Ask PG: do you want HN to be a general news site or not?
Hi Paul,
I know you wrote the HN guidelines specifying 'whatever hackers find interesting' is appropriate. However people take this two ways, either:
A. Whatever gets upvotes is OK, even if a large chunk of the articles on HN are about suicide bombers, the TSA, political leaks, etc and duplicate existing sites like Reddit.
B. Things that specifically Hackers find interesting - as opposed to the general population - belong on the front page.
IIRC you appealed for people to submit Scheme stories a while ago after an influx of new users came to visit, so I'm hoping for 2) to be your answer. If so, is there anything we as a community can do, asides from flagging articles (which we're already doing), to stop HN further becoming a general purpose news site?
(
40 comments
| 52 points
| on HN
)
Do we think we have more interesting commentary? (e.g. is that why we post those articles here?)
They've worked pretty good so far and it is neat to see how effective some minor tweaks have been in sending the 'front' page in the right direction.
The most important page on HN is not the homepage however, it's page #2 of the new submission list, that's where you might still be able to rescue an article that you think does not get the attention that it deserves.
You may want to really consider submitting more interesting stories, 50 or submissions over 4 years is not a whole lot. If everybody that feels like you do would post interesting articles instead of 'Ask PG' stuff about the perceived quality of the site that quality would go up quickly.
edit: though, i admit i'd like to see downvotes on submissions, too, just to see how that would work out here. perhaps two front page lists for an experiment. one that shows the results with downvotes counted, one without.
Example: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2043841
I think that's actually good except for the case where you're flagging spam (it's annoying to have to click twice to flag an obvious spam article when it could have been one click). To have the barrier a bit higher for a thing that will have a large effect is good imo.
but for just a downvote, which has the same but opposite effect as an upvote, placing it right below that upvote would be a good location.
Now, I try to log in at least once a day or every other day and post an "HN-worthy" article if I come across one, or at least try to contribute to the discussion of an article.
My "Fix HN" suggestion: apply a different "decay" rate to the "Ask/Show/Tell HN" posts so that they stay on the front page longer. They're usually more focused on HN-oriented material, and posted by people who post on HN semi-regularly (at least). I'd also lower the flagging threshold to something like 3 or 5 so that people don't abuse this for general news articles.
It occurs to me that any story that takes a long time to consume -- say a long TED talk -- has a built-in disadvantage to a story that can be quickly consumed. That's because of the way the decay rate works.
Ideal HN-bait story? A long-ish story with several technical-looking drawings, charts, and graphs, all around some flame-bait brand/fanboy thing like Apple or Google, loaded with personal drama that involves some famous tech person. If it has some technical googledegook or obscure jargon, all the better.
I don't mean that as a criticism of HN, just trying to flesh out what commonalities I'm noticing. Seems like that would be a first step to critiquing site. For all I know, this is exactly the kind of story pg wants to see. Beats me.
EDIT: This idea of trying to come up with the silliest hn article title in order to demonstrate community trends was so interesting to me that I followed up with a HN Contest http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2048844
I think you're right about the HN-bait stories -- in fact, I have a feeling that a number of people tend to upvote sensational stories (actually, just the titles) without even reading them, which makes the problem even worse.
I assume other people do the same. It's not a good thing to do.
I think the site would be much more useful if it were just Ask/Tell/Show HN stories with some kind of meta filtering on top. How do I find a cofounder? What's the best way to measure traction? How do all these startups get so much media attention? Is there some way to navigate from those questions to all the discussions about it that we've had on HN? If so, and if you could do that with a 100 startup-related issues, it'd be a hell of a more useful site than all the gossip and drama that we end up with.
I certainly do not want to read news that would be to the far right of that diagram. But there are a number of soft skills you do acquire from sometimes leaning on the intersection between "hacker news" and just "news". I don't believe we should limit HN just to the very left because we'd miss those. That being said, this is HN and I don't ever want to come here for CNN content - that's why CNN.com exists.
FYI -- I did not down-vote your comment. I rarely ever down-vote anything on HN.
The are only two differences between political discussions on HN and political discussions in any random moderated forum.
1) The posts are shorter.
2) Most of those involved in such discussions think that the (almost-always) bog-standard partisan/ideological arguments they advance are somehow more insightful because they're smart programmers, entrepreneurs, or just geeks in general.
On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
So yes, things that gratify one's intellectual curiosity. But typically if it suggests a new trend.
By way of example (of what I think not what the rules are) YOU may find articles on high frequency trading to be intellectually satisfying. The majority of HN may not. A few articles as the trend emerges will be generally interesting to the whole crowd here as an emerging trend. But after that it is probably a very specific area of interest that is much less of what we all want our front page filled with.
If that is roughly the definition, then I suppose there would be general news but of a novel, or intellectually interesting nature.
If, on the other hand, by hacker you mean programmer, and by non general news you mean only news related to programming, wouldn't that be slightly too narrow?
I think technology news are dominant here, but the variety now and then I think is a good thing.
On the contrary. Assuming the vast majority of HN are indeed "hackers", and that we do not just blindly upvote, then a post will get upvoted iff hackers find it interesting.
That's correct. B is a subset of A. The TSA, bees, and wikileaks are undoubtably interesting to many people, not specifically hackers.
'B. Things that specifically Hackers find interesting - as opposed to the general population - belong on the front page.'
Note the word 'specifically' and the phrase 'opposed to the general public'. I'm a hacker and I like pizza, however pizza is not a thing specifically Hackers find interesting.
An article about the economics or business of pizza, or someone obsessed with making great pizza (like this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mz91GfoZ-Zs ) might be considered interesting enough to merit going on HN.
Even more confusing - he refers to 2 as being his preference.