Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by srfilipek on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:11AM
(#20633928)
Tesla's page in question is quite clear about their methodology, and I can't really see the fault in it:
> The Vehicle Safety Score represents the “relative risk of injury with respect to a baseline of 15%,” according to NHTSA. Model 3 achieved a Vehicle Safety Score of 0.38, which is lower than any other vehicle rated in NHTSA’s public documents.
How can the NHTSA create a safety score regarding risk of injury, and then say that you can't use it to make a statement about the risk of injury?
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by Hypx on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:57AM
(#20634230)
It also ignores the way a car is being used. Sports cars are consistently more dangerous than say, minivans. This is true even if the minivan is poorly rated and the sports car is top-of-class in its safety rating.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by windexh8er on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:13AM
(#20634367)
Source?
A minivan has a higher center of gravity so in an example where a minivan is cornering aggressively, say to avoid a collision, the rollover likelihood is higher than that of a sports car. As I understand it safety ratings are generally after occupancy protection and aren't concerned with the class of vehicle which goes against what you've claimed.
From the NHTSA website [0]:
"Can I compare vehicles from different classes?
Side crash rating results can be compared across all classes because all vehicles are hit with the same force by the same moving barrier or pole.
Rollover ratings can also be compared across all classes. Frontal crash rating results can only be compared to other vehicles in the same class and whose weight is plus or minus 250 pounds of the vehicle being rated. This is because a frontal crash rating into a fixed barrier represents a crash between two vehicles of the same weight."
And again they are, generally, looking for impact to occupant, for example for the "Side Pole Crash Test Scenario" under "Test Details" they are looking at "Evaluation of injury to the head, chest, lower spine, abdomen, pelvis".
Just because a sports car is a different class of vehicle does not make it inherently less safe. The driver input can change that for any class of vehicle.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by dragontamer on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:05AM
(#20634764)
> Source?
A minivan weighs over 4500 lbs, while a sports car probably weighs 3000 lbs. In most collision situations, the heavier car is safer.
Frontal collision tests (and frontal overlap tests) are against stationary objects. So a minivan is tested with 4500+lbs of weight, while a sports car is only tested with 3000 lbs of weight.
Some tests are weight dependent. Others have a static weight.
-----------
I know some friends who survived getting hit by a bus. Riding in a 5000lb+ vehicle helps in these situations. There is a huge degree of safety that is afforded by just having a heavier vehicle.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by windexh8er on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:13AM
(#20634838)
While that's a great anecdote it's not a source. We could counter your argument by saying that the power to weight ratio of large vehicle is less than that of sports cars. Also because of softer suspensions not tuned for aggressive handling makes for vehicles that get into more crashes due to characteristics that make them worse with regard to stopping before a crash, unable to accelerate out of a compromising situation, or at at odds with a much higher likelihood of rollover due to aggressive maneuvering.
As an aside I have lots of friends who own fast cars who haven't gotten into accidents by avoiding them. Thankfully they were driving lighter vehicles.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by dragontamer on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:19PM
(#20636111)
> As an aside I have lots of friends who own fast cars who haven't gotten into accidents by avoiding them. Thankfully they were driving lighter vehicles.
And we all have friends who regularly avoid accidents in motorcycles. The difference is that you HAVE to avoid an accident to survive them, especially for motorcyclists (the extreme case of smallest but most agile vehicle). While if you're in a big car, you can have an accident and survive.
Its a very big difference. If you ever are a bit tired or distracted, the "trust my reactions to save me" technique will fail.
But if you're tired / distracted, but armored up in a 5000lb or 6000lb vehicle, you'll probably survive whatever hits you.
The survival rate of 18-wheelers (even when they're distracted and tired from driving 10+ hours a day) is quite high. Multi-ton armor just makes things safer.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by nullwasamistake on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @03:10PM
(#20637853)
He's right that heavy vehicles are statistically much safer across the board. If you search for list of cars with lowest accident fatality rate it's almost all giant trucks and SUV's.
You're heavier than the cars around you which helps a lot, but the extra weight also smashes through a lot of obstacles.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by lm28469 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:10AM
(#20635402)
> As an aside I have lots of friends who own fast cars who haven't gotten into accidents by avoiding them.
As in driving aggressively and avoiding accidents they were about to create ? Statistically most accidents are rear ends and side collisions, both of which you most likely won't see coming with enough time to react let alone move your car. And getting plowed by an SUV when you're sitting in a sport car means your head is on the absolute worst position you could think of.
