News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:50PM (#20610765)
This post repeatedly refers to 8chan as "lawless" and "unmoderated" but it is neither. As a whole, it is a public website subject to US law, complete with DMCA and search warrant contact forms. The sitewide rule is that all content must comply with US law.

The media also keeps saying 8chan, 8chan, 8chan over and over, when it is really just the one most popular board ("pol") that is being discussed. But there are hundreds of boards on the site for different topics, which are moderated separately and according to their own rules.

It seems like most of the outrageous incitement to violence people have posted on 8chan would be illegal under Brandenburg v. Ohio (speech is illegal if it will lead to imminent lawless action), given the mostly-valid assumption there will be readers of the post who are both radicalized and armed. This seems like the way to take down most of the violent content on 8chan if anyone would think about it for more than 5 seconds.

This seems like a knee-jerk reaction to moral panic and bad PR, not a solution to anything. Cloudflare would have been in a better position to actually change 8chan if they had kept them on and pressured them.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by ajross on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:23PM (#20610949)
> It seems like most of the outrageous incitement to violence people have posted on 8chan would be illegal under Brandenburg v. Ohio

And yet, no one wants to police that. So... Cloudflare did it themselves.

I mean, look, I get the principled point you're making, but it's on really shaky ground. Either the conduct on that site was garbage that should be removed or it wasn't. And if it was... well, good riddance.

After the third (third!) mass murder advertised on the site, I think the time for principled and careful consideration has passed. Shut the garbage down, then we'll figure out if there's a better way to police this stuff going forward.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:00AM (#20611176)
Matthew Prince could have just said "per our terms of service we don't provide services for websites that violate US law and 8chan allows posts that in our opinion incite imminent lawless action, therefore we're terminating their account". Instead he posted this confused essay that clearly shows he understands neither 8chan nor the relevant law, instead making up weird terms and making it entirely vague what their policy will be for terminating accounts in the future.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by ajross on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:31AM (#20611306)
OK, so 8chan (edit: sorry, should have written "Cloudflare") could have handled this better according to your personal sense of justice or aesthetics or whatever. And... 20 people are dead in El Paso.

It's like we're not even talking about the same thing here. I just don't get your thought process, sorry. You agree that this incitement and radicalization shouldn't have had a forum, I think.

You just... would rather talk about the mechanism by which the forum access was removed than the incitement and radicalization? That's really the hill you're taking your stand on?

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Monday August 05, 2019 @01:01AM (#20611411)
Cloudflare is the gateway to 20% of the internet. Their CEO is harping on a vague term he calls "Rule of Law" as he capriciously and personally terminates a customer's account, demonstrating lack of knowledge of key facts in the process. That was my main topic. Reducing radicalization is obviously important but this action isn't really going to help much there anyway.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by ajross on Monday August 05, 2019 @02:36PM (#20616989)
> he capriciously and personally terminates a customer's account

Oh please, he gave them two (2) (fucking TWO!) mass murders of leniency before he pulled the plug on their CDN access. This was literally a three strikes policy for hate crime shooting sprees, and it's still "capricious" in your eyes? In your opinion, what should the death toll be before a CDN provider can use it as a justification for terminating service?

Sorry, that's just ridiculous.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Wednesday August 07, 2019 @07:40PM (#20640384)
"8chan committed mass murder" is really stretching guilt-by-association in my opinion.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by judge2020 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:27PM (#20610984)
People use twitter all the time to announce crimes, but everyone knows Twitter is a limited medium and tries to police that content.

But I agree with you. After enough incidents of users announcing mass shootings via the website, they should have set up rules and opened moderator/"janitor" applications to police the content. This is exactly what 4chan did when they grew media attention about bad things happening on their site. 8chan didn't do this because it goes against why the site was created in the first place.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by fortran77 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:00PM (#20610815)
A man, spreading a false rumor about a restaurant called "Meat", told people on Twitter to burn down that restaurant. He thought his restaurant was responsible for removing a graffiti mural on a building across the street.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/02/nyregion/crown-heights-ri...

