I have been favoring funds over ETFs the last few years because they have a bit more leeway in what they choose to hold and the friction in getting in/out of them should lead to less chance of pricing dislocation that could cause a lot of unnecessary drama and price volatility.
In the end though, I tend to believe that passive investing may continue to grow until it gets to the point that there is so much "dumb" money out there chasing the same companies that active investing can show real returns above passive.
You probably saw that yesterday but yes I am beginning to feel the same.
And I've been telling my economist spouse for over a year that passive investing boom is going to distort things (and they roll my eyes at me, b/c they hate it when I dabble in armchair economics).
That said, I believe much of tech is crazy over valued, but I think we are in a new paradigm since SO MUCH capital has flowed in private markets (NY Times article about "More Money Than We Ever Imagined" really shows this well). But I am far far from being proven right on that.
Question is, where to put money? Factor funds?
[1] - https://www.wsj.com/articles/wave-of-index-money-is-about-to...
What the comment says: "But there's a big pool of index fund money that will be thrown at this company's stock no matter how poor their governance is or how much self-dealing they do... just because it's public."
https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/SNAP/holders/
AFAIK, most "target date" retirement funds use total market passive investing. Maybe instead of "index investing", I should have said "passive investing".
Vanguard must own a significant share in so many companies right now. I'm starting to believe the narrative that the next crisis is passive investing.
Someone with index funds has no choice: has to dump the good and the bad.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposition_effect
Regardless, my point is smart stock pickers will come in and bid up companies that get oversold. No damage done unless you tried to time the market in your IRA and sold at the bottom. People who continue automatic purchases of broad indexes will be happy (at some point!) for the discount.
But they can be rebalancing instead of going to cash as well; Such as moving from SPY (S&P 500) to SPYD (S&P 500 dividend stocks)
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/01/snapchat-excluded-from-sp-50...
WeWork highlights why I am still skeptical of pure index investing. This company seems rotten, and I would not deliberately buy their stock. But there's a big pool of index fund money that will be thrown at this company's stock no matter how poor their governance is or how much self-dealing they do... just because it's public.