News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by tptacek on Thursday August 08, 2019 @07:25PM (#20649954)
What Apple is doing here is really smart. An under-appreciated wrinkle is that grey-market sales are valued on continuous access; you get paid over a period of time, and if the bug you sold dies, you stop getting paid. Apple isn't just bidding against the brokers and IC in lump-sum payments, but also encouraging people to submit bugs early, before they're operationally valuable for bad actors.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by ChrisCinelli on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:35PM (#20650611)
Is not Apple's move mostly a PR stunt? Standard people will read "The iPhone is so secure that Apple is willing to pays $1M for somebody that find a security vulnerability."

The reality is that they only pay that much for bugs in the kernel that do not require a user interaction.

Other bugs that use a common action on an app that everybody uses, for example opening the stock mail application, may be enough in order to compromise almost all iPhones. Apple seems to pay "only" $100k for those problems.

I just scanned through the comments and clicked on some links so correct me if what I wrote is not accurate.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by Rotdhizon on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:08PM (#20650766)
I'd imagine this is to combat marketplaces like zerodium and the deep web. Traditionally grey hat hackers don't always go through bug bounty programs because the pay is awful compared to what you can get through less ethical sources. By flexing that much cash at bug hunters, they are potentially now offering even more than what you could get on the mentioned markets. The only reason people go underground to sell exploits is for the money. Take away that variable and suddenly there's no reason to sell exploits to bad actors, just sell them straight to the source at Apple and get a fat paycheck.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by xkcd-sucks on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:33AM (#20651361)
On these marketplaces, how do people demonstrate PoC without giving away the intellectual property? Or is it unproven and completely reputation based
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by shellcoder on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:50AM (#20651881)
Reputation plays a big part in it on both sides. Most buys are not Zerodium and putting themselves out there as buyers. So, there is a certain degree of vouching that happens as someone introduces a buyer to a seller.

So, when either party violates the agreement, it reflects poorly on that person who made the introduction, making it harder for them to make those connections in the future. And, these introductions matters, most sellers don't want to just sell to anyone, there needs to be some trust that who you're selling to will be selling it to friendly governments or whatever. Its not like a craigslist ad where you sell to just anyone who answers.

So that acts as a deterrent on the buyer side. It'll be harder to get new sellers if you have a poor, or no reputation.

On the seller side, you're not going to get too many people willing to vouch for you as you start burning bridges by selling non-working exploits.

And on that, the payment scheme acts as a deterrent, like teh great-grandparent said:

> grey-market sales are valued on continuous access; you get paid over a period of time, and if the bug you sold dies, you stop getting paid.

That is, you might get XX Thousand upfront, and then an agreed upon XXX thousand based on the exploit surviving XX days.

So trying to scam the buyer will net you a small amount of the total at best, but I mean, often times they'll hold payment until its confirmed and contracts are written and signed over these sales too, its not under the table payments or anything for the most part. Legitimate business transactions.

So, I guess to sum it up, reputation and a demonstrated, or atleast vouched for past record. There is a lot of trust on both sides.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by tptacek on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:31AM (#20652319)
What's interesting to me about this --- and I've got no firsthand knowledge of the markets --- is that Apple doesn't have to outbid brokers; a broker could offer 50% more than Apple, but that comes with an X% uncertainty penalty. You can sell to Apple and pocket $1MM, or try to structure a deal for $1.5MM and gamble that the bug will survive. I'm betting that's often not a good deal; the lump sum payment is the better option.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by shellcoder on Friday August 09, 2019 @05:31AM (#20652694)
I completely agree, it i an enticing offer from Apple for the reason you lay out.

Not all brokers are alike though, exploit survival is a gamble, but sensible end-buyers usually don't want to burn the exploits either so will use them sensibly. There are some brokers that don't sell exclusively (despite their claims), they have a reputation for exploits getting burned early.

I have not been involved with any iOS exploits, not really my area of interest, but lets say I was. Would I consider selling it off to Apple, yeah, it would be something to consider. I'd consider the market rates too of course, 1MM vs 1.5MM, sure Apple is enticing, 1MM vs 2MM, maybe not. Not sure where I would actually draw a line, but you are right that Apple doesn't need to compete directly with the market rate, just close enough.