Bikers say the same "I'm small, agile and fast, no accidents for me", yet they're disproportionally represented in crash stats.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by windexh8er on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:59AM
(#20635900)
You're example assumes everyone is the victim. Except that all side collisions and rear ends could be avoided by the stiking vehicle stopping faster. Which vehicles are statistically more often found as being the striking vehicle? It's likely that larger vehicles which can't stop quickly are. And in your example you use an SUV as the plowing vehicle, probably because it's mostly assumed you'll be hit by that type of vehicle, partially for the reasons I just stated.
Again, with the biker statement, since you'll never find a data set that would show accidents avoided on the particular vehicle there's a huge swath of underrepresentation of the reality. And one can argue proportionally bikers are in more crashes because there are less of them overall on top of the fact that most drivers of cars and trucks do not pay considerate attention to smaller vehicles.
And finally my comment about the "friends with fast cars" was a tongue in cheek response to the fact that the parent I was replying to made a large jump by saying SUVs are safer because of size and weight.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by windexh8er on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @12:52PM
(#20636471)
Are you implying distracted driving is unique to only Tesla vehicles? The link you posted implies that, and then you immediately generalize your argument.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by dragontamer on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @04:57PM
(#20638966)
I intend to argue in the general sense. People will, in general, be distracted while driving. One protection is to simply be in a heavier vehicle so that you can survive more collisions when you're in a distracted state.
An alternative solution is "don't be distracted", but that doesn't seem to work in practice.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by Retric on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:44AM
(#20635764)
Big has benefits for the occupants in terms of larger crumple zones etc, heavy does not. What’s important is jerk and acceleration not your final velocity.
Electric cars actually weigh more due to batteries, but that’s not particularly helpful.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by rtkwe on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:48AM
(#20634634)
> “the lowest probability of injury of all cars the safety agency has ever tested.”
NHTSA is taking issue with how the results are being framed. The ratings are only valid across classes in some cases and for stuff like front impact rating the numbers are only valid for cars with very similar weights, Tesla is using the numbers to say they have the lowest probability across all cars. See [0] page 7 for the original letter, the NHTSA has very specific guidelines for what their numbers actually mean and how they can't be compared in all cases across different vehicles, Tesla has violated those by comparing their score to all vehicles which definitely includes vehicles outside the +/- 250 lbs weight difference the NHTSA feels is appropriate.
edit: To expand having read more they specifically say that in a collision between vehicles of different classes the numbers become largely meaningless and that the larger vehicle like an SUV will have the lower probability of injury compared to the smaller vehicle.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by Someone on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:52PM
(#20637082)
Aside from the “you can’t compare those numbers across categories” issue, there’s the fact that Tesla makes the incorrect inference “safest per collision” ⇒ “lowest probability of injury of all cars”.
I’m not making any claim about Tesla’s cars (because of its low center of gravity and relatively large weight, they likely are quite a bit safer than the average car in collisions) but if brand B has distracting UI, bad steering, or whatever, that causes it to slam into walls twice as often as cars of brand C, being safer in a single collision may not offset that.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:20AM
(#20633980)
>How can the NHTSA create a safety score regarding risk of injury, and then say that you can't use it to make a statement about the risk of injury?
Government is highly averse to saying or doing anything that could possibly come back to bite them (with exceptions beyond the scope of this comment) hence they will compile stats but are non-committal about drawing any conclusions from or interpreting those stats.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by rtkwe on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @01:52PM
(#20637083)
No it's not even that. The numbers they produce for front impact don't generalize across class and the real rule is basically the larger vehicle will have lower injury risk in mixed vehicle collisions.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by shakna on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:33AM
(#20633722)
More detail can be found at the article's source [0].
---
> The documents, obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request, also include orders for information that NHTSA sent to Tesla following several crashes, including a fatal March 1 crash involving a Model 3 operating on Autopilot. Tesla shares fell 0.5% in New York pre-market trading to $229.51.
