I don’t necessarily disagree with the crux of your point about infrastructure. However, in the case of 5G, why do we need to “beat” other countries? What’s the rush?
Great article from The Verge titled “Wait, why the hell is the ‘race to 5G even a race?” https://www.theverge.com/2019/5/23/18637213/5g-race-us-leade...
I would love to be proven wrong.
I'm much more concerned about how 5G will impact our ability to predict hurricanes. Lives are very much at stake there.
For the other--it's embarrassing. I'm embarrassed that Copenhagen is building a massive new subway system extension for the same money it's costing my state (Maryland) to build a single suburban light rail line. It indicates moral shortcomings of the citizenry--inability to set priorities, inability to cooperate, selfishness, complacency, etc. Same thing with 5G, but add gullibility and hypochondria to the mix.
How, precisely?
5G won't be anywhere near low-latency enough to actually offload processing for these types of devices. (Not to mention, I'd really worry about what happens when a car loses connection.)
> For the other--it's embarrassing.
I appreciate your feelings, but we need to collectively get over ourselves. "Embarrassment" shouldn't be driving billion dollar decisions.
If we need to channel the emotion, let's do where the needs are explicit, like public transit.
I suppose it can't hurt as an additional safety feature, but if we're considering this a requirement for the technology, that makes me very scared, given the inherent unreliability of any type of cellular connection.
In dense urban areas, 4G cell networks don't have sufficient capacity to enable large numbers of people to be using high-bandwidth services. E.g. if there is a road anomaly, such as construction, one of the solutions self-driving-car makers have invoked is a human remote driver jumping in. You can do that with a few cars on 4G, but not at scale with dozens of cars that might be simultaneously blocked by the same anomaly.
> I appreciate your feelings, but we need to collectively get over ourselves. "Embarrassment" shouldn't be driving billion dollar decisions. If you need to channel the emotion, do so with regard to things like public transit where the need is much more explicit.
Less than 5% of Americans use public transit. 96% of Americans use cell phones. Cellular is far more important than public transit.
5G will also enable smart devices to connect over cellular instead of wifi, increasing how much control the device maker has over the device and probably overall increasing connection reliability.
^Although, WiFi 6 is also aiming to solve this problem so I guess these are competing protocols at this point.
> 5G is the absolute last thing standing in the way of self-driving cars.
... more as "everything else is working, we are just waiting for 5g then we have self driving"
Instead I read it as "there is so much else not working yet, that 5g is _not even_ on the list of important things", which seems to be more what you were implying?
If you can't see that these are totally unrelated, then I don't know what to say.
Fiber lines are completely different than "hey these rats that are constantly exposed to 5G radiation that's 20 yards away are acting all messed up".
Can you explain why it is fake? Non-ionizing radiation does have an effect on us. Just because it isn't melting our organs doesn't mean that we aren't effected negatively by it. The independent research shows this, doesn't it?
You have to realize that "high" power radio & other artificial EM transmissions have been going on ever since you were born pretty much everywhere. AM Radio, FM Radio, "wireless" TV, and todays cellphones and wifi base stations. Not to mention all the other radio traffic that is more specialized, like airplanes, HAM radio, police & emergency services, the military, the light you see from your lightbulbs, the EM radiation that emits from your electric wires running through your house, street or nearby electric transformer stations on and on.
None of it has resulted in secret harm and 5G will be no different. The stuff that is harmful will have a lot of warnings around it and won't be secret. Such as UV exposure from the sun.
EDIT: regarding "who stands to gain"--consumers! It's very odd to me that I'd have to defend the technology upgrade treadmill on HN of all places. In October, Apple's going to come out with the A13 chip. Is anyone going to wonder "who benefits?" Or ask "why do we need it?" No, we'll all understand that the A12 is obsolete trash now. That's how this industry works.
I can't see 5G benefiting consumers at all. If you're on a 4G network, you already see no issues with streaming video.
Who is 5G even for? It's a solution seeking a problem.
Other countries are not going to hold up 5G deployment over fake health concerns. If we don't want 5G to be yet another area, like transit and roads, where the US lags woefully behind Europe and Japan, we must fight such distractions.
[1] Remember when San Francisco held up AT&T fiber deployment in the city for years with a lawsuit about ugly fiber boxes? https://stopthecap.com/2011/06/29/san-francisco-still-in-sta...