I'm sure there are those that would rather just go for the bigger profits regardless.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by onetimemanytime on Sunday August 11, 2019 @02:12AM (#20666605)
Plus nothing to stop Apple from offering $2Mil if the bug is really bad....er good.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by grugq on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:06AM (#20651942)
Exactly
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by stuartd on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:22PM (#20659009)
I can imagine it being pretty easy.

Hacker: I have a no user-interaction RCE

Apple: ok yeah

Hacker: gimme a phone number

Apple: here you go

Hacker: …

iPhone: I am pwned

Apple: ok lets do the deal

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by jakobegger on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:28AM (#20651781)
I imagine that a remote exploit should be pretty easy to demonstrate without giving away how you did it?
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by shellcoder on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:59AM (#20651923)
Harder than you might think. Who gets to control the server being compromised?

1. The buyer or someone the buyer trusts, then the buyer can log all the network traffic and find the incoming attack traffic and work out the exploit from there.

2. The seller or someone the seller trusts, can backdoor the software to fake it.

3. Someone they both trust, that would require they have some mutual contacts which while possible I wouldn't count on it.

4. A random victim, more possible, but neither party would want to risk prematurely burning the exploit.

And of course there are a ton of exploits that are not remote, all sorts of local privilege escalations, and there are partial exploits that are sold. Like a multistage exploits like say just the exploit to escape a sandbox, or even just an exploit that requires a memory leak could be sold without a memory leak, or just selling the memory leak. Obviously a fully weaponized exploit sells for the most, but there are buyers for stages also.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by jakobegger on Friday August 09, 2019 @06:35AM (#20653007)
> Who gets to control the server being compromised?

I was thinking about phones, not servers.

> then the buyer can log all the network traffic and find the incoming attack traffic and work out the exploit from there.

Is it really that easy? I'm not a security researcher, but I imagine that most exploits aren't just a magic byte sequence you send to the victim -- so I assumed that just a single observation of a successful attack is not enough to understand it easily.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by shellcoder on Friday August 09, 2019 @07:28AM (#20653291)
> I was thinking about phones, not servers.

that doesn't change things too much, it does introduce some potential difficulties with intercepting certain types of traffic/input to the phone. The question just becomes who controls the hardware being compromised.

> but I imagine that most exploits aren't just a magic byte sequence you send to the victim

Its not, and its not like you can just replay those very same bytes, but its not magic, it all has a meaning and a purpose. While its not easy, you can work out plenty from logs. The entire exploit necessarily is there, things will change, but all the instructions[0] that get injected to do later stages necessarily needs to be sent, or the instructions to generate/cause them.

Its not an easy skill, but its not unheard of.

[0] I'm simplifying a bit to avoid getting into various code execution techniques

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by lbatx on Friday August 09, 2019 @10:08AM (#20654432)
>The only reason people go underground to sell exploits is for the money.

Not reputation? Not the thrill of it? Not hatred of Apple? Not plain maliciousness?

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by izzydata on Friday August 09, 2019 @10:22AM (#20654584)
Some amount of money will likely be able to buyout those reasons, but that isn't guaranteed and all of those reasons are still reasons.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by FrozenTuna on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:41PM (#20657649)
I don't know anyone who hates apple that much. This way, you still get the reputation and thrill. The only people left are malicious actors, like state sponsored attacks.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by auiya on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:14PM (#20656336)
> I'd imagine this is to combat marketplaces like Zerodium

Zerodium already pays double what Apple does. Where's the incentive?

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by esmi on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:13PM (#20657427)
There is no question on the legality of accepting money from Apple. Accepting money from Zerodium comes with some risk for some people.

https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/502/is-it-legal-to-s...

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by jazzyjackson on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:13PM (#20650788)
I think it transcends PR stunt if it actually changes the market for vulnerabilities. $1mil for kernel hacks and 100k for app interactions is just being price competitive with the market.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by d35007 on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:55PM (#20656762)
Before this, some people complained that Apple’s bug bounty rewards were too low. Now they’re higher and a different set of people are complaining that they only did it for PR. It seems like a bit of a “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” scenario.