NHTSA seem rather unkeen for Tesla to say the good without the bad, and are more than happy to try and prove that the marketing fluff Tesla has forwarded isn't a complete enough story for the public to make a decision.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by RichardHeart on Thursday August 08, 2019 @02:17AM
(#20642275)
Tesla's are quite heavy as far as sedans go. I think that enhances their safety in car v car crashes. The average car weighs 2,871 lb. | The average sedan weights 3,351 lb.| SUV avg: 4,437lb | Truck: 4,710lb | 18 wheeler: 15,000 "tare weight" (empty) | 18 wheeler loaded: 80,000lb | School bus: 23,500-29,500lb
Notice the teslas avg weigh more than everything but the semi's. 3: 3,552lb-4072lb | 60D 5,072 lb (2,300 kg) | 70D 5,072 lb (2,300 kg) | 75D 5,140 lb (2,330 kg) | 90D 5,271 lb (2,390 kg) | P90D 5,381 lb (2,440 kg) | 100D 5,421 lb (2,459 kg) | P100D 5,531 lb (2,509 kg)
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by FireBeyond on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @03:53PM
(#20638226)
Tesla seems to be able to bring out the conspiracy theorists. So far, here, there are claims that "Big Auto" "told" the NHTSA to come after Tesla, that NHTSA doesn't have enough Tesla ex-employees, etc., and several that studiously ignore the whole concept of a weight class and bemoan the NHTSA for "bad tests".
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by navigatesol on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:59AM
(#20634240)
>I’ll take this blog post from Tesla over, for example, the Ford commercial showing their concept electric truck pulling a train, any day.
Sounds like you have some pretty serious bias. Meanwhile, Tesla claims their non-existent truck concept can pull 300,000lbs. Has Ford ever claimed something similar?
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by zaroth on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @03:41PM
(#20638121)
Both Tesla and Ford make a factual claim that has important caveats.
Tesla Model 3 does have the lowest weighted probability of an injury of any car ever tested by NHTSA. The Ford prototype did pull 1 million pounds of railway cars.
In the case of Tesla, it’s important to understand the limits and intent of the test and that it’s the lowest probability of injury when crashing into certain types of stationary objects or cars of roughly the same mass. That’s an important caveat but the Tesla did score much better than any other car ever has, and I think it’s fair to brag about that.
In the case of the Ford, it turns out any vehicle that can pull with ~2,000 lbs of force could do the same thing. To me, that makes the demo basically a gimmick and “misleading” to the general public.
By comparison, the world record holder for pulling a train with his teeth pulled over 575,000 pounds. Ok, now that’s impressive! [1]
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by bambax on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:50AM
(#20634187)
It's not "a sound bite", it's the title of the blog post, in a font twice as big as the rest of the article.
And, maybe Ford also sounds like Trump. I don't know. Maybe all salesmen sound alike. I don't much care. "But some other guy did it before" is a weak argument.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by 0xcde4c3db on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:41AM
(#20634588)
It's true that Trump loves his superlatives; many people have noted that to him, something or someone seemingly has to be either the best ever or the worst ever with no middle ground.
On its own, though, that's not very relevant to the Tesla story. It might be made more substantive by linking it to a larger issue, such as how we think about the line between acceptable puffery [1] and unacceptable false advertising, and how that interacts with the mindsets of sales versus product definition versus implementation.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by kalleboo on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:55AM
(#20633845)
If you read the NHTSA letter they go into detail that their crash testing is done against fixed barriers, which means that it doesn't say anything about the safety of a lighter vehicle crashing into a heavier one. In a crash between a big heavy SUV and a Model 3, you can be better off in the SUV even if it has a worse crash rating.
NHTSA describes that they have a specific guidelines document (which has a rule about comparing vehicles 250 lbs apart in weight) which Tesla apparently hasn't followed, so they're not making up rules selectively against Tesla.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by madamelic on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:02AM
(#20633888)
>If you read the NHTSA letter they go into detail that their crash testing is done against fixed barriers, which means that it doesn't say anything about the safety of a lighter vehicle crashing into a heavier one. In a crash between a big heavy SUV and a Model 3, you may be better off in the SUV even if it has a "worse" crash rating.
All I am reading is that the NHTSA has bad tests?
If they are so mad Tesla is saying "We have the best crash test rating of any car", why not change the test to include those issues?
If someone was mad that I said "My code passes all of the tests", but there were still bugs in the code, the issue isn't my statement. The issue is that there is incomplete coverage.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by kalleboo on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:07AM
(#20633907)
They have incomplete tests, since crash testing is really expensive.
But they are upfront in their guidelines about what exactly their tests do and do not say. Their tests are good for comparing cars in the same weight class. They are not good for saying what is the world's safest car.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by madamelic on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:44AM
(#20634152)
If the NHTSA doesn't want their stats in marketing, why not figure out how to make them completely worthless.
Stars is way too marketable and deceptive to begin with. Make it Pass / Fail. 4 stars to actually failing is "fail". 5 stars is "pass". Actually failing being a rejection of approval and such a car wouldn't get a rating.
