friday September 13, 2019 @11:36AM (#20963040)
Moral relativism does not negate good/bad/right/wrong to the point that they are equivalent to "like" and "no like". That is a radical reduction, and removes the whole process of moral reasoning people use to live a moral life.

There are plenty of examples where the "right" thing to do is not pleasant, it is not socially acceptable, etc because it is instead congruent with a greater ethical structure. Please check out some moral philosophy before throwing the whole field into a bin.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by mfer on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:19AM (#20950569)
Who decides what's good or bad? Who decides who decides? Where is the depth of knowledge, logic, and reason behind that? When it comes to good and bad we often lack these things and if we did I would wager we are not on the same page.

"things I like" and "things I dislike" are far more honest and genuine.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by simias on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:42AM (#20950745)
How do you think a society could functions without a minimal set of shared values? Stuff like "killing each other is not super nice" and similar? Aren't values about "good" and "bad"?

Unless you're talking from a purely nihilistic viewpoint which might be rational to some extent but not really productive. "Nothing matter, nothing is wrong, nothing is right, stuff just happens". Okay but where do we go from there?

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by mfer on Thursday September 12, 2019 @11:45AM (#20952796)
I agree that a society needs to have some shared values codified in laws. Things like not killing each other are great examples.

But, are shared values the same as good and bad? We generally consider certain forms of lying to be bad but they are not illegal. And, not everyone agrees on those. So they aren't entirely shared. If we go down the rabbit hole of reason and logic on this it's not so simple.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by moate on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:00AM (#20951514)
Values are about personal preference. "Killing each other is not super nice" isn't a value in any real way due to the dilution words you add.

Take the following thoughts:

Killing people is a bad thing. During wars, soldiers kill people. Soldiers are virtuous people.

Do you believe/know that someone could think they believe all 3 of these things? If yes, what are their values?

Everything is situations. It's context. It's why philosophers play with so many variances of the trolley problem. Nothing is clean and easy, everyone is a hypocrite, nothing matters, stuff happens, and trying to rule a group by trying to worry about individual beliefs instead of aggregate beliefs shared among a majority (a slight difference from your statement that I took as "minimal set of shared values" which I assumed you meant applied to literally everyone).

Point is once you get a group above a certain size, there's only ever going to be majority favored ideas, not universally shared.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by false-mirror on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:41AM (#20950741)
Such a chillingly casual disregard for morality and ethics.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by lexapro on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:16AM (#20950162)
While it doesn't fit a strict definition of "feudalism", large parts of the gig economy are very exploitative, which is also a characteristic of feudalism. And feudalism is generally regarded as a bad thing.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by maehwasu on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:28AM (#20950234)
You're inadvertently making precisely my original point: "exploitation" and "bad thing" are incredibly general properties that exist in many systems, and it's not useful or insightful to compare them to feudalism.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by Retric on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:04AM (#20950465)
If someone called a haircut feudalistic because it was bad then that’s dumbing down words to just good or bad.

Calling a type of employment relationship feudalistic because of the amount of power the employer has is at least somewhat descriptive.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by irishcoffee on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:38AM (#20950713)
feu·dal·ism

/ˈfyo͞odlˌizəm/

noun

the dominant social system in medieval Europe, in which the nobility held lands from the Crown in exchange for military service, and vassals were in turn tenants of the nobles, while the peasants (villeins or serfs) were obliged to live on their lord's land and give him homage, labor, and a share of the produce, notionally in exchange for military protection.

Sure isn't even "somewhat descriptive"

edit for formatting

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by Retric on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:00AM (#20950901)
That’s an incomplete definition.

“The classic definition, by François-Louis Ganshof (1944),[3] feudalism describes a set of reciprocal legal and military obligations among the warrior nobility revolving around the three key concepts of lords, vassals and fiefs.[3]“. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism

It included both economic and military relationships, but importantly: The granting of a landholding to a vassal did not relinquish the lord's property rights, but only the use of the lands and their income; the granting lord retained ultimate ownership of the fee and could, technically, recover the lands in case of disloyalty or death. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fief

Thus these relationships where in effect an extreme form of employment even among the nobility. Much like how joining the US Army has more obligations than going to work for Google.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by weberc2 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:45AM (#20950773)
Only in that it’s a “bad” employment relationship.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by simonh on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:27AM (#20950226)
Which is allowing feudalism to degenerate into just meaning 'bad', rather than actually, you know, meaning feudalism.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by aphextim on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:52AM (#20950845)
>While it doesn't fit a strict definition of "feudalism", large parts of the gig economy are very exploitative, which is also a characteristic of feudalism. And feudalism is generally regarded as a bad thing.

