News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by GuB-42 on Monday August 26, 2019 @08:07AM (#20799118)
In France only few people have 3 phases.

But I think the a reason why high power appliances are more common in Europe is simply because the voltage is higher. Double the voltage means you can pass double the power over the same wires.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by magduf on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:25PM (#20801780)
>Double the voltage means you can pass double the power over the same wires.

Wrong. It means you get 1/4 the resistive loss (in the wires) for the same power. So you can pass 4 times the power over the same wires if you want.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by MertsA on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:35PM (#20815135)
>It means you get 1/4 the resistive loss (in the wires) for the same power. So you can pass 4 times the power over the same wires if you want.

Wrong. P = VI and resistive losses are RI^2. For double voltage at the same power then yeah, R(I/2)^2 = 1/4 * RI^2. For double the voltage but 4 times the power then 4P = 2V(x*I) so x=2 and we square that so it's 4 times as much resistive losses. You can double the power if you double the voltage and keep the same resistive losses. The parent comment was right.

>It means you get 1/4 the resistive loss (in the wires) for the same power.

This is correct, but it scales with the square of the current, so you can't just extrapolate it linearly like that.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by stetrain on Monday August 26, 2019 @10:14AM (#20800008)
Most US houses have 240 (by combining two offset phases of 120v) but that is generally only available at special plugs installed for the range/oven and clothes dryer, not throughout the house.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by alerighi on Monday August 26, 2019 @10:36AM (#20800204)
Nowadays with devices with switching mode power a lot of appliances even sold in the US can accept voltages in the range of 100-240V, and typically these power supplies are more efficient if they are run at 240V. Why in new installations in the US homes don't you put 240V outlet everywhere? For me it would make sense to do that, for example if you have to plug in a computer, or TV, or practically everything modern.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by magduf on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#20801880)
Basically it's inertia. How would people handle using all the existing 120V devices with 240V outlets?

Most Americans don't know this, but there already are exiting NEMA 240V outlets in use in the US. There's, of course, the commonly-known "dryer outlet" and "stove outlet" (which are each unique to that application), but there's also some standardized ones for lower currents than those. Sometimes you'll see them in (older) houses that have very large window-unit air conditioners, because 120V isn't sufficient to run an A/C over a certain BTU rating. IIRC, these outlets look similar to regular 120V outlets except one of the prongs is sideways.

You're absolutely right that most electronics these days can run dual-voltage; they do this because it's very easy to do with modern switching power supplies, and lets you engineer and sell one product worldwide instead of making different versions for different markets, and all you have to do is include a different power cord. However, changing the infrastructure is a totally different proposition. Lots of things don't work on 240V: think about toasters, refrigerators, lights, etc. I even have a German-made electric toothbrush which only runs on 120V (presumably, it uses a simple transformer in the charger base, which is inductively coupled to the toothbrush; the charger base is only rated for 120V, since transformers have to be tapped for the appropriate voltage).

Basically, it would be cool if the entire country switched over to 240V outlets everywhere, as it would give us superior toasters, vacuum cleaners, etc., but there'd be huge confusion for a long time, probably some fires, and the benefit generally isn't worth the cost.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by magduf on Monday August 26, 2019 @05:54PM (#20804168)
I'll also add that switching to 240V would give us lower line losses everywhere on the grid (saving energy). Just think of all the power wasted in house wiring multiplied by millions of households. For an illustration, get out your vacuum cleaner, and vacuum your house. Now that it's been running for a while, grab the power cord: it's rather warm, isn't it? The power also went through your wiring in your walls, through your panel, and up to the transformer for your house, at that voltage. (Even worse, since the US has 120V split-phase power, it was probably unbalanced, leading to even greater line losses.) Doubling the voltage to your vacuum cleaner would mean you'd only waste 1/4 as much energy in the form of heat due to wiring losses, assuming the vacuum has the same-sized motor.

Of course, suddenly switching everyone to 240V would also mean millions of vacuum cleaners and toasters going into the landfill, so that wouldn't exactly be environmentally-friendly either.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by toast0 on Monday August 26, 2019 @11:45AM (#20800768)
In the US, 240V is conflated with high amp circuits, and danger.

