News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by Animats on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:17PM (#20508397)
Well, of course. Just don't sign up for a Google account.

When you get an Android phone new, there's a moment when it asks you to sign up or sign in with a Google account. There's a "later" option". Click that, and then remove the Google one-time startup program. Install F-Droid, and get your apps from there.

The mail program on Android will talk to an IMAP server. Find one to use, and you don't need Gmail. No ads.

On desktop, use Firefox, LibraOffice, and Thunderbird. Install Privacy Badger from the EFF. Videos are uploaded to Vimeo. I have a cheap web site on HostGator if I need to upload anything for someone else to look at, and a Github account for code storage.

I've been doing this for years, and don't seem to be missing out on anything except ads.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by babypuncher on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:36PM (#20508570)
Google tracking is baked into Android pretty deep. Simply not having an account doesn't stop Google from tracking what you do on your phone.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by vetinari on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @02:44PM (#20509128)
It requires being signed in.

If you are not signed in, for extra safety you can also disable google play framework and all google apps. You won't get things like fused location, but hey, that one requires connecting to google services too.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by panpanna on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:36PM (#20509561)
You may or may not be right about this.

The only way to verify this is to install some system level firewall and carefully inspect all logs.

Until you do that, we simple don't know.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by vetinari on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:52PM (#20509670)
Or you can inspect AOSP itself and bring your device to AOSP-like state.

Sure, you won't know whether the vendor of your device didn't modify the firmware itself, but what motivation is there for Samsung, Sony or Huawei to help Google to get user data?

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by southerntofu on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:52AM (#20513617)
> what motivation is there for Samsung, Sony or Huawei to help Google to get user data?

I'm not sure about their motivation, but several vendors are famously known for bundling spyware with their phones. Usually within the keyboard app or some telemetry system.

> bring your device to AOSP-like state

That's a solution but is impossible without having a clean ROM at your disposal. Google's spyware is contained within Google Play Services, which you can't get rid of that easily.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by madez on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:08AM (#20515994)
When one wants an AOSP-like state, they can install LineageOS. That doesn't include Google Play Services, so it isn't difficult to get rid of it.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by vetinari on Thursday August 01, 2019 @08:59AM (#20583318)
Jumping to LineageOS is order of magnitude bigger change, than `adb pm disable` packages. LineageOS has to support your device in the first place, and then you have root your device (and lose some capabilities in the process, like camera processing on Xperias).

Yes, you will get better control over software that runs on your device. You will pay for it by going through more demanding process and the risk of having instabilities, that nobody except you cares about.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:35PM (#20509553)
> Google tracking is baked into Android pretty deep

Citation needed.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by deftnerd on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:59PM (#20509726)
Google requires all apps that are on Google Play to use Firebase, which is baked into the OS, for notifications. Developers might make apps available on F-Droid or through individual download, but most of the time, those are just the same versions available on Google Play and configured to use Firebase.

The problem is that while Android is OS, most apps use functions and OS-level API's available that are only available through the Google Play Services application. This is a good thing for people who have phones from manufacturers who don't update the OS's, but it's a bad thing if you don't want Google Play Services to run.

You don't want Google Play Services (or Google Mobile Services) to run because if it's running, it's talking to Google (even if you never configured an account) in order to use their hosted API's like location detection based on nearby Wifi AP's, push notifications, malware scanning, etc. Whenever it connects to those hosted API's, it POST's a unique device ID.

This is harder than it sounds. The current versions of the stock keyboard, clock, calendar, contacts manager, and even phone dialer all have Google Play Services as a dependency.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @05:29PM (#20510394)
> Google requires all apps that are on Google Play to use Firebase, which is baked into the OS, for notifications.

Only for apps on the Play Store. This is much less restrictive than iOS, which requires you to use APNS for notifications without any workarounds. Also, Firebase is not "built into the OS" and doesn't exist at all in AOSP.

> The current versions of the stock keyboard, clock, calendar, contacts manager, and even phone dialer all have Google Play Services as a dependency.

Those aren't "stock." Those are Google's apps. Many devices don't even use Google's by default. The AOSP implementations don't use Google Play Services at all. It is trivial to install replacements on even Google-flavored Android devices that don't use Google Play Services.

Compare to iOS. Apple knows every app you ever downloaded, and there is nothing you can do about it. Every time you click on an address link, it sends the address to Apple, and there is nothing you can do about it. Any time an app looks up your GPS location, that location is sent to Apple, and there is nothing you can do about it. If you want to write apps for your own device, you need to give card details to Apple, and there is nothing you can do about it. That is what data collection built pervasively into the OS actually looks like

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by millstone on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @12:42AM (#20512408)
What nonsense. Google's panoptic data collection is not excused by AOSP, side loading, or vendor shovelware, all of which are completely irrelevant. Google's detailed picture of the daily physical movements of everyone, cross referenced with their email, web searches, site visits, and who knows what else, is not somehow worse than Apple requiring a credit card to develop for the app store.

