News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by drawkbox on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:54AM (#20467408)
Kvashuk, the complaint suggests, was undone by Microsoft's UST Fraud Investigation Strike Team (FIST), which noticed a suspicious increase in the use of CSV to buy subscriptions to Microsoft's Xbox gaming system in February 2018. The investigators traced the digital funds, which had been resold on two different websites, to two whitelisted test accounts.

From there, FIST proceeded to trace the accounts and transactions involved. With the assistance of the US Secret Service and the Internal Revenue Service, investigators concluded that Kvashuk had defrauded Microsoft, despite efforts to conceal his identity with fake accounts and to hide public blockchain transactions using a Bitcoin mixing service.

In addition to service provider records that point to Kvashuk, the complaint notes that Microsoft's online store uses a form of device fingerprinting called a Fuzzy Device ID. Investigators, it's claimed, linked a specific device identifier to accounts associated with Kvashuk.

Pretty involved dissection, went all the way down to digital fingerprinting to catch it.

The thief was smart about the hiding it, but not smart enough, but he had to know after $10m they would catch on. Reminds me of the McDonalds Monopoly game that the extended family of one of the people that worked at the printing place kept winning which was improbable, then expanded further where everyone would give them a cut of the winnings up to $24m [1].

> Jerome Jacobson and his network of mobsters, psychics, strip-club owners, and drug traffickers won almost every prize for 12 years, until the FBI launched Operation ‘Final Answer.’

Take $10m or $24m from a large corporation, someone is going to notice.

[1] https://www.thedailybeast.com/how-an-ex-cop-rigged-mcdonalds...

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by sametmax on Thursday July 18, 2019 @06:16AM (#20468360)
There are two technical interesting take aways in this:

1 - Microsoft, and probably most big companies, have persistent tracking ID on most stuff that are hard to get rid of and can be used to identify you and devices linked to you in a fuzzy way. I mean, we know about super cookies, fingerprinting and such, but it's another to hear it being used to track somebody that was careful and using multiple anonymous accounts.

2 - BTC mixers will not protect you. Correlating one single wallet with you will make it possible to them retrace the entire history.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by buildzr on Thursday July 18, 2019 @08:07AM (#20468904)
> BTC mixers will not protect you. Correlating one single wallet with you will make it possible to them retrace the entire history.

It's also possible they both knew the address which was paid out to buy the stolen merchandise and they saw he had withdrawals from a bitcoin exchange in bank records. Given these two facts, it's pretty easy to draw a line between them even when mixers are used. But if you don't already know who to suspect this is much harder to do.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by x0x0 on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:40PM (#20472776)
My guess is this was reverse engineered. Once they had identified which employees had access to this digital currency, they looked to see who had $10m or so more than expected, and worked from that person to the bitcoin account.

Driving a Tesla that costs significantly more than your take-home pay is... a suboptimal way to avoid being identified.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by itronitron on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:55PM (#20472887)
obligatory Superman III reference >> https://youtu.be/N7JBXGkBoFc?t=212
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday July 18, 2019 @12:01PM (#20471162)
Hmm, that's not enough evidence to connect him -- he could be withdrawing Bitcoin to cash for something entirely unrelated. Him cashing in Bitcoin is circumstantial.

"I bought some bitcoin for cash a decade ago" explains cashing Bitcoin, so what have you got left as evidence.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by Tuna-Fish on Thursday July 18, 2019 @04:02PM (#20473418)
Sorry, just scratching a pet peeve:

> Him cashing in Bitcoin is circumstantial.

Other than confessions, most convictions happen mostly on the basis of circumstantial evidence. TV and movies have taught people that circumstantial evidence is "weak" and insufficient to get a conviction. This is simply not true. Sufficient amount of circumstantial evidence will put you in jail. The job of the prosecutor is not to meet some specific pre-defined standard, it's to convince the jury.

And if the prosecutor has just spent the last hour talking to the jury about how they could track that x amount of stolen credits were sold for x bitcoin at date y, and this bitcoin was then fed to a mixer, and that on those same day or soon after you converted 0.95x BTC to $, and you could not positively prove where that money came from, if your strategy was just:

> "I bought some bitcoin for cash a decade ago"

Good luck with that.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by koheripbal on Friday July 19, 2019 @12:03PM (#20479743)
Not only that - circumstantial evidence is enough for a search warrant, and a search warrant almost ALWAYS reveals additional evidence.

The point is that once the cops know who you are, you're fucked. Even if they are using classified methods to ID you, they'll then find something circumstantial to get warrants until they find you.