While it doesn't fit a strict definition of "communism", large parts of socialism are very exploitative, which is also a characteristic of communism. And communism is generally regarded as a bad thing.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_killings_under_communist_...

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by lugg on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:14AM (#20950149)
No, linked in article:

> Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon claimed that independent contracting amounts to “corporations trying to oppress workers.” He continued with, “When you hear about folks talking about the new economy, the gig economy, and the innovation economy, it’s fucking feudalism, all over again.”

I think if you take a look over the wiki page [1], he's probably talking about the similarity between classes. It's also in context about more than just the gig economy. And it's also in reference to what people are saying, the way they talk about it, and the way they are selling it to other people. Not talking about the gig economy itself as a concept.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feudalism

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by maehwasu on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:30AM (#20950250)
"Corporations oppressing workers", while being a very bad thing that I am very against, has almost nothing to do with feudalism, even by structural analogy.

As an example of something that would be apropos, Industrial Revolution working conditions and employer/employee dynamics would be far better analogies, although obviously imperfect themselves.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by simonh on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:29AM (#20950243)
It's still got nothing to do with actual feudalism, except that it's also 'bad'. Except for those people who like working in the gig economy and for whom it works very well.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by narag on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:59AM (#20950430)
It's still got nothing to do with actual feudalism...

Yes it has. Feudalism was that exactly: all society, from bottom to top was based on individual asymetrical pacts between two parts, the vassal and the lord. This kind of relation existed between peasants and lords and between lesser and greater lords.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by simonh on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:32AM (#20951218)
All employment contracts are asymmetrical. Almost all contracts are asymmetrical. The defining features that make feudalism different from any other master/servant or employer/employee relationship are completely different from the gig economy and the gig economy oppresses people in completely different ways.

For example a gig economy employee can withdraw their labour at any time; can choose how much or how little they work (sometimes within some very wide bounds); can often choose where they work; can change from one employer to another and back again freely; in some cases can choose to only work at certain times and locations that have better compensation.

Yes of course there are disadvantages and maybe those should be regulated, and maybe in some cases the relationship is abusive by employers, but the above doesn't sound anything remotely like feudalism to anyone who has even the most basic knowledge about feudalism.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by narag on Thursday September 12, 2019 @03:04PM (#20955118)
Asymetrical is not an essential part of the definition, but the fact that it consists of individual pacts. That's different from modern labour in that employer-employee relation has certain rights for the employee recognized because it's a one to many, powerful to powerless... considered individually, while with these rights recognized there's collective bargaining and government-mandated clauses.

The feudalism term clearly seems to be introduced because of that, not because something's good or bad or whatever, but because it's atomizing labour relations.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by harimau777 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:08AM (#20950497)
My understanding is that the definition of feudalism is:

- Royalty allows vassals to "own" land in exchange for a portion of the income from the land.

- Royalty has an obligation to protect the vassals while vassals have an obligation to fight for the land owners.

- Similarly, vassals allowed peasants to "own" part of their land and were obligated to protect them in exchange for part of the income from the land.

- Peasants often were not allowed to leave their land (effectively change employers). However, it's not clear to me if this is an inherent feature of feudalism.

In terms of whether any of this is analogous to feudalism:

- I think you could draw a pretty solid analogy in a situation where a corporation provided a major piece of property (e.g. a vehicle) in exchange for continued labor. However, that seems more like something you see in trucking than in the modern gig economy.

- You could maybe argue that situations where a person rents the property they need to do their job (e.g. a car for Uber) is analogous to the way that peasants rented their land. However, a better analogy might be to some of the schemes where, for example, employees are paid in scrip which they also had to use to purchase their tools.

- You could argue that, feudalism is analogous to how working class people in many cities are unlikely to ever make enough to own a house and therefore they only "own" them (via renting) as long as they keep working. However, this seems like it's more about inequality in general than the gig economy specifically.

- The fact that employees often have to keep working for bad employees in order to avoid being labeled a "job hopper", due to a non-compete, or just due to the difficulties of changing jobs has reasonable similarities to peasants being unable to leave their land. However, these are problems that are actually more common in jobs that are outside the gig economy.

- In at least one sense modern employment relationships are worse than feudalism: In feudalism the vassal has an obligation to protect their peasants while a corporation can fire an employee at a moments notice. However, again this isn't restricted to the gig economy.

Overall, I agree with you that feudalism is a poor analogy for the gig economy specifically. However, I think it is a fair analogy for some aspects of modern capitalism as a whole.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by i_am_proteus on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:28AM (#20950637)
One of the reasons that feudalism ended was the evolution of military technology.

When dominant technology was scarce, it-- armor, warhorses, swords, nutrition, training-- was the dominion of feudal lords, which gave them real power over the peasantry.

