Also, the upcoming Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) meeting in November could be used by China to unify most of APAC against the U.S. The U.S. TPP was a blocking move to prevent the RCEP, which in it's current form covers half the world's economy (India, China, and others).
Negotiations for RCEP have been slow but with the U.S. now burning trade bridges with it's partners, we're probably going to see something interesting happen in November.
Why exactly should the World Bank and the US/Europe be the only top players in the game again?
Has all the strings attached to that help really made the world a better place?
As far as I'm concerned extreme poverty or simply poverty is enough of a goal to target. Attempting to forcefully push country's local politics and governance forward without solving the basic problems of quality of life and all of the luxuries that allow people to focus on less local problems affecting their lives directly, like what they are going to eat next, freeing people up to focus on government and community. That seems like an essential first step.
Otherwise youre just mining the same small group of influential people already in those countries and expecting different outcomes. Not changing leadership or reducing corruption organically through education and the empowerment an influential middle class brings to politics.
It’s a threat from the US perspective, in the US national interest. Currently, the US is the top dog internationally, both economically and politically. As China increases its influence especially in the Asia and Africa region via economic investment and, potentially, demonstration of military prowess, it necessarily means US influence in said region decreases. This decrease in soft power of US means it is more difficult for the US to push for US-friendly policy in said region/country, which is detrimental to the US national interest.
Previous US governments seemed to have more moral constraints in this regard compared to current one (with great power comes great responsibility and all that). Interesting times we have. I for one root for China despite all its flaws - the world would benefit from counter-balance in power since US is less and less a good moral leader it once used to be.
Plus when we compare outward aggressiveness of these 2 states, US very clearly loses. Fearmongering about China is just empty talk when simple historical facts about unjust invasions of sovereign states are compared. You know, the actually important criteria for common folks out there. Compared to that, the debate whether its better if NSA reads my emails compared to Chinese is a bit pointless.
This is probably going to be controversial, but I personally think the US is relatively restrained in its meddling in other nation’s domestic politics given its power and influence. Every nation has its sphere of influence, and they use it for their national interest as needed. In the case of China, it has been building up its military presence in the South China Sea and establishing military base in contested islands to extend their territory claim. It remains to be seem how China will act when it is at the similar power level as the US.
Not to mention how this is a hyper US centric view of things. EU, Canada, Australia, and various other countries have tried pressuring China and it's a huge global bureaucratic system. The tweets coming out of the executive branch of the US doesn't have much effect on the giant multi national diplomatic machines like the World Bank and UN. People love exaggerating his actual power.
Everyone paying attention has known the west does the human rights and democracy dog and pony show every big political event while the reality of actually changing another countries politics and governance is extremely challenging and almost always comes from within or as a result of their wealth being directly tied to acting morally or in the interest of their western partners.
It rarely happens due to diplomatic pressure or boxing them out of trade deals and giving out loans.
I personally don't see how it helps to say one thing while nothing really changes and looking the other way when cameras are off. Honesty would go farther and these countries aren't dumb, they see through it all too. So what difference does it make?
That said, of course being civil and calculated is more valuable than being brash and blundering through diplomacy, but that doesn't mean they have to all be full of shit just to be "nice". You can still be honest and strong and not come off like an asshole while giving the media a perpetual panic attack, because they take every word literally as if they were all well thought out, completely serious, and have multiple hidden dog whistling layers, when it was just some throw away half joking tweet made at 3am because he likes to pump himself and America up. Most people can tell the difference, plenty pretend not to on purpose, but either way it doesn't help the process and gives fuel to the spin masters.
What developing country getting a loan from China was ever going to change Chinas domestic policy otherwise? If all of the West who does billions in trade can hardly make a dent I doubt its worth reducing trade and capital flow to African, latin America, and South Asian countries as a consequence.
The West could have made a statement back then and uphold human rights, now I fear it is too late and the only way restoring human rights and democracy is either a mass uprising in China (which is unlikely given that many young Chinese are fed propaganda, and so much of it that even Chinese living outside of China defend the Chinese government's actions) or outright war which is next to impossible to win except if China would be nuked to the ground and a full-scale global nuclear war.
The fact that many Western governments themselves are turning towards authoritarianism or outright fascism doesn't help either, and some of them are actually taking quite a bit of inspiration from the Chinese playbook, e.g. in mass video surveillance.
It seems entirely vindictive, without a real end goal, merely because the West (not just America or their current exec branch [1] but the west including Canada, EU, Australia, etc) completely failed to change China's political policy by other diplomatic bullying/force so they are extending it into the global economic system designed to help smaller countries and the extreme poor, attempting to box out China and others participation. Which ultimately has no noticeable affect on China, so there are only losers as a result, the small countries in need of capital and trade.
The West completely messed up the TPP via back room deals and other corporate hand outs which destroyed everyone's trust in its intentions. Which killed off their best counter balance due to their own self destructive anti democratic habits - which again started before Trump and was due to die regardless if Trump won.
1. This isn't just about America nor has the West's policy towards China hardly changed due to words of the US executive branch for 2-3yrs vs reality of the last few decades and the massive multi country beaurcracy that runs the world Bank, UN, and others.
Once Trump is gone people will quickly remember that Obama and whoever comes next faced the same impenetrable wall that sovereignty, economic weight, and significant cultural differences that exist including a well perfected anti western propaganda that they reflexively employ to explain away all the bad things that happen, something dictators from ISIS to Venezuela has utilized as excuse #1 forever, which makes any western good will very difficult to exploit. Not to mention the limits of power that one executive branch has to change policy in other countries (which is a good thing) is significantly overstated.