The only way to get away is to completely avoid detection in the first place.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by buildzr on Thursday July 18, 2019 @12:44PM (#20471586)
Sorry if it wasn't clear, I meant his addresses being visible on both the input and output of a mixing process but being discovered via separate means, one via tracing where the codes were sold, one via tracing his bank activity after investigating which account generated the codes.

It certainly could be enough to connect him, if they already know the fraudulent codes were generated from his account, and you can see the mixing process and that he was clearly an output of it, that means that he would have had to buy bitcoin from someone who used his account to generate those codes... that's not going to play well to any judge or jury.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by simplyinfinity on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:57PM (#20473377)
Except it's not... wallet history is public, with exact dates. If he bought it decade ago he should be able to prove it in couple of minutes.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by dangero on Thursday July 18, 2019 @12:30PM (#20471456)
That's really for a jury to decide. It's not circumstantial when they have his device finger printed doing nefarious things at other steps of the theft process for the same amounts of money that are coming out of a coin mixer.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday July 18, 2019 @01:15PM (#20471920)
Are coin mixers really that rudimentary, if they are why would you bother? It seems pretty easy to design a mixer that works, logically, so can noone muster the business backing (or is it legal issues?) to do that, not even in any country in the World?
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by heavenlyblue on Thursday July 18, 2019 @07:27PM (#20474977)
I am yet to see a single mixer that would cryptographically prove that I am not participating in an FBI scheme to mix BTC in order for them to then know who mixed what in the first place.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by samdoidge on Thursday July 18, 2019 @07:20AM (#20468621)
As for 2, I would have thought one of the privacy coins could have been utilised:

Buy Monero with Biticoin -> Transfer Monero to another wallet -> Buy Bitcoin with Monero.

But I guess it isn't that easy.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by sametmax on Thursday July 18, 2019 @07:28AM (#20468667)
Most exhanges ask for KYC, so the BTC wallet would still be attached to your ID.

You need to do that with individuals, which is much harder, especially for a high amount of money.

Not saying this is impossible, but it's no as simple as it used to be.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by magnamerc on Thursday July 18, 2019 @08:27AM (#20469023)
Apparently this also breaks Moneros privacy by identifying a BTC address associated it (even without KYC). You need to buy Monero from LocalMonero if you want to be truly private.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by nabnob on Thursday July 18, 2019 @11:17AM (#20470703)
I'm confused as to why Microsoft needed to use this tracking ID at all.

Wouldn't Microsoft be able to trace the digital currency to the whitelisted test account? I'm assuming there's some kind of approval process for whitelisting test accounts (or at least you have to be in the right permissions group), otherwise anyone (even non-QA) could make a test account that bypasses their security.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by testvox on Thursday July 18, 2019 @11:35AM (#20470904)
Tracing the bitcoin transactions might prove which account stole the money. But the device tracking helps prove which real person was controlling the account.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by antpls on Thursday July 18, 2019 @04:49PM (#20473795)
> 2 - BTC mixers will not protect you. Correlating one single wallet with you will make it possible to them retrace the entire history.

Nothing new here. I thought transparent history was one of the main points of distributed ledgers. BTC was never meant to be anonymous

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by homero on Thursday July 18, 2019 @06:37AM (#20468450)
Well Microsoft has access to full hardware IDs on PC and Xbox.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by iamnotacrook on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:57AM (#20467420)
"he had to know after $10m they would catch on...Take $10m, someone is going to notice"

You don't know that for every person caught after taking $10m there aren't 5 who took $100m then stopped and got away with it. It's just pure speculation.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by onion2k on Thursday July 18, 2019 @06:04AM (#20468307)
You don't know that for every person caught after taking $10m there aren't 5 who took $100m then stopped and got away with it. It's just pure speculation.

I'd assume a $100m hole in a company balance sheets when they get audited would make the news.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by sverige on Thursday July 18, 2019 @06:34AM (#20468437)
But if you're really smart, you might get away with over $10MM (in 1978 dollars!) without the bank noticing for eight days -- when the FBI told them.

https://www.social-engineer.org/wiki/archives/Hackers/hacker...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanley_Mark_Rifkin

https://coolinterestingstuff.com/worlds-biggest-heists-stanl...

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by captn3m0 on Thursday July 18, 2019 @08:03AM (#20468878)
Punjab National Bank, a state-owned bank in India ~lost $1.4B, without knowing about it for more than a year.

~lost is somehwhat vague because all it involved was a Letter of Undertaking that was a "promise" by the bank to return that money. They did honor it, losing billions of dollars.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punjab_National_Bank_Scam

[1]: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/obam...

