News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by whatshisface on Saturday September 07, 2019 @06:30PM (#20907060)
The idea that someone with equal ability to do calculations with both could understand Newtonian mechanics better than they understand quantum mechanics belies an extremely naive view of how easy it is to perceive the true metaphysics of classical mechanics. In fact, the metaphysics of classical mechanics remains unsettled even today, the only reason it seems like there isn't a lot of philosophical debates left to have is that it has fallen out of fashion. A brief conversation with any philosopher will reveal that nobody "understands" the basic essence of being or whatever you want to call it. In fact, if "understand" means "have direct sensation of the true nature of reality," or even "have some grasp of the true metaphysics," then nobody understands anything.

To give a specific example, let's say you have a classical system with only three particles in the entire universe, and further let's say they are interacting via a conservative force. So, how many things are there in the universe? Is each particle communicating with the others to organize their movements? Then, there would be three things in the universe. Is there a potential field permeating all of space, into which the particles project their influence? That would be four things. Is there a "strand of force" connecting each particle to every other particle? Then, there would be six things.

The debates in the paragraph above were alive and well in Newton's time. However they were philosophical debates, not physical debates, because the three suggestions I proposed (along with the other possibilities I didn't mention) are all mathematically equivalent and would lead to the same motion.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by AnimalMuppet on Saturday September 07, 2019 @08:13PM (#20907616)
The thing is, since all those descriptions are mathematically equivalent, nobody cares whether, in a Platonic sense, there are three or four or six things, because it makes no difference.
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by perl4ever on Saturday September 07, 2019 @11:12PM (#20908379)
Isn't the analogy to a similar situation with quantum mechanics, where people seem concerned with different mathematically equivalent interpretations?

You say "nobody cares", but people do care, and if they care in one context, why shouldn't they care in another?

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by AnimalMuppet on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:28PM (#20914483)
Many worlds is an actual difference - one we cannot ever see or prove, but it's different. "New universes are being created" is deeply different from "they are not".

Forces at a distance vs fields? Not so much.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by heavenlyblue on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:44PM (#20914096)
so why do they care about many-worlds interpretation then?
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by MiroF on Saturday September 07, 2019 @09:07PM (#20907860)
> The idea that someone with equal ability to do calculations with both could understand Newtonian mechanics better than they understand quantum mechanics belies an extremely naive view of how easy it is to perceive the true metaphysics of classical mechanics.

This entire comment is arguing against an opinion I believe nobody even stated. But why would we waste time trying to discover the metaphysics of an ultimately incorrect description of physical reality?

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by ncphillips on Saturday September 07, 2019 @09:22PM (#20907933)
Ultimately all descriptions of physical reality are incorrect.
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by analog31 on Saturday September 07, 2019 @09:44PM (#20908035)
"All models are wrong, but some are useful." -- George Box

If we think our models are right, we will push them until we find out where they are wrong. That's what we do, over and over again. Pushing classical physics to its breaking point spawned quantum mechanics. We know there's a breaking point for present day physics too.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by visarga on Sunday September 08, 2019 @02:10AM (#20908892)
In machine learning we have many more models, all being imperfect. The ease of trying out a new model makes them cheap. Hell, we even do AutoML and search the space of billions of possible models. They are all approximations, we don't 'understand' reality. We can only do useful things with them, but there's a limit to what the models can teach us about the metaphysics of the world.
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by MiroF on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:32AM (#20910150)
No offense, but the word "model" is used very loosely in ML to describe what is essentially a black box function that can be computer on a computer.

Models in Physics involve experimentation, validation, interpretability

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by egdod on Saturday September 07, 2019 @10:50PM (#20908302)
There is a description that’s correct. We may never find it, but it exists.
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by lidHanteyk on Saturday September 07, 2019 @11:34PM (#20908451)
Do you have evidence in favor of the idea that, say, there exists a finitely-axiomatized formal system which describes reality? We've been searching for a while, and evidence so far suggests that it's not going to be that easy. Tarski's Undefinability is a non-trivial barrier.