Even a no strings attached trade reform is a difficult ask for the west. If the US added a bunch of human rights stuff they wouldn't even get in the negotiation room. But apparently people think that will magically change with another US election.
There was a long string of failures attempts to force human rights and democracy on other countries. There's far more bad examples for every good South Korea, Japan, and Taiwan (which are successes that have as much to do with historical trends, local culture, and domestic economic influence than it was pure diplomatic influence towards a western style gov).
I'm quite curious to know possible rationals behind that?
To layman like myself, it make absolute no sense, but on some level it got to have a purpose right? even if it's ulterior motive or personal agenda.
It's based in animosity, which is typically economically detrimental: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_discrimination#Animos...
Wait, what? They recently kidnapped an ex-party member in germany. It was 2017 or so. I can't believe that a country which honors you freedom would do something like this.
There is much more freedom of speech than in China, or compared to other SEA countries (maybe except for Thailand, but that has a military coup every 2 years in average).
There is no censorship of foreign media, internet is basically free. You can say whatever you want and nobody cares, people complain about party and officials on Facebook constantly.
On the other hand, they keep arresting people for public protests (google “formosa protests vietnam”), for crazy numbers of years (10, 20 years for protesting). And there are rumors censorship of internet is coming - they made a new law just this January that will allow them to censor Facebook or Google unless they host data here and give data about citizens to the government. It is a question how will they proceed; the party is similarly opaque to Chinese party.
All in all though, it’s around better than other countries in region on average or China but worse than Europe, US, or even Taiwan
You can complain about Party, but once you start actually organizing protests, they will come knocking. But since the economy is growing so crazy, people are generally happy.
and of course as a white expat you are put on a pedestal here and a bit untouchable. It’s bad but that’s how it is.
Don't judge by the anomalies, judge by the everyday life for regular people.
I watched an HK detainee get tortured in a hospital in horror, then remembered we kill thousands of unarmed people every couple years without any trial (many of whom are innocent) and 50-60% of victims are either mentally or physically disabled in some way. Many of them get tortured in similar ways if they make it to prison.
In a different framing, the US looks pretty horrible in comparison to China. It's just that we have gotten used to our own brand of stink.
No it's not.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/233310/distribution-of-t...
Only 215 black people were killed by police last year.
>https://www.theroot.com/here-s-how-many-people-police-killed...
Phrases like "6th leading cause" contain no information.
Is that 5% or 0.01%?
There is no way of knowing, and depends entirely on how deaths are categorized in some unknown underlying classification system.
Should they get a court hearing? Probably. Is that practical, in some cases, if the person could be apprehended. Otherwise it would just be a pony show with a predetermined outcome, making no difference.
Sometimes, they kill citizens and then effectively say shit happens.
i.e. China sending a drone and blowing up a US citizens car, killing him and his family, somewhere in the middle of US and just saying that they were terrorists and a threat to China's security; but not not providing any evidence as that is classified.
Perhaps it would have been better in the specific case to first revoke the person's citizenship?
Revoking citizenship or at least leaving persons stateless is not allowed under UN-Charta afaik. Even then, would you blatantly kill (or better, murder) people? That's not rule of law, but rule of jungle. And as uncivilized as it gets.
I don't see a way to capture and try such an individual without having more citizens put in harm's way, or killed too. If the individual is in a training camp that is targeted and happens to be killed as well - I personally don't think anything of it. But that is starkly different than assassinating some individual in their apartment or hotel, or whatever. To me, one is warfare, and the other is murder - I do make that distinction.
Perhaps we must agree to disagree.
https://www.globalpropertyguide.com/Asia/Vietnam/economic-fr...
So how does that source characterize Vietnam? "Mostly Unfree", 128 in their ranking of countries. And Hong Kong... "Free", 1 in their rankings... though we'll see how well that holds up over the next few years. So not so close to Hong Kong.
Heritage goes on to say...
"Background
The Socialist Republic of Vietnam remains a Communist dictatorship characterized by repression of dissenting political views and the absence of civil liberties. Economic liberalization began in 1986 with doi moi (renovation) reforms to transition to a more industrial and market-based economy. Vietnam joined the World Trade Organization in 2007 and signed the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership in 2018. Vietnam’s economic growth, based on tourism and manufactured exports, was among the world’s fastest during the decade-long tenure of former Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung. In 2016, Dung was forced out after losing election as General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam. State-managed economic liberalization continues under the leadership of General Secretary Nguyen Phu Trong."
So while they do say that things are getting better... they aren't exactly calling it Hong Kong just yet.
FTA:
The Chinese model of the past 20 years thrived on suppliers being close to each other, making production quicker, less expensive and more efficient. Now, as operations become more fragmented, they are threatening to raise costs, stretch delivery times and expose companies to multiple tax and labor regimes
Except for US consumers.
Cops are very corrupt and most people won’t even report traffic accidents. If you are a foreigner/non-vietnamese, many hospitals won’t even treat you. Abject poverty, aside from a couple of big cities.
Some may like it because with a little money, you can get away with anything.
That said, I think the real story is companies preemptively shifting manufacturing out of SE Asia entirely in order to get ahead of the next wave of offshoring.
(Ironically a reversal of USA support for China during the sino Vietnam war)
And I'm not so sure how many Asian nations would go along with that whole situation. Would be a lot of doubling down there by China... and when / if THEY want to offshore some things, where do they go?
It's also politically preferable for the US to depend on a hundred small countries instead of one big competitor. It may also help cushion the next global recession, as each of these international markets will be less correlated with each other than one company in China is with another company in China.
Chinese companies are very tightly integrated with the government's balance sheets, meaning that you can't diversify within China. If one company goes under that means the subsidies ran out, and that means all the other subsidies are running out, which means the economy is toast.