Ken Clarke has also been making statements that he would be willing to back Corbyn in a unity government.
We are in very strange political waters right now. But one thing that seems clear is that the Conservative and Unionist Party seems to be in rather deep existential trouble.
https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-britain-eu-soames/churchil...
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2019/09/03/rebel-leader...
https://www.thelondoneconomic.com/politics/ken-clarke-says-h...
The fact that the last referendum was so close should put increasing EU engagement at full stop to the feature creep. A big change should require a super majority vote to proceed, not a series of creeping measures over time.
And you can argue that the facts on the ground have changed, but the powers offering the referendum are the ones changing the facts.
Why should they be disenfranchised for a long time when they have to face the consequences for much of their lifetime, unlikely the very old?
Not to mention that there is no Brexit in heaven or hell, so the votes of the deceased shouldn't haunt people from their graves.
>And you can argue that the facts on the ground have changed, but the powers offering the referendum are the ones changing the facts
You mean like the 350 million pounds a year for NHS lie? Or the complete failure of the Brexiteers to offer a decent solution to the Irish border mess? How are those remainer's fault again?
What about the fact that the courts have found that the Brexit campaign violated campaign laws, and the reason a new referendum won't be forced is that the vote was non-binding?
Sounds like Brexiteers are actually afraid of democracy.
That is an argument you can make for every election.
And that is why we hold new elections every few years, instead of just sticking with the people we picked last time.
There was a vote, we've spent the last 3 years dealing with it and the result (the deal) was roundly rejected. "Ok, what now?" Is not an unreasonable question to ask people.
The EU didn't have anything to do with the calling of referendum.
The voices calling for a 2nd vote are inside the UK.
>the facts on the ground have changed,
The facts haven't changed, they've just been established for the first time - big difference.
As commented above, it's like asking the voting public "Do you want lower taxes, yes or no?" That depends on an awful lot! How much lower? How is the decrease in revenue going to be handled? Will there be cuts? If so to what? Will there be a debt increase? Etc...
Do we want political decisions of this level of importance and complexity to be made through a process of vague referendums? Seems like madness to me.
Which was the problem with the referendum. As in the example comment above it was like asking "Do you want lower taxes?" Well that kind of depends on a lot of stuff. Are the lower taxes coming from budget cuts (if so, from what), debt increase, or what?
What information then was available but the public didn't know?
> Because no one could have possibly known what the terms of Brexit would be, because they would have to be negotiated.
So then it's fair to say that information was not available.
Let's keep people A and B, but also add people C through CZZZZZ. And now we no longer need to frame it as an intractable argument between two people; we can recast it as an opportunity to re-survey all these people's opinion in order to see how everyone's opinion has changed in light of the new information that's been presented.
There has never been an explicit democratic mandate to cede sovereignty to the united states of Europe. The current clusterfuck is a result of that.
Losing an election does not equate to not having a say.
They now know the realities of a no-deal and the implications it will have.
That's a lot more than they knew before the vote.
Nobody wages war or starts a revolution knowing what the outcome will be either. That's the nature of change.
We're fortunate enough to live in a world where we can vote for change instead of kill for it.
You cannot helicopter parent your voting populace. Otherwise votes just don't matter. If you feel that way, don't give people the right to vote in the first place.
Your political system has to provide an environment where the government (as in the will of the people) can safely fail at doing something important.
IMO, regardless of what is correct, a handful of insane politicians in the UK played a stupid game thinking they could avert a minor crisis and instead created a catastrophe. Those responsible should be pilloried and everyone should learn a great lesson from this. That said, I think that if the UK wants to remain intact, it is forced to take it on the chin and follow through with this.
Afterwards, the country can unite and pick up the pieces and fix it. The EU should also realize the opportunity it has here and be lenient.
The problem is that France and Germany can't stand the threat to their Union and will throw their weight around like the bullies they are. The Scandinavians will be convinced as always that they're just better than everyone else and let the UK suffer. The smaller EU countries simultaneously don't give a shit and also await the conclusion of this so they can see which way the wind blows.