You would need at least a different plug and socket for this, but there are probably still a good number of appliances that are tied to the service voltage, so you would need to run separate circuits or point of use transformers for those. That's confusing and expensive.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by twic on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:32PM (#20801184)
That's an interesting point about using a different plug and socket. Perhaps this would be a good time to deploy IEC 60083 Type G plugs, which were carefully designed for safety at higher voltages? They already see some use, so there is an existing supply chain for plugs, sockets, adapters, etc.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by MrRadar on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:45PM (#20801333)
If the US did start adding 240v circuits they would almost certainly use NEMA 6-15 or 6-20 plugs for compatibility with (the rare) 240v appliances like air conditioners or hotplates which use those plugs today.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by MrRadar on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:42PM (#20801300)
Appliances which use universal power supplies tend to be low power. The highest-power device with a universal PSU that I can think of that the "average" person would have would be a computer, but even high-end gaming computers tend to top out around 500 Watts when running full-bore. Even large TVs don't usually draw more than 100 Watts at most. The rest of the devices with universal power supplies tend to be things like phone chargers which draw almost no power. None of these devices draw enough energy for the increased efficiency to matter. Devices where it would matter tend to have large motors or heaters that run directly off line voltage.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by jbarberu on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:55PM (#20802114)
To my knowledge gaming computers are normally more in the 500W-1200W range, though granted you rarely max out the 1200W. I used to sit north of 500W with my relatively modest build a few years back ([email protected] and only one GPU).
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by vonmoltke on Monday August 26, 2019 @11:20AM (#20800573)
American 240V outlets are two-phase (two hot plus neutral). A European 240V appliance (which is one hot plus neutral) cannot safely be plugged in to such an outlet.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by bartwe on Monday August 26, 2019 @11:45AM (#20800767)
European plugs aren't aware of any hot/neutral polarity and devices are not built to treat a neutral phase differently from a hot phase. A separate grounding wire is used for safety.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by vonmoltke on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:10PM (#20802236)
I'm assuming most European appliances use double-pole switches?
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by rootusrootus on Monday August 26, 2019 @11:25AM (#20800612)
United States 240V is single phase. 120V is split phase, with the neutral drawn from the middle of the coil.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by vonmoltke on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:59PM (#20802146)
You're right, I was confusing that with true multi-phase power.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by magduf on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:36PM (#20801896)
>American 240V outlets are two-phase (two hot plus neutral).

No, that's single-phase. The "phase" is measured across the hot wires; the wire itself isn't the phase. There's no such thing as "two-phase".

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by vonmoltke on Monday August 26, 2019 @02:04PM (#20802187)
Yeah, I got confused because some people lazily refer to split phase as "two phase". Apparently I need a refresher session with my textbooks. :(
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by MertsA on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:32PM (#20816372)
Actually there is janky 90 degrees out of phase two phase power. Who knows if there's anywhere still using it but it was a thing.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by rootusrootus on Monday August 26, 2019 @11:27AM (#20800624)
It is somewhat common to make some of the wall outlets in the kitchen 240V sockets, but definitely not common to equip all the outlets in the house that way.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by realityking on Monday August 26, 2019 @10:59AM (#20800393)
Because any appliance that isn't build for 240V would break, if not hurt/kill you when powered with twice the voltage it was designed for.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by magduf on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:38PM (#20801923)
Well presumably, they'd change the outlets to 240V-specific outlets. We already have NEMA outlets for 240V single-phase applications, even in residential buildings.

Of course, then you'll have the problem where someone moves into a new house and then they can't use any of their stuff because it doesn't fit into the outlet. Then they'll go to Home Depot and buy an adapter, which just converts the physical outlets (and has a big warning about not using for devices not rated for 240V), and use that with their heater or toaster or vacuum cleaner, and start a fire that burns down an entire apartment complex.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by Gibbon1 on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:57PM (#20801476)
As well the long trend in the US is for devices outside the kitchen to use less power. Whens the last time you overloaded a breaker in a bed room?
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by magduf on Monday August 26, 2019 @01:40PM (#20801941)
I used to do it all the time, just by running my laser printer. I was in an old house that some amateur must have wired, so all the power for the entire second floor, plus both bathrooms, plus all the lights on that floor, were routed through a single GFCI outlet. It would pop every time I ran the laser printer, but only the first time. After I reset the breaker (in the dark, because the lights would go out), I could try printing again and it wouldn't pop that time.
Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by user5994461 on Monday August 26, 2019 @09:32AM (#20799712)
In France, old houses have 3 phases. There are 3 phases going into the house from the street poles, and you can catch them at some plugs in the house depending if and where they were wired to (the only home appliance that can use 3 phases is electric stoves).

This used to be the "standard" setup until somewhere in the 20th century when it changed to single phase. Now there is only one phase going to homes.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by GuB-42 on Monday August 26, 2019 @12:15PM (#20801020)
I remember my grandfather who was a carpenter. He had a 3-phase woodworking machine in his garage. It was in the late 80s. He needed a special installation for it, and possibly a more expensive subscription.

He later changed it for a single phase machine, partly for that reason. And then he moved, and he now has only one phase like everyone else.

Re:North American versus European distribution systems (2011) by masklinn on Monday August 26, 2019 @09:20AM (#20799622)
Yeah. Electric kettles are fine instruments in europe while they're infuriating in the US.

That's not always a pure positive though: as kettles work fine I've never seen a thermo pot in europe.