"Our car passes all necessary safety tests" ... good?
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by makomk on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:18AM
(#20634407)
The NHTSA stars are adequate for their intended purpose - showing how well a car holds up in a crash compared to equivalent cars from other manufacturers. You just can't use them to make any conclusion about the overall risk of injury (which depends on the likelihood of a crash happening in the first place), can't compare them between cars of different weight classes, and can't draw meaningful conclusions about the relative safety of different five-star rated cars. Tesla did all three.
The last one might need a little elaboration. The NHTSA battery of tests is relatively small and limited. The lower the risk of injury in those tests is, the more dependent the actual real-world risk becomes on all the scenarios they didn't test. This isn't a hypothetical problem. The Model S also got the best score ever in the NHTSA tests and Tesla did a similar press release about that, but it didn't get the IIHS's highest rating because it performed badly in small-overlap collisions which weren't part of the NHTSA tests.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by saltminer on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:04AM
(#20634754)
> why not change the test to include those issues?
The problem with making comprehensive tests would mean small cars would be disadvantaged. You wouldn't pair up a heavyweight MMA fighter with a strawweight to figure out who is best, and likewise, you wouldn't have a bus and a small car t-bone each other to determine which is safer. (If you think a bus is a bad comparison since they're not usually sold to the general public, just try a pickup truck vs a small car.)
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by asark on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:09AM
(#20634328)
> All I am reading is that the NHTSA has bad tests?
Seems like a testing policy designed to keep people from avoiding buying small cars ever, and/or to keep people from agitating to ban or otherwise legally discourage heavy road vehicles.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by _archon_ on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:16AM
(#20633957)
NHTSA crash test ratings are within the car's class only. A 5 star subcompact may well be less safe than a 4 star minivan. The model S is likely (my opinion) more safe than a model 3.
I believe the Tesla marketing would have been more true if it had included "... in an NHTSA-style incident" or some such. But that's not how marketing works.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by neo4sure on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:58AM
(#20635894)
Well NHTSA’s trying not to offend Big Auto. Once Administration changes the safety goals should be set at a higher bar. Only one car company can meet them.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by Theodores on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:49AM
(#20634182)
There is no such thing as bad publicity and here Tesla are back in the news again. Funny they don't have an advertising budget and here we are learning the lesson that Tesla safety is a cut above the rest even if the marketing claims are slightly off.
I am suspect of the safety of all cars that don't have rally/track style roll cages and four point harnesses (with fire extinguisher in easy reach). But I would go in a Tesla.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by Zenbit_UX on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:06AM
(#20634307)
You really feel you need that for typical car uses or were you joking? I can't see why I'd need a roll cage to do groceries - christ, I drive a motorcycle as my sole vehicle so I think we're on opposite ends of the risk spectrum.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by Theodores on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @09:29AM
(#20634478)
I ride a bicycle. I don't go on motorways with it though.
We have all seen the crash test videos, we have all been driving at twice the speeds in those crash test videos. We have all stepped it on a little bit more to be travelling past the speed limit.
We have all 'rubber necked' at some ghastly accident on the other carriageway and wondered how so much carnage can happen on a perfectly straight road. A million people get killed on the roads globally every year.
On a motor racing event the medics and fire crew are minutes away, ready. There is no on-coming traffic. There are no people drunk or partially sighted on the road. The barriers and run-off areas have been tested. Helmets are mandatory. The road ahead is the same circuit it was two minutes ago, last time it was lapped. Features in the circuit are there to restrict top speed - chicanes etc.
Meanwhile, on the autobahn you can do the same speeds. Or, elsewhere you can find an overtaking car in your carriageway doing 70+ mph, combine that with your 'safe' 50 mph and imagine how that head on crash compares to the test videos that are at a fraction of the speed. Imagine how well your brain copes smashing into your skull in the impact. Just because everyone is driving along in all weather conditions tailgating the guy in front every day does not make it wonderfully safe. So yes I am serious about the need for a roll cage or a Tesla.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by bb123 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:15AM
(#20635448)
Cars have roll cages built into the frame of the vehicle. Thats why they don't crumple under their own weight if they roll. I don't know what kind of Mad Max world you're driving in but an external roll cage and a 4 point harness (as opposed to the 3 point harness already fitted in literally every car) seems like complete overkill for most use cases. Also motorway driving is generally the safest kind of driving, so while your story is certainly evocative I don't think it really justifies your claim that every car should have two roll cages. We don't put cow plows on most cars either, by your logic we probably should.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by grepthisab on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:48AM
(#20635207)
No, not literally. There are a surprising number of cars on the road that are set up for events like autocross and such that have roll cages, etc. I've often seen these kinds of setups on small cars like Mazda Miatas. But, the point is, it's not just for race cars/track-only cars. Maybe you meant something other than "literally" but in case you didn't wanted to clarify that this is a relatively common thing in many circles.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by freehunter on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @11:29AM
(#20635605)
I absolutely meant "literally". It's also a "relatively common thing" in "many circles" for people to modify their cars to have tea kettles installed in the dashboard but since no car ships from the factory like that it's insignificant enough to be completely discounted.