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by JOnAgain on Thursday July 18, 2019 @07:39AM (#20468727)
If they found it. Big company get so complex i don’t think that’s a given. It’s not like they’d be kissing $100m from a single bank account and just be like, that number is low.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by mygo on Thursday July 18, 2019 @07:49AM (#20468775)
this is why you have balance sheets. it would have been caught by the time the accountants needed to figure out total balances and payables and receivables.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by drawkbox on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:00AM (#20467434)
Possibly, in the McDonald Monopoly scam eventually the mob got involved, so maybe some are able to get away with it somewhere.

But like in Office Space, when the account gets big enough it has to eventually be investigated and people aren't smart to run up a big amount but get greedy, whether they find the money or not who knows but someone will know.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by bduerst on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:42PM (#20472794)
Yes, it would be survivor bias, but usually publicly-traded companies have a fiduciary duty to report these types of theft, even if they don't know who committed them.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by ricktdotorg on Friday July 19, 2019 @10:21PM (#20483805)
a recent example where the guy got away with nearly $40m over a number of years. internal billing scam https://www.justice.gov/usao-cdca/pr/ex-accounting-manager-c...
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by johnbrodie on Thursday July 18, 2019 @10:57AM (#20470490)
The explanation in the article is fairly well done. One thing I can't help but think whenever there are more involved processes for catching someone though, is that we'll never know if that was the actual method used. For a large enough case, they could utilize some other, more secretive method, and then parallel construct this (believable) one, with the benefit of already knowing the final answer.

Not something I'm saying _happened_ here, but certainly something I think everyone should keep in mind when they read these types of cases.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by duxup on Thursday July 18, 2019 @10:50AM (#20470397)
From a technical standpoint I wonder what the developer who is stealing is thinking.

I've worked lots of places with access to lots of things. I have technical know how and presumably so does he. Even if I was inclined to do something like this I know that many of my coworkers / people at the company ... are more than capable of tracking down most anything if given enough attention.

The first and best protection I could think of is simply the volume of what is stolen to keep from being noticed. Once noticed with sufficient motivation it's just a matter of time.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by fragmede on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:13PM (#20472492)
Reading between the lines, the article says they got away with it for months, and were only caught because they got greedy - to the tune of a luxury car and a mansion! This smells like a crime of opportunity; most crimes aren't throughly-planned, well-executed Hollywood-grade bank heists - or their digital equivalent, so there also isn't a thoroughly planned exit strategy to a non-extradition country, just a vague notion that something will happen, eventually. Possibly getting caught.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by toyg on Thursday July 18, 2019 @04:49PM (#20473793)
> most crimes aren't throughly-planned, well-executed Hollywood-grade bank heists

And this is why Crime and Punishment is an ageless masterpiece of literature.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday July 18, 2019 @11:56AM (#20471118)
There's lots of things that could impair his reasoning (drink, gambling, other emotional stress, illness), or it could be motivated by revenge, or ...
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by anonymous5133 on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:55AM (#20467724)
Using a bitcoin washing service and then sending the proceeds from the bitcoin transactions to your bank account is not exactly trying to conceal the activity.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by darkpuma on Thursday July 18, 2019 @05:57AM (#20468272)
Trying ineptly is still trying.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by blaser-waffle on Thursday July 18, 2019 @10:05AM (#20469881)
So then what is the play? Send it to someone else's bank account?
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by magashna on Thursday July 18, 2019 @12:10PM (#20471262)
Monero laundering, or holding it for a while. Get too greedy and move too quickly, likely to stumble
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by darkpuma on Thursday July 18, 2019 @04:54PM (#20473839)
> "or holding it for a while."

I wonder if the FBI has an automated system for monitoring bitcoin addresses that are associated with investigations that went cold possibly years ago, and as such no longer have the active attention of any [human] agents. Probably, right? It seems like it would be a good idea anyway.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by bduerst on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:45PM (#20472812)
Are there any reliable and trustworthy Monero exchanges that allow anonymity? Not even Coinbase supports Monero, and Kraken requires identification.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by mtgx on Thursday July 18, 2019 @04:55AM (#20468006)
> Take $10m or $24m from a large corporation, someone is going to notice.

This is the problem with stealing "easy money." It's hard to stop, especially if you don't spend the first portion of money wisely.

It's why card skimmers always get caught, too, eventually. They can't just steal $100,000 and be done with it. That's barely enough for a fully loaded Tesla Model S. They have to keep on stealing, and after a few years of this, are you really going to go back to a 9-5 job paying you $30,000 or less a year for hard work?

So it's not really about criminals "being dumb" about continuing to steal the money, unless you define being dumb the moment they first did it. It's more about them feeling like they have no choice but to keep doing it.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by driverdan on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:21PM (#20472572)
> It's why card skimmers always get caught, too, eventually.

