I was immediately terrified. What if my sister had been hurt, dropped her phone, and it was now in the hands of an opportunistic lowlife? But no. That wasn't it at all. It was instead, that the overloaded cell network, instead of just failing to connect my call, instead, misconnected it.
That was a failure mode I had not predicted. In the end, all my people were fine. But I was shaken. And of course, many other people were not fine.
So many people were calling this number that the system would start hanging up on people at random, so you'd just call back over and over hoping that you'd get connected when the phones went live.
Finally, someone on the other end said "Hello?" and I said "Hi, I'd like to book a room for next summer" and he said "Me too" and I said "good luck!" and hung up.
On Strowger electro-mechanical exchanges one of the nice features is that a random piece of the exchange handles each dialed call. This means the human intuitive approach of "Huh, that didn't work, I'll hang up and try again" actually had a pretty good chance of success if the problem is an electrical fault or something rather than you wrote the number down incorrectly.
I did have a morning once where every call I received was for a business in a Welsh village (I live in England) and the callers were as confused as I was that they'd reached a personal mobile phone instead. The problem resolved itself before it made me annoyed rather than confused.
Me, my friend and other friends of his called both companies to report the error multiple times. All we received was scorn and disbelief. We were told, repeatedly, that it simply couldn't happen. But it did, consistently.
It felt really silly when it got to the stage where I'd call my friend, someone else picked up and I'd go "Oh, hi, it's me again". One day, it just stopped happening.
This was circa 2006
Sadly I couldn't enjoy it, as I was running late for work and mistimed my jump onto a bus, breaking my ankle ...
What precipitated the mis-routing is an interesting question. Perhaps multiple devices switching in/out of a particular cell or node faster than the routing system could accommodate?
I can't remember exact details, because it's not my area of expertise, but I vaguely remember my father (who's a telecommunications network engineer) talking about it years ago.
I know you’re not a network engineer, but it just doesn’t look right.
There is an interesting tension between 'assimilating' information (taking in information that easily fits into your schema) and the need for 'accommodation' (acquiring new information that requires completely re-arranging your schema).
There is a high cost to assimilation, which explains why people will often dig in when faced with facts that require accommodation.
Different disciplines tend to have different words for similar things.
Schemas, worldviews, frames, models, maps. All largely refer to the same thing.
And 'schemas' aren't just theoretical concepts, they have been validated with reaction time studies that strongly suggest they are a real organizing principle in the brain.
I.e.: It takes longer to react to a task that requires accommodation than to react when a task requires only assimilation.
I like this characterization somewhat, though I think there needs to be a [perceived danger] variable not accounted for.
Perhaps:
An emergency is a circumstance in which realities are perceived as existentially dangerous and aren't predictable based on previous experience or world-models
Especially acute is the widespread confusion part. That fits well with my personal (more than I'd like) experiences with true existential emergencies.
Burning Man is managed as an ongoing emergency, and has a 24/7 multi-disciplinary team responding to and triaging incidents as they arise.
Essentially Burning Man is a disaster that's been intentionally paused just before a tragedy. It's kept at that point by some very coordinated and talented people.
Jokes aside, I like this characterization. Makes me think of other cases where a system is designed to be unstable and is then being carefully balanced at the edge of failure; see e.g. modern fighter jets.
I've been collecting / compiling / commenting on similar veins for a while.
There's Robert Ewashuck's paging philosophy (Google SRE):
Pages [alerts] should be urgent, important, actionable, and real. They should represent either ongoing or imminent problems with your service. Err on the side of removing noisy alerts – over-monitoring is a harder problem to solve than under-monitoring....
(The list continues.)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/199PqyG3UsyXlwieHaqbGiWVa...
I've come up with a hierarchy of failures (or alternatively: success kill chain) in problem resolution, starting with "being aware there's a problem":
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2fsr0g/hierarc...
There's the Japanese awareness and response following the bombing of Hiroshima. Short version: the first indication of the 9:15 am attack was a cessation of all communications. Military command wasn't aware of the scope of damage until an overflight was arranged, in early afternoon, and didn't know the actual cause until told by the US the next day.
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1wf9yc/on_disa...
The missile strike on the HMS Sheffield during the Falklands War played out similarly:
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2ab25z/on_disa...
In many large-scale natural disasters, an ominous sign is no reports, especially from outlying areas.
Initial responses to disasters often follow early stages of the Kubler-Ross stages of grief model: obliviousness, denial, sometimes anger. My sense is that grief is another form of major world-model collapse: that some reality that has been internalised and is often a sense of identity is shown to be wrong or inoperative.
Again: it's not that catastrophes and disasters are similar to grief, it's that grief responses are a response to catastrophes and disasters.
And finally, a quote from a ... modern Cupertino ... mystic, Adyashanti:
Make no mistake about it -- enlightenment is a destructive process. It has nothing to do with becoming better or becoming happier. Enlightenment is the crumbling away of untruth. It's seeing through the facade of pretense. It's the complete eradication of everything we imagined to be true.
Source: https://books.google.com/books?id=IZ5LECwss0AC&pg=PT126&dq="...
There's a lot of meat in that, I think.
Terrifying thought in todays terms, imagine we simply stopped receiving news out of Hong Kong and spreading out from there. People on WhatsApp/Instagram there would stop responding. News agencies would wait for their updates and receive none...
Now I want to read that book.
HAMs are typically well prepared for being back in the air first thing and are a very useful source of information from regions that have just suffered a disaster of some sorts.
If an emergency is a circumstance in which ongoing realities are emergent and aren't predictable based on previous experience or world-models, this is a phenomenal example of those dynamics.
Commander Anthony Barnes: That first hour was mass confusion because there was so much erroneous information. It was hard to tell what was fact and what wasn’t. We couldn’t confirm much of this stuff, so we had to take it on face value until proven otherwise.
I've long maintained that the first signs of a disaster tend to be:
- Information doesn't add up.
- Communications are completely severed.
- Old models of understanding don't apply.
- Old filters or sources of information don't apply, and information overload is experienced because it's not clear what to ignore or what to trust.
Our world models give us the means to process and parse information, but also, critically, let us discard extraneous information at little or no cost. When we're placed in unfamiliar or extraordinary circumstances, "foreign territory" as Col. Bob Maar put it, old models do not hold.
Very powerful reading.