It’s true that Apple pins its rewards to specific outcomes, but I think a lot of bug bounty programs do something like this. For instance, Google’s top bounty for Android ($200k) is only awarded if you can provide an exploit compromises that the trusted execution environment (see https://www.google.com/about/appsecurity/android-rewards/).

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by Mirioron on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:06PM (#20656877)
Does it really matter if it's for PR or not? It seems to me like Apple is hitting two birds with one stone.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by kccqzy on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:02PM (#20651008)
I don't think it's a PR stunt. The typical layperson doesn't know what's a kernel, so the difference between a drive-by kernel exploit and an app exploit couldn't easily be summarized and made understood. Yes a layperson will understand the difference after you give them a five-minute primer of operating system theory, but in this age of social media who still has the attention span to sit through that, if their interest isn't in computer science?

So to me, this isn't a PR stunt. It's a necessary "dumbing down" we see all too often. It's no different from journalists digesting and simplifying the content of an advancement in biology or physics.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by Fnoord on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:44AM (#20652371)
> I don't think it's a PR stunt.

I don't get this it is either A or B reasoning. Why can't it be also a PR stunt? Or also contain PR?

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by erikpukinskis on Saturday August 10, 2019 @11:48AM (#20662694)
PR stunt implies that it was cooked up by PR people as something to be in the media. It’s either that or it’s not.

If a company wants to do something and PR gets involved and makes sure the messaging is good, that’s not a PR “stunt” anymore.

A stunt is a trick.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by ChrisCinelli on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:34PM (#20651136)
It could be explained to people ... But look at the titles that the press is putting out.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by throw0101a on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:20AM (#20653618)
> Is not Apple's move mostly a PR stunt? Standard people will read "The iPhone is so secure that Apple is willing to pays $1M for somebody that find a security vulnerability."

¿Porque no los dos? Security and PR.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by onion2k on Friday August 09, 2019 @01:38AM (#20651604)
When I read the article my first reaction was "Only a million?" Considering the importance of a bug like this to Apple's business and the size of their cash hoard, this sounds like they don't actually care that much.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by stagas on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:06AM (#20651700)
Yeah, right? Considering they were about to buy Greece[0] at some point, one would assume that they would hand more budget for something that potentially saves their own business.

[0]: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/should-appl...

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by d35007 on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:01PM (#20656824)
I know some security companies have higher payouts, but do any manufacturers? As far as I can tell, Google’s highest bounty for an Android exploit is $200k. Apple will pay up to $1.5m if you can hack the kernel in a prerelease version of iOS. Zerodium tops out at $2m.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by cryptonector on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:34PM (#20655901)
It has that effect (good PR) as well, but I think tptacek is correct that this will have an effect on the 0day market. If you find a vuln and build an exploit you get to choose whether to do something risky (criminal liability, others might find the same vuln and take the reward, the bug might not live long enough for you to make more than $1M from the black market, further criminal liability from money laundering you ill-gotten gains, ...) or... take the easy $1M. Which would you do? It's obvious.

Now, by keeping these 0days off the market, Apple also gets to further burnish their reputation. It's a good play no matter how you look at it.

Of course, first Apple needed to be fairly certain that there aren't tens of thousands of vulns left to patch!

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by tptacek on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:00PM (#20650727)
No, this is not a PR stunt.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by r_singh on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:35AM (#20651806)
Did your comment just refer to non hackers as "standard people"?
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by vntok on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:44AM (#20651846)
Well it's true. The Hacker News audience is so specific it is not similar to any specific country's population, let alone world population (ie "people" in the general sense).

