I'm not sure anyone knows for sure why this happened, but the best theory i've heard is that the reduction in tick size reduced the expected profits of market makers, because they are collecting less spread on every contract they turn around, while not affecting their potential losses, because external factors which cause the market to jump three basis points will still cause it to jump three basis points. Halved regular profits divided by constant occasional losses equals no longer worth bothering with.
Change the rules on them for arbitrary reasons, the firms that were there leave. At least long enough to build new systems and trading strategies. Who replaces them, anyone? Why?
Increase the tick size, liquidity drops. Decrease the tick size, liquidity drops. The moral there is know why you are changing the rules in the market, how you are doing it and the implementation details and side effects that will result in getting the result you want or just don't do it. This could be better is garbage, know it is. Change is not good for its own sake if you want people to quote.
Market fragmentation aside, adding more price levels to set orders to disaggregates liquidity in the book, usually resulting in lower execution quantity (which increases your overall transaction costs if you’re trying to space trades out).
Multiply x2 and add an extra 10%.
Make that the minimum order placement tick duration.
There would be 1 single global price and no arbitrage between markets possible.
What you're proposing is turning continuous trading into a fast series of auctions, like what happens for every ticker on every exchange at the opening. This would have the disadvantage of no clear bid/ask - how can you be sure that the parties do not withdraw their offers before the next tick? And surely you must allow for offer withdrawals.
All orders are placed at the previously known tick price and later orders will occur at the price declared on the next tick.
Of course no trader should access the “ghost price” before it is announced on the tick.
Propagation delays remain limited to local data centers and in any case it’s about globally known prices.
Where’s the arbitrage here?
The impact of such regulation was tested by the SEC recently with the 'tick size' program. Instead of reducing the minimum increment, some names saw it increased to $0.05. The hope was to increase liquidity while decreasing volatility in these names. In fact, those names experienced decreased liquidity with no decrease in volatility.
HFT is a result of regulation.
[0] https://www.sec.gov/divisions/marketreg/subpenny612faq.htm
[1] https://www.benzinga.com/general/education/18/04/11517027/th...