Apple Maps doesn't know who you are. Siri doesn't know who you are. iMessage is E2E encrypted. Locations are anonymous. If you actually cared about this stuff, you'd be applauding Apple.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lern_too_spel on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:06AM (#20512495)
You've fallen for a simple marketing campaign. What Google does with data has nothing to do with what data Android collects out of the box, which I have demonstrated (and you have not refuted) is less than what iOS collects. You can just as easily send your location, email, and search data to Google on iOS as you can on Android. The difference is that on Android, it is possible (even easy) to choose not to send data to Google or Apple.

> If you actually cared about this stuff, you'd be applauding Apple.

If you actually cared about privacy, you would be damning Apple for handing over the iCloud keys for Chinese users' data to the PRC allowing the PRC to implement dragnet surveillance on iCloud documents, iCloud email, iMessages, etc. to find and disappear dissidents. This is worse than anything Google or even Facebook has done by a stupendous margin.

> iMessage is E2E encrypted.

Since Apple controls the keyserver, Apple has the ability to wiretap any iMessage conversation (https://blog.quarkslab.com/imessage-privacy.html). Since China controls the keyserver inside the great firewall, China has the ability to wiretap any conversation that occurs with at least one user in China. Compare to Android, where you can set Signal as your default SMS handler. One pretends to support privacy, while the other actually does.

> Apple Maps doesn't know who you are.

But it does know where you are and every address link you click on. From there, you are very easy to deanonymize. Compare to Android, which lets you run fully offline mapping applications and set them as the default address handler. Apple's apps are systematically both less useful than alternatives and less private than other alternatives. The only thing that saves them is slick marketing.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by Dunedan on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:31PM (#20508524)
That doesn't prevent Google from collecting information about you. Even though you don't actively use Google on your Android device, doesn't mean it doesn't phone home and reports information to Google.

For example, if you don't actively disable it, your phone sends the names of all Wifi-networks in your proximity to Google, so Google can tell you where you are faster and more accurate than with GPS. Even if you disable it, your phone will still fetch GPS positioning information from Google unless you change that to use another service. And so on and so on ...

That's just one example, but there are multiple occasions where your stock Android phone phones home to Google.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by fyfy18 on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @02:32PM (#20509051)
And this is the sort of thing GDPR is meant to prevent. Unless you explicitly allow it (and a popup checked by default doesn't count), Google cannot use that data for purposes other than providing you with positioning information.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by justinclift on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:12AM (#20512954)
> And this is the sort of thing GDPR is meant to prevent.

Sure. But Google being the immoral company it is has instead chosen to lawyer up, tell people it's compliant with the GDPR, and keep on collecting everything it can get its hands on anyway.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by madez on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:14AM (#20516053)
Even if Google didn't touch by a ten-foot pole the data that it logs and collects for services like faster location finding for Android devices, which I think is unreasonable to assume, it is still accessible to the government under the 'national security' excuse.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by justinclift on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:30PM (#20522322)
Good point. :)
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:35PM (#20508565)
> For example, if you don't actively disable it, your phone sends the names of all Wifi-networks in your proximity to Google, so Google can tell you where you are faster and more accurate than with GPS. Even if you disable it, your phone will still fetch GPS positioning information from Google unless you change that to use another service.

Nope. Sending this data to Google requires an opt in on Android (Google Location Services checkbox in the device setup flow). iOS has the same location system, but it won't even let you opt out of it, and that might be the source of your confusion.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by close04 on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:13PM (#20509824)
For any regular non-technical user locking down most Android phones (presumably some phones come with hardened settings and possibly with no Google services) and keeping the data away for Google is a huge challenge. The default settings are almost always very permissive, you have to dig down through settings to disable everything, and a lot of stuff isn't very obvious for anyone who doesn't expect such behavior. Oh even when the WiFi is off it will still scan for nearby SSIDs to get your position?

https://digitalcontentnext.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/DC...

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @05:21PM (#20510325)
It is much less of a challenge than keeping your data away from Apple on iOS as my previous comment demonstrated.

> Oh even when the WiFi is off it will still scan for nearby SSIDs to get your position?

Again, this is opt in even on Google-flavored Android devices. There is no digging through settings required — the opt in checkbox appears in the setup flow. On iOS, there is nothing you can do to stop your device from doing this.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by millstone on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:23AM (#20512550)
You don't have to do anything to get decent privacy on iOS because it comes like that out of the box.

Do you honestly believe that Google has less data on Android users, compared to Apple for iOS users?

> Again, this is opt in even on Google-flavored Android devices

No, it's opt-out. For example see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2uSGGl0LWc&t=3m41s - setup on a Pixel and all the location stuff is on by default.

> On iOS, there is nothing you can do to stop your device from doing this

Oh, how do I turn this on for iOS?

When I turn off WiFi it says that "improved location accuracy require Wi-Fi".

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lern_too_spel on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @04:06AM (#20513153)
> You don't have to do anything to get decent privacy on iOS because it comes like that out of the box.