With mathematics, we can describe hypotheses of reality, but there may be details and nuances to reality which we're simply not able to observe and thus not able to empirically consider.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by egdod on Saturday September 07, 2019 @11:45PM (#20908488)
> finitely axiomatized formal system

I said “description.” You’re adding additional constraints that may or may not be warranted.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by lidHanteyk on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:26AM (#20910127)
I'm merely helping you catch up on the past century of improvements in logic. What would your description consist of, if not a finite listing of axioms? I bet that you'll complain if my description includes a susbystem for arithmetic, in accordance with Gödel's Incompleteness.
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by egdod on Sunday September 08, 2019 @09:40AM (#20910505)
Why would a description of physics necessarily include a formal system or arithmetic?
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by lidHanteyk on Sunday September 08, 2019 @11:44AM (#20911199)
It necessarily includes a formal system. That much has been hammered into the ground already, and you'll discover it for yourself as soon as you attempt to formalize your description.

All existing attempts to describe physics have encountered some sort of incompleteness. Newtonian physics yields ordinary differential equations, which can encode Turing-complete problems. [0][1] Quantum mechanics yields Hamiltonian operators, which can encode Turing-complete problems too. [2][3] Both of these paradigms predate Turing's work; physics was Turing-complete a long time before you came along to look at the problem.

I can empathize with your original point: Surely reality exists! It seems so real! But reality can be real without existing. Ultimately, our models are only hypotheses about reality, and what they have shown us here is that even our models are so complex as to admit problems that are not going to be solved by mere assertion of existence.

[0] https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F11494645_21

[1] https://sapientia.ualg.pt/bitstream/10400.1/1008/1/05-GCB-st...

[2] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16059

[3] https://eprints.ucm.es/38062/1/spectral-gap_supplementary.pd...

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by egdod on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:26PM (#20911490)
> It necessarily includes a formal system. That much has been hammered into the ground already, and you'll discover it for yourself as soon as you attempt to formalize your description.

That’s a bald assertion, not an answer. And one can certainly imagine descriptions of physics that don’t require a formal system.

Here’s one: “every particle remains at rest for all t.” Now, that doesn’t describe our universe very well. But it might be a perfectly good description of a single-electron universe.

There’s no a priori reason to assume that a valid description of physics is axiomatizable in a formal system. Aruguments to the contrary are necessarily based on our own ignorance, not on anything fundamental.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by lidHanteyk on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:47PM (#20914323)
Sorry, but what is a particle?
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by ofibrvev on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:07AM (#20910621)
We've been searching for a while?

Interesting definition of “while”. Even relative to human civilization (which itself is a drop in the bucket) we haven’t been searching all that long.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by aeternum on Saturday September 07, 2019 @07:58PM (#20907532)
Yes, and this isn't specific to physics. You could say the same about any other scientific field, IE:

Biologists don't fully understand the human brain or aging.

Chemists don't fully understand superconductors.

Astrophysicists don't fully understand black holes.

Computer scientists don't fully understand P vs. NP.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by WhoBeI on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:21AM (#20908582)
Ha!, yes, what does it mean to understand something? To fully understand an apple you must fully understand the entire evolution of the universe, where it came from and down the rabbit hole we go :)

Still, chasing understanding is useful as every now and then something jumps out of the rabbit hole and changes things... Trying to understand the revolutions of the celestial spheres, why black bodies don't emit endless amounts of energy or what it would be like to travel at the speed of light.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by visarga on Sunday September 08, 2019 @02:02AM (#20908865)
Physics is a series of models of the world. None of them is perfect. What is understanding the world when all we have is imperfect models of it?
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by platz on Saturday September 07, 2019 @07:44PM (#20907473)
> The idea that someone with equal ability to do calculations with both could understand Newtonian mechanics better than they understand quantum mechanics belies an extremely naive view of how easy it is to perceive the true metaphysics of classical mechanics.

I don't think that was the OP's idea. He doesn't even reference Newtonian mechanics in the article.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by MiroF on Saturday September 07, 2019 @09:07PM (#20907862)
Agreed. Very confused by the comment
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by cygx on Sunday September 08, 2019 @02:45AM (#20908994)
But note that your specific example of a philosophical question regarding the mediation of forces has since been resolved through advancements in physics (General Relativity, where you have to account for the energy-momentum of the fields permeating spacetime).
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by haecceity on Saturday September 07, 2019 @07:22PM (#20907354)
Do people understand causality?
Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by bsder on Saturday September 07, 2019 @09:21PM (#20907928)
Causality is probably okay. Continuity? Not so much.

The fact that we assume that the rules yesterday are the same as the rules today is one of those axioms that we simply have to accept in order to make progress.

Re:Even Physicists Don’t Understand Quantum Mechanics by internet_user on Saturday September 07, 2019 @09:30PM (#20907968)
Not sure why this is being downvoted?