That's certainly not to say the HN audience is an elite (it's not) but it is comprised of outliers in the sense of people having abnormal jobs and/or abnormal interests compared to the average population in any city-sized slice taken pretty much anywhere in the real world.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by gesman on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:45PM (#20650944)
Apple is making bid for an underappreciated employees of a companies who sell software that can hack iPhones
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by jnbiche on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:22PM (#20651088)
Yeah, I think this is what they're doing. It's clever.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by dantiberian on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:12PM (#20650786)
Another benefit of this is that researchers are no longer incentivised to hold onto bugs. Currently, you need to find a vulnerability just to get onto the device to do further research. If the researcher reported that bug then they would lose that access. Now they are free to report any bugs they find without jeopardising future research activity.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by ChrisCinelli on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:43PM (#20651171)
I am not sure. Not everybody is driven by money. I know a few people that turned down insane job offers because, as they said, "they are not interested about money." I see the "good guys" saying "I would have report this bug even for free" and the "bad guys" "If I hold on this in the long term, I could be able to keep (or eventually) [put your mad science plan here]"

I guess on average it will reduce those holding on. But it will not eliminate them.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by natch on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:44AM (#20651400)
Yes it may not eliminate them but if they hold on too long, someone else may find the same vulnerability and get the reward first. So holding on carries some risk of loss... not just loss of the money, if they really don’t care about that, but also they risk losing the exploit anyway despite holding on.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by dantiberian on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:19AM (#20652005)
The change here is that it reduces the "good guys" saying "I would have reported this bug even for free, but if I did I would lose my access to continue researching".
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by saagarjha on Thursday August 08, 2019 @07:35PM (#20650030)
> Apple isn't just bidding against the brokers and IC in lump-sum payments, but also encouraging people to submit bugs early, before they're operationally valuable for bad actors.

Are independent discoveries of bugs common?

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by tptacek on Thursday August 08, 2019 @07:43PM (#20650071)
Yes, but also bugs "overlap" in multiple different ways; the most obvious is that a "similar" bug in a different code path will, at a company like Apple, Microsoft, or Google, result in a hunt for the same pattern on other code paths, but also the fix for one bug can kill multiple bugs elsewhere. So even though people do sometimes find exactly the same bug --- I'm fond of pointing out that at Matasano, Vitaly McLain found the nginx equivalent of Heartbleed within 2 hours of someone else reporting it --- that doesn't actually have to happen for someone else's work to kill your bug.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by TheSoftwareGuy on Thursday August 08, 2019 @07:54PM (#20650127)
In addition, real exploits often involve exploiting multiple bugs in order to be really useful
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by throwaway3627 on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:07PM (#20650475)
You're conflating an exploit for a narrow bug target class with a malware package which likely contains one or more exploits and probably a payload. The act of exploiting requires much more than an exploit alone to have the desired effect.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by tedunangst on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:41PM (#20650925)
What's meant is that real exploits require one to get RCE, another to break sandbox, another for privilege escalation.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by tptacek on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:04PM (#20656862)
Also maybe an infoleak to set up the RCE.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by geofft on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:39PM (#20650920)
Yes - if you go by the iOS 12.1.1 security notes, for instance https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT209340 , it appears that CVE-2018-4435 was discovered independently (on the same day, even!) by TrendMicro / ZDI https://www.zerodayinitiative.com/advisories/ZDI-18-1365/ and Google Project Zero https://crbug.com/project-zero/1671 , whose reports don't mention each other. CVE-2018-4438 is also credited separately to both Qihoo and Project Zero, and the P0 report https://crbug.com/project-zero/1649 again doesn't mention Qihoo. I've seen this sort of thing with some frequency in previous update reports.

Also, somewhat famously, both Spectre and Meltdown were discovered independently by multiple teams in the same timeframe, who all coordinated disclosure with the CPU vendors etc. https://meltdownattack.com

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by segmondy on Thursday August 08, 2019 @08:57PM (#20650427)
But they also pushed up the price in black market, and if someone in the black market is willing to pay $2mil, $500k ahead, and then the rest over a period of time. Someone might take that payments in bitcoin over Apples $1m which you will have to pay tax on.