Yes, you can modify a stock car until it becomes a race car and then also drive that car on the road. But since no car ships from the factory like that it's insignificant enough to be completely discounted.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by whenchamenia on Thursday August 08, 2019 @08:55AM
(#20644036)
You can order more than a few sports cars with roll cages from the factory. The distinction between road car and race car are blinkers, vin and tags. While you aren't likely to win Le Mons in your daily driver anymore, you sure can drive most race cars on the street.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by grepthisab on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:24PM
(#20640284)
ah, this is one of those moving the goalposts things people talk about. You say one thing, someone comments on it, and suddenly you meant something much more restrictive. I don't see this one in the wild on HN that often.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by lazyjones on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:22AM
(#20633993)
So, basically NHTSA is threatening Tesla because NHTSA believe their own crash tests aren't good enough to base claims about risk of injury on? As in, "5 stars" means "5 stars" and not "low risk of injury"...
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by zelon88 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:27AM
(#20634037)
No, you just don't understand the star system.
Stars are how well the car contains the passengers during an accident in a variety of situations. 5 stars does not mean "low risk of injury" at all. Infact, a 1 star Sterling box truck will probably cut a Tesla with a 5 star rating in half. Guess who's walking away almost 100% of the time?
The star rating is more a rating of how well the car holds together, prioritizes it's occupants, and the effectiveness of it's safety features. They mostly don't consider factors such as the mass of the vehicles involved or other important factors that become non-arbitrary as soon as you enter the real world.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by lazyjones on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @08:47AM
(#20634172)
> Infact, a 1 star Sterling box truck will probably cut a Tesla with a 5 star rating in half. Guess who's walking away almost 100% of the time?
So what is the average risk of injury in all of the following situations for each of these vehicles (Sterling box truck, Tesla Model 3)?
- 50 mph against a thick wall
- 50 mph against a Sterling box truck
- 50 mph against a random car
- 50 mph into a dense forest
- 50 mph falling off a 50 foot ledge
And what's the average risk of getting into these situations, for weighting?
My point is that a Sterling box truck might crush a Tesla Model 3, but the vehicle's own mass isn't always helping and with no airbags and crumple zones the risk of injury is still higher in many common situations. So let's not overrate one particular situation vs a large truck.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by zelon88 on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @10:18PM
(#20641233)
And my point is that, statistically, if you want the lowest risk of injury in the real world you'll buy the one star box truck because you'll have triple the mass of 90% of the vehicles that could possibly hit you.
Everybody buys 5 star cars. So there's an abundance of them. When a Chevy Spark crashes into a Toyota Corolla it's a good representation of what crash tests simulate. Sure they could make every car crash into a semi truck and give them a rating but none of the dummies would survive. None of them. Even the mighty Tesla. But trucker Bob goes home to his family at the end of every shift.
They would be grading flaming chunks of steel and plastic all day. That's why I drive an SUV. Because I'm broke and can't afford a new "safe" car, but in all liklihood I'm bigger than the median vehicle size so that gives me comfort.
Re:Tesla received a cease-and-desist letter from NHTSA over ...
by lazyjones on Saturday August 10, 2019 @05:46AM
(#20661114)
> And my point is that, statistically, if you want the lowest risk of injury in the real world you'll buy the one star box truck because you'll have triple the mass of 90% of the vehicles that could possibly hit you.
Not all crashes involve other vehicles, you have to take into account the frequency of crashes vs. the environment.
> The Vehicle Safety Score represents the “relative risk of injury with respect to a baseline of 15%,” according to NHTSA. Model 3 achieved a Vehicle Safety Score of 0.38, which is lower than any other vehicle rated in NHTSA’s public documents.
How can the NHTSA create a safety score regarding risk of injury, and then say that you can't use it to make a statement about the risk of injury?
The methodology simply doesn't provide the data for making the type of global claims that Tesla make.