> “If that mural goes down, the restaurant gonna go down next,” read one comment on Ms. Price’s post [ on twitter ] , accompanied by flame emojis.

> turns out that about 10 days before the meeting, Apolinar Severino, the owner of the building housing the mural, had told Mr. Caldwell that he claimed full responsibility for attempting to paint over the image of Mr. Price. Mr. Severino had been advised by a real estate agent to whitewash the entire wall while trying to refinance his mortgage on the property, he said.

It turns out the owner of the building was responsible for painting over part of the graffiti and not the restaurant across the street.

I reported the tweet that called for burning the restaurant across the street down to Twitter, and Twitter did remove that tweet, but didn't ban the user.

There's a better article covering the story with links to the false rumors being spread on Twitter -- many with threats -- in the Brooklyn eagle https://brooklyneagle.com/articles/2019/07/25/sean-price-mur...

Maybe I'll go to Twitter's hosting providers and Cloudflare to get all of twitter removed, or at least made a lot slower.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by tenpies on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:04PM (#20610841)
> I reported the tweet that called for burning the restaurant across the street down to Twitter, and Twitter did remove that tweet

You already got 99% more than the average Twitter report. Twitter really needs a better "this tweet is verifiably fake, here is the proof" option that is acted upon with relative speed.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by lostlogin on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:26PM (#20610972)
Some of their highest profile accounts accounts would get hit, and they wouldn’t be wanting that. It would also make them some powerful enemies.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by baddox on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:14PM (#20610903)
Isn’t the concern about the gradual radicalization that occurs in these online communities, and not about specific posts that threaten violence or announce impending mass shootings?
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by slg on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:28PM (#20610987)
And the grandparent's comment about there being boards for other topics is why the radicalization is such a problem (the same thing applies to Reddit and Youtube's recommended video algorithm). The normal content is what attracts people to the site, but once there, they see the radicalized content mixed in with it. This ends up normalizing the radicalized content making it easier to recruit new members. Very few people will go out of their way to go to the Daily Stormer or some other site dedicated specifically to hate. But it is easier to be lured in when that content is just a part of the site.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by the8472 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:33PM (#20611021)
> The normal content is what attracts people to the site, but once there, they see the radicalized content mixed in with it.

I don't think this argument holds when the boards are compartmentalized. Otherwise you could generalize it to the internet as a whole, where things are also compartmentalized into sites.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by slg on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:04AM (#20611183)
You are right in a certain aspect that 8chan is more compartmenalized than Reddit or Youtube, but there is still a world of difference in the discoverability of the various boards on 8chan versus the internet at large. A non-radicalized 8chan user can end up on /pol out of mere curiosity and be pulled in. No one visits the Daily Stormer without a predisposition to hate.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by the8472 on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:10AM (#20611212)
A hyperlink is all it takes to stumble into another site.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by nimonian on Monday August 05, 2019 @01:06AM (#20611427)
I understand. However, I think when one site becomes a domain for this behaviour (and domain is and important word here, in both senses) then the effect is different.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by xfitm3 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:21PM (#20610944)
Isn't banning/silencing communities like these the real radicalization?
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by cthulha on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:39PM (#20611060)
You have an implicit model of how radicalization works which is out of sync with the model others are applying.

The counterexample is that, when racist/fascist/white supremacist content became easier to access through online unmoderated forums such as 4chan, the level of online & offline activity and recruitment became higher.

Secondly, it's hardly news to these communities that they are disliked by others. Have you met an Edgelord?

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by meddlepal on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:29PM (#20610996)
CloudFlare is under no obligation to serve 8chan. There is nothing radical about denying service to unprotected classes of people you don't want in or using your business.

I would agree this is a problem if the US Government was trying to suppress speech.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by ebg13 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:29PM (#20610993)
They're not being banned or silenced. They're being told "get off my property".
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by internet_user on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:15PM (#20610908)
Has it occurred to you that radicalization actually happens offline, perhaps even in childhood, due to some kind of real life events, and nothing to do with internet at all?

All of this rooted in meatspace. The so called "social defeat".