The crossbow, and then the pike, gunpowder, and advances in organization & discipline such as those coming out of the old Swiss Confederacy and Gustavus Adolphus's Sweden changed everything. The fact that sovereign power relied on sizeable armies of citizenry to wage war was politically enabling for the peasants.

Combined with increased individual agency from economic output due to pre-industrial and industrial advances in tech, and the stage is set for democracy.

Some Swiss still carry their swords, now heirlooms, to the polls. If they did not have swords, they would not have polls.

If technology now removes the economic and military agency of the individual, it will also remove his political agency.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by js8 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @07:56AM (#20950412)
I see analogy between capitalism and feudalism in how some people defend rich founders and owners of private companies.

In feudalism, it was common to ascribe the collective success of a nation (or a smaller, land-owning group of people in a given region) to a single individual, the feudal lord. He had the ultimate (and hereditary) authority over the operations of the group, by virtue of successfully coordinating the defense of the group against external threats.

In modern (19th to 21st century) private companies, there is a similar dynamic. There is founder, who is ascribed unlimited power within the domain of his private company, just by the virtue of coordinating its expansion. (He "deserves it" because he "took the risks".) And this power is hereditary - he can decide to pass the ownership of the company to his own descendants.

Sure, the powers of modern capital owners over lives of people are much smaller than in feudalism. But the arguments used to justify the power of capital owners over the operations (and profit distribution) in the company are in principle the same as those used to defend feudal lordship.

In the political domain, humans eventually wisened up and decided that feudal lords should be replaced with democratic republic, because success of a nation is a collective effort, and so the decision making should also be done collectively.

I think this will eventually happen to founders in capitalism too.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by zaroth on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:13AM (#20950526)
There is a system where it works more like the way you are suggesting -- it's called communism.

The key reason why capitalism isn't "Feudalism 2.0" is because companies compete in a marketplace against each other, and there is freedom of mobility between employees across those companies. So maybe you could say that anti-trust law is a key component to ensure that your analogy is false.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by js8 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:37AM (#20950703)
I think you misunderstood my argument. I am not defending a particular system (and almost certainly not communism). I am pointing out that same arguments used to defend the privileges of capitalists were used to defend feudal privileges.

The feudal lords also competed with each other. The freedom of mobility is not relevant if your only choice is just another feudal lord.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by zaroth on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:58AM (#20950885)
> But the arguments used to justify the power of capital owners over the operations (and profit distribution) in the company are in principle the same as those used to defend feudal lordship.

It's a neat metaphor in a storybook sort of way, which is why it seems like you are making a political point and not a economic argument.

> The freedom of mobility is not relevant if your only choice is just another feudal lord.

There are ~30 million small businesses in the US, anyone can start one, and many people do. Anyone cannot decide to become a feudal lord; it is a position taken through force and violence and maintained at the tip of a spear.

> In the political domain, humans eventually wisened up and decided ... I think this will eventually happen to founders in capitalism too.

I think capitalism was the "wisened up" part after the prior attempts which don't allow an entrepreneur to take a new idea, bring it into the world, and own the result for themselves. Well, aside from the ~50% which goes to taxes.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by js8 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:35AM (#20951922)
"which is why it seems like you are making a political point and not a economic argument"

I am making an argument that the principal justification for power of these individuals is the same. It's neither strictly political nor strictly economic argument.

"There are ~30 million small businesses in the US, anyone can start one, and many people do. Anyone cannot decide to become a feudal lord; it is a position taken through force and violence and maintained at the tip of a spear."

Actually, you can decide to become a lord, it happens in mafias and gangs around the world till today. The lords in feudalism (unless it was inherited) rose from chieftains of tribes gaining more and more influence (often by using of violence) over more and more people.

Just like starting a business, becoming a chieftain and lord is very risky. In fact riskier, because the stakes are higher, but also the rewards.

Also, while there are small businesses in capitalism, yes, the core of it in practice are large businesses. And just like the lords, the owners of the large businesses are those who can either outsmart the other small owners, or just win the game of taking the risk. The issue I am talking about - winner (founder) takes all - is much more questionable in larger companies.

The fact that there is no direct violence in economic competition between companies doesn't invalidate the comparison I am making.

"I think capitalism was the "wisened up" part after the prior attempts which don't allow an entrepreneur to take a new idea, bring it into the world, and own the result for themselves."

I interpret the history the other way around. The capitalism only happened after people wisened up and figured that the republic is better than monarchy, in the political sphere. This restricted the use of violence in competition for power, and allowed the companies (and their owners) to rise in the economic competition.