A minivan has a higher center of gravity so in an example where a minivan is cornering aggressively, say to avoid a collision, the rollover likelihood is higher than that of a sports car. As I understand it safety ratings are generally after occupancy protection and aren't concerned with the class of vehicle which goes against what you've claimed.
From the NHTSA website [0]:
"Can I compare vehicles from different classes?
Side crash rating results can be compared across all classes because all vehicles are hit with the same force by the same moving barrier or pole.
Rollover ratings can also be compared across all classes. Frontal crash rating results can only be compared to other vehicles in the same class and whose weight is plus or minus 250 pounds of the vehicle being rated. This is because a frontal crash rating into a fixed barrier represents a crash between two vehicles of the same weight."
And again they are, generally, looking for impact to occupant, for example for the "Side Pole Crash Test Scenario" under "Test Details" they are looking at "Evaluation of injury to the head, chest, lower spine, abdomen, pelvis".
Just because a sports car is a different class of vehicle does not make it inherently less safe. The driver input can change that for any class of vehicle.
[0] https://www.nhtsa.gov/ratings
A minivan weighs over 4500 lbs, while a sports car probably weighs 3000 lbs. In most collision situations, the heavier car is safer.
Frontal collision tests (and frontal overlap tests) are against stationary objects. So a minivan is tested with 4500+lbs of weight, while a sports car is only tested with 3000 lbs of weight.
Some tests are weight dependent. Others have a static weight.
-----------
I know some friends who survived getting hit by a bus. Riding in a 5000lb+ vehicle helps in these situations. There is a huge degree of safety that is afforded by just having a heavier vehicle.
As an aside I have lots of friends who own fast cars who haven't gotten into accidents by avoiding them. Thankfully they were driving lighter vehicles.
I won't berate survivorship bias here.
And we all have friends who regularly avoid accidents in motorcycles. The difference is that you HAVE to avoid an accident to survive them, especially for motorcyclists (the extreme case of smallest but most agile vehicle). While if you're in a big car, you can have an accident and survive.
Its a very big difference. If you ever are a bit tired or distracted, the "trust my reactions to save me" technique will fail.
But if you're tired / distracted, but armored up in a 5000lb or 6000lb vehicle, you'll probably survive whatever hits you.
The survival rate of 18-wheelers (even when they're distracted and tired from driving 10+ hours a day) is quite high. Multi-ton armor just makes things safer.
You're heavier than the cars around you which helps a lot, but the extra weight also smashes through a lot of obstacles.
As in driving aggressively and avoiding accidents they were about to create ? Statistically most accidents are rear ends and side collisions, both of which you most likely won't see coming with enough time to react let alone move your car. And getting plowed by an SUV when you're sitting in a sport car means your head is on the absolute worst position you could think of.
Bikers say the same "I'm small, agile and fast, no accidents for me", yet they're disproportionally represented in crash stats.
Again, with the biker statement, since you'll never find a data set that would show accidents avoided on the particular vehicle there's a huge swath of underrepresentation of the reality. And one can argue proportionally bikers are in more crashes because there are less of them overall on top of the fact that most drivers of cars and trucks do not pay considerate attention to smaller vehicles.
And finally my comment about the "friends with fast cars" was a tongue in cheek response to the fact that the parent I was replying to made a large jump by saying SUVs are safer because of size and weight.
Or you know, not being on distracted autopilot: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jul/01/tesla-dri...
People get distracted, and when they're distracted they'll crash into things.
An alternative solution is "don't be distracted", but that doesn't seem to work in practice.
Electric cars actually weigh more due to batteries, but that’s not particularly helpful.
That is incorrect. Your statement is only true in the case of single vehicle inelastic collisions, which is the only type tests NHTSA conducts.
What I wrote is in quotes and directly taken from the NHTSA site. Those are not my words. Try taking a look at the site first.
1. NHTSA released data showing the Model 3 has the best score in their dataset.
2. Tesla happily publishes this to show off.
3. NHTSA gets grumpy.
4. (???)
NHTSA is taking issue with how the results are being framed. The ratings are only valid across classes in some cases and for stuff like front impact rating the numbers are only valid for cars with very similar weights, Tesla is using the numbers to say they have the lowest probability across all cars. See [0] page 7 for the original letter, the NHTSA has very specific guidelines for what their numbers actually mean and how they can't be compared in all cases across different vehicles, Tesla has violated those by comparing their score to all vehicles which definitely includes vehicles outside the +/- 250 lbs weight difference the NHTSA feels is appropriate.