How often do you see successful people that have a fullfilling life go on rampages?

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by DoreenMichele on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:33PM (#20611020)
Radicalization tends to be a function of getting access to a group of like-minded people who agree with your angry/hostile/prejudiced views while simultaneously being socially cut off from moderating influences. The internet is able to connect isolated individuals with that group of like-minded people.

One of the dangers of Internet access to such is people who only know you online may feel more comfortable with encouraging your radicalization than if it was in person because they aren't in immediate danger, nor at high risk of being asked to participate, etc. It can seem inconsequential to agree with extremist statements. People who might hesitate to agree in person may not hesitate to agree on a discussion board.

There are good and bad things that come out of the relative freedom to speak our minds online. Opportunity for radicalization is one of the bad things that comes of it.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by internet_user on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:38PM (#20611053)
What makes such people seek out like-minded people, the "radicals"?

The roots are firmly in the meatspace.

The seed was planted well before he know what 8chan was.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by DoreenMichele on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:43PM (#20611082)
Sure, but if he can't find a group in person that will validate and amplify his views and also can't find such online, he will probably remain some run-of-the-mill uncouth jackass without feeling so strongly about it that shooting up a mall seems like a good idea he should totally act upon.

There have been studies. Radicalization is generally the product of a social environment that magnifies certain views and actively encourages people to become more extreme.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by baddox on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:19AM (#20611247)
Sure, the human has to physically exist before they can become radicalized. I don’t really follow the point here. It’s still important to figure out where the actual radicalization happens.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by anigbrowl on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:50PM (#20611127)
Seems like you're assuming your conclusion as your premise.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by internet_user on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:01AM (#20611177)
I assume the cause of such behavior is something that's known properly as "social defeat".
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by anigbrowl on Monday August 05, 2019 @02:35PM (#20616974)
While such IRL considerations are absolutely a factor I think ascribing things to a single cause is a mistake.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by geofft on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:24PM (#20610963)
Certainly the radicalization may happen offline. But in the cases at hand, it did not. There is a significant uptick in violence associated with online radicalization, and no corresponding uptick in violence associated with offline radicalization. You can say that the role of the internet is overblown, but the evidence is there.

Besides, it's a sort of weird position to take on an a) online forum b) of tech people that the internet does not have a significant role in facilitating communication that would not otherwise happen.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by bloaf on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:39PM (#20611057)
There has been a significant uptick in everything online over the last 25 years because in that time the internet population has grown from 0.5% of the worlds population to over 55%.

Literature says that the internet does facilitate extremist communication/nucleation, but does not replace the meatspace as the primary radicalization agent. https://academic.oup.com/ia/article-abstract/93/5/1233/40982...

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by internet_user on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:31PM (#20611009)
where is the data? you have something that proves causality of online communication and radicalization?

You make it sound it's almost like terrorism didn't exist before the internet.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by geofft on Monday August 05, 2019 @07:03AM (#20613046)
> where is the data?

All of these shooters have manifestos that describe how they came to believe what they believed.

> You make it sound it's almost like terrorism didn't exist before the internet.

No, I don't. I specifically said "uptick." This line of argument makes as much sense as showing up in a comment thread about the Capital One breach and saying "You make it sound it's almost like privacy violations didn't exist before the internet." Of course it did, but not at this scale, and we're talking about scale.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by anigbrowl on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:50PM (#20611122)
Sure, and people may be driven to check out extremist ideology because of IRL emotional injuries or problems, but that doesn't mean the internet aspect is overblown. I've probably met more people through the internet than via casual socialization.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by internet_user on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:59PM (#20611174)
overblown, as in, it is very hard to believe emotional injuries sustained over the internet are as bad as social defeat IRL.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by philwelch on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:06AM (#20611194)
Unlikely. Media technologies are technologies for disseminating ideas. Different technologies lie on different points of the spectrum between one-to-many and many-to-many.

