/me grumpily clicks link
I am not a lawyer, but I think under european privacy laws those approaches are probably ilegal, too.
If some manufacturer (probably chinese) wants to grab data from people in Europe, they must comply with EU laws even if they don't have an office in the EU.
Not beign able to sell to a huge market is probably a better tactique, but not the only one to use.
We don't have to make everything bad impossible. We can make it a bit harder to do the wrong thing, and then the regulator says "Hey, do the easy thing these nerds recommend or else if we find you did the wrong thing you're in bad trouble".
But a Federal Prosecutor can tell a judge these are the only Smart TVs that do that, and he thinks it's because they're violating the Tialaramex No Snooping Act of 2025, so he wants a warrant to see what HBO receives.
The warrant doesn't magically decrypt the packets - but refusing to obey the warrant is contempt of court, for which you can go to jail. An HBO employee shows the Prosecutor their database labelled "snooping" full of data from Foo Corp TVs that sure enough violates the No Snooping Act.
In today's IoT world where basically everybody does all this potentially shady stuff sending encrypted data to who knows where, and with no legislation on the books saying they mustn't, you would not get anywhere trying to obtain a warrant.
But if things like WebThings Gateway were to make that unusual, so that as I said there aren't other Smart TVs sending mysterious stuff directly to HBO - that changes the balance of probabilities, and it also changes the incentive to regulate / legislate behaviours that are now less common and still undesirable so that what they're doing isn't just immoral it's illegal too.
Circumstances change. In 1975 the idea that you shouldn't smoke cigarettes inside a train, deep under the ground, in a crowded city, was a bit weird. By 1983 it was illegal in London. In 1985 somebody who'd cut a few corners and was lighting a cigarette on the escalator out of the Underground caused a fire in which a lot of people died (a lot of other things went wrong, but none of them would have mattered if not for the cigarette). Today when we're trying to explain that fire to children it doesn't make a lot of sense to them. They don't remember it ever being legal to smoke cigarettes inside a building - it smells bad and looks obviously dangerous - why would somebody be doing it not just inside a building but so deep underground?
But both of those approaches are very difficult and resource-intensive. The first requires many, many hours of reverse engineering to find a security hole which allows you to write unsigned firmware to the device (or find a way to sign your own firmware and then upload it), then hack the firmware to do your snooping (good luck if the firmware updates are encrypted!).
The second is so fiddly and awkward, I've never heard of anyone actually doing it.
Correct, from the moment the IoT device puts a packet on the line, it is encrypted end to end. This is a fundamental aspect of TLS to prevent snooping. To view unencrypted data, you have to access it prior to being sent out on the network which requires you to gain root privileges on the IoT device.
If these closed-source devices send un-encrypted data, you can MiTM these devices when they're on your network. But if they're encrypted, you're SOL.
You find out after you purchase the device, are you going to send it back? What if data collection policies change?
Besides, SSH begins with encryption, how do you audit an SSH connection?
The path to the platform you want looks like the iOS App Store.
Encrypting everything means that IoT devices represent an unknown threat - your "smart" TV connects to Sourceforge and downloads... something every week. What for? Your "smart" thermostat calls the IP of the vendor, maybe to get firmware updates, but it also calls the Disney corporation - what for? You can't snoop any of this because it's using encryption with pinned keys, so MITM doesn't work. Obviously hardcore reverse engineering is possible, but it's extremely expensive. So in practice it won't get done.
But, if we can popularize a safe option, we can just flag all the unsafe approaches that are popular today. We can teach vendors that this is a bad idea and they shouldn't do it, and (cross fingers) it might go away, like X-ray shoe sizing.