They don't always get caught.

> This is the problem with stealing "easy money." It's hard to stop, especially if you don't spend the first portion of money wisely.

This is very true. Easy money skews how you think. When I was into credit card fraud money became less meaningful. I could get almost anything I wanted for free using stolen cards.

That said, I also kept my activities below what I considered a safe threshold, volumes that would be less likely to cause a large investigation.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by gwd on Thursday July 18, 2019 @08:34AM (#20469066)
> This is the problem with stealing "easy money." It's hard to stop, especially if you don't spend the first portion of money wisely.

Plus there's a weird psychological effect in some people where they feel guilty and actually want to get caught. A few years ago I dropped my wallet somewhere, and someone picked it up and used the contactless cards a couple times. They caught him when, the next day, he was shouting and threatening people and generally acting obnoxious, and was arrested with my wallet (complete with my photo ID) still on him.

Why did the guy suddenly get himself arrested? Why didn't he at least get rid of the wallet first? Maybe there's no connection between the two, but people are complicated.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by baybal2 on Thursday July 18, 2019 @01:21PM (#20471981)
I doubt that this played a role, that's just a such personality type which predisposes a person for crime and trouble, or the "without brakes" behaviour
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by gwd on Friday July 19, 2019 @05:49AM (#20477287)
...and one of the things that plays into that "personality" type is how they feel about themselves. It's a very common pattern that when people are treated better than what they think they deserve, they feel uncomfortable, and subconsciously do something to sabotage things, so that things go back to the expected and familiar. (I'm preparing to adopt, and that's one of the things we're consistently warned to keep an eye out for: children from chaotic, abusive households doing things to provoke you and make you angry, so that you treat them the way they're used to being treated.)

People are complicated and it's difficult to find individual causes; and everyone responds to things differently. I'm not trying to say that everyone who commits crimes just has low self esteem. People have choices; and there are genetic and other environmental factors (exposure to lead being a big one). But it's quite certain that subconscious "I deserve to be punished" motives are a thing.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by watwut on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:51PM (#20473321)
> Why did the guy suddenly get himself arrested? Why didn't he at least get rid of the wallet first? Maybe there's no connection between the two, but people are complicated.

Most likely, stealing your wallet was part of impulsive behavior. Your was not first wallet and him being threatening or obnoxious was not his first such time. Most low level criminals are like that.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by IG_Semmelweiss on Thursday July 18, 2019 @09:58AM (#20469805)
No. Has nothing to do with psychology.

The name for this in statistics is ergodicity. Nassim Taleb, an expert on this subject, as well as many other authors in risk management have established that even professionals in statistics fare very poorly in understanding ergodicity in real life.

In short , its not psych, its human nature

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by zulln on Thursday July 18, 2019 @06:07AM (#20468325)
> It's why card skimmers always get caught, too, eventually.

Given how much money actually is estimated to be skimmed and how few that actually get caught I doubt this.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by natrik on Thursday July 18, 2019 @09:49AM (#20469716)
The guy in the article here was making $116,000 per year.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by gingabriska on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:19AM (#20467520)
>The thief was smart about the hiding it, but not smart enough

I am interested in knowing in what ways he could have never been caught? What did he miss?

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by ars on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:26AM (#20467570)
He should have slowed down maybe.

Also got greedy - he could have had 1 million and live on the interest, but he had to keep going.

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by brianwawok on Thursday July 18, 2019 @01:25PM (#20472027)
Most people over-estimate the long term life of a million dollars in 2019.

Standard wisdom gives you the 4% rule.. i.e. you can spend 4% of a balance to have a principle last forever (Based on historic stock market data, no guarantee it will actually work in the future).

4% of a million is only 40k. Can you live on 40k a year? Yes, billions of people make less than or equal to 40k a year. However most software devs like this guy who was making over 100k a year would be "content" to retire on 40k a year.

He would need at least 3 million to live on the 120k a year ;)

Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by bduerst on Thursday July 18, 2019 @02:47PM (#20472830)
This is also handy napkin math for retirement.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by justsid on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:09PM (#20472999)
More like handy napkin math to figure out that my retirement plan is going to involve me dying young.
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by brianwawok on Thursday July 18, 2019 @05:40PM (#20474186)
That's no fun
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by tuananh on Thursday July 18, 2019 @03:46AM (#20467679)
he sold it for much cheaper value. 10m could have been sold for 1 or 2m
Re:Ex-Microsoft dev used test account to swipe $10M in store... by dd36 on Thursday July 18, 2019 @05:23PM (#20474040)
We only know about the times it is noticed.