[0] https://www.plainsite.org/documents/fnrhg/tesla-nhtsa-foia-r... (still reading but see bottom of page 3 and top of page 4 and the NHTSA letter on page 7)
edit: To expand having read more they specifically say that in a collision between vehicles of different classes the numbers become largely meaningless and that the larger vehicle like an SUV will have the lower probability of injury compared to the smaller vehicle.
I’m not making any claim about Tesla’s cars (because of its low center of gravity and relatively large weight, they likely are quite a bit safer than the average car in collisions) but if brand B has distracting UI, bad steering, or whatever, that causes it to slam into walls twice as often as cars of brand C, being safer in a single collision may not offset that.
Government is highly averse to saying or doing anything that could possibly come back to bite them (with exceptions beyond the scope of this comment) hence they will compile stats but are non-committal about drawing any conclusions from or interpreting those stats.
---
> The documents, obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request, also include orders for information that NHTSA sent to Tesla following several crashes, including a fatal March 1 crash involving a Model 3 operating on Autopilot. Tesla shares fell 0.5% in New York pre-market trading to $229.51.
NHTSA seem rather unkeen for Tesla to say the good without the bad, and are more than happy to try and prove that the marketing fluff Tesla has forwarded isn't a complete enough story for the public to make a decision.
---
[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-08-07/tesla-dra...
Notice the teslas avg weigh more than everything but the semi's. 3: 3,552lb-4072lb | 60D 5,072 lb (2,300 kg) | 70D 5,072 lb (2,300 kg) | 75D 5,140 lb (2,330 kg) | 90D 5,271 lb (2,390 kg) | P90D 5,381 lb (2,440 kg) | 100D 5,421 lb (2,459 kg) | P100D 5,531 lb (2,509 kg)
Sounds like something Trump would say.
Pretty much anyone can be made to sound like anything when you take a sound bite.
I’ll take this blog post from Tesla over, for example, the Ford commercial showing their concept electric truck pulling a train, any day.
[1] - https://www.tesla.com/blog/model-3-lowest-probability-injury...
Sounds like you have some pretty serious bias. Meanwhile, Tesla claims their non-existent truck concept can pull 300,000lbs. Has Ford ever claimed something similar?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Au3U72CX74I
It just isn't as big an accomplishment as it looks, since it was on a railway.
Tesla Model 3 does have the lowest weighted probability of an injury of any car ever tested by NHTSA. The Ford prototype did pull 1 million pounds of railway cars.
In the case of Tesla, it’s important to understand the limits and intent of the test and that it’s the lowest probability of injury when crashing into certain types of stationary objects or cars of roughly the same mass. That’s an important caveat but the Tesla did score much better than any other car ever has, and I think it’s fair to brag about that.
In the case of the Ford, it turns out any vehicle that can pull with ~2,000 lbs of force could do the same thing. To me, that makes the demo basically a gimmick and “misleading” to the general public.
By comparison, the world record holder for pulling a train with his teeth pulled over 575,000 pounds. Ok, now that’s impressive! [1]
[1] - https://youtu.be/CTeb19ICMD4
And, maybe Ford also sounds like Trump. I don't know. Maybe all salesmen sound alike. I don't much care. "But some other guy did it before" is a weak argument.
On its own, though, that's not very relevant to the Tesla story. It might be made more substantive by linking it to a larger issue, such as how we think about the line between acceptable puffery [1] and unacceptable false advertising, and how that interacts with the mindsets of sales versus product definition versus implementation.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery
NHTSA describes that they have a specific guidelines document (which has a rule about comparing vehicles 250 lbs apart in weight) which Tesla apparently hasn't followed, so they're not making up rules selectively against Tesla.
All I am reading is that the NHTSA has bad tests?
If they are so mad Tesla is saying "We have the best crash test rating of any car", why not change the test to include those issues?
If someone was mad that I said "My code passes all of the tests", but there were still bugs in the code, the issue isn't my statement. The issue is that there is incomplete coverage.
But they are upfront in their guidelines about what exactly their tests do and do not say. Their tests are good for comparing cars in the same weight class. They are not good for saying what is the world's safest car.
Stars is way too marketable and deceptive to begin with. Make it Pass / Fail. 4 stars to actually failing is "fail". 5 stars is "pass". Actually failing being a rejection of approval and such a car wouldn't get a rating.
"Our car passes all necessary safety tests" ... good?