Broadcast television, and radio to a lesser extent, is very close to a one-to-many media. There might be a small handful of national networks that can disseminate ideas, and they can only do so in ways that are easy to detect and control by authorities. In an authoritarian state like the Soviet Union there might be only state-controlled broadcasting and it really was one-to-many. In a free country like the United States, you might end up with 3-4 broadcast networks. That's not enough to get a broad spectrum of opinion, which is why the midcentury Overton window was so narrow compared to today.

Cable and satellite television went closer to many-to-many. (Print is also closer to many-to-many than radio and television, but radio and television are more popular since they don't require the effort of reading or the skill of literacy in order to consume, so the presence of radio and television reduces the impact of print.) This broadens things a bit because then you can watch Fox News, though the biggest reason for Fox News was probably an unmet market niche. The broadcast networks plus CNN, for various reasons (likely the internal biases of the journalists themselves), had drifted to a noticeable center-left bias by the 1990's. This left a massive opportunity for a right-biased news network to capture a rough half of the market that was "underserved" to some extent. Conservative talk radio was a similar story.

Print was somewhat more broad, but even then, there were usually small numbers of "respectable" opinionated magazines you could buy on either side of the spectrum (e.g. National Review, The Nation, Mother Jones, The Weekly Standard, etc.) but publication was a big enough hurdle that these outlets often served as moderating voices (e.g the National Review effectively excluding the John Birch Society or Ayn Rand from the "respectable right").

The internet is an extremely many-to-many platform. I mean, I'm just some random idiot you've probably never met and now you're hearing all of my thoughts about something of national importance. That's pretty fucking insane when you think about it. And just like cable, talk radio, and publishing slightly widen the bounds of the Overton Window compared to the broadcast television oligopoly, the internet has done something potentially even worse. I don't think there is a single Overton Window at all anymore. And the old media can't handle this. In another era, this National Review cover alone (https://amp.businessinsider.com/images/56a21e51c08a80431d8b8...) would have completely ended a Republican candidate. In today's era, that man is the President. Similar forces have normalized people like Bernie Sanders, someone who actually existed for a long time but would never have become a national figure in an earlier era.

And yeah, I really think this is all part of the same mechanism. People like Timothy McVeigh were radicalized in person. There aren't that many of him. There are a lot of small scale domestic terror attacks and at times even entire mobs of people (Charlottesville for one example, Portland antifa for another example) who commit acts of political violence. And the more these kinds of events happen, and are publicized, the more this type of behavior becomes normalized, becomes something within the realm of things people think about as something that someone might do in a given situation.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by geofft on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:28PM (#20610990)
> Cloudflare would have been in a better position to actually change 8chan if they had kept them on and pressured them.

So, this was Cloudflare's position as of earlier today: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/aug/04/mass-shoo...

> "It would be the easiest thing in the world and it would feel incredibly good for us to kick 8chan off our network, but I think it would step away from the obligation that we have and cause that community to still exist and be more lawless over time."

> "For us the question is which is the worse evil? Is the worse evil that we kick the can down the road and don’t take responsibility? Or do we get on the phone with people like you and say we need to own up to the fact that the internet is home to many amazing things and many terrible things and we have an absolute moral obligation to deal with that."

So, the question for you and for Matthew Prince-as-of-a-few-hours-ago is, if Cloudflare was in fact in such a better position to actually change 8chan, why didn't they?

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:40PM (#20611065)
I would say that Matthew Prince and associates just wanted to feel better about themselves, avoid further bad PR, and not have things be awkward around town.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by clairity on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:01AM (#20611178)
i generally oppose silencing (online) speech, even the ugliest of it, because not only does it not quell the violence we wish to avoid, but it can enrage the already marginalized among us who tend to carry the most insult.

as such, even taking down the offending material, while possibly legal, will only escalate the situation, requiring ever more force to control. sure, you may successfully thwart this attempt, but what about the next one? rising stakes eventually lead to a police state undergirded by pervasive surveillance.