But the question why should somebody keep unlimited and indefinite control over something (be it company or state) just by virtue of organizing people around creation of that something still stands.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by zaroth on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:57PM (#20954360)
> I am making an argument that the principal justification for power of these individuals is the same.

You're drawing an analogy in the roughest possible terms. "A person can choose to become X", where X is a company or a lord, does not logically imply anything about the two things other than they are both choices. (Everything at some level is arguably a choice, so in fact this says nothing).

Similarly, "Doing thing X is risky" where X is starting a company or starting a gang, is not a logical argument for anything other than two random things are both "risky" (but perhaps in markedly different ways).

> Also, while there are small businesses in capitalism, yes, the core of it in practice are large businesses.

Roughly half of all employment, and the majority of employment gains, comes from small business. Roughly half of GDP comes from small business.

> And just like the lords, the owners of the large businesses are those who can either outsmart the other small owners, or just win the game of taking the risk.

In any competitive environment (be it sports, or selling widgets, or war) there are winners and losers depending on the preparation, skill, and execution of the players. "Football is war" is a metaphor, not a rigorous argument for why the Geneva Convention should apply to football.

> The fact that there is no direct violence in economic competition between companies doesn't invalidate the comparison I am making.

The fact that two things are meaningfully different in almost every sense does though. The only comparisons you've made are only in the most general metaphorical sense.

> The question why should somebody keep unlimited and indefinite control over something (be it company or state) just by virtue of organizing people around creation of that something still stands.

Besides the obvious point that no one has unlimited or indefinite control over anything, the tenants of private property are a well argued philosophical stomping ground. Why anyone should be able to own anything that they pay for... If they ever truly own it, if it is being taxed annually, or merely rented it from the State... If they should be able to keep it, or how much of it their family should be able to keep after they die... Whether a person can fully transfer title in something they create even if they are paid for it...

The fundamental reason that we let people own the things that they create or that they pay for is because that becomes the incentive for people to work hard to create great things, and because it's a way to give meaning to life. The fundamental reason that we don't take everything away from people the moment they die, but merely take just a large share of it, when it's over a certain amount, is roughly similar.

Other countries have tried to do it different ways, and IMO they have all turned out orders of magnitude worse for the wear.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by weberc2 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:50AM (#20950814)
Feudalism is joining the esteemed ranks of now-meaningless words like “violence”, “cancer”, “white supremacy”, and “patriarchy”.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by krapp on Thursday September 12, 2019 @09:11AM (#20951002)
> Feudalism is joining the esteemed ranks of now-meaningless words like “violence”, “cancer”, “white supremacy”, and “patriarchy”.

All of those words have well-established and commonly understood meanings.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by weberc2 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @12:01PM (#20953029)
They do, but that doesn't rebut the fact that they are (recently) commonly used without intelligble meaning.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by krapp on Thursday September 12, 2019 @03:11PM (#20955199)
They are used with intelligible meaning.

You and others may disagree with the political or cultural implications behind the way these words are used, but that disagreement doesn't render that rhetoric invalid, or make them meaningless.

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by weberc2 on Thursday September 12, 2019 @04:27PM (#20956075)
I would love for someone to give meaning to those terms that I might have something concrete to disagree with (or perhaps even agree with--who knows?). The historical, well-known, coherent definitions patently refute their espousers' arguments, and if there was an alternate meaning why can't anyone articulate it coherently? If there are coherent, alternate meanings, they're kept as closely guarded secrets. Why would these people use words, but keep their meanings secret? It seems far more plausible that these people are choosing words with some specific negative emotion attached and applying them to their political opponents, and using the lack of any actual meaning as a sort of plausible deniability.
Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by heymijo on Thursday September 12, 2019 @08:49AM (#20950810)
> Feudalism: the dominant social system in medieval Europe, in which the nobility held lands from the Crown in exchange for military service, and vassals were in turn tenants of the nobles, while the peasants were obliged to live on their lord's land and give him homage, labor, and a share of the produce, notionally in exchange for military protection.

Large power imbalance between the workers and those with means? Check. Not in use since Medieval times and thus an analogy unlikely to be confused? Check

An analogy, by definition, only has to bear partial resemblance to the thing being compared. The power imbalance in feudalism and the gig economy is clear.

So no, feudalism does not mean "things I think are bad".

Re:California bill will drive a national debate over how to ... by mrfredward on Thursday September 12, 2019 @10:25AM (#20951788)
>The power imbalance in feudalism and the gig economy is clear.

I'd say capitalism, communism, socialism, mercantilism, and every economic system in history, when done at scale, usually end up with some people having far more power than others. If a power imbalance is as deep as the comparison goes, school is feudalism, dating with a significant age gap is feudalism, traffic stops are feudalism...everything is feudalism.