That is basically code word for political fiefdoms seizing power.
No cloud-hosted or SaaS company should allow silos or redundancy around communal services.
This is long overdue and Dara is making the right move to clean up.
But to your point.... should the Engineers be reallocated to a bench until properly utilized? Yes. Moves like this can be poisonous to culture long-term.
(edit: sorry, see below too)
If anything, Uber has invested in too much tech for the sake of being tech heavy, which may not be best suited for their business (outside self-driving, which needs heavy tech investment).
Edit: By not that far away I'm talking 5-15 years. I'm not talking next week. Amazon burned cash for at least 20 years.
But remember that there is a lot of value between "no computer on board" and "fully self-driving". Cars already have things like lane assist technology, smarter cruising technology, collision avoidance, software to help maintain distance between the car ahead of you, smarter breaking, better mapping and routing technology.
These are valuable features that can generate revenue even if fully automated self-driving cars never happen, or happen in 100 years. These are also features that can help older drivers with slower reaction times stay behind the wheel and keep driving, thus increasing the number of human drivers.
Alphabet was to more cleanly separate (in branding and organizationally) the core Google business from other ventures, which moved the moonshots out of Google proper. It wasn't to kill moonshots, though it may be accurate to say it was in part about being better at maturing them.
This assumes drivers that correctly allocate the source of maintenance costs among all uses of the vehicle in assessing cost/benefit of driving for Uber.
So, it assumes no new supply of drivers misjudging costs, and no drivers with multiple income streams that fail to recognize the source of maintenance costs and that Uber is losing money.
It's basically a “no one will buy lottery tickets or engage in other less-than-break-even gambling for non-entertainment purposes” argument, except that gambling venues are usually required to publish their net payout stats, while Uber isn't.
That's a pretty optimistic view; many people don't seem to share it.
[Citation needed]
I wasn't referring to Uber's technology specifically, only that self-driving cars are what is required to make Uber as successful as they hope to be.
I doubt that. Uber's place in the market is very much theirs to lose. It's more reasonable to think that this is the market for software engineers in SV/SF starting to correct itself.
Moreover, hiring a long-term employee today versus tomorrow might save money for a place like Google, assuming we expect competition and wages to continue to increase.
It strikes me that if Uber is laying off software engineers, their company outlook must be very, very dire. A layoff is perhaps better strategy than firing the bottom 5%, which would likely preclude the departed from re-joining at a better time. But probably the wrong message to send to a cohort like software engineers-- a layoff is a legal confirmation that the company made a big mistake.