this is multi-rooted social problem that's certainly bigger than one company, especially a tech company. it's not even certain that online outlets like 8chan don't lessen real violence by allowing members to find consolation among like-minded people rather than stewing in their anger.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by tomatotomato37 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:22PM (#20610946)
I think a point of contention over the unmoderated aspect is that compared to it's sister site 4chan which will actively coordinate with authorities and temporarily take the site down whenever evidence is being collected, 8chan appears to treat the authorities with contempt to the point of needing a search warrant. It's creator Fredrick calling for the site's shutdown was the killing strike in my opinion, though the site had /g/ establish a full Tor infrastructure years ago so it's not going to really truly die anytime soon

Speaking of 4chan if I was Hiro right now I would be batting down the hatches and moving most of the moderation force to the problem boards to snipe any incoherent manifestos until this all blows over.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by the8472 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:30PM (#20611003)
Requiring a search warrant seems like due process to me, not contempt. In many other cases handing over data to law enforcement without a warrant is seen as surveillance and a breach of privacy.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by mLuby on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:34PM (#20611023)
>treat the authorities with contempt to the point of needing a search warrant

Everyone must comply with lawful orders—that's the point of the law. Respect is not mandatory (so long as it doesn't interfere with lawful orders); it is earned and can be lost.

If this were not true, the right to avoid self-incrimination would be meaningless.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by tomatotomato37 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:52PM (#20611139)
The thing is that Moot (and probably Hiro too) actively intercepts and forwards mass-shooty type stuff it to the cops instead of waiting for a warrant to avoid this exact situation. Emphasis on intercept, you can't have a media shitstorm decrying you as the axis of evil if the only thing they can find on your site is mass speculation because a mod autosaged the shooter's manifesto 3 minutes after it was posted
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by mLuby on Monday August 05, 2019 @03:23AM (#20612017)
Questions:

1. What is "autosaged"? UrbanDictionary was no help… ^__^;

2. By intercept do you mean "notice quickly" or "prevent from arriving/posting"?

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by tomatotomato37 on Monday August 05, 2019 @08:22AM (#20613507)
1. Autosage is kinda equivalent to shadowbanning a thread; realistically a mod would just flat delete risky threads of this nature but I just felt like using the lingo

2. Notice quickly and take down; 4chan doesn't really have a way to prevent a post from arriving in the first place aside from simplistic text filters

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by cthulha on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:32PM (#20611016)
> Cloudflare would have been in a better position to actually change 8chan if they had kept them on and pressured them

I call bullshit.

What plan do you have in mind for _Cloudflare_ to create a culture change on _8chan_?

How does this fit into Cloudflare's strategy and competencies as a network provider?

Are you suggesting they have some obligation to provide service and to try and shape the community, or just that they are compelled to provide a commercial service to people who encourage massacres?

You haven't thought through your own suggestion.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:43PM (#20611087)
It had already been against Cloudflare's ToS to transmit unlawful content, like child pornography or sex trafficking. These things do not exist on 8chan. I am suggesting that Cloudflare could have clarified or expanded "unlawful content" to include certain types of incitement to violence that are normally considered within 1st amendment bounds.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by taurath on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:36PM (#20611041)
> This seems like a knee-jerk reaction to moral panic and bad PR

I’m not so sure. We “ban” drug markets and terrorist groups by denying them access to infrastructure all the time. Private businesses get to decide which businesses they provide services to. Freedom of assembly doesn’t mean you get to live in a trash strewn public square, nor on private property that is leeching toxic waste into the surroundings.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by word-reader on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:52PM (#20611138)
Drug markets and terrorist groups are against US law while racist speech and broadly advocating the necessity of violence are not. Cloudflare had previously drawn the line at providing services for any US-legal content, then they suddenly changed it after a lot of bad press in a pretty poorly written blog post.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by taurath on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:38AM (#20611333)
Whats the difference between 8chan /pol/ and a terrorist telegram group? The telegram group probably has fewer people planning attacks on US citizens.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by tomlockwood on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:32PM (#20611012)
> This post repeatedly refers to 8chan as "lawless" and "unmoderated" but it is neither.