I think if it goes up for referendum again, we'll actually see only 60% of the voter turnout of the last one. Could still go either way. In either case, the UK won't survive it. The only way forward is through.
It's better to leave yourself open to having a different/better thought in the future. Incidentally that's my biggest problem with tattoos.
This is a baseless and false claim.
"Nobody wages war or starts a revolution knowing what the outcome will be either"
Even if true, this isn't relevant ... it cherry picks extremely chaotic changes to shore up a completely invalid argument.
"That's the nature of change."
No, it isn't ... well understood, predictable changes are executed all the time.
"We're fortunate enough to live in a world where we can vote for change instead of kill for it."
Not relevant.
Last I checked it's impossible to predict the future. Please educate me otherwise, because we'll make a fortune in the bond markets.
edit - people can disagree with me all they like, however I am not just making this up, so disagreeing with me will not make this go away.
Here is the 'Referendums in the United Kingdom - Constitution Committee', from the UK House of Lords;
'223. We recognise that because of the sovereignty of Parliament, referendums cannot be legally binding in the UK, and are therefore advisory. However, it would be difficult for Parliament to ignore a decisive expression of public opinion.'
https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200910/ldselect/ldco...
I suppose you could try to argue that 52% is 'decisive'.
Is that because someone decided you had to accept any deal the car salesman made?
Perhaps you should have had the option of walking away.
Likewise, 'not being in the EU' means spending millions, possibly billions of pounds on lawyers to renegotiate deals (that we already have). We've already had to borrow lawyers from the EU because we do not have the legal manpower to enact Brexit!
The worst thing about this is that the position the UK will be in, means that it does not have a good standpoint for bargaining.
If the US loses trade deals with the UK, that's not terrible because the US still has trade deals with hundreds of other countries. If the UK loses trade deals with the US, that's catastrophic and puts us in a worse position for every other trade deal after that.
The entire reason why Asia sees Brexit as "an oppotunity"[1][2] is because Britain will be on the back foot for all trade deals, they can negotiate harder and we are in a compromising position.
[1]: https://asiahouse.org/india-sees-brexit-opportunity-indian-h...
[2]: https://www.worldfinance.com/home/asia-finds-post-brexit-opp...
It's almost like, I don't know, a bilateral trade agreement.
The UK is using lawyers from Europe, not from the EU, which is a political body. It's a very important distinction: the UK is withdrawing from a body where unelected people write laws, not making a xenophobic statement, despite people's attempts to frame it that way.
They are elected.
"A Member of the European Parliament (MEP) is a person who has been elected to serve as a popular representative in the European Parliament"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_to_the_European_Parl...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Member_of_the_European_Parliam...
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/at-your-service/en/be-heard/el...
> not making a xenophobic statement, despite people's attempts to frame it that way.
Please explain why you think Joe Cox was murdered. Please explain why you think so many UKIP members are outed racists[0][1][2][3][4] (Notably, even Farage left UKIP because of the extremism). Please explain what you think the British National Front stands for.
0: https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk/2018/01/henry-bolto...
1: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/apr/26/ukip-a...
2: https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/henry-bolton-ukip-racis...
3: https://www.itv.com/news/2018-12-04/former-ukip-leader-nigel...
4: https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/ukip-choking-racism-i...
(List of random bad things)
I'll let you explain how those things are relevant. There will always be racists and crazy people. Mass immigration may create more of them if that's what you wish.
You also write about racism yet link to an article about Islam. Islam isn't a race, you can read more about it using an internet search engine.
I stated their relevance above.
> There will always be racists and crazy people.
Please explain why there has been a noticable increase in 'crazy people' and fascist ideologies in the public eye since the introduction of brexit.
> Mass immigration may create more of them if that's what you wish.
[citation needed]
> You also write about racism yet link to an article about Islam. Islam isn't a race, you can read more about it using an internet search engine.
