Re:Ask PG: do you want HN to be a general news site or not?
by jacquesm on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @10:14AM
(#2048847)
Flags are already downvotes on submissions so even if you don't get enough flags in time to 'kill' the article it will definitely go down in the rankings when it gets more flags.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask PG: do you want HN to be a general news site or not?
by noodle on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @10:29AM
(#2048898)
i know, but to get to something to flag it, you have to perform more clicks. you have to really disagree with something to want to go flag it. a downvote button on the list would make it much more convenient and more likely to get used to tag something mostly off topic but not blatantly bad.
Re:Ask PG: do you want HN to be a general news site or not?
by jacquesm on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @10:31AM
(#2048906)
> you have to perform more clicks. you have to really disagree with something to want to go flag it.
I think that's actually good except for the case where you're flagging spam (it's annoying to have to click twice to flag an obvious spam article when it could have been one click). To have the barrier a bit higher for a thing that will have a large effect is good imo.
Re:Ask PG: do you want HN to be a general news site or not?
by noodle on Wednesday December 29, 2010 @10:41AM
(#2048950)
which i think is true for flagging, which is more than just a downvote. make it more inconvenient for the thing that can kill a story or report spam.
but for just a downvote, which has the same but opposite effect as an upvote, placing it right below that upvote would be a good location.