We should also remember that there are tons of people outside the US who are into this. Africa, Asian, Eastern Europe. They don't have to worry about the legality of selling an exploit.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by notatoad on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:06PM (#20650473)
>But they also pushed up the price in black market

isn't that the point? sure, it makes selling on the black market more valuable for the hackers willing to do that, but it also makes purchasing an iPhone exploit less accessible for anybody else. that's a good thing.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by segmondy on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:14PM (#20650798)
Money is not a problem to Nation state actors. Not even $10M will stop any country. Even an African dictator motivated will easily pay $50M if that means getting what it takes to stay in power.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by coldtea on Thursday August 08, 2019 @10:32PM (#20650886)
African dictators care for mobile OS hacks for staying in power?
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by myrandomcomment on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:11PM (#20651039)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs is a pretty well done video on the rules to be a dictator.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by roboys on Friday August 09, 2019 @04:50AM (#20652408)
Gathering intelligence is a key part of staying in power.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by magashna on Friday August 09, 2019 @08:49AM (#20653785)
If it makes it easier to spy on the competition, why not?
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by secfirstmd on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:09PM (#20650484)
Yeah but that cost has to be passed on at some point to an end consumer.

This move from Apple makes people like me, working with human rights defenders and journalists, happy.

Why?

Because it drives up the costs for the NSO Groups, Hacking Teams and Gammas of this world. They either pass on (and take a hit reducing their revenue/internal capacity) or drive up their costs (making it harder for crappier regimes to afford / reducing the frequency that high end exploits will be used.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by codyb on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:55PM (#20650705)
That seems like a pretty valid viewpoint. The higher the cost, the less people with access, and the more likely people go with Apple’s offer.

Besides that, earning a 1 million dollar reward for cracking the iOS kernel is probably a nice ticket to a pretty well paying gig at some security firm.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by swagasaurus-rex on Thursday August 08, 2019 @11:27PM (#20651112)
Right. Being able to claim (with proof) that you collected on a $1,000,000 bounty, from Apple no less, makes you massively more employable no matter where in the world you live.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by briandear on Thursday August 08, 2019 @09:07PM (#20650476)
They do have to pay tax; that they choose not to is a crime in most countries.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by devin on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:05AM (#20651939)
I agree it’s a smart move, but I don’t know that I agree with the figure. Anyone who claims this bounty could make 500k+ at Apple without question. In some ways it seems like a recruitment exercise.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by kaustyap on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:16AM (#20653973)
What is the probability of an Apple developer introducing a hard to catch bug and sharing the information with third-party so that they share the bounty?
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by redleader9345 on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:18AM (#20653994)
I don't know. But I do know that the way to prevent that is to handcuff all the developers with crushing process heaviness. Then they won't introduce anything malicious, because they won't introduce anything at all.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by kaustyap on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:23AM (#20654033)
Yeah, what is not clear is if they would catch and fire developer/team who introduced $1M bug.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by esmi on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:29PM (#20657576)
Given the published corporate policy on leaking I think it’s safe to conclude they would be fired, and most likely prosecuted when possible.

“The Cupertino, California-based company said in a lengthy memo posted to its internal blog that it "caught 29 leakers," last year and noted that 12 of those were arrested. "These people not only lose their jobs, they can face extreme difficulty finding employment elsewhere," Apple added.”

https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/news/articles/2018-04-13/apple...

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by 95014_refugee on Friday August 09, 2019 @09:49PM (#20659661)
Apple does not have an "internal blog".

Bloomberg.

Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by esmi on Friday August 09, 2019 @03:17PM (#20657474)
I think the probability is very low. Apple pays developers very well, and you're asking them to risk all future salary and their freedom. That’s going to cost a lot. Much more than $1M, I would think.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by sigmar on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:09PM (#20655635)
If someone wanted to do that, they could have made a ton of money before Apple started this bounty.
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by riffraff on Friday August 09, 2019 @12:49AM (#20651415)
Isn't it much simpler and cheaper for apple to buy the same exploit through the same brokers anonymously?
Re:Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone by Twisell on Friday August 09, 2019 @02:59AM (#20651916)
That would be a scam if bug on the grey market are paid over time until fixed.

Then Apple could buy and fix ASAP so the researcher get screwed. So yeah it’s cheaper but if someone notice just wait for the backfire! Guaranteed one time payement seem like the fair way to go.