You obviously haven't done the bare minimum of reading on why Islamaphobia is deeply related to racism and in most forms consititutes racism and systemic bias. There are some good overviews of the relationship between islamaphobia and racism in the following links:
https://newhumanist.org.uk/articles/2512/is-it-racist-to-cri...
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/opendemocracyuk/taking-raci...
http://theconversation.com/why-uks-working-definition-of-isl...
Is it going to be another yes/no vote? If so, why not have a third, fourth, and fifth referendum, until you get the result you want?
Is it going to be a 'Deal/No deal/No', pick one vote? Why are you subdividing the "Yes" option, then? Why not subdivide the "No" option, too?
Is it going to be a two question vote, with 'Yes/No', and 'If Yes wins, Deal' and 'If Yes wins, no Deal'? I'm going to go out on a limb here, and say that you are not going to like the outcome of that one, either.
They might also not, however. Sometimes voters get disappointed, change their ideas, viewpoints, or their personal life simply changes. No matter, the populace as a whole gets a chance to vote in new people and parties next time around. It's exactly this willingness to change one's viewpoint or political orientation which embodies the responsibility voters carry to maintain this democratic process.
Why is this referendum that fundamentally different? A lot of things have changed, a lot of issues have occurred. I also don't see why subdividing the options would be that harmful. Otherwise, following your reasoning, a two-party system would also be the best system in any democratic country (either this person, or that other fellow).
Have they?
The problem with this vision of a continuous process is an obvious one. The people (Parliament) who have both the power to call a referendum and to delay Brexit overwhelmingly support remain. There's nothing stopping them from delaying and holding referendums until they get the answer they want. Virtually none have made any effort to design any kind of a Brexit (other than May, who really came back with the most obvious and possible plan that anyone would have expected her to), which looks like they're planning to fail.
That Parliament is trying every possible way to cancel doing something they didn't want to do in the first place seems utterly unsurprising.
Britain had a bit of a sweetheart deal in the EU, anyway, it's no wonder that they aren't willing to give them an even better deal in some sort of half-exit.
In a democracy, we know that an election will take place every 4 years/5 years/whenever the government fails a vote of confidence. Those are the rules, we vote for people with that expectation. (I also believe that representative democracy is rubbish, but that's neither here nor there.)
In a referendum, you are asked a question. Should Brexit happen, or not. Not 'Should Brexit happen, oh, and if we don't like the outcome, should we have another referendum?'
I supposed that technically, nothing about posing a referendum question precludes another referendum from taking place, before the first referendum is enacted into law. But can you imagine if, when we had an election, if the government didn't like the result, they'd just delay transitioning power to the winners, and would instead host another election? And another one? And another one, until they win?
It's also not clear that in the past three years, a single person living on the British Isles has changed their opinion on the matter of whether or not Brexit should actually happen.
No rules are being changed, and "people" is obviously too broad here.
"In a referendum, you are asked a question. Should Brexit happen, or not. Not 'Should Brexit happen, oh, and if we don't like the outcome, should we have another referendum?'"
Who is "we" here? The folks who want a new referendum are those who regret the outcome of the first one for various reasons, including being lied to.
"if the government didn't like the result, they'd just delay transitioning power to the winners, and would instead host another election? And another one? And another one, until they win?"
It's not "the government" who doesn't like the result. This framing is invalid, and frequently intentionally so.
"It's also not clear that in the past three years, a single person living on the British Isles has changed their opinion on the matter of whether or not Brexit should actually happen."
It is extremely clear that many have. If not, there wouldn't be so much pushback against another referendum.
If my partner and I decide together to buy a car, and then find out later that we can only get financing at 20%, then it is no way disingenuous to have another talk about whether we really need a new car. On the contrary, I would be quite peeved if my partner went ahead and blithely signed a 20% loan for a car without further discussion, and defended that decision by saying, "We already talked about this."