The last one might need a little elaboration. The NHTSA battery of tests is relatively small and limited. The lower the risk of injury in those tests is, the more dependent the actual real-world risk becomes on all the scenarios they didn't test. This isn't a hypothetical problem. The Model S also got the best score ever in the NHTSA tests and Tesla did a similar press release about that, but it didn't get the IIHS's highest rating because it performed badly in small-overlap collisions which weren't part of the NHTSA tests.
Elon is saying more than "My car passes all of the tests"
The problem with making comprehensive tests would mean small cars would be disadvantaged. You wouldn't pair up a heavyweight MMA fighter with a strawweight to figure out who is best, and likewise, you wouldn't have a bus and a small car t-bone each other to determine which is safer. (If you think a bus is a bad comparison since they're not usually sold to the general public, just try a pickup truck vs a small car.)
Or, they can do what they have done and tell Tesla to stop exaggerating the claims, which is a pattern with this company.
Because testing cars is expensive, and why should the association be beholden to a manufacturer's desire for marketing?
Seems like a testing policy designed to keep people from avoiding buying small cars ever, and/or to keep people from agitating to ban or otherwise legally discourage heavy road vehicles.
I believe the Tesla marketing would have been more true if it had included "... in an NHTSA-style incident" or some such. But that's not how marketing works.
I am suspect of the safety of all cars that don't have rally/track style roll cages and four point harnesses (with fire extinguisher in easy reach). But I would go in a Tesla.
We have all seen the crash test videos, we have all been driving at twice the speeds in those crash test videos. We have all stepped it on a little bit more to be travelling past the speed limit.
We have all 'rubber necked' at some ghastly accident on the other carriageway and wondered how so much carnage can happen on a perfectly straight road. A million people get killed on the roads globally every year.
On a motor racing event the medics and fire crew are minutes away, ready. There is no on-coming traffic. There are no people drunk or partially sighted on the road. The barriers and run-off areas have been tested. Helmets are mandatory. The road ahead is the same circuit it was two minutes ago, last time it was lapped. Features in the circuit are there to restrict top speed - chicanes etc.
Meanwhile, on the autobahn you can do the same speeds. Or, elsewhere you can find an overtaking car in your carriageway doing 70+ mph, combine that with your 'safe' 50 mph and imagine how that head on crash compares to the test videos that are at a fraction of the speed. Imagine how well your brain copes smashing into your skull in the impact. Just because everyone is driving along in all weather conditions tailgating the guy in front every day does not make it wonderfully safe. So yes I am serious about the need for a roll cage or a Tesla.
So literally every car then.
Yes, you can modify a stock car until it becomes a race car and then also drive that car on the road. But since no car ships from the factory like that it's insignificant enough to be completely discounted.
Stars are how well the car contains the passengers during an accident in a variety of situations. 5 stars does not mean "low risk of injury" at all. Infact, a 1 star Sterling box truck will probably cut a Tesla with a 5 star rating in half. Guess who's walking away almost 100% of the time?
The star rating is more a rating of how well the car holds together, prioritizes it's occupants, and the effectiveness of it's safety features. They mostly don't consider factors such as the mass of the vehicles involved or other important factors that become non-arbitrary as soon as you enter the real world.
So what is the average risk of injury in all of the following situations for each of these vehicles (Sterling box truck, Tesla Model 3)?
- 50 mph against a thick wall
- 50 mph against a Sterling box truck
- 50 mph against a random car
- 50 mph into a dense forest
- 50 mph falling off a 50 foot ledge
And what's the average risk of getting into these situations, for weighting?
My point is that a Sterling box truck might crush a Tesla Model 3, but the vehicle's own mass isn't always helping and with no airbags and crumple zones the risk of injury is still higher in many common situations. So let's not overrate one particular situation vs a large truck.
50mph Model 3 vs a 50mph Sterling Box Truck.
Situations when OTHER objects run into you. Its unfortunate, but people "armor up" and buy heavier vehicles for safety in these situations.
Everybody buys 5 star cars. So there's an abundance of them. When a Chevy Spark crashes into a Toyota Corolla it's a good representation of what crash tests simulate. Sure they could make every car crash into a semi truck and give them a rating but none of the dummies would survive. None of them. Even the mighty Tesla. But trucker Bob goes home to his family at the end of every shift.
They would be grading flaming chunks of steel and plastic all day. That's why I drive an SUV. Because I'm broke and can't afford a new "safe" car, but in all liklihood I'm bigger than the median vehicle size so that gives me comfort.
Not all crashes involve other vehicles, you have to take into account the frequency of crashes vs. the environment.