It always rank so highly for so many terms, with complete nutjob advice.
Someone at Google doesn't like them.
> We also know about Google firing James Damore and their ideological echo chamber.
They are already displaying their own bias based regardless of what they think Goolge's bias is.
Damore was fired because he violated California labor law. But the post continues with lines like:
> Now, I’m not a conspiracy theorist
...
> But it seems like they decided that there’s no way to algorithmically penalize certain sites — so instead they do it manually, behind the scenes, without telling anyone.
Without any evidence of this what-so-ever.
It's one thing to say "Google are not doing a good job of filtering out mis-information/commercialization without penalizing high quality information from smaller sites/institutions" it's another to say that this is a conspiracy from the "echo chamber bias" of their employees to suppress the speech of people who don't agree with them.
From Wikipedia[1] referring to a Guardian article:
> The company fired Damore for violation of the company's code of conduct.
Which is correct?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google%27s_Ideological_Echo_Ch...
I’m actually really frustrated with these changes and would like to start using an alternative. I like startpage but they use google search results so that’s not a viable alternative. Guess I’ll have to check out duck duck go’s Bing powered performance.
They were already doing it with the carousel (google "american inventors") but if they are doing it with what seemingly is the list of organic results this is very, very troubling.
Where did the idea of google neutrality come from? Google would be useless if they didnt blacklist what they perceive to be spam.
From Google. They've stated time and time again that it's a magic algorithm and they don't hand-pick winners and losers. And it's a good thing, too, otherwise you're just inviting corruption. Top spots are literally worth millions, and if there's an small army of people that decide who ranks where, they are an obvious target for bribes.
This doesn't look that hand picked, though, more like somebody didn't check what would happen if they rolled out some algo change and targeted way too broad.
in this case, some better sites resemble spam enough that they were also hit. a basic false positive, collateral damage.
> in this case, some better sites resemble spam enough that they were also hit. a basic false positive, collateral damage.
I believe that as well, though not necessarily because of "spam", but because of the topic. I was just trying to explain how people might think that Google doesn't manually curate their results.
They absolutely know, that if you search Disney, and Disney isnt the first result, they wrote it incorrectly. They also know their product has less value if it returns spam, which is why they fight SEO artists.
They do try to distance themselves from "choosing" the top result for "best construction store" or "best news site" by shouting the world algorithm, to distract the conversation. That doesnt mean they dont carefully craft the algorithm to return a relevant top result.
I found https://medium.com/@mikewacker/googles-manual-interventions-... an interesting read on that topic. It's not just a crafted algorithm, but there are different algorithms and employees choose different algorithms for some queries if they/journalists dislike what the original algorithm considered most relevant.
I'd fully expect to see these interventions fed back into the algorithm so Google can better predict "this search term is likely to be targeted by partisan or otherwise suspiciously motivated actors".
That's all implementation details, at the end of the day site X is on top and site Y is not, and Google decided that.
And as mentioned in the sibling thread, that's the value of Google Search. If you disagree that X should be on top, then find an alternative search engine that has some different ranking algorithm, but there's no such thing as an objective search engine.
Maybe.
There's a chance you're seeing an unintentional side-effect of inclusion-oriented school projects getting hordes of people to Google stuff like "African American inventors".
As evidence, I really doubt this difference is editorial-based:
https://www.google.com/search?q=purple+musicians (shows the carousel)
https://www.google.com/search?q=purple+inventors (no carousel)
LOL, pretty funny results there.
Nice job though, Edison.
How is it news? :thinking:
Some, like Mercola, peddle highly-controversial, near anti-vax content.
But on the other end of the spectrum, Examine.com should be the gold standard. Quality Raters should use it as an example of a site to emmulate. Much higher quality content and informative content than WebMD, IMO.