I'd encourage anyone who thinks it's plausible that /pol/ is "moderated" and "lawful" to go read that board for a few minutes. Perhaps then they can comment here on whether there's a problem with the moderation, or the policing, of the board.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by lasagnaphil on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:00AM (#20611175)
Have you read the comment fully? 8chan is not just /pol/, it's an amalgation of hundreds of boards with different content and moderation rules.
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by tomlockwood on Monday August 05, 2019 @01:04AM (#20611418)
> Have you read the comment fully?

What response are you expecting here?

As a subset of 8chan, if /pol/ isn't properly moderated or policed, 8chan isn't properly moderated or policed.

If a subset of a thing does not have a particular quality that must be universal for it to be true for that thing, then that thing does not have that quality.

I'm very happy to help you out with this or any other first year undergraduate philosophical logic problems you may be having.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by khawkins on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:47PM (#20611109)
Actions like these unite communities under a common threat. Voices of moderation and internal division is reduced as they fight for their common space. The people who are saying "it's us v.s. society at large" are lionized and the people who want to criticize violent or hateful acts are ignored.

The community will find a way around this, there's no doubt. But now they're more radical and more threatened than they used to be. The harder it is to get to the community the more insulated and radical it becomes as fewer outside voices come in. Only the most dedicated continue on, and those are the people you want to deradicalize more than anyone.

These boards have been open to everyone, if others wanted to talk to these people and provide counter arguments they're free to do so. It's the only thing that's going to go a long way in dissolving toxicity in these communities.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by sytelus on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:20PM (#20610933)
Brandenburg v. Ohio is interesting. Technically doesn't it mean that any speech that calls for action against existing law loses protection from First Amendment? I'm sure SC judges will make sane decisions for now but doesn't this door wide open for this possibility? Given most speech needing First Amendment protection is against some law, this SC decision feels very troublesome to me. Especially now that SC judges are appointed strictly to align with government, Brandenburg v. Ohio can be used for any speech against government to be deemed outside of first amendment protection. No?
Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by javagram on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:23PM (#20610951)
> Brandenburg v. Ohio is interesting. Technically doesn't it mean that any speech that calls for action against existing law loses protection from First Amendment?

No. From the Wikipedia description of the case, “The U.S. Supreme Court reversed Brandenburg's conviction, holding that government cannot constitutionally punish abstract advocacy of force or law violation.“

The entire point of the ruling was that the government cannot punish someone for merely advocating against the law. And even dangerous speech is okay if it’s not likely to be acted on. “free speech and free press do not permit a State to forbid or proscribe advocacy of the use of force or of law violation except where such advocacy is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action.”

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by philwelch on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:31PM (#20611004)
“Imminent” and “lawless” are the operable terms. I can legally opine to my hearts content about how it could hypothetically be a good idea to rob every bank in New York but if I’m not inciting anyone to actually specifically do so, that’s not legally imminent. Likewise, if I propose a series of constitutional amendments, the net effect is to legalize or legally mandate some sort of atrocity, there’s a case that I’m not even technically advocating for lawless action.

But the primary value of Brandenburg v. Ohio was in rejecting the early 20th century jurisprudence based on the “clear and present danger” status set by Schenck v. United States.

Schenck and the rulings that followed it gave legal cover to imprison people who advocated for draft resistance as well as effectively banning Communist parties (on the theory upheld in Whitney v. California that communism entails the violent overthrow of the US Constitution). Brandenburg and its successor cases effectively overturned that entire line of legal reasoning in favor of an extremely strict standard that only allows the government to prohibit things like inciting mobs or engaging in criminal conspiracies.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by anigbrowl on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:27PM (#20610980)
Zzz, how many mass murders do you need before you decide there's a structural problem? That's 70 people dead so far this year from people using 8ch as a launching pad for terrorism, and just including the very obvious ones (Christchurch and El Paso). It's rational for Cloudflare to pull the plug and limit their owners' liability.

And no, /pol/ is not the only hive of extremism on 8ch, although it's the best known and although there are many other boards.

Re:Terminating Service for 8Chan by cfv on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:31PM (#20611006)
You're complaining about the unfair closing of a bar because drugs were only sold in the toilets area.

That's not how it works anywhere.