It's amazing that somebody who works in tech would fall for that marketing when it is so obviously a lie. Consider that iOS sends every GPS location ever requested by your phone to Apple, and there is nothing you can do about it. Likewise, you can't stop Apple from knowing about every app you install on your phone or every address link you click on. If you want to develop apps for your own device, you have to hand over card details. "Out of the box," iOS tells Apple every phone number you SMS and when. And worst of all, if you're Chinese, you have no privacy at all on an iOS device.

> Do you honestly believe that Google has less data on Android users, compared to Apple for iOS users?

For users who care about privacy, absolutely. For users who care about usability, Google has more data but provides a more useful experience. That's a trade-off that is possible to make on Android. On iOS, you are stuck with poor privacy and worse usability.

> No, it's opt-out.

You are correct. That is still much better than not being able to opt out of sending every GPS lookup to Apple at all.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by close04 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:28AM (#20513024)
> Again, this is opt in

It's not and it's not even suggested that it exists as a feature on any of the Android devices I ever owned or played with. The dialog for setting up location has no option that absolutely turns off every method that is directly used to determine/infer location. Ok, this is also a user education problem but Google certainly isn't doing anything to suggest the "precise location" won't just provide a precise location to the user.

And most people take the common sense approach and assume turning off WiFi will actually turn it off. Instead not only are they still tracked, they lose battery life too.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by Animats on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:54PM (#20509682)
Right. I use Mozilla's location services, OpenStreetMap, and ZaNavi with locally stored maps.

Not from fanaticism. It's just less hassle. Google is always getting in your face, wanting something or pushing an "upgrade" or or advertising something. Don't need that.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by joosters on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:23PM (#20508459)
Surely your phone is still repeatedly in touch with Google servers because you've got all that Google software on there. Just because you haven't signed in with a google account doesn't mean Google don't know who you are.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by skybrian on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @02:27PM (#20509000)
It doesn't mean they know who you are, either. That depends on what data is transmitted, what is stored, who has access to it, and what it means philosophically to know who someone is. There is not enough information to say.

If there is tracking data associated with a phone but it's not associated with your real name, in what sense can you say they know you?

There is a risk someone (who?) can connect it with other data somehow, and then all the pieces fall into place. But maybe it hasn't happened yet?

So, this is all preventative. Nobody knows what's going to happen, but better to avoid tracking, just in case.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @08:05PM (#20511290)
Postal code (available via weak geocoding) of work + home locations is 90% effective in identifying a single individual.

Anynymised hash caad09aeb361e1d6052c81db1db0e8523e34fca0909b6b2f21bd2ae39f9045e2 with > 0.90 probability of nocturnal location X and diurnal location Y is not anonymous.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by lonelappde on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:15PM (#20509365)
If the police come to arrest Mr Anonymous because my phone activity matches something of interest, they will learn who I am when they knock down my door.

My phone has a cellular account with my name attached to it.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by skybrian on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:27PM (#20509483)
Well, at least you have a fairly specific threat model. But opsec for avoiding discovery by the police seems pretty hard?
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by com2kid on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:23PM (#20508461)
Bonus work:

Make sure none of your friends upload a photo with you in it, which basically means they don't take your photo with an Android phone.

If somehow your picture does get onto an Android phone, somehow make sure you aren't labeled.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by komali2 on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:43PM (#20508634)
Better: Download a fuckload of https://thispersondoesnotexist.com/ photos, create social media accounts under your name, and bloat the accounts with these photos while tagging yourself.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by hombre_fatal on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:05PM (#20509280)
All that work just to have your misinformation trivially filtered out.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by komali2 on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:01PM (#20509753)
Trivially how?
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by saltminer on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:43PM (#20510019)
Facial recognition isn't fooled unless others participate in this, and even then it's going to be localized. Google Photos recognizes that the John Smiths in my contacts are unlikely to be the same John Smiths in thousands of other peoples contacts, and can easily differentiate between the 2 John Smiths in my contacts because I've tagged a few of each.

If your friends who have added you on social media also uploaded random crap and tagged you in it, it could fool the facial recognition for your group of friends, but if <distant relative> who has no mutual friends with you on social media tags you correctly in their photos, it probably won't fix it for your friends since it will probably assume they're 2 different yous.

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by sdan on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:37PM (#20509569)
Smart idea. I love it.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by sverige on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:23PM (#20508458)
In my experience, the difficulty is spending the time and energy to set these things up for family who might not be as willing to stray from the path of least resistance.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @01:39PM (#20508595)
That's why the best choice is just to recommend your family get an iPhone. The default/least resistant path is far more private.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @03:09PM (#20509307)
Apple are harvesting just as much data, they're just being less evil with it... For now.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by makosharky on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @06:59PM (#20510989)
Apple takes steps to encrypt the data so that even they don't have access to it.
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by amaccuish on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @04:41PM (#20510007)
IMAP doesn't support push :(
Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by Animats on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @06:52PM (#20510952)
Sure it does. Since 2009.[1]

[1] https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5550

Re:Never-Googlers: Web users take the ultimate step to guard... by amaccuish on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:37PM (#20517565)
I was refering specifically to IMAP and the Android default mail client.